Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T06:39:59.964Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The influence of Parker spiral on the reflection-driven turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 April 2026

Khurram Abbas*
Affiliation:
Department of Physics, University of Otago, 730 Cumberland St., Dunedin 9016, New Zealand
Jonathan Squire
Affiliation:
Department of Physics, University of Otago, 730 Cumberland St., Dunedin 9016, New Zealand
*
Corresponding author: Khurram Abbas, khurram.abbas@postgrad.otago.ac.nz

Abstract

The solar wind is observed to undergo substantial heating as it expands through the heliosphere, with measured temperature profiles exceeding those expected from adiabatic cooling. A plausible source of this heating is reflection-driven turbulence (RDT), in which gradients in the background Alfvén speed partially reflect outward-propagating Alfvén waves, seeding counter-propagating fluctuations that interact and dissipate via turbulence. Previous RDT models assume a radial-background magnetic field, but at larger radii the interplanetary field is known to be twisted into the Parker spiral (PS). Here, we generalise RDT phenomenology to include a PS, using three-dimensional expanding-box magnetohydrodynamic simulations to test the ideas and compare the resulting turbulence with the radial-background-field case. We argue that the underlying RDT dynamics remains broadly similar with a PS, but the controlling scales change: as the azimuthal field grows it ‘cuts across’ perpendicularly stretched, pancake-like eddies, producing outer scales perpendicular to the magnetic field that are much smaller than in the radial-background case. Consequently, the outer-scale nonlinear turnover time increases more slowly with heliocentric distance in PS geometry, weakening the tendency (seen in radial-background models) for the cascade to ‘freeze’ into quasi-static, magnetically dominated structures. This allows the system to dissipate a larger fraction of the fluctuation energy as heat, also implying that the turbulence remains strongly imbalanced (with high normalised cross-helicity) out to larger heliocentric distances. We complement our heating results with a detailed characterisation of the turbulence (e.g. spectra, switchbacks and compressive fractions), providing a set of concrete predictions for comparison with spacecraft observations.

Information

Type
Research Article
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of an expanding plasma parcel in the solar wind. (Top) Geometry of the expanding box with axes aligned to radial ($x$), azimuthal ($y$) and normal ($z$) directions. The solar wind initially flows radially outward, while the box expands transversely. The mean magnetic field $\bar {\boldsymbol B}$ (green) is radial near the Sun but rotates into a PS with angle $\varPhi$ as $a(t)$ increases, so that $B_y/B_x \sim a(t)$. Wave vectors $\boldsymbol{k}$ are shown at angle $\vartheta$ to $\bar {\boldsymbol B}$, with azimuthal ($k^{(Y)}$) and normal ($k^{(Z)}$) components indicated. (Bottom) Comparison of eddy evolution under (a) purely radial and (b) PS expansion. In the radial case, the perpendicular scale $\ell _\perp$ grows uniformly with expansion. In the PS case, rotation of the mean field changes $\ell _\perp$ creating three-dimensional anisotropy of the eddies.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Evolution of key parameters for waves under solar-wind expansion, plotted versus expansion factor $a$. Thick black: radial field ($\varPhi _0=0^\circ$). Coloured: PS cases ($\varPhi _0=2^\circ{-}20^\circ$, darker colours correspond to smaller $\varPhi _0$). (a) Wave amplitude $z^+/v_{\textrm {A}}$ stays roughly constant for the purely radial case, and in the PS case remains constant initially but then decays as $\propto a^{-1}$ once the azimuthal component becomes significant and $v_{\textrm {A}}\propto a^0$. (b) Obliquity $\sin \vartheta (a)$: the angle between $\boldsymbol k$ and $\bar {\boldsymbol B}$ initially decreases and then increases again as the mean field rotates azimuthally, producing a clear inflection with a PS. (c) Expansion cascade parameter $\chi _{\textrm {exp}} = (k_\perp \,z^+_\perp )/(\dot a/a)$ for the out-of-plane case ($\varphi = \pi /2$): turbulence is sustained while $\chi _{\textrm {exp}} \gtrsim 1$; $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$ initially decays as $\propto a^{-1}$ for both radial and PS cases, but for PS it starts increasing and eventually flattens as $a^{0}$ once the azimuthal component becomes dominant. (d) $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$ for in-plane wave vectors: shown for $\varphi =\pi$ (solid) and $\varphi =0$ (dashed); in both cases, the wave vector lies in the $x$–$y$ plane. For $\varphi =0$, the wave passes through purely parallel propagation.

Figure 2

Table 1.Simulation parameters for the expanding-box runs. High-resolution (HR) runs use $1200^3$ grid points; moderate-resolution (MR) runs use $720^3$. The parameters explored are; $\varPhi _0$ the initial PS angle, $L_{x0}/L_{\perp 0}$ the initial box aspect ratio (where $L_{\perp 0}$ denotes both $L_{y0}$ and $L_{z0}$), $\dot a$ the expansion rate, $A_0$ the initial fluctuation amplitude and $\beta _0$ the plasma beta. Also, ${k}_{\textrm {peak}}$ sets the centre of the Gaussian peak in $k$-space, $\chi _{\textrm {exp,0}}$ the initial expansion-to-nonlinearity ratio and $k_{\textrm {w}}$ sets the width of the Gaussian peak.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Snapshots of the Elsässer fields $|\boldsymbol z_\perp ^\pm |$ perpendicular to magnetic field in the $y$–$z$ plane. The top two rows (a) show different stages of expansion for the A05-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ$ case with a radial $\bar{\boldsymbol B}$ simulation at $a \approx 6$ (left), $a \approx 22.35$ (middle) and $a \approx 50.35$ (right). These snapshots illustrate the turbulent evolution from an initially imbalanced regime to a magnetically dominated and balanced phase. The bottom two rows (b) show the snapshots of the Elsässer fields in the PS case for A05-$\varPhi _0=1.5^\circ$. Elsässer fields $|\boldsymbol z_\perp ^\pm |$ are shown at three stages of expansion: $a \approx 11$ (left), $a \approx 19.7$ (middle) and $a \approx 67.7$ (right) with the spiral angles of $\varPhi \approx 16.1^\circ , \; 27.3^\circ , \; 60.57^\circ$, respectively. The system remains turbulent, with distinctive anisotropic structural features due to the component of the mean magnetic field along $y$. Note that in each panel, fluctuations are normalised by their root-mean-square value at each time.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Three-dimensional visualisations of the Elsässer fields $|\boldsymbol z_\perp ^\pm |$ perpendicular to the magnetic field at $a \approx 3.5, \; 11.5,\; 21$ for the HR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ$ and HR-$\varPhi _0=4^\circ$ simulations. White arrow shows the direction of mean magnetic field in PS run.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Evolution of normalised Elsässer wave-action energies, $\tilde E^\pm (a)/\tilde E^+_0$, as a function of $a$. Solid curves denote outward wave-action energy ($\tilde {E}^+$) and dashed curves denote inward wave-action energy ($\tilde {E}^-$); line colours correspond to different initial PS angles. Panel (a) shows the high–resolution runs (HR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ$ and HR-$\varPhi _0=4^\circ$). In the radial case ($\varPhi _0=0^\circ$), the outward energy decays approximately as $a^{-0.6}$ up to $a\sim 15$, after which $\tilde E^+$ flattens and rises slightly, indicating that turbulent heating effectively shuts off. In the PS runs, the outward energy continues to decay to larger $a$, maintaining an imbalanced cascade and sustained dissipation for longer. The inset displays the normalised cross-helicity $\sigma _c$ for these runs. Panel (b) shows A05-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,2^\circ ,5^\circ$ runs with similar initial $\chi _{\textrm { exp,0}}$ as panel (a) but reduced amplitude $\textrm {A}=0.5$. The lower amplitude, near-reduced magnetohydrodynamics (RMHD) case decays slightly more slowly than the high-amplitude case, roughly as $\tilde E^+\propto a^{-0.5}$, possibly because the higher-amplitude spherically polarised fluctuations help to make reflection more efficient. (c) The runs MR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,2^\circ ,5^\circ$ have higher initial $\chi _{\textrm {exp,0}}$, which leads to steeper decay following approximately $\tilde E^+\propto a^{-0.8}$. The runs with larger spiral angles (e.g. $\varPhi _0=5^\circ$) were terminated at smaller distances due to numerical instabilities discussed in § 3.3. Note that the first snapshot $(a=1)$ is omitted to improve visualisation, since the inward-propagating mode $\tilde z^-$ is negligible at that stage.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Evolution of correlation length $\ell$ as a function of $a$ for magnetic-field ($\boldsymbol{B_\perp }$) fluctuations for the MR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ$ and MR-$\varPhi _0=2^\circ$ runs. Each curve represents projections along the field ($\parallel$, blue), perpendicular($\perp$, brown), $\hat {e}_T$ direction ($\perp ,T$, green) and $\hat {e}_N$ direction ($\perp ,N$, orange). The dashed black line indicates the $a^{1}$ power-law scaling for reference. In the radial case (left panel), $\ell _{\perp }$ grows nearly linearly with $a$, consistent with expansion-driven eddy widening at early times then transitioning to faster growth at late times (see Meyrand et al. 2025). In contrast, the PS geometry modifies the growth: $\ell _{\perp ,T}$ saturates and remains nearly constant, while $\ell _{\perp ,N}$ increases more slowly than linear.

Figure 7

Figure 7.The time-scale ratio $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$ plotted as a function of expansion factor $a$. We computed this using Alfvénic perpendicular correlation lengths for magnetic-field fluctuations for the HR-$\varPhi _0 = 0^\circ ,4^\circ$ (left) and MR-$\varPhi _0= 0^\circ , 2^\circ ,5^\circ$ simulations (right). The solid lines show $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$ calculated from $\ell _{\perp ,T}$, and the dotted lines show $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$ computed from $\ell _{\perp ,N}$. In the radial case, we averaged both to compute $\ell _{\perp }$, and $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$ decays as $a^{-1}$. In contrast, the PS geometry breaks this symmetry: both $\ell _{\perp ,T}$ and $\ell _{\perp ,N}$ remain smaller than in the radial case yielding systematically larger $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$. This sustains turbulence at larger $a$ because $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$ remains greater than unity for longer range.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Measured $\chi _{\textrm {A}}$ versus $a$. Note that we take the average of transverse and normal perpendicular correlation lengths $\ell _\perp = (\ell _{\perp ,T} + \ell _{\perp ,N})$ for this figure.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Ratio of wave energies $\tilde E^+/ \tilde E^-$ plotted against $\chi _{\textrm {exp}}$ for all simulations (HR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,4^\circ$ and MR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,2^\circ ,5^\circ$, A05-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,2^\circ ,5^\circ$). The thick lines denote the perpendicularly averaged values for each case, while the faint solid and dashed curves correspond to the $\hat {\boldsymbol{e}}_T$ and $\hat {\boldsymbol{e}}_N$ components, respectively. The black dashed line indicates the theoretical scaling corresponding to the prediction from RDT theory (§ 2.4).

Figure 10

Figure 10.Perpendicular energy spectra in the HR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ$ and HR-$\varPhi _0=4^\circ$ simulations. All spectra are plotted versus dimensionless perpendicular wavenumber $k_\perp L_\perp$ ($L_\perp$ is the co-moving perpendicular box length). (a) Radial field evolution of outward and inward energy Elsässer spectra ${\mathcal{E}}^\pm$ at the indicated expansion times, showing the development of imbalance with scale. (b) At $a=20.5$ the magnetic ($\mathcal{E}_M$, purple) and kinetic ($\mathcal{E}_K$, green) spectra for the radial run; magnetic energy dominates across the inertial range. (c) The HR-$\varPhi _0=4^\circ$ Elsässer spectra at $a=5.5$, demonstrating a stronger imbalance. (d) Magnetic and kinetic energy spectra for $\varPhi _0=4^\circ$ at $a=20.1$, which display comparable inertial-range slopes.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Parametric evolution of cross-helicity $\sigma _{c}$ and residual energy $\sigma _{r}$ as a function of expansion factor $a$. Panel (a) shows results from the HR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,4^\circ$ simulations: circles correspond to the purely radial run and squares to the PS run. Panel (b) shows the A05-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,10^\circ$ simulations for both the radial and the higher initial Parker-angle case ($\varPhi _0=10^\circ$). Coloured points represent $a = 1$ (dark blue), $a \sim 10$ (orange) and $a \sim 30$ (yellow). The black circle indicates the condition $\sigma _c^2 + \sigma _r^2 = 1$. Inset of (a) shows the alignment parameter $\sigma _\theta$ versus $a$ for the HR–$\varPhi _0=0^\circ$ (blue) and HR–$\varPhi _0=4^\circ$ (orange) simulations. The radial run exhibits progressively stronger anti-alignment (more negative $\sigma _\theta$) with $a$, while the PS case flattens, indicating saturation of the alignment. In (b) for the PS case, points with $a\gt 20$ are identified as affected by numerical instability: these points are plotted for completeness and the region they occupy is highlighted (highlighted, details in Appendix B).

Figure 12

Figure 12.Fly throughs of the magnetic field for the high-resolution radial (HR–$\varPhi _0=0^\circ$a, c, d) and PS (HR–$\varPhi _0=4^\circ$, b, d, f) simulations at three expansion factors along the direction (1, 0.707, 0.392). Top row: (a) radial and (b) PS at $a=3.5$ ($\varPhi \sim -13.75^\circ$); middle row: (c) radial and (d) PS at $a=11.5$ with $\varPhi \sim 38.8^\circ$; bottom row: (e) radial and (f) PS at $a=20$ at $\varPhi \sim -54.5^\circ$. In each panel the total field strength $|\boldsymbol{B}|$ is shown in black; $B_\parallel$, $B_T$ and $B_N$ are shown in blue, purple and orange, respectively. Each component is plotted normalised to $\bar {B}$ (vertical axis $B_i/\bar B$) versus normalised distance $l/(aL_\perp )$, emphasising how component behaviour and $|\boldsymbol{B}|$ evolve with expansion.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Evolution of SB fraction ($f_{z} \geqslant z_{\textrm {th}}$) in MR-$\varPhi _0= 0^\circ$ (solid) and MR-$\varPhi _0=2^\circ$ (dashed lines). Both runs produce SBs, but the PS case exhibits systematically larger SB fractions across effectively all $a$ and a stronger growth of large-angle deflections with $a$ up to the point where fluctuation amplitudes decline; the downturn in ($f_{z} \geqslant z_{\textrm {th}}$) at the largest $a$ is caused by the overall decrease in fluctuation amplitude. Right panel: the amplitude $z^+/v_{\textrm {A}}$ versus $a$ for all the simulations listed in the table 1. Dotted black lines show the WKB expectation for a radial field ($z^+/v_{\textrm {A}} \propto a^{1/2}$) or azimuthally dominated field ($z^+/v_{\textrm {A}} \propto a^{-1/2}$).

Figure 14

Figure 14.Evolution of (a) magnetic compressibility $C_B$, and (b) density fluctuation amplitude $\delta \rho _{\textrm {rms}}/\langle \rho \rangle$ for the MR$-\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,2^\circ ,5^\circ$ simulations. All cases start with relatively large $C_B$ because of the linearly polarised initial conditions.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Solutions to the linear expanding incompressible MHD equations, for radial magnetic field ($\varPhi _0 = 0^\circ$; left) and PS ($\varPhi _0 = 5^\circ$; right). Initial conditions are a pure outward perturbation set by the normalised polarisation $\tilde {\boldsymbol{z}}^+(a=1)=\boldsymbol k_0\times \bar {\boldsymbol B}$ and $\boldsymbol z^-(a=1)=0$. The other parameters used are ($|\boldsymbol k_0|=2\pi$, $\theta _{p0}=70^\circ$, $\varphi =90^\circ$), but results do not depend strongly on these choices. Solid lines show the outgoing component $|\boldsymbol z^+|$ and dashed lines the inward component $|\boldsymbol z^-|$; colours label different $\varDelta \in \{8.6,4.3,1.3,0.4,0.1\}$ (legend). The grey vertical dashed line marks $\varPhi =45^\circ$ as a guide.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Snapshot of $|\boldsymbol{z}^\pm _\perp |/|\boldsymbol{z}^\pm _\perp |_{\textrm {rms}}$ in the $y$–$z$ plane at $a=39$ for MR-$\varPhi _0=5^\circ$ run showing the onset of grid-scale, speckle-like noise at large spiral angle.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Time series of the outward energy for the MR-$\varPhi _0=0^\circ ,2^\circ ,5^\circ$ runs. The red curve is an additional run with $k_{\textrm {peak}} = (3.0, 3.0)$ and ($\varPhi _0 =10^\circ$), included to illustrate the behaviour at larger expansion $a$ ($\varPhi \gtrsim 70^\circ$). The red shaded region marks the time at which inward energy increases abruptly for $\varPhi _0=10^\circ$ run.