The news that the 2015 Pulitzer Prize in History would go to Elizabeth Fenn's Encounters at the Heart of the World: A History of the Mandan People came as no surprise to scholars in Native American and Indigenous Studies.Footnote 1 We have become proudly accustomed to the fact that books focused on early North American aboriginal history win some of the major prizes in the profession. As important as prize recognitions, however, those books—along with a host of equally excellent work (much of it cited in this Forum's introductory essay)—have changed the very nature of our understanding of the early American past. They have pried open old colonial histories, insisted on a longue durée of Indigenous power that stretched well into the nineteenth century, and complicated dualistic black-white understandings of race and slavery. We can now recognize, for example, that North America was a veritable continent of slavery, a global meeting place of slave systems that featured scores of Indigenous forms of slavery, all placed in dynamic motion in relation to the complex power dynamics attached to various colonial and imperial encounters. We now debate the terms and chronologies used to describe Indigenous political formations—empire, nation, confederacy, social formation—and we understand these to be co-constitutive with an uneven movement from contesting empires to an imperial nation-state in North America.Footnote 2 Less visible, perhaps, but equally important has been a body of work concerned with American Indians in the twentieth century, a historiography somewhat difficult to date, but marked in my mind by Hazel Hertzberg's 1971 Search for an American Indian Identity: Modern Pan-Indian Movements. Hertzberg introduced to the scholarly world a critical body of Native intellectuals and activists, Indian progressives who, in Frederick Hoxie's words, “talked back to civilization.”Footnote 3 Subsequent scholarship has revealed rich historical complication: Indigenous political organizing in tribal, national, and international contexts, military service in multiple wars, major shifts in federal policy and legal decision making, social and cultural challenges and innovations, and the ongoing dynamics of settler colonialism.Footnote 4 But if the early American historiography emphasizes Indigenous power—formulated, in the classic sense, by Richard White, who argued that equivalence of power was the defining aspect of the “middle ground”—the twentieth century offers a story of highly differentiated power, the uneven relationships visible in the aftermath of American military conquest and ongoing efforts to implement social, economic, political, and cultural subjugation of Indigenous people.
In that context, it has made sense to situate recent Indian histories at smaller scales—the community, the organization, the family, the reservation, the individual life. In these settings, both structural domination and complex forms of engagement and resistance become visible and compelling sites for analysis. Connecting nineteenth and twentieth centuries, for example, Frederick Hoxie's Parading Through History reveals complicated social, political, and economic dynamics among Crow people. Melissa Meyer's emblematic community study focuses on the White Earth Ojibwe reservation. Nicolas Rosenthal and James LaGrand have explored urban Indian communities in Los Angeles and Chicago, while Brenda Child's My Grandfather's Knocking Sticks begins with an exploration of her grandparents' Bureau of Indian Affairs files.Footnote 5
One might argue that scholarship on the twentieth century reflects significant shifts in the narrative strategies of American Indian history. In earlier writings, federal policy created a narrative center, a point of commonality around which individual tribes might be arrayed. The more tightly focused studies of the twentieth century invited scholars to unravel the complexities of uneven power at a scale that allowed one to find agency and negotiation less visible as part of a national story of American conquest and Indian defeat. What was lost, however, was the opportunity to synthesize across Indigenous histories in order to build new and powerful master narratives.Footnote 6
This question—of the power of a master narrative that centers Indian experiences—matters, for there are centrifugal forces pushing Indigenous histories outward, toward the margins. Powerful ideological structures surrounding the West, Indian “vanishing,” and American self-recognition continue to whisper quietly but persistently that Indian people are somehow outside of history. The relatively small demographic presence of Indian people in the United States maps on to an assumption that Indian histories—while of course tragic—are essentially finished. They easily slide into occasions for emotional catharsis rather than accountability and serious engagement. The ways that we have centered critical inquiries into race on a black-white paradigm have continued to leave Indigenous histories at the edges of important social and theoretical concerns.
In the nineteenth century, slavery, the Civil War, and Reconstruction trump conquest, the Indian Wars, and the reservation era. In the twentieth, African Americans organizing around civil rights trumps Indians organizing around citizenship, treaty rights, and sovereignty. Analyses of the rise of the New Deal state gesture to the Indian New Deal, but fail to see the global significance of its formations of indirect governance. Indians may have been part of the urban histories of the post-World War II period, but the policies of Termination and Relocation seem a footnote to the larger demography of human movement. Indeed, the reduction of twentieth-century Indian populations to something on the order of 1 percent of the U.S. population testifies both to the logic of settler colonialism (“the elimination of the Native,” as Patrick Wolfe has phrased it) and to the difficulties for historians of seeing Indigenous pasts in a situation of unevenness and domination.Footnote 7 The affective feeling of Gerald Vizenor's coined word survivance—survival and resistance in a complex world of both material and ideological power—aptly captures a twentieth-century dynamic, in which the defiant—but relatively weak—claim “we are still here!” replaces, say, the Comanche claim to an empire that stretched into Northern Mexico.Footnote 8
I have tried in the preceding paragraphs to bracket the period between the Civil War and the New Deal. If what came before was in many cases contests of unevenly but often closely matched power, and what came after was characterized by extreme imbalances in power, then one might point to the Gilded Age and Progressive Era as containing a set of critical moments during which those changes took place. In a broad sense, the period offers historians the chance to do what historians do: explain change over time that moves human conditions from one state of possibility to another. How did the American state constitute itself anew through forms of military power, territorial control, population surveillance, social relations, and cultural production that were both residual and emergent? How did Indian peoples perpetuate political structures and cultural coherence in the face of military domination, land loss, and extraordinary cultural repression? What did it mean to Indian people to suddenly become a small minority within an imperial nation-state? How did new American economies centered on industrial production, continental and global transportation, highly abstracted value, and accompanying forms of speculation sit in relation to the resources and labor relations made possible by the acquisition of Indian land and the domination of Indian people? How would Indians adjust to the imposition of capitalist markets and social relations?
As the contributors to this Forum demonstrate so well, there are significant and telling insights to be gained from placing an American history defined by periodization in dialogue with an Indigenous history defined by Indian social and political formations. This dialogue will likely be characterized by the complication of what has been a classic analytical pairing in American history: on the one hand, the black movement from slavery to freedom to civil rights; on the other, the paradoxical rise of the United States as an empire of liberty. Together, these have offered a powerful narrative firmly and beautifully anchored by the trauma of the Civil War, a centering event that generates cause-and-effect genealogies stretching across the entire fabric of U.S. history. Indigenous histories offer analytical and narrative possibilities that unsettle this pairing, visible, for example, in works by Tiya Miles, Barbara Krauthammer, David Chang, and Claudio Saunt (among others), who have complicated black-white binaries and familiar histories in powerful ways.Footnote 9 Or consider recent work by historians who have viewed the Civil War as a Western struggle, or—alternatively—see the wars of Western dispossession as reverberations of the Civil War.Footnote 10
The Forum contributors imagine similar linkages, overlaps, and dialogues: the relation of military, police, and civilian authority in Reconstruction and on the Reservation; the nature of citizenship and the still-forming state; the place of subaltern people in the booming culture industries; and the specificities of local, contextual, and complex racial projects even in the midst of what Michael Omi and Howard Winant have usefully described as broad racial formations—such things as the rise of Jim Crow, the legitimating discourses of scientific racism, various forms of immigrant exclusion, the contradictory desires associated with primitivism, and imperialist nostalgia.Footnote 11 As important, however, Indigenous histories should push all historians of the United States to take seriously the nature of colonialism and imperialism during a period of transition and continuity. Indeed, on this topic the conversation has visibly changed over the last decades. At one time, scholars rarely made the connection between continental and overseas empire. Then it appeared as a kind of obligatory gesture, a wave at North America even as the focus turned offshore, and 1898 became a ritual marker that kept imperialism and colonialism offshore as surely as 1890 kept Indian people locked in the nineteenth-century past.Footnote 12 Contemporary scholarship is marked by increasingly textured understandings of the coexistent and co-constituent relation between ongoing settler colonial (also imperial) practices in North America with the practices of empire overseas.
The pieces in this Forum demonstrate that there are many other opportunities for similar reevaluation and reexamination. They suggest that, in a number of contexts, the overriding questions of historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era and of Native North America overlap to the point that they are often indistinguishable. In their introduction, Boyd Cothran and Joseph Genetin-Pilawa ask for the conversation to begin. As you come to the end of this Forum, I think you will agree with me that it has indeed begun—and done so in an extraordinary and promising way.
