Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T14:39:00.180Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Why DO dove: Evidence for register variation in Early Modern English negatives

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 September 2005

Anthony Warner
Affiliation:
University of York
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The development of “supportive” (or “periphrastic”) DO in English suffered a curious and sharp reversal late in the 16th century in negative declaratives and questions according to Ellegård's (1953) database, with a recovery late in the following century. This article examines the variation between DO and the full verb in negative declaratives in this database, from 1500 to 1710. It is shown that both register variation and age-grading are relevant, and that the periods 1500–1575 and 1600–1710 have radically distinct properties. The second period shows substantial age-grading, and is interpreted as having introduced a fresh evaluative principle governing register variation. Negative questions supply data that suggest that the development of clitic negation may have been implicated in the development of the new evaluation. This change in evaluation accounts for the apparent reversal in the development of DO, and we can abandon the view that it was a consequence of grammatical restructuring.I want very sincerely to thank Tony Kroch for giving me an electronic version of the database used by Ellegård (1953), in an act of straightforward generosity; also Ann Taylor for her work in compiling it, and Celeste Tereszczuk who completed this task. I am also grateful to the British Academy who funded a period of research leave which gave me time to investigate this, and to audiences at ICEHL 12 (held at the University of Santiago), at the Linguistics Research Seminar at the University of York, and at NWAVE 32 for their comments.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
© 2005 Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

DO in negative declaratives 1600–1710

Figure 1

Proportion of DO for 1655 versus lexical complexity, 1600–1710.

Figure 2

Occurrence of DO in texts of low versus high lexical complexity 1600–1710

Figure 3

DO in negative declaratives 1500–1575

Figure 4

Proportion of DO for 1535 versus lexical complexity, 1500–1575.

Figure 5

Occurrence of DO in texts of low versus high lexical complexity 1500–1575

Figure 6

DO versus date in texts of lower lexical complexity.

Figure 7

DO versus date in texts of higher lexical complexity.

Figure 8

Superimposed running averages from Figures 3 and 4.

Figure 9

Incidence of DO in negative declaratives in the Helsinki Corpus

Figure 10

DO in negative declaratives 1500–1575

Figure 11

DO in negative declaratives 1600–1710

Figure 12

DO for 1655 versus age of author. 1600–1710.

Figure 13

Occurrence of DO in texts by younger versus older authors 1600–1710

Figure 14

Variation between Auxiliary + pronoun subject + NOT and Auxiliary + NOT + pronoun subject in negative questions in the Helsinki Early Modern English Corpus

Figure 15

Variation between DO + pronoun subject + NOT and DO + NOT + pronoun subject in negative questions 1500–1599

Figure 16

Variation between DO + pronoun subject + NOT and DO + NOT + pronoun subject in negative questions 1600–1710

Figure 17

Variation in negative questions with a personal pronoun subject between lexical verb, DO + pronoun subject + NOT, and DO + NOT + pronoun subject

Figure 18

Order of NOT and personal pronoun subjects in negative questions 1500–1710