Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 April 2026
Indo-European consonantal noun-declension shows, as is well known, the following endings for the singular and plural (the dual is not discussed at this point):
1 For noun-accent in Lithuanian see, most recently, N. van Wijk, Die baltischen und slavischen Akzent-und Intonationssysteme 42-60, Amsterdam, 1923; T. Torbiörnsson, Die litauischen Akzentverschiebungen und der litauische Verbalakzent 10-26, Heidelberg, 1924; G. Bonfante, in Studi baltici 1. 76 sqq. (1931).
2 Apparently for *tàm, with compensatory lengthening for loss of -m (K. Brugmann, Grundriss der vergleichenden Grammatik der indogermanischen Sprachen2 1. 389, Strasbourg, 1897-1916).
3 For the accent—one would expect circumflexes, but άμαρτή is explicitly attested by Aristarchus—see O. A. Danielson, Grammatische und etymologische Studien 1. 13, Upsala, 1888; H. Hirt, Indogermanische Grammatik 5. 287, Heidelberg, 1929.
4 The termination is of uncertain origin (references in J. Endzelin, Lettische Grammatik 306, Heidelberg, 1923). It seems identical with that seen in OCSlav. kamen-e, sloves-e, etc., and perhaps with the -a of the Skt. dat. type of
(Hirt, Grammatik 3. 10-11, Heidelberg, 1927; cf. Brugmann, 2. 1. 185-6), possibly even with -a < *-o in Kanis. šuppi-y-a, genu-w-a (Gray, in JA 218. 324 [1931]). Torbiörnsson (Akzentverschiebungen 24-5; cf. van Wijk, Intonationssysteme 65), however, derives it from -e < -ēn (*namie͂-ēn > *
> *nami-e >
).
5 For the formation of these three cases on the neut. plur. *toi, see below, p. 189.
6 For various explanations of this difficult form, see E. Kieckers, Handbuch der vergleichenden gotischen Grammatik 108, Munich, 1928; H. Hirt, Handbuch des Urgermanischen 2. 32, Heidelberg, 1932.
7 A. Meillet, Le Slave commun 337, 354, Paris, 1924.
8 Cf. Hirt, Grammatik 2. 175-6, Heidelberg, 1921; 3. 42-4. Does this alternation likewise explain such formations as Greek λίθεος,
,
< *
, *
,
(cf. also Ion.
< *
)?
9 For the formation of these three cases on the nom. plur. fem. *tāi, *təi, see below, p. 189.
10 For the current explanations of
:
, etc., cf. Brugmann-Thumb, Griechische Grammatik4 178, Munich, 1913.
11 Cf. A. Meillet, Esquisse d'une grammaire comparée de l'arménien classique 48, Vienna, 1903; Stolz-Schmalz, Lateinische Grammatik6 289-90, Munich, 1928. With the type of *ĝéno/es-o one may compare such adjectival formations in -o- to stems in -o/es as Skt. rajas-ά-, tamas-ά-, rabhas-ά-, Greek
< *
(cf. OHGerm. kilbir-a),
< *
,
< *
-, Lat. creperum < *crepos-o- (cf. crepus-culum), OHGerm. egisa (cf. Goth. agis, Greek
), Lith. znalesa (cf. Lat. holus); and with the type of *
, Skt. uṣas-yá-, Greek
< *
,
<
Lat. Venerius < *
(Brugmann 2. 2. 543-4, 192).
12 In Mélanges de linguistique offerts à . . . F. de Saussure 123-52, Paris, 1908. The view of H. Ehrlich (Untersuchungen über die Natur der griechischen Betonung 66-79, Berlin, 1912) and Kent (in Language 6. 310-2 [1930]) that this ī represents an old loc. in -ei seems less probable (cf. Stolz-Schmalz 268-9). J. Schrijnen ('De latijnsche genitief singularis van de o-stammen', in Mededeelingen der koninklijke akademie van wetenschappen te Amsterdam, Afd. Letterkunde, 67, series A, no. 4, Amsterdam, 1929) regards the Italic forms as borrowed from the pre-Indo-European peoples of Italy; and H. Möller (KZ 49. 219-29 [1920]) seeks parallels between Indo-European and Semitic (cf. the Arab. 'genitive' maliki 'of a king'). For the types in -ī, cf. also Hirt, Gram. 4. 305, Heidelberg, 1928.
13 This interpretation appears more plausible than the current view (e.g. Stolz-Schmalz 202, 248), which considers i as weakened from u < o, though that u is probably found in the types locu-ples, Comatu-marus. For the Gaulish forms see A. Holder, Alt-Celtischer Sprachschatz 2. 2, Leipzig, 1896 sqq.
14 For such interpretations, see Brugmann-Thumb 265, 295, 461-2, 410-2; Hirt, Grammatik 3. 51-2.
15 Cf. L. H. Gray, in AJPh 51. 273-85 (1930).
16 Cf. Brugmann-Thumb 217-8.
17 Meillet, Esquisse 47. For the Kanisian types hûmand-aš, ammêl, see Gray, in JA 218. 322-3.
18 Meillet, Slave 378-9; Endzelin, Grammatik 372-4; H. Pedersen, Vergleichende Grammatik der keltischen Sprachen 2.168, Göttingen, 1909-13. For other explanations of the OPruss. forms, see R. Trautmann, Altpreussische Denkmäler 262, Göttingen, 1910; N. van Wijk, Altpreussische Studien 58-9, The Hague, 1918. For Skt. máma see Meillet, in Bulletin of the School of Oriental Studies 6. 435-7 (1931).
19 Cf. C. Uhlenbeck, 'Agens und Patiens im Kasussystem der indogermanischen Sprachen', in IF 12 (1901). 170-1 (cf. KZ 41. 400 [1907]), denied by Hirt, Grammatik 3. 391. Meillet, in MSLP 20. 176-8 (1916), considers that the neuter type of Skt. yugám, Greek
, is itself a stem-form, and that -m is here not an inflexional ending, as it is in the acc. masc. type of Skt.
, Greek
, in which connexion it may be noteworthy that Kanisian shows the neut. sing, type irmala as contrasted with the acc. sing. masc. irmalan < *-om. Hirt, Grammatik 3. 86-94, regards the neut. -om as a determinant.
20 Cf. Meillet, in MSLP 18. 433-4 (1913).
21 Cf. Meillet, in MSLP 22. 52 (1922).
22 Here, perhaps, belong Greek adjectives of the type of τοῖος (the type of
is apparently built on the 'indefinite case' of the type of χαμαί), despite the genitival types τοῖ ο, οοιο (for other explanations see Brugmann-Thumb 212-3; H. Hirt, Handbuch der griechischen Laut-und Formenlehre2 436, Heidelberg, 1912). Hermann (
217-9), less probably, thinks that the plural -oi was carried through from the loc. sing. of the noun. For the vexed question of OHGerm. dei, cf. Brugmann, Die distributiven und kollektiven Numeralia der indogermanischen Sprachen 60, Leipzig, 1907.
23 So most recently by Thumb-Hirt, Handbuch des Sanskrit2 178, 495, Heidelberg, 1930; cf. Brugmann 2. 2. 152-3.
24 Brugmann 2. 1.253-4.
25 For further details, see below, p. 192-3.
26 Cf. Brugmann 2. 2. 76-7, 80, 795, 820; E. W. Fay in AJPh 32. 408-9 (1911).
27 Cf. Sturtevant, in Language 8.1-10 (1932). Whether one may safely put Greek adverbs of the type of
< *
here seems doubtful, for one would then expect
(cf. πούς < *πότ-ς < *-
); and the type of οὕτ beside οὕτως is ambiguous, since it was more probably an instr. than a loc. The most plausible explanation of the final -s here still seems to be that of Brugmann 2. 2. 700, 737-8. The Turfanian abl. wramäṣ as distinguished from the gen. wramis is considered to contain the postposition -ṣu (W. Schulze, E. Sieg, and W. Siegling, Tocharische Grammatik 36, 294, Göttingen, 1931).
28 'Quelques remarques sur le sens du génitif indo-européen', in Festschrift Vilhelm Thomsen . . . dargebracht 21-3, Leipzig, 1912, and MSLP 22. 50.
29 A case-ending -t seems to recur in the Kanis. instr. type irmalita (conventionally read irmalit), Greek κατά, OWelsh cant < *kṃ-ta, Greek μ∊τά, Lat. ita, ali-uta (Gray, in JA 218. 324-5).
30 OPruss. mensan, krawian, etc., considered instr. by Trautmann 226-7, are regarded as acc. by van Wijk, Studien 81 sqq. (but cf. OCSlav. krŭvnija̜.). For OPruss. schisman, see Trautmann 264; for the OPruss. instr. māim, ib. 269-70 and van Wijk 92-3; for examples in OLith., B. Bezzenberger, Beiträge zur Geschichte der litauischen Sprache 133-4, Göttingen, 1877. Here also belongs the Phryg. dat. σεμουν (cf. J. Fraser, in Transactions of the Cambridge Philological Society 6. 2. [1913] 10. 12).
31 It is generally recognised that the rule whereby -ι appears before consonants, but -ιν before vowels ('νῦ
, e,g. εὐ
'
, but
), is a late development (cf. Brugmann-Thumb 168-9). Outside Attic-Ionic, this -v is found only in the dat. plur. in Thessalian and Heraclean (C. D. Buck, Greek Dialects 78, rev. ed., Boston [1928]).
32 For other explanations, see Brugmann-Thumb 291; Hirt, Formenlehre 423; J. Wackernagel, Sprachliche Untersuchungen zu Homer 138-9, Göttingen, 1916. For the distribution of the forms, see F. Bechtel, Griechische Dialekte 1. 74; 2.124, 189, 254, 403, 584, 605, 736, Berlin, 1921-24.
33 F. G. Aleksandrov, 'On the Declension of -o-Stems in Sanskrit' (Russian), in Uč. zapiski v školy g. Odessy 2. 108-13 (1922) (known to me only from Indogermanisches Jahrbuch 11. 138 [1927]), considers the pre-form to have been *
, on the pattern of the plur. Whether such Arm. local adverbs as astēn, aststin < *-in, *-en belong here seems uncertain (cf. Meillet, Esquisse 63, 69); they suggest, rather, the postpositional -en of Osc. exaisc-en, Umb. arven < *arve-en.
34 For a summary of the various explanations, see Kieckers 108; Hirt, Urgermanisch 2.32. Hirt, Grammatik 3. 60, 86-97, considers the element as < *o/em, which appears without case-value at least in Skt. ah-ām, mahy-ām, ay-ām. He denies (ib. 54-6) that -s in *-bhi-s originally had a pluralising force.
35 On the problem of bh/m see A. Meillet, Les Dialectes indo-européens 119-23, Paris, 1908.
36 For explanations of the form, see Wackernagel-Debrunner, Altindische Grammatik 3. 107, Göttingen, 1931. Whether the type of OCSlav. rody belongs here, as Meillet (Slave 356) holds, seems not wholly certain.
37 Cf. above, p. 187. For Lith. auluosè, algosè beside OLith. namasu, dienosu, see Endzelin 300.
38 For the whole problem of the Celt. forms, see F. Sommer, 'Das keltische Dual', in Miscellany Presented to Kuno Meyer 129-41, Halle, 1912, and for the Teut., most recently, Kieckers 174. Greek άλγᾱ' is formed by analogy with αύλώ.
39 J. Plākis, Leišu valodas rokas grāmata 60, Riga, 1926.
40 Cf. R. Thurneysen, Handbuch des Alt-Irischen 148, Heidelberg, 1909. The difference in accentuation between the Lith. dat. dual aulám, algóm and the instr. aulam̃, algõm is scarcely original (Brugmann, 2. 2. 202-3).
41 Buck 316-7 thinks that Διυ μοιυν 'appears to contain an inherited u connected with the u-diphthong attested by the Sanskrit and Slavic dual forms (Skt. táyos, ChSl. toju). The -αιυν is analogical, like αιν after -οιν'. Derivation of the type of ἵππιιν from *ek̂ṷoi-u-i- (A. Cuny, Le Nombre duel en grec 36-7, Paris, 1906, La Catégorie du duel dans les langues indo-européennes et chamito-sémitiques 47, 60-1, Brussels, 1930), or from a pre-form in *-οισιν (cf. Brugmann-Thumb 272; Hirt, Grammatik 3. 67) seems less probable than the view suggested in the text.
42 Cf. the rendering of (πτ̑ωσυς) γενi κή by (holev) serakan 'generic' in the Arm. version of the grammar of Dionysios Thrax (ed. Cierbed 34, 52, Paris, 1830; cf. ser = γ ∊νος, ib. 50).
43 Cf. Meillet, Introduction àl'étude comparative des langues indo-européennes5 151-3, 217-21, Paris, 1922.
44 Cf. Brugmann 2. 1. 156-66.
45 One cannot assume *pedo-, for the types of Greek
, Lith. aũlas, Lat. servus, Gaul. Andecamulos, OCSlav. rabŭ presuppose *-os, not *-os, ‘šwā secundum’ giving a in Greek, Italic, and Celtic, i in Lithuanian, and ĭ in Slavic.
46 Contrast, for example, Skt. bhárāmi, bhárāmas with dádāmi, dadmás.