Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 April 2026
The history of science records many illustrations of the human inclination to cling to a neat generalization regardless of the evidence behind it. Within our own field we may mention the classification of languages as inflected, agglutinating, or isolating; and the obviously false dogma that phonetic laws operate without exception.
1 Grundriss der Vergleichenden Grammatik der Indo-germanischen Sprachen 1. 289f. (1886).
2 Von Bradke, Über Methode und Ergebnisse der Arischen Altertumswissenschaft 70; Brugmann, Grund. 1.2 543; Kurze Vergleichende Grammatik 157.
3 Die Indogermanische Sprachwissenschaft 53 (1925).
4 American Journal of Philology 32. 36-57 (1911).
5 So Whitney, Sanskrit Grammar 16; Brugmann, KVG 44.
6 It may be objected that Indo-European g [
] must have suffered some change before the Aryan change of gw [gw] to g' [
] before e and i. This argument was, in fact, advanced long ago by Collitz, Bezzenberger's Beiträge zur Kunde der Indogermanischen Sprachen 3.179 (1879). It is only necessary to assume, however, that original
and g w] gw] before e and i were distinguished in some way during the Aryan period. Probably the former was pronounced further forward in the mouth than the latter, but it certainly was not a sibilant or even an affricate.
7 Indogermanisches Jahrbuch 1. 14-17 (1914).
8 Indogermanische Forschungen 42. 90-132 (1924).
9 See Kretschmer, Einleitung in die Geschichte der Griechischen Sprache 270 f. (1896); Idg. Sprachwissenschaft 19-22, 54 (1925).
10 Idg. Sprachwissenschaft 54.
11 Mitteilungen der Deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft 61. 26 (1921). He has been followed by Vendryes ap. Meillet and Cohen, Les Langues du Monde 21. In an article which reached me after this paper had gone to the printer, Kretschmer, Glotta 14. 300-19 takes the same position, and mentions the linguistic arguments which I have discussed in the text.
12 Forrer writes me he intended to say “noch nicht,” although “bereits” is printed.
13 Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft 76. 155 (1922).
14 Some Indo-European Coincidences in Hittite, Ottawa, Kas. (1925).
15 See Forrer, ZDMG 76. 217 (1922).
16 Die Boghazköi-Texte im Umschrift, Erster Band, Einleitung, Die Keilschrift von Boghazköi (1922).
17 So Vendryes, Revue Celtique 34. 129-142 (1913); Meillet, Idg. Jahrb. 1. 16 (1914).
18 Op. cit. 38 f., 41.