Published online by Cambridge University Press: 12 March 2026
It has been shown by Keenan & Comrie 1977 that restrictive relative clauses (RC's) in many or perhaps all languages are subject to several constraints which make reference to the Noun Phrase Accessibility Hierarchy and to a classification of RC's based on their surface-structure properties. It is argued here that our understanding of RC-formation in universal grammar is further enhanced if a modified version of the classification of RC's, proposed informally by Givón 1975, is used instead of the classification of Keenan & Comrie.
This is a thoroughly revised version of a paper delivered at the 1977 LSA Summer Meeting in Honolulu. I would like to thank Roger Higgins, Ed Keenan, Bernard Comrie, Fred House holder, and Robert Stockwell for a variety of helpful comments and criticisms on earlier WRITTEN versions. Most of these have been incorporated into the text in some fashion.
The following abbreviations are used in the text:
| AA | Afro-Asiatic |
| Aust. | Austronesian |
| CNPC | Complex Noun Phrase Constraint |
| DO | Direct Object |
| Dr. | Dravidian |
| GEN | Genitive |
| HC | Hierarchy Constraint |
| IE | Indo-European |
| IO | Indirect Object |
| NC | Niger-Congo |
| NPAH | Noun Phrase Accessibility Hierarchy |
| NPrel | Relativized Noun Phrase |
| NR-S | Non-Reduction Strategy |
| OBL | Oblique |
| OCOMP | Object of Comparison |
| Postnom | Postnominal |
| Prenom | Prenominal |
| PRO-S | Anaphoric Pronoun Strategy |
| RC | Restrictive Relative Clause |
| REL-S | Relative Pronoun Strategy |
| ST | Sino-Tibetan |
| SU | Subject |
| UA | Ural-Altaic |
| WO-S | Word Order Strategy |