Published online by Cambridge University Press: 12 March 2026
This paper juxtaposes two well-known competing hypotheses about the structure of resultative and descriptive sentences in Chinese. According to the P[rimary] P[redication] hypothesis, the second verb in a ...V1...V2... sequence is treated as the main verb of the sentence; according to the S[econdary] P[redication] hypothesis, the second verb is treated as a complement to the first. Three major arguments for PP are reviewed and shown not to be cogent, and an alternative analysis is proposed for each of the issues raised: the distribution of A-not-A questions, negation, aspect marking, and the properties of certain complex causative constructions. The otherwise peculiar distribution of the negative and A-not-A morphemes turns out to follow from a principle requiring them to be lexically realized in INFL, and a D-Structure analysis of complex causative sentences consistent with the SP hypothesis explains the related facts in a desirable way. Additional arguments for SP are presented which turn on certain facts of anaphora, verb reduplication, scope of negation, and tone sandhi.
Earlier versions of this article were presented at colloquia in 1986-87 at MIT, UCLA, Cornell University, CUNY Graduate Center, Tsing Hua University, at the 1986 International Conference on Sino-Tibetan Languages and Linguistics, and at the Centre de Recherches Linguistiques sur l'Asie Orientale (CRLAO), CNRS, Paris. Part of this research was carried out during my visit to the CRLAO in the summer of 1987, and I am grateful to my hosts, particularly François Dell, Alan Lucas, and Alan Peyraube, for their hospitality and assistance during my stay there. Among the many people in the audiences who have provided useful comments I am most grateful to Len Babby, John Bowers, Tom Ernst, Ken Hale, Audrey Li, Mei Kuang, Tim Stowell, Ting-Chi Tang, Sandy Thompson, Liejiong Xu, Moira Yip, and especially Tsulin Mei. In addition, C. L. Baker and Grant Goodall made a number of helpful suggestions on the penultimate version which led to considerable improvements in the final version.