No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 April 2026
[IH ъA became IE ə. IH ъ? became Hitt. a; IH ъx became Hitt. aḫ(ḫ); IH ъγ became Hitt. aḫ before a vowel, a before s.]
1 I assume four IH laryngeals:', a glottal stop of palatal color;
., a glottal stop of velar color; x, a voiceless velar spirant; and γ, a voiced velar spirant. A = any laryngeal; Ạ = either
. or x; E = either ‘ or γ;? = either ‘ or
.; H = ‘,
., or γ.
2 Mémoire sur le système primitif des voyelles dans les langues indo-européennes, especially 134–84, = Recueil des publications scientifiques de Ferdinand de Saussure 1–268, especially 127–73.
3 Here and elsewhere in this paper I substitute my own symbols and terms for those used by the scholars cited.
4 Especially Rev. de Phonétique 2.102 f.
5 De Hettitische Ḫ, een Bijdrage tot de Studie van het Indo-Europeesche Vocalisme 214–22.
6 Hittitisch and die anderen indoeuropäischen Sprachen 180.
7 Prace Filologiczne 11.232–4 (1927), Études indoeuropéennes 1.55–72 (1935).
8 Kurylowicz cites sēd- as containing ‘ə plus occlusive’; he does not give the meaning, and I do not know any such Indo-European combination. He does not give an illustration of ‘sonante plus ə‘, and so I have had to supply one.
9 Rev. de Phonétique 2.101–9.
10 In this and the next two paragraphs I write all laryngeals A so as not to anticipate the following argument from their probable phonetic character.
11 Brugmann, KVG 82.
12 Greek Adjectives in -αιος, to appear in CP 36 or 37.
13 On which see Greek Adjectives in -αιος.
14 Sapir, Lang. 14.269–74; Sturtevant, Pronunciation of Greek and Latin2 73 and fn. 43, Greek Adjectives in -αιος; Austin, Lang. 17.91.
15 F. de Saussure, BSL 7.cxviii; A. Cuny, Rev. de Phonétique 2.118–20; Kurylowicz, Ét. indoeuropéennes 1.46–50; Sturtevant, Lang. 16.180–2, 17.1–11.
16 Couvreur, De Hettitische Ḫ 217–21; cf. H. Pedersen, Hittitisch 180.
17 W. Petersen, JAOS 59.189 fn. 25, maintained that Hitt. sanḫḫ-, parḫḫ- and tarḫḫ- do not correspond to Skt. seṭ-verbs. He said that ‘Skt. sani- occurs only in sanitur “outside of, without”, which shows no semantic connection with Hitt. sanḫḫ-.’ He must have consulted p. 1141 of the Monier-Williams dictionary instead of p. 1140 under san-, where he would have found several indubitable seṭ-forms. He derived Skt. tárati from a ‘monosyllabic root’ and neglected the seṭ-forms cited above. He grudgingly admitted seṭ-forms in Gk. πϵράω and Goth. faran, but found the existence of such forms as Skt. piparti somehow comforting. He did not mention Hitt. walḫḫ-.
18 See HG 46 f.
19 The only exceptions I have noticed are: ša-na-aḫ-ti (KBo. 4.14.2.61, 65, 71) ša-na-aḫ-ta (KVB 19.67.2.10), wa-la-aḫ-zi (KBo. 3.23.1.6, 7, 4.9, 10).
20 So Holger Pedersen, Hittitisch 127.
21 So HG 143.
22 So HG 88.
23 Lang. 16.82.
24 Friedrich, IF 41.370 f.; Kurylowicz, EI 1.30, 74.
25 Schulze, QE 37; Sommer, Gr. Lautstudien 5–8.
26 Sturtevant, Lang. 16.81–7.
27 Lang. 16.86.
28 Sturtevant, Lang. 15.153 fn. 29, 16.84, 86.
29 On the etymology, see Sturtevant, Lang. 14.72 f.
30 Sturtevant, Lang. 16.276 and fn. 9, Greek Adjectives in -αιος, CP 36 or 37.
31 AJP 50.360–9, TAPA 60.33 f., Lang. 7.170, HG 114–6.
32 Hittitisch 89, 185 f.
33 Sturtevant, Lang. 14.239–44.
34 Evidence for loss of Hitt. ḫ between consonants has been alleged in gen. esnas from esḫar ‘blood’, but see above p. 186.