Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 April 2026
While the cyclic application of a phonological rule hinges upon the erasure of inner labeled brackets or phrase boundaries, the late (or post-cyclic) pitch assignment rules of Japanese crucially depend on the information provided by the inner phrase boundaries. Thus we find a basic incompatibility between the principle of the transformational cycle and the nature of Japanese accentuation. This paper first points out a serious flaw in McCawley's cyclic analysis of the accentual system of Japanese, and then offers a non-cyclic re-analysis. Since English is being decycled by a number of people, what follows helps to further weaken the theory of the transformational cycle in phonology.