Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 April 2026
For more than a generation now the bulk of scientific linguistic publication in America has been devoted to descriptive linguistics and the vast majority of the last generation of students of linguistics have devoted themselves largely to that field. The larger measure of scientific advance has accompanied the larger measure of devotion. That is to be expected. There have, of course, been notable exceptions. But I believe the facts will bear me out in my observation that these notable exceptions have been due to the continued labors of an older generation of scholars.
1 The recent articles by Tedesco in Language and elsewhere are happy contributions to the future Sanskrit etymological dictionary.
2 I have no intention of belittling the scholarship or the contributions of Émil Boisacq. At the time of the publication of the first edition, his dictionary was a valuable repertory of Greek etymology.
3 Cf. Brugmann, Grundriss 2.3.48 ff.
4 Ibid. 336 ff., 390 ff.
5 Comparative grammar of the Hittite language 228 ff.
6 Buck, Grammar of Oscan and Umbrian 169.
7 Cf. Pedersen, Vgl. Gramm, d. kelt. Sprachen 2.355.
8 Sieg, Siegling, and Schulze, Tocharische Grammatik 364.
9 Ibid. 385.
10 Cf. Couvreur, Hoofdzaken van de tochaarse Klank- en Vormleer 73.
11 For the Hittite forms and comparisons see Sturtevant, op.cit. 239 f.
12 Tocharisch vom Gesichtspunkt der indogermanischen Sprachvergleichung 153.
13 The question of the origin of the -t as from IH dh, vs. -ti (to be read as -te) = IE -tai, is of no consequence here. For this argument cf. Sturtevant, op.cit. 263-4.
14 Op.cit. 266 f.
16 The novel thesis of P. Kretschmer, in Objektive Konjugation im Indogermanischen (Sitzungsberichte d. Österr. Akad. d. Wissensch., Phil.-hist. Kl., Vol. 225, Abhl. 2, 1947), that the s of the s-aorist is a remnant of an old oblique case form of the IE demonstrative *80, *sā, if acceptable, does not of course affect the above contentions regarding the identity of the various s-formations. It will be necessary, however, to show for all of them the original ‘objective’ (i.e. transitive) value assumed on a very meager basis for the s-aorist. If that can be done, then we have added materially to the creditability of Kretschmer’s hypotheses and also of my own.