Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 January 2026
We present new data on peer review practices in linguistics journals, reporting the results of an online survey of editors. This paper aims to increase understanding of the processes and practices of peer review for everyone involved—editors, authors, reviewers, and readers. Apprehending concretely how peer review happens from beginning to end and how editors think about it should help to demystify the process, especially for graduate students and early career researchers, and make the experience somewhat less stressful across the board. Editors, authors, and reviewers all share, we trust, a desire for high professional standards and best practices. We hope to stimulate further discussion of these issues in the field and development of field-wide standards.
We thank members of the Committee of Editors of Linguistics Journals for sharing their practices of peer review with us, in the survey and far beyond it. This paper has been shaped by discussions and comments from many people, and we are grateful to Lubie Alatriste, Claire Bowern, Ewa Czaykowska-Higgins, Robin Dodsworth, Katie Drager, Peter Grund, Mirva Johnson, Lex Konnelly, Jorge Rosés Labrada, Samantha Litty, Monica Macaulay, Onowa McIvor, Christine Mallinson, Carolina Amador Moreno, David Natvig, Panayiotis Pappas, and Tom Purnell for providing feedback and sharing their reflections with us. We also thank Sophia Chan, who provided keen research assistance, and Denae Dyck, who provided meticulous copyediting support. We benefited greatly from feedback from Andries Coetzee and John Beavers. The usual disclaimers apply.