Published online by Cambridge University Press: 02 January 2018
The recent spate of cases successfully relying on CPR 19.6 has failed to clarify the content of the ‘same interest’ required by the rule. Interpretation of ‘same interest’ must give effect to the overriding objective set out in CPR 1.1(1), which provides that cases must be dealt with ‘justly’ and ‘fairly’. In line with the aspirations of the new Civil Procedure Rules, the overriding objective emphasises improving access to justice and reducing the costs of litigation. A number of recent decisions permitting reliance on CPR 19.6 make particular reference to the rule's potential to achieve these goals. However, reducing costs is only one goal of civil procedure and it is argued that whether a procedure, or its use in particular circumstances, is just or fair depends on balancing those purposes and principles of civil procedural law which it supports against those which it inhibits. This article demonstrates how balanced reference to the principles of procedure supports a test for ‘same interest’ based on finding ‘a common question of law or fact’.