Published online by Cambridge University Press: 02 January 2018
In a previous article in Legal Studies I suggested a general framework of rules for analysing problems of restitution which arise from ineffective transactions. It was explained that normally a claim should be available to a party who has performed his part, usually based on mistake or failure or consideration, or on ‘policy’ grounds. A benefit to the recipient of goods and services will usually be shown by the fact that in making the agreement he requested the performance Problems may arise, however, when the factor which renders the contract unenforceable also provides an argument against allowing a claim in restitution. One problem which arises frequently with goods and services is that the factor which vitiates the contract makes it difficult to show a benefit. For example, when the defendant mistakes the nature of the goods which he is purchasing, it may be impossible to say that he requested them for the purpose of showing they are of benefit to him.