Published online by Cambridge University Press: 02 January 2018
History, as much as logic, has shaped the English real property law of today. The richness of that history is one of its strengths, but is also a potential source of weakness, as where the boundaries between similar, but distinct rights are neither theoretically nor logically distinguished. Whilst this may often not be of practical concern, none the less a lack of logic may lead to inconsistency or uncertainty in the law (or indeed both). Particularly is this so where social pressures require protection for new situations, as for example where a flat owner requires the certainty that his right to park his car is a proprietary right.
That provides one justification for seeking a strong and consistent theoretical framework. Another is that as we integrate more closely with our European partners, we may be compelled to accept into our thinking concepts which are at present alien to us.
The authors are grateful to Professors John Alder, John Bell and Mark Thompson for their helpful comments on an earlier draft of this article, and to Sarah Waters for her research assistance.
See Hunter v Canary Wharf Ltd [1997] 2 All ER 426 at 440, per Lord Goff.