No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 24 February 2006
Bringing Religion into International Relations. By Jonathan Fox and Shmuel Sandler. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004. 224p. $55.00.
With this book, Jonathan Fox and Shmuel Sandler offer the most comprehensive meditation to date on the question of religion as a factor in international relations. Stating as their central purpose a desire to “expand the boundaries of international relations theory by the inclusion of religion as a variable in the research of international politics” (p. 4), the authors provide a superbly structured overview of a topic that has been crying out for sustained engagement for some time now. While the questions asked (and many of the answers eventually posited) are by no means wholly original, Bringing Religion Into International Relations finally offers IR a systematic baseline of inquiry that subsequent scholarship on religion and international affairs can build upon or challenge.
With this book, Jonathan Fox and Shmuel Sandler offer the most comprehensive meditation to date on the question of religion as a factor in international relations. Stating as their central purpose a desire to “expand the boundaries of international relations theory by the inclusion of religion as a variable in the research of international politics” (p. 4), the authors provide a superbly structured overview of a topic that has been crying out for sustained engagement for some time now. While the questions asked (and many of the answers eventually posited) are by no means wholly original, Bringing Religion Into International Relations finally offers IR a systematic baseline of inquiry that subsequent scholarship on religion and international affairs can build upon or challenge.
The opening, and a recurrent, theme in the book relates to the question of why international relations theory has tended to ignore religion in its attempts to explain behaviors and outcomes in world politics. For Fox and Sandler, the answer lies in the Western-centric orientation of IR theory and—more specifically—its internalization of the Enlightenment norms of secularism and rationality. The authors seek to redress this shortcoming by establishing a place for religion as an explanatory variable in IR theory. After an opening that explores religion's absence from IR, the book proceeds through five chapters that offer distinct and valuable vantage points from which to engage the question of religion and IR. Signaling a welcome preference for analyzing religion primarily as a normative force in international politics, the authors begin by anchoring their argument in the idea of religion as a source of political legitimacy at a variety of levels of analysis. They then go on to explore the processes of linkage politics that allow seemingly domestic religious conflicts to take on international dimensions—with a particular emphasis on the impact of religion on conflict interventions. We move on to an examination of transnational religion as an ontological phenomenon within the international system in a chapter that focuses in large part on the Muslim world and political Islam.
The final two substantive chapters are also the book's most methodologically rigorous. Fox and Sandel are keen—with good reason—to make the point that their treatment of religion in this volume should not be confused with Samuel Huntington's largely (but only implicitly) religious definition of civilization in his infamous Clash of Civilizations thesis (1996). To this end, Chapter 6 of Bringing Religion offers an excellent overview of the Clash debate and then goes on via a cross-sectional comparative analysis of ethno-religious conflicts to provide further fodder for the empirical refutation of Huntington's theory. A subsequent chapter employs single case study methodology to explain the transformational dynamics whereby a conflict whose origins seem to contain a strong element of religion actually proceeds according to a rather different logic—in this case, focusing on the Palestinian-Israeli conflict and the role of religion in mobilizing and fostering legitimacy for a dispute whose core causes often more closely resembled those of secular intrastate conflict. The final chapter, tantalizingly entitled “Toward a Theory of International Relations and Religion,” proves, unfortunately, to be heavy on the “toward” and rather light on actual theory. After summarizing the key arguments and findings of the book, this concluding section offers a number of suggestions for future research agendas (such as the need for better metrics of religion in quantitative work) and also some reflections on the definitional quandaries posed by religion to IR and the social sciences more widely.
This latter insight provides a good entry point for outlining some of the book's shortcomings. Clearly aware from the very outset of the difficulties inherent in trying to define religion (a point first raised on p. 2), the authors get around the problem by choosing not to define religion. Their stated preference is one that tries to focus “not on what religion is, but what it does” (p. 176)—more specifically, by focusing on religion as a source of worldview, identity, legitimacy, and institutional basis. This approach arguably works for their immediate purposes in this book, but we would do well to hesitate to wade any more deeply into the tides of religion and world politics until we better understand the nature of the former. More specifically, it may well be that any attempt to develop and consistently operationalize religion as simply yet another explanatory variable will fall afoul of the critiques that have long been leveled at those, such as Robert Keohane, who argue similarly about gender and international relations. Indeed, the number of forces in the world that act as sources of identity, worldview, and legitimacy are so numerous that until we say something more specific about the nature of the worldviews and identities inculcated through sacred discourse, we will not get very far.
While this never claims to be the first-ever book on the subject, there do seem to be a number of points throughout the volume where insights offered by earlier writers on religion and IR do not seem to have been covered, critiqued, or even acknowledged in the bibliography. Without wanting to belabor the point or appear to expect that everything ever written about religion and world politics should have been included in this book, there are a number of earlier (mainly edited) books on religion and international affairs that might have deserved at least a nod—more specifically, Douglas Johnston and Cynthia Sampson's (eds.) Religion: The Missing Dimension of Statecraft (1995) and K.R. Dark's (ed.) Religion and International Relations (2000). Susanne Rudolph's (ed.) Transnational Religion and Fading States (1997) offers important insights on questions dealt with in Chapters 4 and 5. James Piscatori's Islam in a World of Nation-States (1986) and Adeed Dawisha's (1983) edited volume on Islam in Foreign Policy were both early and important engagements with the question of Islam's role in the international system. It is also worth pointing out that from within IR itself, scholars working in the vein of critical and poststructural theory have been profitably engaging religion as a source of meaning making for well over a decade now.
Finally, we might reasonably ask whether IR as a disciplinary project is even the best point of departure from which to try to understand the role of religion in world politics. Fields such as sociology and anthropology—often featuring “thicker” engagements (in the Geertzian sense) with the lived experience of religion as a system of world-ordering symbols and practices—have become increasingly sensitive to the transnational and global nature of contemporary life, while avoiding the sometimes stifling analytical constraints of state-centric IR.
None of this, however, should detract from the fact that Fox and Sandler have, with Bringing Religion, done the discipline of IR a singular service by giving us a first and desperately needed book-length monograph on religion and international relations—and one that certainly sets a strong standard of scholarship for future work in this increasingly important topic.