There has been a lot of discussion over the past decade about the relevance of institutions in political science. This has led to the emergence of an explanatory discipline, new institutionalism, a prominent social theory that focuses on developing a comprehensive study of institutions, the way they interact, and the effects of institutions on society—thus providing a way of viewing how institutions evolve in very different ways, or how institutions shape the behavior of individual members and produce change. In this collection of essays, edited by André Lecours, a case is made for the ways new institutionalism helps reframe and renew the theoretical and analytical importance of political institutions in the determination of a variety of political phenomena and outcomes, as a group of scholars—mainly from Canadian universities—address a set of complex issues related to new institutionalist research.
New institutionalism does not constitute a unified body of thought. Instead, Peter A. Hall and Rosemary C. R. Taylor (Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms, 1996) identify three schools of thought: historical institutionalism, rational choice institutionalism, and sociological institutionalism. Lecours begins the book with a review of the main conceptual, methodological, and epistemological differences among these three schools of thought and concludes that “there are different ways of conducting institutional analysis, and all of them bring their own insight to the study of politics” (p. 19). With this view that heterogeneity within new institutionalism does not preclude it from theoretical and analytical applicability, he sets the stage for the book's contributors to explore the value of different approaches in the debate over the place of institutions in political science.
There are five main sections in this book. The first includes three chapters and is devoted to theoretical reflections on new institutionalism. The contributions assess some of the main theoretical weaknesses inside the institutionalist framework. The authors revise and clarify crucial ambiguous concepts, starting with institution, and then considering others, such as ideas, interests, rationality, strategy, identities, or culture, to integrate them coherently with institutional analysis. Institutional change becomes another central aspect reviewed from an institutionalist perspective. The contributors also address questions regarding the theoretical distinctiveness of new institutionalism, including a critique of historical institutionalism (Chapter 4, “Institutions and Political Rationality,” by Hudson Meadwell).
The second section explores institutionalist theory in the study of Canadian politics in both English and French language scholarship. From methodological and epistemological positions closer to historical institutionalism, the two chapters in this section examine the presence of an institutionalist tradition and the extent of the new institutionalism in Canadian politics.
The third section searches into new institutionalism in comparative politics, paying special attention to possible explanations of sociopolitical change. Democratic transitions are the first topic in comparative politics analyzed from a historical institutionalist approach. Nationalism and party aggregation are the other two political processes closely studied, this time from a rational choice institutionalism angle.
The fourth section deals with some connections between new institutionalism and public policy analysis in three different cases. One case centers on the structure of policy networks and the behavior of groups in Westminster parliamentarism. Another case discusses the welfare state redesign involved in the logic of current policy experiments in both Britain and Canada. The last case takes the institutional structure of the American and Canadian political systems together with the dynamic of group interests to explain the failure of both governments—American and Canadian—to amend the Migratory Birds Convention. All the cases, therefore, illustrate the influence of institutions on policymaking, the mobilization of actors, and policy outcomes.
The fifth section focuses on new institutionalist analysis in the field of international relations. This provides insight into intricate issues such as war and peace, sovereignty, international personality, or diplomatic recognition. Institutional elements become pertinent to democratic states' likelihood to engage in warfare (Chapter 13 by Norrin M. Ripsman). Additionally, institutional isomorphism—the tendency to be structurally identical—plays a role in the global institutionalization of “One China,” as well as in the spread of the European concept of state among East Asian politics (Chapter 14 by Der-yuan Maxwell Wu, and Chapter 15 by Jeremy Paltiel, respectively).
The wide range of perspectives included in this book provides ample evidence to demonstrate the worth of new institutionalist research in different subfields of political science. Institutions depicted beyond material structures' constraints (old institutionalism) become a substantial vehicle and a quite-influential element in the practice of politics that the new institutional approach tries to apprehend. This extensive collaborative work meets the goal of showing the broad possibilities new institutionalism provides for analytical purposes. However, detractors to new institutionalism can interpret this supposedly positive aspect as one important drawback of the theory since it does not seem to represent a coherent and unified school, but rather a cumulative result of three distinct intellectual traditions embodying different methodological and epistemological positions, as well as separate ontologies and interpretations of political processes. Far from denial, the book takes such diversity as a bigger extent of understanding.
This edited collection makes some significant contributions. Working to confirm rather than extend new institutionalism theory, its primary contribution to the field is its implications for practice, especially to scholars in political science. The chapters offer a broad spectrum of analytical tools within new institutionalism in the scrutiny of the relationship between institutions and other variables. Furthermore, the focus on the study of institutions and their pervasive influence on human actions is of central significance to a number of disciplines, including the provision of, therefore, new interdisciplinary relevance to economics, sociology, and other social sciences.
