Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-18T02:29:50.007Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Contrast enhancement as motivation for closed syllable laxing and open syllable tensing

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 June 2019

Benjamin Storme*
Affiliation:
University of Lausanne
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper proposes that closed syllable laxing and open syllable tensing of non-low vowels are motivated by conflicting strategies of contrast enhancement in vowel–consonant sequences. Laxing enhances the distinctiveness of consonant contrasts by allowing for more distinct VC formant transitions, in particular in sequences involving a non-low vowel followed by an oral labial/coronal/velar consonant (e.g. [p t k]). Tensing enhances the distinctiveness of vowel contrasts by providing more distinct formant realisations for vowels. Linguistic variation results from different ways of resolving the tension between maximising vowel dispersion and maximising consonant dispersion. Laxing typically applies before coda consonants as a way to compensate for the absence of good perceptual cues to place of articulation. The hypothesis that laxing enhances the distinctiveness of postvocalic place contrasts is supported by a study of mid-vowel laxing in French, which corroborates the general claim that perceptual contrast plays a role in shaping phonotactic restrictions.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019 
Figure 0

Figure 1Tense–lax vowel alternations in the F1×F2 space.

Figure 1

Table ILanguage sample, with vowel inventory, tense–lax pairs and sources.

Figure 2

Table IIThe basic tense-lax patterns found in the language sample.

Figure 3

Table IIIConsonants available in word-final position in the languages in the survey. (a) In Javanese, [k] and [ʔ] are in complementary distribution word-finally: [k] occurs after [ə] and [ʔ] after other vowels. According to Dudas (1976), [ʔ] derives historically from [k]. (b) For Keley-i, Hohulin & Kenstowicz (1979) do not cite any word ending in [b] or [s], but these could be accidental gaps. (c) For Dutch, the table reports consonants available as C1 in C1C2 clusters. (d) For Klamath, only plain consonants are shown. There are also series of glottalised consonants, aspirated consonants and voiceless sonorants.

Figure 4

Table IVDistribution of tense and lax vowels before the consonants listed in Table III (L: lax vowels only; T: tense vowels only; C: tense–lax contrasts; empty cell: place of articulation missing in the language or unavailable in this position). (a) In Bario Kalabit, /i u/ lax to [ɪ ʊ] before all dentals except the rhotic [r]. (b) In Chamorro, /i u e/ lax to [ɪ ʊ ε] before three major places of articulation; /o/ laxes to [ɔ] only before velars. Laxing also occurs before prevocalic [ʔ]. (c) In Paluai, [i ɪ] contrast everywhere except before the word-final nasals [m n ŋ], where [ɪ] occurs. (d) In Québec French, high vowels are always lax except before the fricatives [v z Ʒ].

Figure 5

Figure 2Schematised F1 VC transitions into [p t k] after (a) low and (b) high vowels.

Figure 6

Figure 3F2(C) as a function of F2(V) and the resulting acoustic F2 difference for [b], [d] and [g] in VC sequences: (a) [b]–[d]; (b) [b]–[g]; (c) [d]–[g]. Δ denotes the difference between the two lines. Data from Sussman et al. (1997).

Figure 7

Table VPercentage of correct identification in English VC sequences with dereleased stops, i.e. stops whose release bursts have been edited out (Lisker 1999: 53). The results are similar for unreleased stops. The ‘average’ column reports the percentages across all three places. Values below 90% are given in bold.

Figure 8

Figure 4Mean F1 and F2 (Hz) of the Standard French vowels, with standard deviations (measured at the midpoint of the vowel).

Figure 9

Table VIAverage vowel duration (ms), with standard deviations.

Figure 10

Figure 5F1 of vowel before [p t k] in C2 position, measured 5 ms before the end of the vowel (mean and standard deviation).

Figure 11

Table VIISummary of the results of the acoustic study. Cases in which the F1 or F2 acoustic distance (Δ) between the two consonants in the corresponding row is larger after the lower vowel than after the higher one are indicated by ‘+’, those in which the distance is larger after the higher vowel than after the lower one by ‘–’ and those in which there is no significant difference by ‘0’.

Figure 12

Figure 6F2 of vowel before [p t k] in C2 position, measured 5 ms before the end of the vowel (mean and standard deviation).

Figure 13

Figure 7Perceptual distances between [p], [t] and [k] after French high, tense mid and lax mid vowels: (a) English listeners; (b) French listeners. Error bars represent standard errors.

Figure 14

Table VIIISummary of the results of the perceptual study. The symbol on the left of the slash corresponds to the results for English listeners, the one on the right to French listeners. There is a single symbol when the results were the same for both groups of listeners. Cases in which the perceptual distance (d) between the two consonants in the corresponding row is larger after the lower vowel than after the higher one are indicated by ‘+’, those in which the distance is larger after the higher vowel than after the lower one by ‘–’ and those in which there is no significant difference by ‘0’.

Figure 15

Table IXAttested patterns vs. patterns predicted by the duration-free Dispersion Theory model (/VC1,2/ = /VC1 VC2/; A = attested; P = predicted; ATB = across-the-board).

Supplementary material: File

Storme supplementary material

Storme supplementary material 1

Download Storme supplementary material(File)
File 44.7 KB