Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T02:36:11.461Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Is phonological consonant epenthesis possible? A series of artificial grammar learning experiments

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 November 2018

Rebecca L. Morley*
Affiliation:
Ohio State University
*
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Consonant epenthesis is typically assumed to be part of the basic repertoire of phonological grammars. This implies that there exists some set of linguistic data for which epenthesis is the best analysis. However, a series of artificial grammar learning experiments found no evidence that learners ever selected an epenthesis analysis. Instead, phonetic and morphological biases were revealed, along with individual variation in how learners generalised and regularised their input. These results, in combination with previous work, suggest that synchronic consonant epenthesis may only emerge very rarely, as a result of a gradual accumulation of changes over time. It is argued that stored stem–allomorph pairs should be adopted as the null hypothesis in cases of potential epenthesis, and that a universal criterion is needed for rejecting this hypothesis. Such a criterion requires a formal theory of exceptions, a necessity for falsifiability in phonological theory.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2018 
Figure 0

Figure 1Training and test paradigm: sequential presentation of singular and plural forms.

Figure 1

Table IFull list of stimuli across all conditions, both training and test item stems. Items separated by / indicate substitutions: a training item used as a test item, and vice versa, for a particular condition. The item in parentheses was used only in training. See the full list of conditions in the online supplementary materials.

Figure 2

Figure 2Spectrograms of example stimuli: (a) [gaidu - ək] (spliced, with transitions removed); (b) [gaiduwək] (unspliced, natural production).

Figure 3

Table IIExperiment 1 (learning biases). For each condition, number of participants, example training stimuli and token counts (unique stems) for each stem type are given.

Figure 4

Table IIIExperiment 1: average proportion of glide responses for novel stem types.

Figure 5

Table IVExperiment 1: Bayesian logistic regression: average proportion of glide responses for novel stem types by condition. The reference level is the Natural condition. A single measure of average glide response was calculated for each participant. No random effects were included.

Figure 6

Table VExperiment 2 (evidence and allomorphs). For each condition, number of participants, example training stimuli and token counts (unique stems) for each stem type are given.

Figure 7

Figure 3Experiment 2: average response rate by allomorph for consonant-final stems.

Figure 8

Table VIExperiment 2: accuracy by stem type.

Figure 9

Table VIILogistic regression: accuracy (one measure per participant) as a function of condition, stem type and the interaction between condition and stem type. Condition reference level=CTrained-1; Stem Type reference level=Back Vowel. No random effects were included.

Figure 10

Table VIIILogistic regression: accuracy as a function of condition for all trained stem types combined. The reference level is the Anti-natural condition. No random effects were included.

Figure 11

Table IXExperiment 3 (generalisation). For each condition, number of participants, example training stimuli and token counts (unique stems) for each stem type are given.

Figure 12

Figure 4Experiment 3: average response rate by allomorph for consonant-final stems.

Figure 13

Table XExperiment 3: mean response rates (%) by allomorph for consonant-final stems. Expected response rates, based on training levels, are given in parentheses. Significance is indicated by *.

Figure 14

Figure 5(a) Boosting metric 1: a given allomorph was chosen for at least % of test items; (b) boosting metric 2: a given allomorph was chosen at levels significantly greater than baseline frequency (one-sided Wilcoxon signed rank test; α=0.05).

Figure 15

Table XIExperiment 3: consonant-final stems. Percentage of participants, by condition, and by allomorph, who were judged to be boosters under B1 and B2 respectively (see §2.4.3).

Figure 16

Table XIIExperiment 3 (generalisation). For each condition, number of participants, example training stimuli and token counts (unique stems) for each stem type are given.

Figure 17

Table XIIIConsonant-final stems: mean percentages of segmental vs. subsegmental analyses by condition.

Figure 18

Table XIVProportion of pre-epenthesisers by condition. Grey cells indicate stem types held out during training.

Figure 19

Table XVSet of deletion-biasing conditions, with example training stimuli, and specific deletion analysis. (Suffix-final [k] is an exception to the rule for the Variable-3 condition.)

Figure 20

Table XVISummary of findings by hypothesis.

Figure 21

Table XVIIHypothetical precursor epenthesis system, showing surface forms after loss of prefinal and preconsonantal coronals.

Supplementary material: PDF

Morley supplementary material

Tables S18 and S19

Download Morley supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 144.6 KB