Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T00:50:42.567Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Adding Another Level Individual Responses to Globalization and Government Welfare Policies

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 May 2015

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Literature on the compensation hypothesis overwhelmingly concentrates on either the macro or micro level of the relationship between globalization and welfare spending. This paper explicitly addresses this shortcoming by using individual citizens and country-specific characteristics in a hierarchical model framework. We start by examining individual’s context-conditional reactions to actual economic globalization and welfare generosity; after which, we make the effect of actual economic globalization (welfare generosity) conditional on whether the individual is a globalization winner or loser. In contrast to theoretical expectations, our results indicate that actual economic globalization does not affect people’s perception in the manner expected by the compensation hypothesis. However, individuals display more positive attitudes toward globalization if welfare state generosity is proxied using government spending on active labor market programs.

Information

Type
Original Articles
Copyright
© The European Political Science Association 2015 
Figure 0

Fig. 1Diagrammatic representation of compensation hypothesis

Figure 1

Fig. 2Diagrammatic representation of our argument

Figure 2

Fig. 3Theoretical expectations for Hypotheses 3a and 3b

Figure 3

Table 1Descriptive Statistics of Dependent and Country Variables

Figure 4

Table 2Descriptive Statistics

Figure 5

Table 3Random-Intercept Logistic Model

Figure 6

Table 4Random-Coefficient Logistic Model

Figure 7

Fig. 4Simulated predicted probability of seeing globalization as positive given four different combinations of 4th income quartile and trade openness Note: simulations are for a male individual with a center political attitude. Active labor market, education and age are kept at their median values.

Figure 8

Fig. 5Simulated predicted probability of seeing globalization as positive given four different combinations of education and trade openness Note: simulations are for a male individual in the 3rd income quartile with a center political attitude. Active labor market and age are kept at their median values.

Figure 9

Fig. 6Simulated predicted probability of seeing globalization as positive given four different combinations of winner and trade openness Note: simulations are for a male individual in the 3rd income quartile with a center political attitude. Active labor market and age are kept at their median values.

Figure 10

Fig. 7Simulated predicted probability of seeing globalization as positive given four different combinations of 4th income quartile and active labor market Note: simulations are for a male individual with a center political attitude. Openness, education and age are kept at their median values.

Figure 11

Fig. 8Simulated predicted probability of seeing globalization as positive given four different combinations of education and active labor market Note: simulations are for a male individual in the 3rd income quartile with a center political attitude. Openness and age are kept at their median values.

Figure 12

Fig. 9Simulated predicted probability of seeing globalization as positive given four different combinations of winner and active labor market Note: simulations are for a male individual in the 3rd income quartile with a center political attitude. Openness and age are kept at their median values.

Figure 13

Table 5Random-Intercept Logistic Model

Figure 14

Table 6Random-Intercept Logistic Model

Figure 15

Table 7Random-Intercept Logistic Model