No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 April 2004
When I arrived in Washington, D.C. to attend the first APSAConference on Teaching and Learning, I did not know what to expect.Although I have been a regular participant in the APSA AnnualMeeting and attended many workshops on teaching and curriculardevelopment, this didn't seem to be the same. All of my contactswith the program committee and APSA had seemed more informal,specific, and intense. They had clear expectations of this smallgroup of 40. Unlike the Annual Meeting, we would not be presentingour research for 15 minutes, answering questions from the audience,responding to the discussants' comments, and then spend theremainder of the conference as a passive observer. At the plenarysession the expectations were made more explicit. We would spendmore time in our groups of 10 or 15 throughout the weekend—but wewould still only have approximately 15 minutes to formally presentour work. Our curiosity was palpable, how would a group of academicsspend the remainder of our time?
When I arrived in Washington, D.C. to attend the first APSA Conference on Teaching and Learning, I did not know what to expect. Although I have been a regular participant in the APSA Annual Meeting and attended many workshops on teaching and curricular development, this didn't seem to be the same. All of my contacts with the program committee and APSA had seemed more informal, specific, and intense. They had clear expectations of this small group of 40. Unlike the Annual Meeting, we would not be presenting our research for 15 minutes, answering questions from the audience, responding to the discussants' comments, and then spend the remainder of the conference as a passive observer. At the plenary session the expectations were made more explicit. We would spend more time in our groups of 10 or 15 throughout the weekend—but we would still only have approximately 15 minutes to formally present our work. Our curiosity was palpable, how would a group of academics spend the remainder of our time?
In the weeks leading to the conference we had heard from our moderators, using a listserv and discussion group to virtually interact. But we were not required to submit our presentation in advance, although some colleagues had already posted their presentation on the discussion group. In the working groups' initial meeting we spent time talking about ourselves, our areas of specialization, our institutions, ourselves. Topics that academics generally have no difficulty addressing—in great detail. But this initial session set the tone. The conference was not a series of monologues, but conversations. In my workgroup, at least, we interrupted each other continuously but cordially, frequently the only way that academics are able to have conversations. It did not feel so much that we gave presentations, but that we led conversations about our prepared topics. Unlike the Annual Meeting, we weren't demonstrating our research and seeking feedback, we were discussing how our projects (which varied greatly) were designed, implemented, evaluated, and changed. We all wanted to know how these various pedagogical approaches could be adapted to other situations and institutions and in what way they could be better tested and improved. It seemed more collaborative.
Most of workshops on teaching, assessment, and curriculum design I have attended over the years have been multi-disciplinary or directed by faculty in the humanities. At times, I have found them frustrating and irrelevant because they often quickly deteriorate into the anecdotal level or to concrete “teaching tips.” It was exciting to talk about these same topics—innovative pedagogy and technology, service learning and civic engagement, departmental and classroom assessment, diversity and global issues—but with people sharing the same disciplinary perspective. We recognized overlap between all the sessions. As academics, almost all of us assess the success of our classroom the same as we evaluate the quality of our research—so assessment seemed to span the different workgroups. As passionate teachers, we seek active pedagogies to pull our students into the excitement of political science by forcing them to experience learning methods that are not passive—so the various workgroups considered specific classroom techniques, civic engagement, and new technology. As political scientists, we insist that our students comprehend diverse cultures and analyze the implications of differential power within these communities—so issues of diversity and the global world were continuously examined. Although we were divided into specific topic groups, the overlap was remarkable.
Each working group included representatives from all levels of the professoriate and from very different types of institutions. My working group had two graduate students, assistant, associate, and full professors, representatives from departments from two to 70 faculty members, graduate and undergraduate faculty, and members of institutions that ranged from small private colleges, historically black colleges and universities, small state universities, community colleges, and research-1 schools. Most of us did not know each other before the conference and many of us are engaged not only in our disciplinary research, but also in the scholarship of teaching and learning. And we talked for three wonderful days. The goal for each group was to provide a comprehensive presentation for our final plenary session. These presentations found the commonalities in the presentations, identified continuing questions in each area, considered how to expand this conference to bring in more faculty while retaining the wonderful attributes of the small working groups, and discussed ways for APSA to become more involved in the scholarship and issues of Teaching and Learning. We didn't want to leave. We promised to send each other material, research, and projects that we had used in our own departments and classrooms to be adapted in others.
The best endorsement of this conference is that 40 political scientists came to Washington, D.C. for three days in the spring, when the weather was beautiful. We attended every session; even when our tracks did not meet, we participated in the other groups' sessions. With institutional budget cutbacks, most of us paid our own way and no one really complained—it had been worth it.