Our State-Level Economic Model incorrectly forecast the outcome of the presidential election. The model's projections were based on the two-party vote in the prior election, the status of the incumbent party in the election/reelection cycle, national and state unemployment rates, and changes in real per capita personal income levels for state residents. Even before the Republican nomination process began, President Obama's success in the 2008 campaign coupled with the electoral advantage typically enjoyed by first-term incumbents bode well for his reelection chances. However, by the arrival of the fall campaign, unemployment remained high and income growth was stagnant, meaning that the president faced significant economic headwinds. Our estimates indicated that Governor Romney would carry most of the battleground states. We were wrong. President Obama carried all but one of them.
When Obama's two-party vote percentage is regressed on the estimates published in this journal's October issue, we find a fairly consistent over-performance of the president relative to our forecast. Specifically, this regression produces a Y-intercept of 1.77 (t-value = 1.30) and a slope of 1.06 (t-value = 36.44) with an R-squared of 0.964. This result suggests that current economic conditions did not pull down the president's vote share by as much as our model anticipated.
Surely many explanations can account for our inaccurate forecast. Among the first to consider is the model's underlying assumption that a poorly performing economy will generally erode the vote received by the in-party candidate as voters grow more concerned about economic conditions. By a variety of economic indicators, it was apparent that the economy was underperforming relative to prior election cycles at the time of the 2012 campaign.
When asked by exit pollsters about the nation's current economic condition, three out of every four voters responded that it was either “poor” (31%) or “not so good” (45%). Such an unfavorable perception of the economy by a large subset of the electorate should generally benefit the out-party candidate. However, when asked which candidate would better handle the economy, voters were nearly perfectly divided. Forty-nine percent trusted Romney to do a better job on economic issues, while 48% preferred the president.
Although the economy was by far the issue of most importance among voters in this election, exit poll data from this year's election also revealed that a majority of voters did not blame the Obama administration for the poor economy. According to responses from a question asking whether President Obama or President George W. Bush was more to blame for the country's current economic problems, 53% stated that President Bush bore most of the responsibility. Only 38% considered the incumbent president responsible. Thus, despite the salience of the economy in this election and the generally negative impression of the current economy held by most voters, the even bifurcation of the electorate regarding which candidate would better handle the economy further neutralized what should have been an inherent advantage for the Romney campaign.
Symposium Authors
Alan Abramowitz is the Alben W. Barkley Professor of Political Science at Emory University. He can be reached at polsaa@emory.edu.
Michael Bednarczuk is a graduate student at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. His current research focuses on campaign effects and voter mobilization. He can be reached at bednarc2@uwm.edu.
Michael J. Berry is an assistant professor in the department of political science at the University of Colorado, Denver. He can be reached at Michael.Berry@ucdenver.edu.
Kenneth N. Bickers is a professor in the department of political science at the University of Colorado, Boulder. He can be reached at Kenneth.Bickers@colorado.edu.
James E. Campbell is a UB Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University at Buffalo, The State University of New York. He currently serves as chair of the Political Forecasting Group, a related group of APSA. His research interests center on American macropolitics and electoral change. He is the author of three books and more than 70 journal articles and book chapters. His most recent book is The American Campaign: U.S. Presidential Campaigns and the National Vote. He can be reached at jcampbel@buffalo.edu.
Alfred G. Cuzán is Distinguished University Professor in the department of government in the University of West Florida. He can be reached at acuzan@uwf.edu.
Robert S. Erikson is professor of political science at Columbia University. His research on American elections has been published in a wide range of scholarly journals. He is coauthor of The Timeline of Presidential Elections (Chicago), The Macro-Polity (Cambridge), Statehouse Democracy (Cambridge) and American Public Opinion (Pearson). He is a former editor of the American Journal of Political Science and Political Analysis. He can be reached at res14@columbia.edu.
Douglas A. Hibbs, retired, has been a professor of both economics and political science and has taught graduate courses in applied econometrics, empirical macro-political economy, and macroeconomic theory. He has published five books and dozens of articles in journals in economics, political science, and sociology. An active consultant and occasional university lecturer, Hibbs regards his research on aggregate votes for president as pinning down quantitatively the persistent influence of objectively measured political economic fundamentals, rather than predicting votes optimally or tracking them statistically after the fact. He can be contacted at douglas@douglas-hibbs.com.
Thomas M. Holbrook is department chair and the Wilder Crane Professor of Government in the department of political science at the University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee. He can be reached at holbroot@uwm.edu.
Florian M. Hollenbach is a PhD candidate at Duke University with a focus in political economy and methods. His current interests are the political economy of taxation, redistribution as well as state capacity and revenue extraction in developing countries. Additional interests include applied statistics and economic development. He can be reached at florian.hollenbach@duke.edu.
Bruno Jerôme is an associate professor in the department of Economics at the University of Paris 2 and member of the Law and Economics Center of Paris 2. He can be reached at bruno.jerome@gmail.com
Véronique Jerôme-Speziari is an associate professor in the department of Management at the University of Paris Sud 11and member of the Paris 2 Laboratory of Management. She can be reached at veronique.jerome@gmail.com.
Carl E. Klarner is an assistant professor in the department of political science at Indiana State University. His research interests include campaigns and elections, state politics, and welfare policy, especially as these three subjects pertain to political and social inequality and reform. He can be reached at Carl.Klarner@indstate.edu.
Michael S. Lewis-Beck is F.Wendell Miller Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of Iowa. His interests are comparative elections, election forecasting, political economy, and quantitative methodology. Professor Lewis-Beck has authored or co-authored over 200 articles and books. He has served as editor of the American Journal of Political Science and of the Sage QASS series (the green monographs) in quantitative methods. He can be reached at michael-lewis-beck@uiowa.edu.
Brad Lockerbie is a professor and chair, department of political science at East Carolina University. He can be reached at Lockerbieb@ecu.edu.
Jacob Montgomery is an assistant professor in the department of political science at Washington University in St. Louis and a Fellow at the Center for Political Economy. His research is in the areas of political methodology and American politics. He graduated with a BA fromWake Forest University with majors in political science and mathematical economics. He earned an MS in statistical science, as well as his PhD (2011) in political science from Duke University. He can be reached at jacob.montgomery@wustl.edu.
Helmut Norpoth is a professor of political science at Stony Brook University. He is coauthor of The AmericanVoter Revisited and has published widely on topics of electoral behavior. His current research focuses on public opinion in wartime. He can be reached at helmut.norpoth@sunysb.edu.
Charles Tien is a professor in the department of political science at Hunter College and The Graduate Center, CUNY. He can be reached at ctein@hunter.cuny.edu.
Michael D. Ward is professor of political science at Duke University. His primary interests focus on developing predictive models of political phenomena. His PhD (1977) is from the home of political science predictions, Northwestern University. Much of his current work focuses on predicting the onset and duration of international crises and domestic events such as rebellion, insurgency, and ethnic and religious violence. In addition, he works on link prediction in the context of the dynamic evolution of social networks. He first learned about forecasting from Kenneth Frank Janda. He can be reached at michael.d.ward@duke.edu.
Christopher Wlezien is professor of political science at Temple University. His research on American and comparative politics has appeared in numerous journals. He is coauthor of The Timeline of Presidential Elections (Chicago) and Degrees of Democracy (Cambridge) and coeditor of a number of other books, including Who Gets Represented? (Russell Sage). He is the former founding editor of The Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties and currently coedits the “Poll Reviews” section of Public Opinion Quarterly. He can be reached at Wlezien@temple.edu.
