Introduction: A Tale of Two Contests
In October of 2016, less than two weeks before the election of Donald J. Trump to the White House, Saturday Night Live (SNL) aired a stunning installment of ‘Black Jeopardy!’, a recurring sketch hosted by Kenan Thompson as Darnell Hayes.Footnote 1 In this episode, Keeley (Sasheer Zamata) and Shanice (Leslie Jones), two Black women, were joined by Tom Hanks as Doug, a white man and MAGA-hat wearing Trump supporter. Though Darnell is initially skeptical that Doug is prepared to play ‘Black Jeopardy!’ the four bond over their shared appreciation for ‘big girls’, lottery tickets, and Tyler Perry movies, and their aversion to dogs, corporations, and the government. At one point, Darnell approaches Doug for a handshake; at first taken aback (and literally stepping back), Doug then gratefully clasps the other man's hand. The sketch ends when a new category is announced, ‘Lives That Matter’, and the fragile bonds between Doug, Darnell, and the other contestants begin to fray. Doug announces that he ‘has a lot to say’ about the category. ‘Well, it was good while it lasted’, Darnell replies.
When it aired, the sketch provoked think-pieces about the overlapping interests of Black Americans and poor whites and many aimed at reconciling the two groups. Dan Zak's article for the Washington Post highlighted the ‘common ground’ among contestants, concluding, ‘in a campaign year that's hinged on racial discord, partisan rancor and a deep suspicion of anyone who is “other”, the sketch was deliciously cathartic.’Footnote 2 For liberals, this catharsis probably hinged on a widespread belief that, as painful as the 2016 campaign had been—and precisely because it had been so painful, Trump would soon be out of their lives. With this expectation in mind, liberal viewers could afford to be magnanimous, even ‘affectionate’ to fellow citizens like Doug, especially as played by Tom Hanks, often called America's dad.Footnote 3
Though far removed in time and place, the tensions in this installment of ‘Black Jeopardy!’ recall another comic performance in a charged political moment, Aristophanes’ Frogs.Footnote 4 Initially performed in Athens at the Lenaean festival of 405 BCE where it won first prize, the play was popular enough to be reperformed, possibly the following year.Footnote 5 Frogs, named after one of its choruses, stars the god of theater in an unlikely role: dressed as his brother, the hero Heracles, Dionysus enters the underworld looking for Euripides, whom he considers Athens’ last good poet. Dionysus makes his way to the underworld with an enslaved man named Xanthias and the two pass through various trials. Though Dionysus begins the journey dressed as Heracles, he switches roles with Xanthias when they encounter Heracles’ enemies; at one point, Dionysus-as-Xanthias and Xanthias-as-Heracles compete to see who can withstand a beating better. At the end of his quest, Dionysus is surprised to encounter both Aeschylus and Euripides vying for primacy in the underworld. Facing off in a contest of wit and poetry, each tries to convince Dionysus that he is the poet the city needs. Contrary to his initial plan, Dionysus judges Aeschylus the winner and is allowed to bring him back to life.
In addition to playing with poetry and mythology, Aristophanes also reflects on a contemporary political scandal. Frogs was initially performed just a few months after the battle between Athens and Sparta at Arginusae, a group of islands off the coast of what is now Turkey. This battle, near the end of the Peloponnesian wars, was a Pyrrhic victory for Athens—though triumphant, many of the Athenian crew died in a storm, their bodies never recovered. The historian Xenophon tells us that the generals deemed responsible for this failure were accused without proper trial, stripped of their property, and executed, while Frogs implies that some of the enslaved people who had fought in the battle received freedom and citizenship.Footnote 6
The scale of this manumission is hotly debated, but the emancipation of even a fraction of the thousands of enslaved rowers thought to have participated in the battle would have sent a shock through the city. As Peter Hunt reminds us, ‘freeing other people's slaves en masse was a practice associated with tyranny’, even if the assembly itself enacted the proposition.Footnote 7 The fact that the city had simultaneously executed citizens—high-status generals, no less—would have thrown each decision into harsher light.
If it were not enough to come to terms with these recent events, the Athenian people were also faced with a quandary: what to do with the perpetrators of an oligarchic coup a few years earlier in 411 BCE. This coup had been repressed by the time of Arginusae as well as the play's initial performance in 405 BCE, but not entirely resolved, and the recently reinstated democratic government had yet to decide how and whether to punish the revolutionaries.
Contests are a managed form of violence: the blows that Doug takes and receives are mediated and softened by the rules of the game and what everyone can expect from it, just as Dionysus’ and Xanthias’ competition seems to leave them unscathed and Euripides’ loss is played down as an insult rather than a continuing death sentence. Yet the stakes in both comedies are higher than they appear. Like ‘Black Jeopardy!’ with Tom Hanks, the contests between Aeschylus and Euripides, and between Dionysus and Xanthias earlier in Frogs, evoke recent civic traumas as the audiences face a political decision, a national election for one and the aftermath of a failed coup for the other. Violence against revolutionaries, generals, and enslaved people in Athens, on the one hand, and violence against Black people in the United States, on the other, lurks behind this combative frame. Contests are a microcosm of each society's structures and a place to test those structures.
Yet the societies these competitions reflect are quite different. In 5th-century Athens, generals could be executed, enslaved rowers freed, and oligarchic revolutionaries reincorporated into the community. By contrast, racial constructions in the 21st-century United States are much less flexible. Black people of higher social status have not been protected from racial profiling or police violence, nor did enslavers in the early United States follow ancient Greek categories of enslavement. Ancient Greeks enslaved people from all over the world, including their own cities, and while no enslaved person could expect freedom manumission was common. In the United States, by contrast, race and enslavement reinforced one another and obstructed freed people's full rights. The legacy of racialized enslavement underwrites continuing violence against Black people today.
In what follows, I do not equate the deaths of Black people in the United States with the experience of people enslaved in the ancient world. Rather, I hope that both the surprising similarities and vast differences between ancient Greece and the 21st-century United States will help each to illuminate the other, providing scholars of the ancient past with a new way to understand confusing aspects of Frogs and provoking them to recognize their own, perhaps unacknowledged, connection to the racial injustices of the present.
Because the status distinctions that Aristophanes and SNL interrogate are not equivalent, neither is the significance of that interrogation. These performances, similar in some respects, hit audience members very differently. Yet both offered the chance to reflect on recent history in the relatively safe space of comedy. In this article, I explore how audiences of Frogs could think through Athens’ contemporary problems by way of recent public disasters. As my comparison between Frogs and ‘Black Jeopardy!’ will show, comedy's remembrance of trauma allows audiences to consider and then put away their recent past in favor of the hope of a better future. But this is a future in which the past has been only partially confronted. Instead of providing genuine truth and reconciliation, the space of comedy promotes a false reconciliation that papers over lingering disharmony.
Frogs and the Battle of Arginusae
Like critics who highlighted the overlapping interests of Black and poor white Americans in ‘Black Jeopardy!’ with Tom Hanks, Frogs seems to want to move its audience towards reconciliation with the revolutionaries, rather than further violence. The character of chorus-master, often thought to speak with the authority or even in the voice of the playwright, addresses the audience about a third of the way into the play, in the epirrhema of the parabasis:
And if someone erred, caught up in the wrestling holds of Phrynichus [one of the leaders of the revolution], I say that it should be possible for those who slipped at that time to plead their case and erase their former mistakes. For that's no shame to the city, I say. How dishonorable it is for those who fought just once at sea to suddenly be Plataeans, and owners instead of slaves!Footnote 9 Yet I can't call these things anything but well-done; in fact, I praise them. For they are the only things you did sensibly. It seems fair that you disregard this single mishap, since they—men (and their fathers!) who fought at sea alongside you, men related to you by blood—are strenuously begging you.
It is disgraceful for the city to reward those who fought at sea on one occasion, the chorus-master argues, making them potential enslavers instead of enslaved, and then deny the same rights to those who slipped up only once (as revolutionaries), and are their most valuable fellow citizens. A city willing to enfranchise enslaved people should also restore the rights of citizens.
As David Konstan notes, the enfranchisement of enslaved people and reenfranchisement of citizen revolutionaries are not exactly equivalent:
There is a connection between the two propositions in the idea of generosity, but in respect to status distinctions, the incorporation of slaves into the citizen body runs exactly counter to the view that native citizens ought on no account to be expelled from full participation in the city.Footnote 10
Nevertheless, this argument in the parabasis creates a dialogue between the aftermath of Arginusae and the fate of the revolutionaries and asks how the people's decision to enfranchise enslaved rowers can help them understand what to do with their errant citizens.
But if Frogs stages an investigation into what will become of the revolutionaries, those freed after Arginusae are not its only reference point. Peter Hunt has argued that the people's outrage at the manumission of those they had considered their property may have contributed to their rage at the generals, who commanded the enslaved rowers in the battle.Footnote 11 Without attempting to prove Hunt's suggestion, I argue that Frogs puts the manumission of enslaved rowers at Arginusae and execution of the generals afterwards into conversation and offers these two extraordinary events as models for Athens as it considered the fate of the oligarchic revolutionaries. This provides a new reading of Arginusae within the play.
Aristophanes himself may or may not have intended audience members to think of the generals when they saw Frogs for the first time. Here it is important to understand the timing of the play's composition as well as Arginusae and its aftermath:
The timing of the play's composition has long interested scholars because the playwright Sophocles seems to have died as Aristophanes was writing, complicating whatever original plan he had for portraying the dynamic between Aeschylus who had died half a century earlier and Euripides. It is possible that Aristophanes did not begin writing Frogs until after Sophocles’ death in the summer of 406 BCE, though that would have left a mere six months before the staging of the play in Jan./Feb. 405 BCE. The current scholarly consensus is that Aristophanes began composing Frogs prior to Sophocles’ death but revised the play before it was staged, and that this revision produced some inconsistencies in the play as we have it.Footnote 12
The battle of Arginusae occurred right around the time of Sophocles’ death. Its aftermath, including the enfranchisement of enslaved rowers and the generals’ trial and execution, played out in the second half of 406 as Aristophanes was completing the play and beginning to produce it. Yet preparations for the battle, including perhaps the promise of citizenship to enslaved rowers, were being made much earlier, in the winter of 407/6, providing Aristophanes with advance notice for some of the themes he would explore in the play. It is perhaps this advance notice that explains why Frogs makes explicit reference to the battle and its effect on enslaved rowers but not to the trial of the generals, an unforeseen outcome of the battle.
If Aristophanes had been interested in treating the trial and execution of the generals, he may not have had time to revise the play before its staging. Or perhaps the trial was still too fresh and painful to risk addressing directly—Aristophanes wanted to win the dramatic contest, after all. Because these are unanswerable questions, it is best to see the trial of the generals as haunting the play, a spectre whose presence is not intended by the author so much as activated by the way Frogs interacts with audience memory. Because Frogs tries to leverage the example of the enslaved rowers, attention is also directed to the counterexample of the generals.
While the chorus-master speaks explicitly of the revolutionaries, his comments could characterize the generals equally well. Their mistakes are mere hamartias, ‘errors’, they should be able to erase after a proper trial (691) and they are called citizen-brothers who have often fought alongside members of the audience at sea (697f.). The chorus’ antepirrhema in the following lines (718–35) offers a different point of view, emphasizing the inequality of citizens by drawing on a discourse of metals.Footnote 13 The ‘old money’ of the city has been devalued by mixing with ponēroi, ‘the worst of the worst’ (725; 731). The identity of these debased men is not specified: newer politicians, as Dover suggests, who threaten to replace the disgraced (but aristocratic) revolutionaries, or the newly manumitted rowers of Arginusae.Footnote 14 The ambiguity is productive, once again allowing audience members to relate the revolution, Arginusae, and their consequences.
In the antepirrhema of the parabasis the chorus makes an argument about fundamentals, that the strata of Athenian society are essentially different and unequal. This assertion softens the chorus’ preceding advice to forgive the revolutionaries, reaffirming audience members’ sense of their own status and guaranteeing its stability. Audience members who are ambivalent about accepting the advice articulated in the epirrhema have an out, as it were, articulated by the chorus itself in the antepirrhema. They can move past the oligarchic revolution without subscribing to the equality of all citizens.
By asking how Frogs draws attention to these recent traumas, my interpretation adds to the ongoing conversation about Aristophanes and politics. While earlier generations of scholars traced political allusions or tried to pin down Aristophanes’ own political commitments, those of today explore the socio-political meanings that comedy creates and forecloses.Footnote 15 Yet I also intervene in this modern conversation by reexamining how comedy educates its audience in political matters. Ralph Rosen, for example, has argued against Aristophanes’ ‘didactic seriousness’:
Simply put, if satire fails in its comedy, it fails as satire; but if it fails in its didacticism—that is, if it fails to live up to its claim of actual moral instruction—satire's efficacy not only remains intact, but can even be enhanced by the comedy that arises from the irony of a didacticism exposed as a sham.Footnote 16
I am sensitive to how satire undermines its own seriousness but maintain that comic scenes provide material from which audiences can derive political insight.Footnote 17 Rather than taking the form of didactic ‘content’ like a straightforward moral or political endorsement, comic teaching mediates sensitive topics.Footnote 18 As Osborne says, the politics of Aristophanes ‘lie in the themes that the play explores. They come from making the audience think about issues that they might otherwise ignore or repress.’Footnote 19 The results will be unpredictable, but comedy creates a space in which new ways of relating can emerge.
Frogs creates this space of possibility by deploying three pairs of characters who imitate and vie with one another: Dionysus and Heracles, Dionysus and Xanthias, and Aeschylus and Euripides. These pairs and their cycling through of roles replay the role reversals in Athens’ recent history: democrats becoming oligarchs, enslaved people becoming citizens, and lauded generals dying as criminals. These role reversals would have had special significance for the large portion of the Athenian audience who had themselves played a role in a civic drama.Footnote 20 Frogs capitalizes on the participation of citizens in drama to underline role reversals in the city's recent history.Footnote 21
By having its main characters swap roles, Frogs downplays the seriousness of such reversals and destabilizes the very notion of essential difference that made the aftermath of Arginusae so shocking. But what it means to watch these reversals play out is left to audience members to interpret. Commentators within the play, including the chorus leader, the chorus, and Aeschylus and Euripides, direct the audience towards the problem of the oligarchic revolutionaries and their fate. While Euripides models honest appraisal of what Athens has done for and to its free and enslaved people, Aeschylus wins by telling the people what they want to hear: that discretion is the better part of valor, and that they can become whole without facing their recent actions.Footnote 22 But this is only one possibility for living out the experience of watching the play; comedy's didacticism is fragile and open.Footnote 23
Swapping Roles, Questioning Status
Frogs begins its engagement with the battle of Arginusae by deploying Xanthias, a character who explicitly and implicitly recalls the enslaved rowers freed in the battle's aftermath.Footnote 24 Though Xanthias is still enslaved, he imagines having fought and now being free. Through his imagination, we see another Xanthias, an alternate who stands in for the manumitted rowers walking the streets of Athens.
From its opening lines, Frogs plays with the tension between enslaved people and their enslavers. When Dionysus and Xanthias first appear, Xanthias is carrying their luggage and sitting on a donkey, with Dionysus walking alongside. Xanthias begings by asking, metatheatrically, how the play should open, ‘with one of the usual jokes?’ (ti tōn eiōthotōn, 1). Dionysus replies that anything is fine except ‘I am weighed down’ (piezomai, 3), that is Xanthias can tell whatever jokes he likes as long as he does not complain about being enslaved—as enslaved characters often do in comedy.
Though this allusion to enslavement is a comic trope, the trope carries real weight (so to speak).Footnote 25 Through this exchange and our laughter at Xanthias, the basic order of Athenian society with its gradations of status and power is affirmed. But as will occur more than once in the play, the status quo is not so much a conclusion as a question, one that raises specific concerns about the sudden social shifts the audience has witnessed following the oligarchic revolution in 411 and the battle of Arginousiai and its aftermath in 406/405.
As this scene continues, a series of jokes reveal how seemingly essential status categories are constructed. After Dionysus instructs Xanthias to keep silent about his burdens, the god tries to convince Xanthias that, perched on their donkey, he in fact bears no burdens. ‘How can you carry something when you are carried by another?’ (πῶς γὰρ φέρεις, ὅς γ’ αὐτὸς ὑφ’ ἑτέρου φέρει;), asks Dionysus. ‘I don't know’, replies Xanthias, ‘but my shoulder sure feels it’ (πὐκ οἶδ’⋅ ὁ δ’ ὦμος οὑτοσὶ πιέζεται, 29f.), reprising the verb piezomai, ‘to be weighed down’, discussed above. A few lines later, Xanthias mourns the fact that he did not fight at Arginusae:
Alas, what a wretch I am! Why oh why didn't I fight at sea? If I had, you'd be mightily sorry.
Dionysus’ abuse forces Xanthias to consider the status he might have enjoyed had he fought at Arginusae and won his freedom, or, as the joke implies, won his freedom and come to enslave people himself. If mere chance separates Xanthias from Dionysus, then the differences between them must be arbitrary.Footnote 26
When Dionysus and Xanthias arrive at the river Styx, the gateway to the underworld, Dionysus asks Charon to ferry them across. He agrees to take Dionysus but will only have Xanthias on board if ‘he's fought at sea for his very life’ (νεναυμάχηκε τὴν περὶ τῶν κρεῶν, 191).Footnote 27 This and the previous allusion to Arginusae invite us to imagine another Frogs, one in which Xanthias had fought in the battle and been rewarded with freedom. By depicting Xanthias’ manumission indirectly, as a missed opportunity, Frogs prompts its audience to briefly remember and then put aside the manumission of enslaved people after Arginusae. In Frogs, an enslaved person had the chance to fight and be freed but is still safely enslaved. This fantasy does not imagine a world without Arginusae or the manumission of enslaved rowers, but instead creates an intermediate zone in which the audience can both affirm their decision to enfranchise enslaved people and enjoy the suffering of Xanthias, who continues to play his established, subordinate role.
After Xanthias has been sent off, Charon tries and largely fails to instruct Dionysus in rowing (198–205). Dionysus’ poor rowing is both a comic trope and may allude to how citizen soldiers struggled to row at Arginusae; it also highlights the competence and heroism of the enslaved rowers in the battle.Footnote 28 Specifically, Dionysus’ failure highlights the unjust way Charon has treated Xanthias. Charon refuses to allow Xanthias on board but welcomes Dionysus, even though, by Dionysus’ own admission, the two are equally ‘untried, unseaworthy, and un-Salaminian’ (apeiros athalattōs asalaminios, 204), a fact borne out by Dionysus’ poor performance.Footnote 29 When Dionysus admits that he is un-Salaminian, he positions himself as a man of Athens rather than a god, making explicit that he has been playing another role all along, a concerned citizen of the city.
While the opening scene of the play affirms the enslaved–enslaver status quo, I have argued that the following three hundred lines undermine the essentialism of these very status distinctions. This lays the groundwork for Xanthias and Dionysus to trade places in the scenes that come next. If Xanthias reminded audiences of the enslaved rowers at Arginusae before, here he will enjoy some of their rewards.
Once Dionysus and Xanthias have arrived at the threshold of Hades, Dionysus in his disguise as Heracles is berated and threatened by the porter Aeacus for stealing Cerberus, the three-headed dog guarding the underworld. Terrified that Aeacus will punish him, Dionysus convinces Xanthias to assume the lion skin and club he has been wearing to impersonate Heracles (494–500). As soon as Xanthias has taken on the role of Heracles, however, Persephone's maid Planthane welcomes him with tasty food and the promise of dancing girls (512–15). His ‘slave’ Dionysus, on the other hand, is left literally holding the bags. As the scene unfolds, we witness how quickly status can reverse and result in disparate treatment. However, Xanthias’ and Dionysus’ reversals do more than represent the recent status shifts in Athens; they interpret them as causally connected. Xanthias rises because Dionysus falls, and for Dionysus to recapture his high status Xanthias must reoccupy the lower. Read back onto the battle of Arginusae and the oligarchic coup, this scene seems to suggest that enslaved rowers at Arginusae profited at others’ expense and that the reinstatement of the revolutionaries may likewise come at a price.
One particular reference in this scene invites audience members to remember the executed generals and think about their reversal of fortune alongside that of the enfranchised rowers. After Dionysus has told Xanthias that he himself will resume the role of Heracles, the chorus comments:
These are the actions of a man who has intelligence and understanding and has done his share of sailing. He knows to always roll himself over to the side that's doing well rather than to stand like an inscribed pillar in a fixed position; to turn around to the softer side is characteristic of a clever man, a real Theramenes.
The chorus characterizes Dionysus, who has just reclaimed his divine role from Xanthias, as a clever man who ‘rolls with the ship’ and positions himself to enjoy the ‘softer’ things in life, like Theramenes, one of the oligarchic revolutionaries who served at Arginusae and was assigned to coordinate the rescue of stranded Athenians after the battle, but escaped execution for his failure to do so.Footnote 30 By introducing Theramenes, a citizen who betrayed the city twice but remained a part of the community, the chorus allows the audience to knit together the oligarchic revolution with the trial of the generals and invites them to think through the fate of revolutionaries like Theramenes while also remembering the trial of citizens like themselves. The nautical imagery of this passage, especially andros peripepleukotos, a ‘man well-versed in sailing’ (535), alludes to the enslaved rowers at Arginusae who were later freed and enfranchised and recalls Charon's line to Dionysus and Xanthias at the entrance to the underworld, that he only ferries people who have ‘fought at sea for their very life’ (νεναυμάχηκε τὴν περὶ τῶν κρεῶν, 191). Though Dionysus’ poor rowing for Charon proved that he was anything but peripepleukōs, here he has learned how to ‘sail’ around misfortune and end up on top.
When Dionysus resumes his disguise and dominant position, he once more faces the complaints of those wronged in the course of Heracles’ last visit. Plathane and the Landlady threaten Dionysus with violence and death, promising to knock his teeth out, toss him to the executioner, and cut his throat (572–6). Ultimately, however, they settle their hopes for revenge on a court trial, and the Landlady calls for representatives:
I'll just go get Cleon; he'll issue a summons today and wind these things out of him.Footnote 31
The threat of a summons and court may have reminded audience members of the trial of the generals just months before, but more importantly it allows Dionysus’ and Xanthias’ punishment to take the form of a competition; in this competition, it is not the god and enslaved person who are on trial so much as the ideology of a strict difference between them (605–73).Footnote 32
When Aeacus reenters the scene to punish Xanthias-as-Heracles, he calls once more for punishment (605). Xanthias reveals that he is not Heracles or a god at all, and, when Dionysus contradicts him, persuades Aeacus to torture them both for the truth (616). This interrogation builds thematically upon Plathane's and the Landlady's expressed desire in the previous scene for both trial and violence. Although the characters themselves draw no connection between the Landlady's summons of Cleon and Aeacus’ return at 605, the porter fulfills her summons and carries out the trial she had hoped for.
Until this point, Xanthias-as-Heracles had enjoyed minor privileges over Dionysus, now himself disguised as an enslaved man. When Xanthias suggests that Aeacus torture Dionysus, however, he leverages his status as Heracles to the fullest. Xanthias argues that, if Dionysus is truly a god, he won't feel anything (634), recalling Dionysus’ assertion that he, not Xanthias, is the real god of the two (530f.). Yet Dionysus convinces Xanthias to subject himself to the same test, even though they both know that Xanthias is mortal:
Xa.: All the more reason why he should be whipped, for if he is a god, he won't feel a thing.
Dion.: Alrighty then, since you say you're a god, won't you share the same blows with me?
Xa.: Fair enough.
Xanthias has the upper hand, at least for the moment: Aeacus, Plathane, and the Landlady are willing to torture Dionysus, with Xanthias’ life as forfeit if he is found to be lying (617). But Xanthias turns this opportunity on its head, choosing to compete with Dionysus in endurance. Crucially, both Xanthias and Dionysus react to the flogging in the same way, masking their cries of pain by making lame jokes. Aeacus admits he cannot tell the difference between them (666f.); their fight is a draw.
Though this trial is supposed to reveal which of the pair is divine and free and which is mortal and enslaved, it in fact proves the vulnerability of both kinds of bodies. In a play that uses the emancipation of enslaved rowers after Arginusae to bring attention to the undecided fate of the revolutionaries, this scene focuses the audience on how status relates to punishment or protection from punishment, inviting reflection on the trial of the generals. Yet because the trial in the underworld ends in a draw, neither enslaved man nor god triumphant, audience members are brought to an understanding of what these groups share and how easily status distinctions break down when the body is endangered.
Once Aeacus has admitted himself unable to tell Dionysus and Xanthias apart, the flogging stops and the chorus-master delivers his advice in the parabasis, quoted above. The audience's attention is turned away from the complex and perhaps irresolvable dynamics of status and brought to bear on the concrete and discrete problem of the revolutionaries. When Dionysus and Xanthias reappear and make their way to Euripides, they have put aside Heracles’ costume and resumed their original roles.
As the first part of the play demonstrates, status in the world of the Frogs is a zero-sum game. Dionysus and Xanthias cannot both occupy a powerful position; one must be subordinated to the other. But their revolution in and out of each other's roles also deconstructs the givenness of any one position. If each can play the enslaved person and each play the god, what difference is there, really, between them? Crucially, however, this role-playing ends with the characters back in their original positions.
At this point Dionysus leaves Xanthias to continue his quest for Euripides alone. But finding Euripides, it turns out, is only half the battle. When Dionysus finally meets his hero, the younger playwright is locked in a struggle with Aeschylus for the throne of tragedy. Rather than simply resurrecting Euripides as he intended, Dionysus decides to adjudicate their dispute through a series of tests. Many of the tests are aesthetic and inconclusive, so Dionysus finally asks each playwright to offer the city advice about the coup of 411 BCE; whoever offers the best advice will be the winner (1417–23).Footnote 33
Dionysus requests both general advice for the city's well-being and specific instruction as to what should be done about Alcibiades, the most infamous of the revolutionaries. The playwrights’ answers represent different approaches not only to Alcibiades but to the revolutionaries as a group; when Aeschylus compares Alcibiades to a lion cub who must be humored (1431f.), he echoes the advice of the parabasis to reincorporate the revolutionaries into the citizen body. Euripides, on the other hand, says he ‘hates’ (misō, 1427) someone who has behaved as Alcibiades has done. There's no room for him in Euripides’ Athens.
But the two playwrights are arguing about something more fundamental than a mere vote for clemency would indicate. While Euripides boasts that he has taught his characters:
To think, to see, to understand, to love to twist, to scheme, to suspect the worst, to carefully consider everything.Footnote 34
Aeschylus replies that:
A poet must hide what is wicked, not parade it around and teach it. For little boys have a teacher to point things out to them, but grown men have poets.
This exchange reveals a striking difference between the two playwrights. Euripides orchestrates his dramas to showcase and encourage shrewd, independent, critical thinking about the realities, however ugly, of this world. Aeschylus, on the other hand, believes that it his duty as a poet to conceal what is bad about human nature and human society and to control the opinions of his public the way a teacher molds the mind of a child. Although both acknowledge their responsibility to educate and better the Athenian population, Euripides wants to talk frankly about Athens’ mistakes while Aeschylus is content to overlook them.
In as much as Aristophanes’ strategies reflect a city still struggling to come to terms with its past, the movement of the play also indicates that his audience at the same time wants the past to be past, forgotten. By the end of Frogs, as we have seen, Athens’ ‘good’ decision, the manumission of enslaved people, has been celebrated, while its ‘bad’ decision, the execution of generals, has been rejected, and, in the person of Euripides, left in the underworld. Aeschylus, the older playwright of a heroic age, is brought back to replace recent history with the fantasy of a better time.Footnote 35
Reconciliation in the Time of Trump
While most commentators in 2016 read ‘Black Jeopardy!’ with Tom Hanks as conciliatory, Jamelle Bouie recognized its darker undertones:
It's not that working blacks and working whites are unable to see the things they have in common; it's that the material interests of the former—freedom from unfair scrutiny, unfair detention, and unjust killings—are in direct tension with the identity politics of the latter (as represented in the sketch by the Trump hat). And in fact, if Hanks’ character is a Trump supporter, then all the personal goodwill in the world doesn't change the fact that his political preferences are a direct threat to the lives and livelihoods of his new friends, a fact they recognize.Footnote 36
Rewatched a few weeks or years later, even white liberals might agree with Bouie's perspective as a Black man. The threads of discord that punctuate Doug's nascent friendship with Darnell and the other contestants are more ominous, and Darnell's concluding remark that their camaraderie was ‘good while it lasted’ more damning. Hanks’ character Doug, who might have originally seemed misguided but lovable, now represents the winner in the national election of 2016, his thoughts about ‘lives that matter’ freighted with the weight of additional deaths: Jocques Clemmons, Botham Jean, Atatiana Jefferson, Breonna Taylor, and George Floyd, to name but a few. This pattern seems all the more unchanging (and perhaps unchangeable) against the background of Donald Trump's unlikely rise from struggling businessman and reality star to President of the United States, a role reversal on a par with those staged in Frogs.
Yet the ending, and overall meaning, of the sketch remains open to both hopeful and pessimistic (or realistic) interpretations. Those who would like to experience reconciliation can do so because the sketch leaves certain things unsaid. It ends before Doug can expound on which lives matter and which do not. It ends before the handshake Darnell and Doug share turns into the attack Doug expects. In Aristophanes’ Frogs, detente is achieved in a similar way, by evoking and then discreetly turning away from the tensions that Arginusae and its aftermath brought to the surface. Xanthias’ and Dionysus’ reenactment of recent role-reversals in the city is resolved when Aeacus gives up on telling them apart. Xanthias and another enslaved man introduce the contest between Euripides and Aeschylus, but Xanthias’ last line is at 808, over 700 lines from the end of the play; Dionysus continues on alone. Instead of resolving the question of Dionysus’ and Xanthias’ true nature, which Persephone and Pluto never adjudicate, the play turns to Euripides and Aeschylus, who have been asked to reflect on a concrete, and discrete, problem in the city—the fate of the revolutionaries—rather than the way status is meted out to its members. ‘Black Jeopardy!’ with Tom Hanks surfaces the racial tensions, inequities, and injustices that are endemic in the United States but focuses viewers on the problem of the 2016 election: not so much whom to vote for, but how the nation can survive the campaign.
Both Aristophanes and the writers of SNL are constrained and directed by their need to attract an audience. Just as Aristophanes worked to appeal to the judges who would evaluate his play, the writers of SNL respond to ratings. While Aristophanes’ personal politics are usually assumed to be elitist and somewhat antidemocratic, he is careful never to undermine the power of the Athenian people.Footnote 37 So too SNL and its writers are usually considered liberal-leaning, regularly satirizing the Trump administration and the President himself, but this did not stop them from welcoming Trump as a guest-host during the 2016 campaign. In his four-minute monologue, Trump downplays his feud with actor Rosie O'Donnell and gracefully dodges an accusation of racism from comedian Larry David.Footnote 38 The sketch that features him focuses on a bad hair day, not his violent rhetoric against women, immigrants, and people of color.
Given these constraints, the way ‘Black Jeopardy!’ with Tom Hanks ends is both artistically effective and strategic for the show, which is saved from indicting Trump's supporters outright. Aristophanes takes a similar approach, using the chorus-master to argue for reconciliation but softening this stance in the antepirrhema, and turning away from a clear statement about status differences in Athenian society. In 405 BCE and 2016 CE, audiences were given a kind of ‘delicious catharsis’ (to paraphrase Zak), a way to reexperience some of the worst aspects of recent civic history in safety, and without having to commit themselves to social change. A primary effect of these contests is to move audiences toward civic harmony, but this harmony is an illusion. It can only be sustained, as Aeschylus advocated, by ‘hiding what is wicked’, by not staging the oligarchs’ terrible violence or the violence of the police and ‘All Lives Matter’.
This ambivalence is not neutrality; looking away from civic conflict gives life to a particular view of the citizen body, one that cannot sustain difference. For political theorist Danielle Allen, the way citizens define ‘the people’ is core to how and whether democracy functions. In Talking to Strangers, her book about school desegregation in Little Rock, Arkansas, Americanness for most whites meant being ‘unified’ and homogenous, a vision that desegregation threatened to destroy. Instead of unity, Allen calls for a definition of citizenship based on wholeness, ‘the coherence and integrity of a consolidated but complex, intricate, and differentiated body.’Footnote 39 The question then becomes, as she says, ‘what modes of citizenship can make a citizenry whole without covering up difference?’Footnote 40 How can trust be established or reestablished among people with different beliefs, identities, and interests?
When Danielle Allen published Talking to Strangers in 2004, she could say with a certain amount of confidence that even ‘given current levels of distrust, the end of the world is [not] at hand. The United States is nowhere near an internal apocalypse.’Footnote 41 As I write this in 2020, the picture looks much bleaker. Uprisings after the deaths of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor have inaugurated new waves of consciousness, discussion, and protest in the ongoing movement for Black lives, but entrenched white supremacy as well as the potential reelection of Donald Trump and the ravages of Covid-19 make the future of racial justice less certain than ever.
For law professor and justice reform activist Bryan Stevenson, the first step forward is telling the truth about the past. In a July 2020 interview with Ezra Klein, Stevenson explained how important it is for Americans to ‘know…the actual history’ of their country, especially its foundation in genocide and enslavement:
If you don't know your history, you can't really begin to understand what your obligations are, what your responsibilities are, what you should fear, what you should celebrate, what's honorable and what's not honorable.Footnote 42
For Stevenson, the ability to discern honor and dishonor flows from an honest confrontation with history. For Aristophanes, on the other hand, the opposite is true. As the chorus-master says in the parabasis, the people will escape shame if ‘those who slipped up plead their case and erase (lusai) their former mistakes’ (691). This erasure is literally an unloosing, an unyoking. But as Stevenson argues, we are always yoked to history. History is an inextricable part of who we are. His interview continues:
I believe it's important for anyone who identifies as an American, as a citizen of this country, to not simply embrace all the things about American history that we think are glorious and wonderful, but to also acknowledge and accept the things about our history that are tragic and devastating…If we're going to claim American citizenship and American identity, there has to be a willingness to say ‘we’ just like there's that willingness to say ‘we’ when an American does something great.Footnote 43
One of the techniques of wholeness Allen calls for, then, is to identify with all of history even as we remain individuals with our own histories. Becoming the ‘we’ Stevenson imagines means seeing ourselves in the lives of others, and this is something comedy can help with. But to be truly transformative and reconciling, the playful space of comedy has to make room for the consequences of this larger vision. We must see what happens when Keeley, Shanice, Darnell, and Doug overshoot the safe territory the sketch explores.
This may be asking too much of comedy, or any art form for that matter. While holding artists accountable for the conversations they begin, it is we who decide where to take those conversations after the performance has ended. Though Frogs favors Aeschylus’ approach to the city's problems, comedy is a teacher like neither playwright. This genre employs a pedagogy that is in some sense amoral, pushing audiences in one direction but also expecting them to push back.
