In the first throes of madness Seneca's Hercules declares, ‘I shall be borne aloft to the world's high spaces’ (in alta mundi spatia sublimis ferar, HF 958).Footnote 1 To Amphitryon these are the unspeakable thoughts of a mind that is hardly sane, but nevertheless great (pectoris sani parum, / magni tamen, 974f.). For Gilbert Lawall, writing the first essay in the 1983 collection of Ramus essays on Senecan tragedy, the fundamental question of the play is the moral quality of its hero, who in his madness becomes a ‘caricature of his real self’.Footnote 2 John Fitch, writing just a few years later, argued for a continuity of characterization between the hero of the labours and the murderer of his family.Footnote 3 My own essay is concerned less with the morality of Hercules’ character and actions than with the poetics of sublime aspiration and the imagery of grand literary endeavour. Seneca's conception of sublime poetry, as embodied in the figure of tragic Hercules, I discuss through his reception of Lucretius, Virgil, and Horace. The ambivalence Fitch and others have observed in this tragedy of Herculean overreaching I interpret first in the light of a plurality of literary models of transgressive poetics. Juno and the chorus both see violence and danger in the figure of Hercules, but yet do not see the same figure. This difference is located to some degree in the different genres and particular texts which define their perspectives. The Hercules who makes war on the heavens and commits the drama's primary action is very much the creation of Juno and the tragic energies of famous programmatic passages of Aeneid 1 and 7. Lyric offers an alternative conception of sky-towering fame. In the latter part of the article I consider the Lucretian paradigm of heroic rebellion against tradition and Hercules’ failure to break the pattern of Junonian madness. Finally I reflect on the tensions of the Georgics—ars and labor holding ingenium and furor in fragile balance—and see them overwhelmed in the civil war which Hercules Furens, a more powerful Orpheus, wages with himself.
Sublimis and the Poetics of High Ambition
Sublimis does not always have an aesthetic sense in Latin literature, but it appears in a number of contexts where poetic register is commonly interpreted as part of its sense. Lucretius, whose imagery of natural violence and whose paradoxical union of horror and pleasure will characterize also the early modern tradition of sublimity, is described by Ovid as sublimis in a catalogue of poets.Footnote 4 The word features prominently in programmatic poems of Horace, whom Philip Hardie describes as ?reaching for the poetic and moral high ground’ at Carm. 1.1.36 (sublimi feriam sidera uertice, ‘I shall soar aloft and strike the stars with my head’).Footnote 5 Carm. 3.1 sees Horace assuming the lofty role of Jupiter and turning to a more political and more Pindaric conception of lyric verse, before retreating from such aspirations at the close: cur inuidendis postibus et nouo / sublime ritu moliar atrium? (‘why should I struggle to build a towering hall in the modern style with a doorway that arouses envy?’ Carm. 3.1.45f.). This characteristically Horatian retreat from grandeur is as much poetic as social: the Roman atrium which Horace rejects is inspired by the proud palace of Pindar Ol. 6.1-4.Footnote 6 Pindar, for Horace, represents the upper limit of lyric, a poetic height from which he has no wish to fall, Icarus-like.Footnote 7 Carm. 3.25, in which Horace is transported by Bacchic ecstasy into new territory where he may tell of Caesar's eternal glory, is followed by Carm. 3.26 at whose close Venus is invoked to touch Chloe with her ‘lofty whip’, (sublimi flagello, Carm. 3.26.11).Footnote 8 Withheld from what is perhaps Horace's most sublime poem,Footnote 9 the word sublimis appears incongruously at the close of its slighter companion.
At the funeral of Pallas the juxtaposition across the caesura of agresti and sublimem replays the fatal collision of pastoral and high epic: hic iuuenem agresti sublimem stramine ponunt (‘Here they place the youth aloft on his rustic bed’, Virg. Aen. 11.67).Footnote 10 Henry Day (2013), 212, writes simply (of the image of Pompey as an oak tree in Lucan's first book) that, ‘the Pompeian oak… rises sublimis (136), a sublime thing’. Seneca himself uses the word of the high style to which he is sometimes transported: oblitus tum legis pressiorisque iudicii sublimius feror et ore iam non meo (‘forgetful then of my rule and of my more restrained judgement, I am swept to loftier heights by an utterance that is no longer my own’, Dial. 9.1.14). At the close of the same dialogue he returns to the discussion of a poetic madness that surpasses mortal limits in its pursuit of the heights:
cum uulgaria et solita contempsit instinctuque sacro surrexit excelsior, tunc demum aliquid cecinit grandius ore mortali. non potest sublime quicquam et in arduo positum contingere, quam diu apud se est; desciscat oportet et solito et efferatur et mordeat frenos et rectorem rapiat suum eoque ferat, quo per se timuisset escendere.
(Sen. Dial. 9.17.11)When it has scorned the vulgar and the commonplace, and has soared far aloft fired by divine inspiration, then alone it chants a strain too lofty for mortal lips. So long as it is left to itself, it is impossible for it to reach any sublime and difficult height; it must forsake the common track and be driven to frenzy and champ the bit and run away with its rider and rush to a height that it would have feared to have climbed by itself.
(tr. Basore)The passage is discussed by Alessandro Schiesaro,Footnote 11 with reference to the transgressive poetics of Thyestes and the aspirations of Atreus: ‘All sublime, grandiose poetry is nefas, is inevitably implicated in transgressive actions, since it abandons self-composure in a heady atmosphere of semi-prophetic creation’ (55). Hercules Furens shares with Thyestes a genesis in the tragic anger of Juno and the summoning of a Fury in the Aeneid.Footnote 12 The heights of heaven and the depths of hell, worlds beyond mortal limits, are figurative representations of a grand poetic register. Horace's pedestrian satire creeps along the ground (sermones… repentis per humum, Ep. 2.1.250f.); epic and tragedy, challenging the boundaries of the physical world, represent themselves as poetically different. The impulse to surpass boundaries is transgressive by definition, and often overtly criminal as when characterized as unleashing furies from their prisons beneath the earth or as seeking to topple the Olympian gods. Virgil imitates Homer's description of Strife, towering from earth to the heavens (Il. 4.440-43), in his description of Fama, sister of the giants, born in anger against the gods (Aen. 4.178-80). For Hardie, this personification of the spoken word is ‘a dark double of the poet, twinned in rivalry with the epic poet's own expansionist ambitions’.Footnote 13 Although the poetics of nefas, which rejoices in overturning what tradition has sanctioned, is hugely influential in the discourse of epic and tragic ambition, there exist other more nuanced representations of grand aspiration.Footnote 14 In Hor. Carm. 2.19 ecstasy, gigantomachy and katabasis mark an amplification to lyric's generic limits, but an amplification that is insistently fas. Footnote 15 In Carm. 3.25 straying from the path in a state of Dionysiac madness to insert Caesar among the gods is characterized as dangerously ambitious rather than criminal: a ‘sweet peril’ (dulce periculum, 18).Footnote 16 Hercules’ attempt, in Seneca's tragedy, to insert himself among the gods is a familiar gesture in the poetics of sublimity, but these poetics, while commonly transgressive, show significant variation.
LonginusFootnote 17 applies the same image of Strife which informed Virgil's Fama to Homer himself, apparently more with admiration rather than a sense of the poet's dark double (Longin. 9.5—the text is fragmentary). As Doreen Innes (2006), 308, has noted, liberation characterizes Longinus’ imagery of sublimity.Footnote 18 When we are imprisoned by our own desires (Longin. 44.6), political tyranny (44.2f.) or when we are ‘swathed round from our first tender thoughts in the same habits and customs’ (τοῖς αὐτοῖς ἔθεσι καὶ ἐπιτηδεύμασιν ἐξ ἁπαλῶν ἔτι φρονημάτων μόνον οὐκ ἐνεσπαργανωμένοι, 44.3), we cannot produce sublime poetry. Only by breaking free of the constraints of habit and custom, by daring to reshape our textual universe do we achieve high art.Footnote 19 James Porter argues with reference to Longinus that gigantomachic imagery is purged of any moral offence in a poetics of the sublime precisely because it is to be interpreted figuratively.Footnote 20 One may compare the clear separation made by Gregson Davis on Hor. Carm. 3.4.6: ‘pius, as so often in the Odes, is not so much a moral as a literary badge of competence.’Footnote 21 But Longinus hesitates to distinguish so sharply. Homer's visions of theomachy and the shattering of the cosmos (Il. 20.61-65) he describes as blasphemous and indecent unless interpreted allegorically (Longin. 9.6), but more generally as ὑπερφυᾶ, (‘remarkable’ 9.5). The word is carefully chosen: ‘monstrous, extraordinary, in good and bad sense’ according to the definition of LSJ.Footnote 22 Shattering epic visions such as these cannot be treated independently of their literal subject; moral ruin is not transfigured absolutely in metapoetic metaphor. For Longinus, the sea parting in joyous recognition of its divine master (Hom. Il. 13.27-29) is ‘much better’ (9.8) because the divine is there represented as ‘truly undefiled, great and pure’ (ἄχραντόν τι καὶ μέγα…ὡς ἀληθῶς καὶ ἄκρατον, 9.8).
The opening act of Seneca's Hercules Furens encourages metaliterary interpretation, with its presentation of a number of figures familiar in literary programmes. Juno's invocation of a Fury to set the tragedy in motion, and her fears of an impious assault on the heavens, are followed by an ode modelled on an ode in Euripides’ Phaethon.Footnote 23 The chorus contrasts its own simple life with that of Hercules, who has returned from the Stygian waves and now sets his sights on Olympus:
Let glory carry another man to many lands, let chattering fame praise him in every city, and raise him equal to the heaven and stars. Let another man ride aloft in a chariot: As for me, let my own land protect me at a safe and private hearth.
Although this lyric rejects sky-reaching fama, it does not view such ambition as Juno does, as a path forged by destruction (iter ruina quaeret, HF 67).Footnote 24 The opening act of the play thus presents, poetically as well as ethically, the ambivalence of the transgressive hero. It is an ambivalence drawn from the variety of Seneca's models: Juno's perspective has its roots in the Aeneid, but the chorus quoted above in Horatian lyric.Footnote 25 Through this variety of sources Seneca presents contrasting images of the poetics of high ambition.
The First Ode of Hercules Furens: A Medley of Genres
The myth of Phaethon, first introduced by the Euripidean intertext, foreshadows events later in the play. Hercules will like Phaethon fail in his ambition to replace his divine father (HF 924-73) and be ruined. Reminiscences of Ovid's account of Phaethon's fatal chariot ride in the opening lines of Seneca's first ode and in his description of Hercules’ madness maintain the parallel.Footnote 26 If the first ode's characterization of heroic ambition as riding high in a chariot is part of a recurrent engagement with the myth of Phaethon, its lyric form and brief priamel recall Horace and in particular Odes 1.1 and the rejection of a life of Olympic and political glory (Carm. 1.1.3-8). In his recent book on Senecan intertextuality, Christopher Trinacty argues that tragedy, with its lyric interludes, dialogue and epic descriptions, is an amalgam of modes which draws widely from the Latin literary tradition for its inspiration.Footnote 27 In this particular case the chorus’ rejection of heroic ambition is both an ethical and a poetic choice: the lyric voice of the chorus recoils not just from a life of perilous struggle, but from the elevated register of sublime poetry. A similar effect is achieved at the opening act of Thyestes where the epic/tragic scene of the Fury summoning Tantalus to drive his descendants to crime (and to infect the Argolid with a fiery heat inspired, again, by Ovid's description of Phaethon's chariot ride)Footnote 28 is followed by a chorus whose vision of kindly gods watching over the cool beauty of the river Alpheos is radically different. Such difference may be construed in ethical terms—the chorus’ faith in providence and a natural order contrasting with the Fury's pursuit of crime and anger beyond limits—and in poetic terms. Unlike epic and tragedy, lyric is not generically disposed to range beyond limits, and indeed it defines itself by its reluctance to do so.Footnote 29
Juno ends her introductory monologue in Hercules Furens with the words:
Now my war must be set in motion: the day brightens, and radiant Titan rises in saffron dawn.
Her epic call to armsFootnote 30 carries over into the opening of the first ode, with the military metaphors of the dawn's victory over night:Footnote 31
Now few stars shine faintly in the falling sky. Vanquished night gathers her wandering fires as the light is reborn; the Dawnstar brings up the rear of the glittering army.
Agmen (‘army’) is commonly used for a column of troops, and Fitch suggests that ‘rara micant perhaps echoes Vergil's evocative reference to campfires in an unguarded enemy camp…(Aen. 9.189f.).Footnote 32 Agmen can be used for groups of animals—though ‘often w. strong reminiscence of mil. senses’ OLD s.v. 9) and indeed Fitch in the new Loeb translation renders cogit nitidum Phosphorus agmen as ‘the Dawnstar shepherds the glittering throng’.Footnote 33 I have preferred the more military ‘brings up the rear’ for cogit: this ode will become a peaceful, georgic song, but not yet. Titan looks out over Mount Oeta, where in his later tragic history Hercules will be consumed, and where ‘the thickets made famous by Theban Bacchants grow red, spattered with daylight’ (iam Cadmeis inclita Bacchis / aspersa die dumeta rubent, 134f.). A ‘Thracian paramour’ (Thracia paelex, 149), Philomela, sings among her plaintive nestlings. The death of Pentheus and Philomela's song for the murdered child Itys are as ominous as the intertextual presence of Phaethon, and all are tragic characters. The song will turn from such material to celebrate the simple life of shepherds and a georgic regime of labor… durus (‘hard toil’, 137). The shift is generic as well as ethical.
One may compare the structure of a poem like Horace, Carm. 4.12. In the opening stanzas the poet moves from rivers swollen with winter snows (hiberna niue turgidi, 4.12.4) via the lament of Philomela and the lusts of kings (regum…libidines, 4.12.8) to the tender grass (tenero gramine, 4.12.9) and hills of Arcadia (colles Arcadiae, 4.12.12). The poem is an invitation to Virgil, though the historical poet was already dead. As in Carm. 1.3, where Horace defines his lyric poetics against Virgil's epic ambitions,Footnote 34 here also Virgil's surviving texts—not least the generic composite that is Ecl. 6—offer a foil for an alternative Horatian programme.Footnote 35 Scholars have interpreted the variant strains of Horace's spring music differently. For Michael Putnam, Philomela is a tragic character;Footnote 36 for Davis, she is more elegiac.Footnote 37 But the key point is that Horace, having paid tribute to Virgil, presents the alternative poetics of his lyric conuiuium. Thoughts of black fire (nigrorumque memor… ignium, 4.12.26), and poetic memories of the Aeneid, threaten at the close of his poem, and it is from such epic death and violence that the lyric song offers respite.Footnote 38 In Seneca's ode as in Horace's ethical choices are framed as choices between the discourses characteristic of different literary genres. Seneca emphasizes the diversity of the dawn chorus:
and all around sounds a mingled throng, proclaiming the day with voices blending.
From this medley of literary voices the chorus and Hercules make contrasting selections.
Lucretius and the Violent Pursuit of Serenity
The sun's rising brings hard toil (labor… durus, HF 137) to shepherds and others, whose simple lives, however hard, are tranquil ease compared explicitly to the trials of the restless city (159-63) and implicitly to the tragedies that populate the slopes of Mount Oeta. If an opposition between city and country is generally familiar, the conjunction labor durus is, as Fitch notes,Footnote 39 particularly Virgilian, occurring twice in the Georgics (2.412 and 4.114). Labor appears thirty-four times in the Georgics and defines the new world order after the Golden Age: labor omnia uicit / improbus et duris urgens in rebus egestas (‘Toil conquered the world, unrelenting toil, and want that pinches when life is hard’, Georg. 1.145f.). Paradoxically this unrelenting toil allows the recovery of something at least reminiscent of the Golden Age: secura quies (‘repose without care’, Georg. 2.467) in the land where Justice last walked the earth.Footnote 40 Again, prominent among the cares from which the farmers are free are the pursuit of wealth and political power.Footnote 41 The very phrase secura quies recurs at HF 175. While Hercules hastens to visit the gloomy dead (187) the chorus recommends that we live joyful while the fates allow (178). The song ends with the words, alte uirtus animosa cadit (‘Spirited valour falls from great height’, HF 201).
Commentary on the ode roots the chorus’ resistance to Herculean ambition in the poetry particularly of Virgil (Georgics) and Horace (Odes).Footnote 42 Generalizing about these authors Hardie writes, ‘For the Augustan poets, Virgil and Horace above all, Lucretius is the source of vatic commitment and sublimity of purpose and expression, which yet neither Virgil nor Horace is able—or willing—consistently to sustain’.Footnote 43 Of course the Georgics define themselves poetically with reference to many more authors and genres than Lucretius’ didactic epic: Virgil calls on Bacchus to remove his tragic buskins before treading the grapes (Georg. 2.7f.),Footnote 44 chooses a terrain free from ‘the bizarre heroic ploughings of the Argonautic saga’Footnote 45 (and distinguishes his current project from a future martial epic (Georg. 3.8-39). But the relationship with, and deviation from, Lucretius remains of cardinal importance. In his praise of the happy farmers and the land where Justice last walked the earth, Virgil writes:
Blessed is he who has been able to win knowledge of the causes of things, and has cast beneath his feet all fear and unyielding Fate, and the howls of hungry Acheron! Happy, too, is he who knows the woodland gods…
(tr. Fairclough rev. Goold)His aim is not simply to distinguish the subject matter of the Georgics from that of De Rerum Natura, but also its poetic register. This passage is commonly interpreted as a disavowal of Lucretian sublimity: the Georgics will not return in heroic triumph from Acheron, but seek felicity in a different literary mode.Footnote 46 The subjection of religious fear through knowledge of the causes of things is above all the victory of Lucretius’ Epicurus. Hercules, whose reckless descent to the underworld the chorus condemns, resembles Epicurus. Epicurus’ conquest of death liberated humanity from fear, and in Seneca's play Hercules’ victory, for as long as it lasts, is also seen as a liberation. The chorus of Thebans celebrates his return with the words, ‘and now no fear remains: nothing lies beyond the underworld’ (iam nullus superest timor: / nil ultra iacet inferos, HF 891f.). The nightmare of feeling oneself crushed beneath the weight of the earth after death is conjured by both poets (Lucr. 3.893, Sen. HF 858-60)Footnote 47 only to be banished, in very different ways, by the victories of their respective heroes.
Lucretius characterized Epicurus’ victory as a gigantomachic assault on religion's repressive tyranny.Footnote 48 Juno strives to crush Hercules (et me prementem, HF 74), but fears a second gigantomachy, which in his madness Hercules threatens to perform:
Will you receive me and unbar the sky? Or shall I tear down the door of the stubborn heaven?… Let the Titans prepare war, raging madly under my leadership.
Prominent in Seneca's account of Hercules’ madness is the image of the door: in quick succession the hero hallucinates that he is at the gate of heaven, the gate of hell and the gate of Mycenae (HF 961-1002), all barred against him. He breaks through a fourth, the door of the palace of Thebes, to commit the murders that are the play's tragic action. It is a powerful and repeated image of violent transgression. Festus derives the etymology of sublimis from limen, a lintel or threshold.Footnote 49 The verb resero (‘unbar’) appears elsewhere in the imagery of ‘poetic-vatic unlocking’ and the unleashing of sublime inspiration.Footnote 50 Crossing the doorway is an image that Lucretius uses of the inspiration for his poem, how religion stirred the courage of Epicurus’ mind…
…so that he should desire, first of all men, to shatter the confining bars of nature's gates. Therefore the lively power of his mind prevailed, and forth he marched far beyond the flaming walls of the heavens.
(tr. Rouse rev. Smith)It is a passage Seneca knew well. He recalls it to characterize both Alexander the Great's mad hunger for conquest and the enquiring passion of the human mind:Footnote 51
quaerit quod suum faciat, scrutatur maria ignota, in oceanum classes nouas mittit et ipsa, ut ita dicam, mundi claustra perrumpit.
(Sen. Ep. 119.7)He seeks something which he can really make his own, exploring unknown seas, sending new fleets over the Ocean, and, so to speak, breaking down the very bars of the universe.
(tr. Gummere)cogitatio nostra caeli munimenta perrumpit nec contenta est id, quod ostenditur, scire. ‘Illud scrutor, quod ultra mundum iacet…’
(Sen. Dial. 8.5.6)Our thought bursts through the ramparts of the sky, and is not content to know that which is revealed. ‘I search out that,’ it says, ‘which lies beyond the world…’
(tr. Basore)In redefining heroism, claiming the glorious imagery of conquest for more worthwhile pursuits, Seneca's philosophers follow in the steps of Lucretius. Lucretius’ Epicurus is characterized as the corrective of an epic hero, winning renown for the only victories that really matter, whether storming the citadel of superstition or hurling spears beyond infinity's edge (Lucr. 1.958-83).Footnote 52 For Monica Gale the gigantomachic impiety of Lucretius’ Epicurus is a provocation: ‘yes, the Epicureans are “Giants”, but it is not they who are impious, nor are they responsible for dragging down heavenly things to earth. Rather, believers in astral theology are in fact the impious ones.’Footnote 53 In similar provocation Lucretius assumes the mantle of the uates (poet/priest) in order to take a stand against religion and the threats of the uates. Footnote 54 Lucretius’ rebellion is not properly a rebellion against the gods, but a rebellion against a particular fama, what is said, about the gods.Footnote 55 His world-shattering victory is the textual victory of his own rival telling and a reorientation of epic poetry.Footnote 56 In this way he offers a paradigm for other sublime (inter)textual struggles for liberation.Footnote 57
Epicurus breaks through the flaming ramparts of the sky, but to acknowledge ultimately, nature's limits, as supernatural fantasists do not. The philosopher-hero, ranging free in the universe, learns that potential is not infinite, that there are deep-set boundaries at the heart of things (finita potestas….atque alte terminus haerens, Lucr. 1.75-77).Footnote 58 This phrase is a formula, a refrain in De Rerum Natura (1.77, 1.596, 5.90, 6.66). Although Seneca's Hercules and Lucretius’ Epicurus are both gigantomachic figures, Megara exhorts her husband to unLucretian excess: erumpe, rerum terminos tecum efferens (‘burst forth, taking with you nature's boundaries’, HF 290). Hercules, as she characterizes him, knows no limits. Breaking through the barrier leads in his case not to divine revelation and peace—and an acceptance of the deep-set boundaries that cannot be moved—but to delusion and murder.Footnote 59
Comparisons between Hercules and Epicurus go back to Lucretius: ‘But if you think the deeds of Hercules rival his, you will stray much further from true reasoning’ (Herculis antistare autem si facta putabis, / longius a uera multo ratione ferere, Lucr. 5.22f.). The Nemean lion and the hydra are remote and unimportant terrors compared to the monstrous desires which ‘tear humanity apart’ (scindunt hominem, 5.45). Our problem is not the hydra, but the monsters of the soul, the battles and dangers which ‘coil their way’ (insinuandum, 5.44) into minds unpurged by philosophy. When Seneca's Hercules falls into madness, he imagines he sees Tisiphone ‘fortified with snakes’ (serpentibus uallata, HF 985) a metaphor adapted from the hydra conquered by Hercules at Lucr. 5.27 (uallata colubris). Fitch has argued convincingly for a continuity between Hercules sane and insane, that the pattern of his heroic life ‘is already close to insanity’Footnote 60 before ever Juno intervenes. The labours shape his hallucinations; they give his madness its distinctive form.Footnote 61
Although Herculean virtue diverges from Epicurean, it also recalls it. At the moment of Hercules’ madness in Seneca's tragedy, the abrupt transition from a prayer for eternal peace and springtime to a gigantomachic assault on the barred gate of heaven (HF 927-73) is Lucretian. If the language of Seneca's description of a peaceful idyll is more immediately influenced by Augustan poets,Footnote 62 the progression from a pacified heaven to a war on heaven is the sequence of the first hundred lines of De Rerum Natura. Love of smiling Venus and war on religion's tyranny are there presented as contrasting facets of the Epicurean life and the Lucretian poem. One way of reconciling Hercules sane and Hercules insane is through such Lucretian paradox: the violent pursuit of serenity, the passionate triumph of reason. The Lucretian triumph combines a detachment from the terrors of mortal existence with awe at nature's grandeur. To understand the causes of things is simultaneously to be released from fear and to bring within the purview of the human mind the infinity of space and the destructive power of the earthquake.Footnote 63 These are paradoxes that characterize also the passages of Seneca's prose I have quoted. His philosopher-hero bursting through the ramparts of the sky (Dial. 8.5.6) appears in the dialogue De Otio (‘On Peace’) addressed to Serenus.Footnote 64 The description of poetic madness soaring aloft (Dial. 9.17.11) appears in the dialogue De Tranquillitate Animi (‘On Tranquility of Mind’) addressed again to Serenus.Footnote 65 In the Naturales Quaestiones a philosophical viewer spurns such cautious advice as offered in the first ode of Hercules Furens and chooses the heroic path:
securus aspiciet ruptis compagibus dehiscens solum, illa licet inferorum regna retegantur. stabit super illam uoraginem intrepidus, et fortasse quo debebit cadere desiliet.
(Sen. Nat. 6.32.4).Secure, he will view the ground gaping open with its framework broken, even though the regions of the dead are uncovered. Without fear he will stand at the edge of that abyss [pause] and perhaps he will jump into the place where he will have to fall.Footnote 66
(tr. Corcoran)Gareth Williams comments on this passage, ‘Such a man serenely embraces the rage of nature… In his complete grasp of nature and his fearless superiority over all that she throws against him, such a man embodies the Lucretian/Senecan sublimity of thought that transports the mind beyond conventional human vulnerability… The transcendent perspective is…another version of the megalophrosyne, the mental grandeur, that elevates the sublime sapiens across his corpus’.Footnote 67
Tony BoyleFootnote 68 finds another parallel for Seneca's philosophical hero in Astyanax, who at the end of Troades ‘walks with lofty gait’ (sublimi gradu / incedit, 1088f.) to the top of Troy's walls, remained dry-eyed while all wept (1099-1100) until finally, ‘he leapt down of his own accord’ (sponte desiluit sua, 1102). Before his fall Astyanax ‘turned his gaze fiercely this way and that, fearless in spirit’ (uultus huc et huc acres tulit / intrepidus animo, 1092f.). The description of the mere child Astyanax echoes that of great Hercules at HF 953 (quo, nate, uultus huc et huc acres refers?).
The challenging gaze is a defining feature of the rhetoric of poetic grandeur since Epicurus faced down religion: primum Graius homo mortalis tollere contra / est oculos ausus (‘a man of Greece was the first that dared uplift mortal eyes against her’, Lucr. 1.66f.).Footnote 69 Not all manage to follow Epicurus’ example. Helen Lovatt, writes of Ovid's Phaethon, undone by Lucretian daring, ‘His failure to drive the chariot is repeatedly portrayed as a failure of the Olympian gaze (Met. 2.178-81).’Footnote 70 In what is often read in metaliterary terms as a narrative of poetic ambition, the fantastic visions of the upper realms unnerve the hero, and his horses run to headlong ruin.Footnote 71 Ingo Gildenhard, discussing the influence of Lucretius on Virgil's Hercules in Aeneid 8, coins the phrase ‘drama of vision’ for such confrontations (37), and the opposition of those who dare and those who fear to see.Footnote 72
Seneca's Hercules tragedy is no less concerned with dramas and contests of vision. Discussions of the drama of vision in Lucretius typically note the poet's indebtedness to earlier theatre,Footnote 73 and Seneca may be viewed as engaging with his tragic antecedents via the pattern given such prominence in this epic intermediary. Juno recounts:
I myself saw, when he had shattered the darkness of the underworld and subdued Dis, I saw him showing off to his father his brother's spoils… I saw the daylight faltering at the sight of Cerberus, and the Sun afraid; I too was seized with trembling, and as I gazed at the three necks of the defeated monster, I feared what I had commanded.
The fear of Juno and the Sun—and that of CerberusFootnote 74 —stands in sharp contrast to the joy with which Hercules accepts his terrible tasks: laetus imperia excipit (HF 42). Hercules’ own account of his latest labour stresses his unrivalled ability to withstand the sight of horror:
Pardon, Phoebus, if your eyes have seen anything forbidden. I brought earth's hidden things into the light under orders. And you, ruler and father of the heavenly gods, hold out the thunderbolt to shield your vision; and you who rule the seas with the second-drawn scepter, make for your deepest waters. All who look from on high on earthly things, for fear of being defiled by this strange sight, should turn their gaze away and lift their eyes to heaven, shunning such a monstrosity. Let only two behold this enormity: he who brought it, she who ordered it. For Juno's hatred the earth is not broad enough to assign me punishment and suffering: I have seen places inaccessible to all.
Amphitryon remembers the serene gaze of the infant Hercules:
Twin snakes with crested heads turned their mouths toward him; the child crawled to meet them, looking into the serpents’ fiery eyes with a relaxed and calm heart; he endured their tight coils with a serene expression…
This is the realization of the Lucretian hero, the image if ever there was of a man serenely embracing the rage of nature. But it is a poise that will fail in Hercules Furens, when the contest of the hero's infancy is ironically recalled later in the play, and when in some sense Hercules becomes the snake that his own child cannot face:Footnote 75
Terrified by his father's blazing eyes, the child died before being wounded, terror snatched his life away.
Lovatt comments, with reference to the epic tradition, ‘Perhaps the uncontrolled nature of the violence conveyed by blazing eyes makes it both more than, and less than, human.’Footnote 76 In the grip of madness Hercules is mastered by monstrous violence to become Juno's creation, the intertextual product of the furor and ira of the Aeneid. Juno at the end of her prologue turns the snaky furies (agmen horrendum anguibus, 101) against herself and thus models the tragedy's climactic act:
So that Alcides may lose his mind and be driven on, moved by mighty rage, I must feel madness first.
The Lucretian hero offered within the epic tradition an alternative construction of controlled violence and sublime poetics. But it is Hercules’ doom to succumb to Junonian anger and to the influence of Virgil, whose hellish images of creative energy are so familiar in the work of his epic successors.Footnote 77 Erik Gunderson offers a quite different reading of the play, yet stresses also the impulse to repeat in this and other Senecan tragedies: ‘Of course, many of Seneca's dramas are repetitive… And yet there is also regularly within them a striving to make a break. A fantasy shimmers before our eyes: perhaps this last example that we are presently watching will not so much belong to the old set of examples as be the first element in an entirely new set.’Footnote 78 In intertextual terms the Junonian poetics of the Aeneid are a paradigm from which Hercules fails to escape. Juno comments ironically, ‘When the crime is completed, let his father admit those hands to heaven’ (scelere perfecto licet / admittat illas genitor in caelum manus, HF 121f.), knowing that the act of criminal madness will make an Olympian ascent impossible. One shimmering fantasy—elusive, for tragedies are constrained to repeat—is an alternative poetics of sublimity. They appear, in outline, Lucretian rather than entirely new, only to recede in an explosion of Junonian anger.Footnote 79
Georgic Labor and a Mightier Orpheus
As noted above the first chorus of Hercules Furens opposes a life of georgic labor durus (‘hard toil’) and the daily round of cares (137f.) to the dangerous uirtus of Hercules, which hastens to the lower world (186f.) and aspires to the upper (194-96). Georgic moderation recoils from the limitless ambitions and careless violence of sublime poetry.Footnote 80 But the opposition is not so simple. Hercules is, if such a thing is possible, a georgic figure writ large: labor appears repeatedly of the labours of Hercules (41, 71, 248, 313, 605 etc.) and he returns from the underworld to defend his wife and ‘flock’ of children (gregem, 203). The chorus defines its own life as harmless (innocuae… uitae, 159), in contrast to the transgression-filled lives of the powerful, yet Hercules will claim later that his own heroic labores have secured the ruris innocui labor (‘toil of the harmless countryside’, 930). Amphitryon complains that he has had no day free from cares (207f.), confirming perhaps how remote his life is from georgic tranquility. His prayer to Jupiter to impose a limit (modum, 206) and bring an end (finem, 208) to disaster situates Hercules’ life firmly in the world of Junonian anger,Footnote 81 yet even to the humble folk each day's dawning brings cares. It is only because the shepherd discharges his cares that the flocks are free to gambol in their idyll (139-45) and he himself can lead a tranquil life.
The paradox of a georgic figure writ large is familiar from Virgil's Georgics. Even as the Georgics defer the celebration of military conflict and global mastery for another work and another day (Georg. 3.10-39), analogies between farming and warfareFootnote 82 and arguments from geographical determinism bring the political glory of Rome within the orbit of a poem about the land of Italy.Footnote 83 Furthermore, the characterization of the poetics of the Georgics as disavowing Lucretian sublimity and violent passion in favour of labor and cura is only half true. Monica Gale writes: ‘The poet is like the farmer; in the irrationality of his inspiration, he is like the unruly nature that the farmer strives to control.’Footnote 84 This fragile balance between ars and ingenium reflects at the poetic level the natural law of the Georgics, by which the principle of degeneration (Georg. 1.197-203) is offset in the animal world only by careful breeding for strength and emulous ambition (Georg. 3.49-283) which must yet be contained.Footnote 85 If the ‘civil war’ between the anthropomorphized bulls of book 3 culminates in a sublime simile and the majestic violence of a tsunami (Georg. 3.237-41), the beekeeper must for the good of the hive intervene to end the civil war of the bees by killing the weaker king (Georg. 4.88-90).Footnote 86 As the animals of Georgics 3 are possessed by passion and defy any curb or restraint, so too the poet is transported:
But sweet desire hurries me over the lonely steeps of Parnassus; joyous it is to roam o'er heights, where no forerunner's track turns by a gentle slope down to Castalia. Now, worshipful Pales, now we must sing in lofty strain.
(tr. Fairclough rev. Goold)This recalls Lucretius’ description of the impassioned poet of Nature at 1.922-30, where the poet, smitten by the thyrsus and love of the muses, is inspired to wander untrodden paths.Footnote 87 Bacchic inspiration drove Lucretius into new territory—within a hundred lines of the poet being struck by the thyrsus, his philosophical disciple is found throwing a spear at infinity's edge—and a recognizably similar ecstasy grips his successor, Virgil.Footnote 88 This is the sublime madness that the Georgics typically recoil from, but cannot or will not let go entirely. It is hardly surprising that continuity in Seneca's tragedy between georgic and Herculean labor destabilizes any simple opposition, when the Georgics themselves struggle to resist the dangerous lure of the sublime. I record as ominous the parallel noted by Roger Mynors in his commentary on Georg. 3.284-94: ‘No other book [in the Georgics] has a similar division, with a subsidiary preface to the second half and an invocation; but no other book demands it. A. 7.37-45 has a few similar features.’Footnote 89
Juno realizes Hercules can be defeated only by himself (HF 84f.), and the madness she invokes is that of ‘Rage, always armed against itself’ (in se semper armatus Furor, 98). Critics have rightly traced the inspiration of Seneca's play to the Aeneid, to the anger of the Virgilian Juno, and the unleashing of civil war in Italy. I agree, but suggest that we may valuably extend the range of Seneca's Virgilian past to the Georgics, which offer an earlier lens through which to view Herculean aspiration. The dialectic between ars and ingenium plays out in the epyllion of the Georgics in the persons of Aristaeus and Orpheus. The hive is restored through Aristaeus’ care; Eurydice lost by Orpheus’ uncontrolled passion and mourned in his song. If the praise of a humble labor durus in the first ode of Seneca's tragedy recalls one aspect of the Georgics, the second ode (524-91), recalls another. At its close it celebrates Hercules for surpassing Orpheus with a more successful and more violent katabasis (590f.), though later events will align the heroes as destroyers of their loved ones.Footnote 90 In poetic terms Orpheus in the post-Georgic tradition is typically associated with poetry in its more powerful and passionate modes.Footnote 91 His unconsoled lament and sparagmos at the hands of Bacchants ties him particularly to the genre of tragedy.Footnote 92 Charles Segal (1983) has discovered the figure of Orpheus himself or Orphic patterns in almost all of Seneca's tragedies. Medea and Hercules alike recall the poet Orpheus only to exceed his power, in an image of the emulative poetics of Seneca himself.Footnote 93 Not all would agree that ‘[t]he death of Orpheus, like those of the Civil Wars which it reflects, is sanitized in the Virgilian scheme’ (of the Georgics),Footnote 94 but the location of the origins of Seneca's determinedly unsanitized poetics of excess in the passions and poetry of Virgilian civil war is uncontroversial.Footnote 95
The madness of Orpheus, barely recuperated by the labours of Aristaeus, is an ethical and poetic tension revisited in subsequent poetry, most notably the Aeneid. Readings vary, from Segal's vision of an Aeneas who combines within a single figure the polarities, ethical and aesthetic, of Orpheus and Aristaeus,Footnote 96 to emphasis on Aeneas’ corrective repetition of Orpheus: ‘Orpheus’ descent to the underworld is famously replayed in Aeneid 6… but the context of the katabasis is ideologically transformed, with successful nationalistic and pious enterprise replacing failed and sentimental self-indulgence.’Footnote 97 Another Virgilian reiteration of the figure of Orpheus is Hercules himself, descending to a quasi-underworld in the cave of Cacus in Aeneid 8.285-305.Footnote 98 Again readings vary, from Putnam's vision of a Hercules whose monstrosity mirrors that of Cacus and feeds back corrosively into our reception of the parallel triumphs of Aeneas and Augustus,Footnote 99 to Gildenhard's accommodation of sublime violence: ‘beneath all the undeniable complexities, Virgil's plot is one of salvation and triumph.’Footnote 100
The problematic victory of the Virgilian Hercules is a subject to which Seneca returns in his tragedy.Footnote 101 But on no construction could Seneca's plot be represented as one of ‘salvation and triumph’ or as a corrective repetition of Orpheus. The hero becomes the monster as, at the moment of his successful return from the underworld, furor overwhelms him with irreparable tragic consequence. Hercules’ labours are unmade in a catastrophe more violent than that of Orpheus. Still under the influence of anger he determines to eclipse and obliterate himself:
An impious monster, savage, merciless, wild, has long been ranging before me. Come, my right hand, attempt to undertake a huge work, greater than the twelve labours.
The impulse driving the protagonist to a greater work is the most familiar in Seneca's poetics. Here a more violent Orpheus exceeds the figure who was for the Augustans a paradigm of the uates and an image of an all-puissant poet. In Odes 3.25 an ecstatic Horace ranged across a wild landscape among Bacchants whose god lent them the power even to uproot trees. Seneca's Hercules in his greater madness threatens to cut down forests and burn the groves of Bacchus (HF 1285-87).Footnote 102 What gives Hercules Furens a distinctive voice and makes its hero a more complex character are traces of Lucretian patterns of poetic aspiration, and here the memories of the Georgics, of furor and labor held in tension on the dangerous brink of sublimity. That Hercules, under the influence of Junonian madness, decisively upsets such a balance is beyond dispute. The civil war passions of the Aeneid and the Georgics alike erupt in universal ruin. But among the ruins is a recognizably Virgilian dialectic: Herculean grandeur, poised between Orphic madness to which it is likened and georgic labor, which it resembles, is a Virgilian construct. These are polarities in Virgil's metapoetic discourse whose balance and tension Seneca presents in Hercules Furens before overwhelming and upstaging.Footnote 103
