It has long been noticed that in his Oedipus, Seneca diverges conspicuously from his primary model, Sophocles’ Oedipus Tyrannus (OT), in a number of aspects.Footnote 1 Prominent among these is an expansive, two-part ritual sequence at the play's center, comprising a prodigy-filled yet spectacularly unsuccessful sacrifice and extispicium followed by a more successful, if no less terrifying, necromancy to raise the slain Laius. This article concentrates on the sacrifice and extispicium (Sen. Oed. 288-402). I argue that in this episode Seneca has employed tragic contaminatio (the weaving into one play of significant elements from two or more different source plays) and allusion to produce an exceptionally innovative scene that is a remarkable display of the Roman playwright's ingenuity.Footnote 2 For while Sophocles’ OT remains an active intertext, Seneca has also imported elements from Euripides’ Phoenissae. His primary model for the passage, moreover, is actually to be found in a different Sophoclean Theban play, Antigone. Specifically, Seneca has reworked and elaborated upon the climactic reversal scene between Creon and Tiresias in Antigone (998-1114), in which the seer reports on the corruption of the prophetic rites he has just performed and identifies Creon as the cause of the pollution, both for his continued refusal to allow the burial of the fallen Polyneices and for his entombment of the living Antigone.
In incorporating material from these earlier tragedies to augment his version of Oedipus’ story, Seneca has used several different poetic strategies inherited from his Greek and Roman predecessors in tragedy and epic.Footnote 3 Notable among these is, first, increasing the visual impact of a scene by the representation onstage, ‘in real time’, of actions or events traditionally envisioned as occurring offstage, then reported after the fact by a messenger.Footnote 4 In this instance, Seneca has transformed the Sophoclean Tiresias’ report of the (offstage) divination that prompted his appearance in Thebes to admonish Creon into a fully-fledged spectacle imagined as performed before the eyes of an audience.Footnote 5 A second strategy is the poet's exploitation of the flexibility of the mythic tradition, a flexibility which extended to character construction and allowed not only for varying representations of the same character but also for partial conflation of different characters due to similarities in their paradigmatic qualities and situations.Footnote 6 Seneca's partial blending of characters and situations from earlier tragedies into his Oedipus is particularly effective not only because Tiresias and Creon appear in all three Greek plays but also because there is a genealogical connection between Oedipus and Creon. And since for his Oedipus Seneca has inverted the situation (and, in the case of Tiresias, the characterization) of his models in certain significant ways, there is increased dramatic irony in his version, as the Senecan audience has greater knowledge than any of the drama's characters. As a third strategy, Seneca takes advantage of the sacrifice and extispicium as spectacle to highlight the allusive and metatheatrical aspects of his scene; and because contamination is the very subject of Seneca's episode, it may be viewed as a metatheatrical commentary on the creative process of contaminatio itself.Footnote 7
By encouraging his readers, via contaminatio and allusion, to compare Tiresias’ attempted divination in Oedipus to its counterpart in Sophocles’ Antigone, Seneca brings into stark relief the greater complexity of Oedipus’ tragic situation in his play. The Tiresias of Antigone immediately recognizes the source and meaning of the polluted rites with which he has been busied and identifies the gods’ anger at Creon's refusal to allow Polyneices’ burial as the cause. In contrast, through the deeply disturbing behavior of the ritual elements in Oedipus, which simultaneously appear to demand interpretation yet defy Tiresias’ comprehension, Seneca draws attention to the many interrelated factors that have contributed to render his Oedipus’ guilt and fate overdetermined.Footnote 8 In addition to the crimes of parricide and incest foretold by Apollo's oracle, these contributing factors include: the entire problematic history of the Theban land, the earliest origins of which were ill-omened, both involving and presaging civil war; the future crimes of Oedipus’ family, especially those of his sons; the confounding of Nature, evidenced most obviously in the devastating effects of the plague, due in Seneca's version both to the unnatural births that characterized Thebes’ distant past and to the unnatural acts of Oedipus and Jocasta that are the most recent manifestation of Thebes’ corrupted nature; and finally, a Bacchic dimension, involved in the play's emphasis on revenge, which begins to exert its influence in the sacrifice. The insufficiency of the extispicium to supply the most immediately necessary information (‘who is Laius’ killer?’), and the need to summon Laius himself through necromancy, further suggest that the entire cosmos—including not only the earth and the upper world, but also the underworld—is involved in Oedipus’ (and Thebes’) plight.
A Euripidean Entrance for Seneca's (‘Sophoclean’) Tiresias
Seneca's Oedipus, in contrast to his Sophoclean counterpart, already possesses a sense of his own culpability at the start of the play: in the prologue, he reports explicitly Apollo's oracles, which foretold his patricide and incest, and he proceeds to describe his attempts to thwart them, even going so far as to consider himself responsible for the plague-ridden Thebes’ plight. By transferring information revealed only in the later scenes of Sophocles’ OT to the opening of his own tragedy, Seneca alerts his audience from the start that he has a different plan for how his version of the drama will unfold.Footnote 9
The play's lengthy second act falls into two parts (202-287; 288-402), the first commencing with Creon's relation of his visit to Phoebus’ oracle to receive the god's riddling instructions, and continuing with Oedipus’ curse on the murderer of Laius, then Creon's description of the triple crossroads where the attack on Thebes’ former king occurred. The second part, our focus here, begins when Tiresias arrives, guided by his daughter Manto, an entrance that interrupts the exchange under way between Creon and Oedipus. Further attempts are now made to discover the identity of Laius’ killer through sacrifice and extispicium. When these methods fail to provide clear messages or to evoke the murderer's name, Tiresias proposes the use of necromancy to raise Laius himself for questioning, and the act ends as the participants depart to perform the ritual.
Let us first consider Tiresias’ arrival in Seneca's play:
Creon: At just the right time, summoned by Phoebus’ oracle, Tiresias rushes in, though slowed down by his trembling knees, and Manto as his companion is leading her father widowed of sight.
Tiresias’ entrance in Oedipus is depicted as sudden and unexpected. Nonetheless, the prophet's arrival is marked as ‘just in time’ (in tempore ipso, 288) by Creon, who surmises that Tiresias was summoned directly by Apollo's oracle. Creon further points out, with seeming paradox, that Tiresias, despite his slowness due to the trembling knees of old age, rushes in (tardus accelerat, 289), led by Manto.
Boyle has labeled Seneca's in tempore ipso to signal the timing of Tiresias’ entrance a ‘clear metatheatrical marker’, not only because the seer's appearance at this point coincides with the audience's expectation of his imminent arrival, based on the precedent of Sophocles’ OT, but also because the specification of Tiresias’ arrival as ‘timely’ both points to the immediate need for the prophet's help to identify Laius’ killer and highlights the fact that his entrance at this particular moment in Seneca's play effectively prevents additional questioning of Creon by Oedipus.Footnote 11 In tempore ipso serves as an allusive indicator as well, one which involves an inversion of detail. In Sophocles’ OT, Tiresias’ arrival was anticipated: in OT 287-89 Oedipus assured the chorus that the prophet had been summoned by him on Creon's advice. Moreover, Sophocles’ Oedipus expressed surprise (and perhaps impatience) that Tiresias had been so long in coming:
Indeed, I have not acted negligently in this matter, either! For at Creon's word I sent a two-man escort to bring him; and I have long been surprised that he is not here.Footnote 12
There are additional telling allusive elements in Seneca's presentation of Tiresias, which signal our first, brief but significant, instance of contaminatio. While Tiresias had an unnamed boy as escort in Sophocles’ OT, the boy was addressed only once, as Tiresias prepared to depart (444), and he never spoke. The introduction by Seneca of Tiresias’ daughter Manto, as well as his emphasis on the seer's aged weakness, recall most closely Tiresias’ entrance in Euripides’ Phoenissae.Footnote 13 In Phoenissae, Creon's son Menoeceus had been sent on an urgent mission to bring Tiresias to Thebes. The seer arrived exhausted from his journey and accompanied by his (unnamed) daughter, who carried with her the ‘lot tablets’ of divination on which Tiresias’ notes from the bird omens he had recently interpreted were recorded:
Tiresias: Go in front to lead me, daughter! You are the guiding eye for my blind steps, as a star is the guide for sailors. As you set my feet here on the level ground, go ahead of me, so that I do not stumble. Your father is weak. And guard my lot tablets with your maiden hand, lots I took when I perceived the bird omens in the holy seats where I prophesy.
Child Menoeceus, son of Creon, tell me how much remains of the road through the city to your father. For my knees are weary; and since I take small steps, my progress is slow.Footnote 14
In the ensuing exchange between Euripides’ Creon and Tiresias, the audience's attention was further directed to the laborious and unavailing haste of the Methuselan Tiresias’ journey from Athens as reason for his extreme weariness. Seneca's appropriation of this Euripidean moment is indicated not only by his inclusion of Tiresias’ daughter Manto but also through his Creon's description of Tiresias’ pace as slow, yet rushing (tardus accelerat, 289), and of his trembling knees (tremulo genu, 289), details that recall the weary knees and slow progress of Euripides’ prophet at Phoen. 843f.
Seneca has done more than simply allude to Euripides here. Rather, he has imported from Euripides’ Phoenissae the aged Tiresias’ arrival in Thebes with his daughter and initial encounter with Creon as a significant building block in his construction of a new sequence of scenes that will augment and reconfigure the ‘Sophoclean OT’ kernel of his tragedy. This brief instance of Euripidean contaminatio served Seneca's purposes in a number of ways. First, his adoption here of Euripides’ emphasis on Tiresias’ weakness due to age and his need for a sighted escort will prove, in the upcoming lines, to be an early intimation of Seneca's distinctive characterization of the seer as less vigorous and knowledgable than his traditional representation, a characterization that serves in part as motivation for the performance of prophetic rites in the upcoming scene. Moreover, the figure of Tiresias’ daughter in Phoenissae, who was not only her father's guide but also the guardian of his divination tablets, very likely suggested to Seneca the greater development of Manto's role for his tragedy.Footnote 15 A third purpose once again involves the timing of Tiresias’ arrival in Oedipus. In Sophocles’ OT, Creon was not present for the confrontation between Tiresias and Oedipus; therefore, a noteworthy aspect of the seer's ‘timely’ arrival in Seneca's play is its coincidence with Creon's presence. Another motivation for Seneca's allusive importation of the meeting between Creon and Tiresias from Euripides’ play, then, was that it served to set the stage for his more elaborate instance of contaminatio, from Sophocles’ Antigone. In preparation for this, the Roman playwright has arranged to keep Creon around for much longer. For, although Creon does not speak again, he remains on stage, to be addressed by Oedipus in 399f. I will return to this point. For now, it is enough to note that Oedipus, Tiresias, and Creon, never together in Sophocles’ OT, share the stage of Seneca's Oedipus for this unusual episode.
While Seneca has chosen to employ Euripides’ Phoenissae as his model for Creon's introduction of the prophet, his portrayal of the initial encounter between Oedipus and Tiresias is composed in response to the pair's Sophoclean meeting. When Seneca's Oedipus first addresses the seer, in 291f., his words recall the Sophoclean chorus’ description of Tiresias in OT 284-86:
You, consecrated to the gods, your head closest to Phoebus’, explain the oracle's response; tell whom it seeks for punishment.
I know that the one whose power of sight is closest to that of lord Phoebus is lord Tiresias; from him, someone making inquiry in these matters, lord, might learn the clearest information.
The words of Sophocles’ chorus point to one of the primary motifs of Sophocles’ OT, the association of blindness with knowledge and insight; and Sophocles’ Oedipus greets Tiresias with an acknowledgment of the seer's special access to knowledge: ‘even though you cannot see, you understand what manner of disease besets our city’ (OT 302f.). Still, the Sophoclean Oedipus does not assume that Tiresias has arrived in Thebes with prior knowledge of the words of the Delphic oracle or the identity of Laius’ killer. Instead, he makes a request of the prophet:
Do not, then, refuse to employ a message from the birds or if you have any other course of prophecy, and save yourself and the city, and save me, and save us from all the pollution coming from the dead man.
Contrary to Oedipus’ expectation, the Tiresias of the Oedipus Tyrannus requires no new means of prophetic divination; he has full knowledge from Apollo already and is able to point to Oedipus himself as Laius’ murderer and the source of Thebes’ pollution.Footnote 16
The first words spoken by Seneca's Oedipus to Tiresias (at 291f.) suggest that the king expects a prophet who is as knowledgeable and confident as his Sophoclean counterpart and who, like the full-knowing seer of the OT, will require no further prophetic rituals to help him interpret the oracle's words. In a metatheatrical sense, it would appear that Seneca's Oedipus has ‘read’ his Sophoclean OT and based his expectations of the prophet on it.Footnote 17 Seneca's Tiresias, however, in pointed contrast to his Sophoclean counterpart—and indeed more like the prophet Sophocles’ Oedipus seemed to expect—does not yet possess knowledge of the oracle's meaning; instead, he calls for sacrificial rites to assist him in seeking the desired clarification:
Tiresias: That my tongue is slow to speak, that it seeks delays, should not indeed surprise you, great-souled as you are. For the one who lacks sight, a great part of the truth lies hidden. But where my native land, where Phoebus summons me, I shall follow: the fates must be rooted out. If my blood were hot and youthfully strong, I would receive the god directly into my breast.
Lead to the altar a bull whose hide is white and a heifer whose neck has never been pressed down under the curved yoke. You, my daughter, guiding your father who lacks the light, report the clear signs of the fate-speaking ritual.
Thus it can be seen that Seneca's recasting of the Sophoclean meeting between Oedipus and Tiresias involves a pointed allusive inversion. When in Oedipus 293f. the prophet insists that his hesitation to speak and desire to delay should come as no surprise to Oedipus, the reader who recalls the OT passage remembers that there, too, Tiresias was reluctant to speak, but for a different reason: the Sophoclean seer knew already the dreadful truth about Oedipus’ family and was resolved to suppress it for as long as possible (OT 316-18).Footnote 18 The surprise for Seneca's audience (and in a metadramatic sense, for the Senecan Oedipus who seems to anticipate a Sophoclean Tiresias) comes in the remainder of the Senecan Tiresias’ speech, where instead of refusing to share a truth he knows will be painful, he professes to have only partial access to the truth due to his blindness and extreme age, requiring the assistance of divination to discover Apollo's design.
At this point, Seneca further develops the innovation he first introduced through the allusive contaminatio from Euripides’ Phoenissae; that is, his notably different characterization of Tiresias, which is quite possibly the Roman tragedian's own creation.Footnote 19 For whereas in both Sophocles’ Antigone and Oedipus Tyrannus, as well as in Euripides’ Phoenissae, the seer is described as old and blind, he nonetheless expresses full confidence that his prophetic powers of inspiration and interpretation are operating at full strength. In contrast, Seneca's Tiresias appears markedly less self-assured.
We will examine the reasons for Seneca's unusual characterization of Tiresias further when we consider the relationship between Seneca's episode and the encounter between Creon and Tiresias in Sophocles’ Antigone. For now, it should be recalled that in Sophocles’ OT, it is Tiresias’ initial reluctance to disclose the knowledge he clearly possesses that leads to the famous angry exchange between king and prophet. Seneca's reimagining of the scene omits that exchange, replacing it instead with a divination such as that anticipated by Sophocles’ Oedipus but rendered unnecessary by Tiresias’ prior knowledge of the plague's source.Footnote 20 Let us turn now to examine how Seneca has reworked and elaborated upon the encounter between Creon and Tiresias in Sophocles’ Antigone 998-1114 in his creation of this spectacular ritual event.
Ritual and Theatrical contaminatio I: Seneca's Oedipus and Sophocles’ Antigone
The Antigone’s penultimate act, which followed Creon's order for Antigone's living entombment, was ‘the key scene of reversal in the play’; and Tiresias’ long speech (998-1032), with its vivid, detailed description of a tainted divination and the direct conviction of Creon as source of the gods’ anger, has been called by Griffith ‘a virtual “messenger speech”.’Footnote 21 The scene opened with Tiresias’ unexpected arrival: once the chorus had finished their ode, the seer announced himself and the boy who led him. Differently than in Oedipus Tyrannus or Euripides’ Phoenissae, Tiresias’ appearance in Antigone was prompted not by a summons from the king but by Tiresias’ own recognition that there was something seriously wrong in Thebes based on the corruption of the prophetic ritual he had just performed. In his frighteningly powerful speech, the seer reported on his contaminated rites and explained their import:
You will know, when you hear the indications of my craft! As I took my place on the ancient seat for the observation of birds, where there was for me a gathering of every kind of bird of omen, I heard an unfamiliar sound, as the birds were screeching in a terrible and incoherent frenzy. And I knew they were tearing each other with murderous talons; for the whirring of their wings was not at all unclear. Immediately, alarmed, I began to try burnt offerings on the all-blazing altar. But Hephaestus did not raise flame from my sacrifices; instead, over the embers a slimy ooze from the thigh bones melted, and it smoked and sputtered. High into the air, the gall was sprayed, and the streaming thighs were bared of the fat that had concealed them. Such failing omens of divinatory rites that gave no signs I learned from this boy; for he is guide to me, and I am to others. And it is because of your will that the city suffers from this disease. For our altars and all our sacred hearths are filled by the birds and the dogs with carrion from the ill-fated, fallen son of Oedipus. And the gods are no longer accepting from us the prayers that accompany sacrifices or the burning of thigh bones, and the birds of omen no longer screech out cries that provide useful signs, having devoured the fat and blood of the dead man.
Sophocles’ Tiresias pointed specifically to Creon's refusal to bury the slain Polynices as the literal and religious cause both of the polluted sacrifices, which prevented communication from the gods to mortals, and of the gods’ angered refusal to accept the prayers that accompanied the divination. Tiresias denounced the king for bringing disease upon the city (1015), and he advised Creon to ‘give way to the dead man’ (Ant. 1029), that is, to bury the corpse. Creon's initial response was defiant. This provoked a second speech from Tiresias (1064-86), in which he identified both Creon's living burial of Antigone and his refusal to bury Polynices as his unholy crimes, foretold the death of Creon's son Haemon as necessary repayment for this outrage, and foreshadowed the death of the king's wife Eurydice (1078f.). After this speech, Creon (with the chorus’ guidance) at last acknowledged his crimes and set out (too late) to remedy them. The chorus insisted that Creon himself must perform the actions of Polynices’ burial and Antigone's release (1100-07).
There are obvious similarities between the scene in Sophocles’ Antigone and that between Oedipus and Tiresias in the Greek playwright's Oedipus Tyrannus. Both episodes involved confrontations between Tiresias and Thebes’ current ruler, and in both plays Thebes’ plight was attributed to a violation by the ruler of the gods’ laws regarding the treatment of the dead (who was also in each case a member of the royal family). Another, less pronounced, connection between the two plays, which perhaps in part prompted Seneca to combine them, is the request by Sophocles’ Oedipus (OT 310-13) that Tiresias perform rituals of divination much like those on which the seer of Antigone reports.Footnote 22
Parallels between Seneca's episode of failed ritual in Oedipus and that in Sophocles’ Antigone are even more striking, so much so, in fact, that it is clear that Seneca has appropriated this Sophoclean passage, by means of contaminatio, for his Oedipus. In both plays, Tiresias arrives unsummoned, and in both, he presides over the rites but employs a sighted guide who necessarily relays much of the information about the elements of divination to the blind seer. While the rites performed are not identical, also common to both is the fact that all elements of the sacrifice, including both the ritual flame and the examined beasts, are confounded. Noteworthy as well are certain similarities of dramatic structure regarding the position of Seneca's and Sophocles’ sacrifices in relation to the immediately subsequent events in the respective plays. At the end of the Antigone episode, immediately following Creon's departure to bury Polynices and release Antigone from her living grave, the chorus sang a hymn to Dionysus invoking the god's presence; and their plea for Bacchus’ aid included a description of their city as ‘gripped by the assault of plague’ (1140-42). The Antigone chorus’ hymn was to be imagined as simultaneous with Creon's actions, as is evidenced by the fact that a messenger arrived just after the ode to describe the intervening events. In Seneca's play, the failed extispicium is followed by the necromancy ritual; and between them, represented as occurring simultaneously with the necromancy, there is also a choral hymn to Bacchus. There is no similar ode in Sophocles’ OT. Footnote 23
Moreover, in Seneca's Oedipus it is Creon, not Oedipus, who is directly involved in the attempt to raise Laius, at least temporarily, from the dead. This decision is represented within the play as based on (Roman) religious practice: at Oedipus 397b-99, Tiresias points out that it is unlawful for Oedipus himself, as king, to look upon the shades, and he orders him to choose a representative to act in his place.Footnote 24 Oedipus delegates the responsibility to Creon:
Tiresias: Announce to whom you entrust the rite; for it is against sacred law for you, who hold the highest powers of the kingdom, to look on the shades of the dead.
Oedipus: Creon, this task demands you, to whom my kingdom looks as next after myself.
Along with the allusion to Roman religion, the Senecan Tiresias’ anxiety to protect Oedipus from pollution provides a source of obvious dramatic irony; and it serves another purpose for the Roman playwright, as it provides a plausible pretext for the avoidance of a direct confrontation between Oedipus and his father during the upcoming necromancy. Furthermore—and most significant for our purposes, as it points allusively to Seneca's employment of contaminatio—Seneca's decision to highlight Oedipus’ delegation of Creon to perform the ritual, ‘to whom my kingdom looks as next after myself’ (400), calls to mind Creon's counterpart in the Antigone, who ruled in Thebes as Oedipus’ successor and found himself, like his predecessor, deeply involved in problems concerned with lawful behavior in regard to the dead.Footnote 25 The close of the Antigone scene is again relevant here. When Sophocles’ Creon decided to bury Polynices and release Antigone, the chorus insisted that Creon perform these actions himself: ‘Go then and do it, and do not leave it to others!’ (δρᾶ νυν τάδ’ ἐλθὼν μηδ’ ἐπ’ ἄλλοισιν τρέπε, Ant. 1107); and Creon himself acknowledged that in so doing, he would act in conformity with the established laws (Ant. 1111-14). In both Seneca's Oedipus and Sophocles’ Antigone, then, it is Creon who, in accordance with what is lawful—though the definition of lawful is reversed in Seneca's play—must directly engage in activity that involves the dead.
Metadramatically, then, for the reader who recognizes Seneca's importation of the Antigone scene, Creon can be viewed as an allegorical representative of the process of contaminatio itself, since the appropriation of elements from different plays is often manifested in the partial conflation of characters. Seneca reinforces this connection in two ways. As noted above, when Oedipus refers to Creon as ‘second to himself’ (ad quem secundum), he calls the audience's attention to Creon as his successor as Thebes’ ruler in the city's mythological history, which simultaneously calls to mind his role as protagonist in his own tragedy, Antigone. But secundus can also mean ‘a copy or duplicate of’. Thus, when Seneca employs the verb respiciunt (‘they look upon’) in line 400, as dramatist he points to the fact that while the subjects of Thebes’ kingdom might only see Creon as Oedipus’ successor, the putative spectators in Seneca's audience would literally have been able to see—since they are both on stage simultaneously—Creon as not only Oedipus’ second in command but also, in a sense, his double, an embodiment of the dramatic power of contaminatio. Footnote 26
solet ira certis numinum ostendi notis: Prophetic Uncertainty, contaminatio, and Ritual Overdetermination
Because Seneca has both elaborated upon his Antigone model and employed it with a certain inversive force, there are, in addition to the similarities, significant differences between the two scenes that are especially important for our understanding of Seneca's play. A notable difference is that whereas the divination in Antigone was reported by Tiresias after the fact, the sacrifice and extispicium in Oedipus are envisioned as performed before the audience. One means employed by earlier Roman tragedians to achieve greater visual impact in their plays was the representation onstage of events that tragic poets had traditionally represented as occurring offstage, including especially gruesome or violent acts. Fragments of Accius’ Antigona, for example, suggest that Antigone's capture after her burial of Polynices, an event reported after the fact in Sophocles’ play, was presented onstage in Accius’ version.Footnote 27 Seneca's more immediate model for his own violations of tragedy's stage restrictions was Ovid's Metamorphoses, in which the earlier poet took full advantage of epic's freedom from such strictures by representing even the most gruesome events as occurring ‘in real time’. Seneca can be argued to have surpassed Ovid in this regard, in that by returning to the tragic genre he represented his events as enacted on an actual stage.Footnote 28
Seneca's decision to stage the sacrifice was no doubt motivated by a desire to prolong and intensify its spectacular effect. Ahl was surely right also to see Seneca's extensive presentation of the scene as, in part, an attempt ‘to Romanize the myth of Oedipus’ for an audience more accustomed to a variety of types of divination rituals (and perhaps less readily impressed by a report from the Delphic oracle).Footnote 29 Performance of the gruesome elements before the audience also provided uariatio to the extended ritual sequence, since the necromancy was to be described to Oedipus (and the audience) after the fact, through the report of Creon.Footnote 30 The nature of the sacrifice and extispicium as spectacle was further emphasized by its performance before four onstage spectators (Creon, Oedipus, Tiresias, and Manto), none of whom grasped fully the meaning of the individual elements. This served to enrich the dramatic irony, as Seneca's audience was afforded a better understanding of the sacrifice's meaning than any of the tragedy's characters.
Direct dramatization of the sacrifice and extispicium, especially as it centered on the exchange between Manto, who attempted an accurate description of the confused ritual elements, and the blind Tiresias, who struggled to interpret them, also enabled Seneca to highlight in particular two aspects that were the most important distinctions between his scene and that in Sophocles’ Antigone and Oedipus Tyrannus: the different characterization of Tiresias and, most significant for Seneca's purposes, the only partial interpretability of the more complex sacrificial elements in his tragedy.
Let us begin with Tiresias. As has been pointed out, the most notable distinctions between Seneca's Tiresias and the Sophoclean (and Euripidean) depictions of the prophet are Seneca's inversion of the traditional association of the seer's blindness with knowledge and insight, evidenced in the Senecan Tiresias’ insistence that ‘for one who lacks sight, much of the truth lies hidden’ (uisu carenti magna pars ueri latet, 295), and his creation, instead, of a link between Tiresias’ old age and an apparent reduction of his divinatory power. Seneca's unusual characterization of Tiresias serves a number of purposes. As Schiesaro noted in regard to the seer's role in the necromancy scene, Tiresias as uates can be viewed as a figure for the poet.Footnote 31 The claim by Seneca's Tiresias of incapacity for direct inspiration from Apollo due to his advanced age (si foret uiridis mihi / calidusque sanguis, pectore exciperem deum, ‘If my blood were hot and vigorous, I would receive the god directly into my breast’, 297b-298), if read intertextually and metapoetically, can thus be seen as a reference to the belatedness of Seneca (and of course, of his Tiresias) in the tragic tradition. This reading should not, however, be pressed too far; for the Senecan Tiresias’ inability to receive the god's power directly can also be viewed as a quality he shares with his counterpart in Sophocles’ Antigone.Footnote 32 Whereas Sophocles’ Tiresias in OT seemed to have direct access to Apollo (OT 376f., 409f.), in Antigone (and in Euripides’ Phoenissae), as in Seneca's Oedipus, the prophet performed sacrifices and rites of divination to discover the gods’ designs. Furthermore, the Senecan Tiresias’ ‘unSophoclean’ assertion that ‘for one lacking sight, much of the truth lies hidden’ also, of course, lends itself to an ironic reading, since in Seneca's play, especially highlighted in the sacrifice and extispicium, those who can physically see also lack understanding.
The most significant difference between Seneca's and Sophocles’ ritual scenes, however, is in the nature and interpretability of the rites themselves. Tiresias in the Antigone immediately recognized the source and meaning of the polluted divination he conducted. In Seneca's Oedipus, on the other hand, the ritual elements are more problematic, in that they appear to require interpretation yet simultaneously defy Tiresias’ divinatory expertise. Before making a closer comparison between the two passages, let us consider more closely certain of the unusual aspects of Seneca's rites.
As Pratt first discussed in detail, for the mythologically-informed Senecan reader who knows of Oedipus’ and his family's past and future criminal history, many of the unnatural aspects of the sacrifice can be understood, by ‘easily recognizable allegory’, to be linked with events in Oedipus’ own story, including later events in Seneca's play; such links accord well with the sympatheia between all aspects of nature that pervades the play.Footnote 33 Some of the most obvious connections are the fire's divided flame (321-23), the libation wine changed to blood (324), and the smoke that clouds Oedipus’ head (325-27), which can all be seen as indicative of the hostility, bloody warfare, and eventual divided funeral fires of Oedipus’ sons Polynices and Eteocles. Oedipus’ smoke-clouded eyes and the bull that averts its face (337-39) as it struggles against death even after two blows (343f.) and whose blood flows over its eyes and face (349f.), can all be readily interpreted as representative of Oedipus’ own self-blinding; and the heifer that thrusts herself against the sacrificial knife (341f.) portends Jocasta's suicide as depicted in Seneca's finale. As for the entrails themselves, in addition to their diseased state, the two heads of the liver are most obviously indicative of civil strife (and are interpreted as such by Manto at 359f.); and the connection with Oedipus’ sons is confirmed by the seven veins spreading in the liver's hostile side (363f.). Further, all the organs are in the wrong places (366f.). At the climax of her description, Manto exclaims natura uersa est; nulla lex utero manet (‘nature is inverted; no law remains in the womb’, 371), and she discovers that the cause is a fetus in the unmated heifer, located in an unnatural place (373-75), a phenomenon figuratively reflective of incest and of Jocasta's unnatural births.Footnote 34
While these are some of the most readily apparent allegories, several of the ritual's elements can be symbolically linked to more than one aspect of Oedipus’ (and Thebes’) multi-layered and guilt-ridden history and future. One instance of this, labeled by Pratt ‘an exceedingly ingenious intimation’, occurs in Oed. 360: en capita paribus bina consurgunt toris (‘look! Two heads rise up in equal swellings!’). As Pratt noted, because torus can also mean ‘marriage couch’ or ‘marriage’, the image interpreted by Manto as portending fraternal strife might at the same time signify the two marriages of Jocasta, to Laius and then Oedipus.Footnote 35 I offer here two additional examples of multivalent allegories that have not been fully explored but that point to the manifold complexity of the disordered world the ritual's elements reflect.
Allegorical Depths: Bacchic ‘Interference’ and the (Un)natural History of Thebes
First, let us reexamine the libation wine that turned to blood (Oed. 324) just after the ‘combative flame’ (pugnax ignis, 321) and the ‘hostile embers’ (discors fauilla, 323) each divided into two warring sides, which Pratt interpreted as associated with the mutual murder of Oedipus’ sons.Footnote 36 The ‘wine become blood’ has another significance as well, however, as it also symbolically represents the importance of Bacchus in Thebes’ history and presages his unusually conspicuous role in Seneca's version of Oedipus’ tragedy.Footnote 37 Notably, it is the addition of the wine (libata Bacchi, 324)—regularly designated metonymically by Bacchus’ name in the Oedipus—to the flame that causes the smoke to settle around Oedipus’ head and eyes (Oed. 325-27).Footnote 38 The libation is thus closely associated with the smoke, and so also with the clouding of Oedipus’ eyes that presages his self-blinding.
This is not to suggest that Bacchus, rather than fate or the force of Apollo's oracle, is responsible for Oedipus’ self-punishment. Thebes’ native-born god does, however, play a meaningful role in Oedipus’ tragedy as Seneca presents it. The Bacchic dimension of the play, which was introduced in the opening choral ode (Oed. 113-16), will be foregrounded more forcefully both in the upcoming ode (403-508), a hymn seeking the god's favor but also recalling his problematic involvement in Thebes’ past, and in the necromancy.Footnote 39 Indeed, in the necromancy, libations first of blood, then of milk and finally, wine (fundit et Bacchum, 566) are necessary to summon the shades of the underworld, which include, notably, Agave and Pentheus as the last to appear before Laius himself (Oed. 615-18).
During the extispicium libation, Tiresias’ reaction to Manto's request that he interpret the meaning of her description of the changeable sacrificial flame and of the wine's disturbing effects is also suggestive of Bacchus’ influence, as the priest describes himself in 329 as ‘wandering amidst the turmoils of a thunderstruck mind’ (inter tumultus mentis attonitae uagus). The decidedly Bacchic connotations of attonitus in Seneca's Oedipus are reinforced when in the necromancy, directly after the wine libation, Tiresias is also ‘thunderstruck’ and begins to speak in ‘a voice that is deeper and frenzied’ (grauiore… uoce et attonita, 568). In the play's final scene, the chorus will also use similar language to introduce the Bacchus-maddened Agave, to whom Jocasta is compared (1005f: Iocasta uecors, qualis attonita et furens / Cadmea mater; ‘Jocasta, crazed, like the thunderstruck and raging Cadmean mother’). Also in the play's finale, when the blind Oedipus asks ‘What god at last well-disposed toward me has poured out a dark cloud over my head?’ (quis deus tandem mihi / placatus atra nube perfundit caput? 999b-1000),Footnote 40 his language recalls lines 325-27, when the smoke that followed the wine's transformation to blood clouded his eyes; and the king's question is in a significant sense a legitimate one, since in Seneca's Oedipus not only Apollo, but also Bacchus, as well as Dis, are intimately involved in the fulfillment of Oedipus’ fate. Finally, in light of these other associations, we are also encouraged to see a link with Bacchus in the sacrificial animals themselves, especially since the bull, the animal most closely associated with Bacchus, exhibits the nearest symbolic connections with Oedipus.
Another complex nexus of imagery is signaled by Manto's exclamation in Oed. 371 that ‘nature is inverted; no law remains in the womb’ (natura uersa est; nulla lex utero manet) and her discovery of the monstrosity of the unmated heifer's fetus, positioned in an unnatural place (Oed. 373-75). The language employed here suggestively points not only to Oedipus’ incestuous birth and the king's immediate family history but also to the much longer problematic mythological history of Thebes itself. This connection, present already in the Bacchus ode and necromancy, takes on especial relevance in the third choral ode (709-63), which includes a lengthy treatment of the city's earliest history, including especially its associations with unnatural births and civil wars.Footnote 41
In this lyric passage the chorus, in response to the raised Laius’ accusation against Oedipus both as his murderer and the incestuous partner of Jocasta, attempts to absolve Oedipus from responsibility for Thebes’ current plight. By recalling the city's founding and early history, the chorus supports its claim that it is not fate's pursuit of the Labdacids in particular, but the even more ancient wrath of the gods against Thebes that has brought on the city's perils. The interconnections among Oedipus’ situation, Manto's descriptions of the elements of the sacrifice, and several features of the chorus’ stories soon become apparent. Of most immediate relevance here, the chorus, in relating the story of Thebes’ founding by Cadmus, specifically recalls Phoebus’ orders that Cadmus follow a straying cow ‘which neither the ploughshare nor the curved yoke of a slow cart had governed’ (quam non flexerat / uomer aut tardi iuga curua plaustri, 720f.), and it was from this ‘ill-omened cow’ (inauspicata de boue, 723) that Cadmus originally named the region's people (Boeotians). The resonances between the inauspicata bos that long ago lent its name to Thebes and the ‘cow whose neck has never been pressed by the curved yoke’ (curuoque numquam colla depressam iugo, 300) which in the sacrifice scene seemed so closely linked with Jocasta (esp. Oed. 341f.; this is also the innupta bos of 373) now also strongly suggests a link between Thebes’ present problems and the city's most distant past.
In the next lines of the ode, we are reminded that Thebes has produced monsters from its earliest origins. With imagery that is again reminiscent of Manto's description of the entrails of the sacrificial heifer and its unnaturally-conceived fetus (371-75), the chorus recalls that the Theban land itself once brought forth armed men ‘in an impious birth’ (feta tellus impio partu / effudit arma, 731f.).Footnote 42 The battle between these ‘earth-born men’ was Thebes’ original civil war (agmina campos cognata tenent, ‘ranks of kinsmen took the field,’ 738); and this internal strife of the distant past (also 748-50), in addition to that still to be fought between Oedipus’ sons, contributes to destabilize any straightforward or exclusive association of the divided sacrificial flame or the diseased entrails with Thebes’ future rather than its history.
When relating how these first native-born Theban warriors fell on the same day as their ‘ungodly birth’, the chorus points out that ‘their mother saw returned to her own bosom the sons she had just brought forth’ (genetrixque suo reddi gremio / modo productos uidit alumnos, 746). These words recall, most immediately, similar words from Laius himself in his accusation of Oedipus in 638-40a (egitque in ortus semet et matri impios / fetus regessit, ‘he has pushed to the source of his birth and forced unnatural childbirth back on his mother’). Moreover, both passages recall the words of Apollo's oracle as reported by Creon in 237f. (tecum bella geres, natis quoque bella relinques, / turpis maternos iterum reuolutus in ortus; ‘you will wage war with yourself, you will leave war to your sons also, you who have foully returned once again to your maternal source’). There is at least one more contributor to this nexus: when pointing to the allegorical elements of the sacrifice and extispicium, Pratt suggested a double meaning in the bull's aversion to face east at the sacrifice's start in 338 (primos ad ortus positus), translating the words alternatively as ‘facing its original source’, that is, its ‘mother’, which Pratt saw as symbolizing Oedipus’ behavior in regard to his mother Jocasta, connected with lines 238, 638f., and 1011f.Footnote 43
Once all these different but related links are joined, it becomes evident that there is a significant connection not only between the ritual's complex symbolism and Thebes’ (and Oedipus’) present situation, but also with the city's origins and its most distant past. This third choral ode, then, reinforces for Seneca's audience the recognition that already in the sacrifice and extispicium, several of the ritual's disturbing elements were resistant to immediate interpretation because they were conveying multiple layers of thematic significance simultaneously.
Even without an exhaustive exploration of the potential symbolic implications in the ritual's various elements, it is by now clear that there are a number of factors that contribute to the extispicium scene's multi-layered discourse and add to the ritual's (and so Manto's) inability to provide a transparent, readily interpretable message or for Tiresias to receive one. The difficulty and apparent confusion that is manifested in the divination's elements might, therefore, most productively be seen as the cumulative result (the ‘overdetermination’) of the many interrelated factors involved in Oedipus’ fate in Seneca's version, all vying to assert themselves in the ritual's symbolism.
Ritual and Theatrical contaminatio II: Recapitulation, Metadramatic Commentary, and Preparation for Another New Path
The Senecan reader who recalls Tiresias’ reported divination from Sophocles’ Antigone is struck by the contrast between the confident and unambiguous comprehension of the ruined sacrifice's import by Sophocles’ Tiresias and the troubled uncertainty of his Senecan counterpart, who not only attempts in vain to extract the desired information from the infected rites (‘who is Laius’ killer?’) but also fails to grasp fully why it is that the signs are not readily comprehensible. The distinction between Sophocles’ and Seneca's prophets—and between the signs they must interpret—is discernible from the start of Tiresias’ report to Creon in Antigone (999-1004). Sophocles’ Tiresias began with the observation of birds, and despite his blindness the prophet was able himself to discern that the birds were tearing each other with their claws (of which the whirring of their wings [1004] was for him an obvious indicator). Sophocles’ Tiresias’ confident ability, despite his blindness, to hear and interpret (or better, to recognize as uninterpretable) the birds’ cries without assistance contrasts sharply with Seneca's prophet, who is wholly dependent on Manto's descriptions of the ritual element but even with her aid is unable to interpret their meaning. A striking example of the greater complexity in Seneca's elements occurs near the end of the Oedipus episode, when just after Manto's description of the sacrificial bull that has attempted to rise and attack the priest, she must inform Tiresias that the unusual sounds he hears are not the moans of cattle, but the groans of the altar fire (Oed. 381-83). When a sacrificial flame emits sounds not readily distinguishable from those of animals, interpretation is understandably problematized.Footnote 44
Sophocles’ Tiresias experienced none of the difficulty or confusion that affects Seneca's prophet because the spoiled rituals in Antigone, which produced no meaningful signs whatsoever, themselves held the message for him.Footnote 45 The birds’ cries were meaningless because they had consumed pieces of Polyneices’ unburied corpse; and the altars, too, were defiled with carrion left there by birds and dogs. The angered gods were no longer accepting Tiresias’ sacrificial prayers. The particulars of the individual contaminated elements did not require further interpretation as providing specific messages in their own right. Also, Sophocles’ audience, in contrast to Seneca's, was neither encouraged nor required to interpret the rites allegorically. Further, there was no linguistic ambiguity in the Antigone scene of the type that exists throughout Seneca's.
From the start of the sacrifice, Seneca's Tiresias, like his Sophoclean counterpart, expected to receive clearly interpretable messages from the gods. In Oed. 302, he instructed Manto to ‘relate the manifest signs of the fate-speaking rite’ (manifesta sacri signa fatidici refer). At each step, however, the reliable signs anticipated by the seer are not forthcoming; instead, each ritual element behaves in a complicated and disturbingly ambiguous manner. In Oed. 328b-34a, Seneca's Tiresias, amazed that he cannot explain the meaning of the flame's action, makes an allusive gesture toward Sophocles’ Antigone, with metadramatic force, when he exclaims:
What can I explain, wandering amidst the turmoils of a thunderstruck mind? What am I to say? There are dreadful evils, but they are deeply concealed. The anger of the gods is usually shown by sure signs. What is it that they want to be revealed and yet do not want, and so they hide their fierce anger? The gods are ashamed of something.
Solet (331) often serves as both allusive and metatheatrical marker in Senecan tragedy. It is perhaps most famously employed by Medea at the end of her play, when she vaunts to Jason coniugem agnoscis tuam? sic fugere soleo ; ‘Do you recognize your wife? This is how I always escape’ (Medea 1021b-22).Footnote 46 In Oedipus 331, Tiresias recalls the manner in which sacrifices, and the seer's ability to interpret them, typically function in tragedy, which is as they did for his counterpart in Sophocles’ Antigone, where the thoroughly corrupted rituals—the birds’ incoherent songs, and the prophet's inability even to produce the sacrificial flame—were clear indications of the gods’ anger at Creon's defiance of their laws.
Based on his traditional prophetic insight (and reflective also of the metadramatic, literary-historical knowledge he ‘possesses’ as representative of the tragedian as uates), Seneca's Tiresias senses—and rightly, since Oedipus’ situation in this play, including the manifold sources of his guilt, is more complicated than Creon's in Antigone—that there is something that the gods want simultaneously both to reveal and to conceal, something of which they themselves are ashamed.Footnote 47 Seneca's Tiresias therefore resembles Sophocles’ prophet in that he knows, and repeatedly expresses, that sacrifices should produce dependable signs. At Oed. 351f., after the meaning of yet another element proves indeterminable for Tiresias—in this case, the blood from the slaughtered bull and heifer that has flowed in novel and disturbing ways—the seer nonetheless remains resolved on continuing to seek reliable messages:
These ill-omened rites stir up great fears. But tell me the sure signs of the entrails.
Throughout the divination, the unnatural behavior of the sacrificial elements—behavior that cries out for interpretation but at the same time defies clear interpretability—indicates to Seneca's Tiresias (and reinforces for the audience) that something is unusually wrong. Furthermore, because the source of the evil is only partially and ambiguously revealed through the sacrifice, Laius’ killer has not yet been identified clearly.Footnote 48
At this point, it is the persistent ‘Sophoclean Tiresian’ certainty in the efficacy of ritual that leads Seneca's prophet not to despair at the extispicium’s failure to elicit the desired information fully but rather to give the confident instruction that ‘another path must be tried’:
Neither birds that cut through heaven's heights on light wings, nor entrails torn from living breasts, can call forth the name. Another path must be tried: he himself must be summoned out from the regions of eternal night, so that once sent up from Erebus he can identify his murderer. The earth must be unsealed, prayers must be made to the implacable will of Dis, and the populace of infernal Styx must be drawn out here.
With Tiresias’ words in 390-97, Seneca's prophet (as the poet's representative) introduces the upcoming necromancy, with its own multilayered thematic and metapoetic implications. At the same time, Seneca as poet retraces his path, for a moment, back to Sophocles’ OT, and specifically to Oedipus’ request to Tiresias at OT 310-13:
Do not, then, refuse to employ a message from the birds or if you have any other course of prophecy, and save yourself and the city, and save me, and save us from all the pollution coming from the dead man.
The programmatic phrase alia temptanda est uia in Oedipus 392, with its double allusion both to OT 311 and to Virgil's famous temptanda uia est in Georgics 3.8, through which the earlier Roman poet announced his intention to ensure his lasting fame through the pursuit of a fully novel poetic endeavor, has been viewed as Seneca's means of underlining his own intentions to innovate in the upcoming necromancy scene.Footnote 49 As is now clear, with 390-92 Seneca in fact marks for his audience his spectacular innovations in both the previous and the upcoming scenes. This is, for Seneca, one force of alia, ‘another,’ in 392; for he has already blazed one innovative path in his sacrifice and extispicium through his creative fusion, via contaminatio, of elements not only from Sophocles’ Oedipus Tyrannus but also from Euripides’ Phoenissae and, most elaborately, from Sophocles’ Antigone. Seneca further highlights his innovatory use of contaminatio with an ‘allusion via omission’: Tiresias’ words in 390f., reinforced by the repetition of nec at the start of each line, not only recall Oedipus’ (unfulfilled) request of Tiresias in OT 310f. but also serve as a reminder of what Seneca's own importation of his Greek models did not include, since in both Euripides’ Phoenissae and Sophocles’ Antigone, Tiresias had conducted an ornithoscopy. Here as elsewhere in his tragedies, Seneca is no slavish imitator; instead, like the bees he employed to describe the creative process in Epistle 84, he brought the full resources of his talent to bear as he blended his varied sources into a scene that is entirely his own.Footnote 50
