Cardinal Wolsey, archbishop of York and Henry VIII's chancellor, was appointed as papal legate a latere by Pope Leo X on 17 May 1518.Footnote 1 Wolsey was to exercise legatine powers in the English realm until his fall from grace in October 1529. As the pope's representative in Henry VIII's realm he was to wield almost unprecedented authority over the English Church, including the power to conduct visitations of religious houses, convene legatine councils and intervene extensively in the jurisdiction of bishops. This activity is well known to historians, but a neglected aspect of his legatine authority is his power to grant dispensations.Footnote 2 The aim of the present edition is to assemble documents evidencing Wolsey's dispensing powers and his exercise of them.
Dispensations formed an important part of ecclesiastical jurisdiction by Wolsey's time. The rules of canon law then bound all members of the Catholic Church, and dispensations were important because they relaxed some of these rules, expressly those which were man-made and not divine in origin. Hence canon law derived from scripture was not dispensable,Footnote 3 but that introduced by popes and councils might be. The human law that dispensations relaxed largely concerned marriage, ordination, and ecclesiastical benefices. Marriage dispensations were the main kind sought by laity, naturally, and most dealt with impediments arising from kinship, principally the prohibited degrees of consanguinity (kinship by blood) and affinity (relationship through marriage) not covered by Leviticus 18–20.Footnote 4 Other marital impediments, from which dispensations were less commonly sought, included public honesty and cognatio spiritualis. The former arose where one marriage partner was betrothed to someone related to the other partner within the prohibited degrees, but the betrothal had been broken off without consummation.Footnote 5Cognatio spiritualis, or spiritual kinship, usually applied in instances where the parent of one spouse had presented the other for baptism, or less commonly confirmation. Most couples sought marriage dispensations before marrying, but they might also do so retrospectively, especially if they had only learned of the impediment in question after marrying.Footnote 6 Other, non-marital, kinds of dispensation were largely sought by clergy. Many of these dealt with impediments to ordination, notably: illegitimate birth (defectus natalium), which might also debar religious, including women, from appointment as head of their order or one of its houses without a dispensation; being under-age (defectus aetatis), which for ordinands to the priesthood meant being below the age of twenty-five; ordination on Sundays or feasts outside of the four general ordination days in each year (extra tempora statuta a iure);Footnote 7 and physical deformity (defectus corporis), principally affecting ordinands’ hands or eyesight. Clergy also requested various dispensations regarding the holding of benefices, particularly two or more together. This was pluralism, and canon law expressly forbade this where the benefices were ‘incompatible’, generally meaning that each had ‘cure of souls’ requiring the incumbent to administer the sacraments to his parishioners, notably confession. Pluralism clearly involved non-residence in at least one of the benefices held; dispensations might also free clergy from obligations to reside in their benefices, and not only where held in plurality, but also in other permitted circumstances, notably for study-leave at university.Footnote 8 Male religious might likewise seek dispensations, known as ‘capacities’, allowing them to leave the religious life and obtain secular benefices. Other more miscellaneous dispensations and related graces, such as special licences, notably to eat meat and dairy produce in Lent and other fasting-periods, also existed and will be discussed later.
Authority to grant these various dispensations and other graces largely resided with the pope, who issued them by virtue of his plenitudo potestatis; canon law further reserved to the pope absolution from certain grave sins, known as ‘reserved cases’, notably assaults on clergy and apostasy.Footnote 9 Petitioners solicited dispensations from the papal curia by at least the late eleventh century, and penitents’ requests for papal absolution go back even earlier. The origins of this system of papal graces has even been traced back to the Early Church though it was probably only with the growth of papal power from the late eleventh century and the development of a universal body of Western canon law from the twelfth century that such graces were granted in significant numbers.Footnote 10 Letters conferring these graces were issued by the papal chancery initially and many were copied in its registers. These testify to rising demand for such papal favours across Western Europe, and the system of papal graces, though it would be attacked as an abuse later by Protestants, largely seems to have expanded in response to this popular demand, since people found such graces useful. Consequently, just as the papacy increasingly delegated cases appealed to its judgement to lesser churchmen in response to growing judicial business at the curia from the mid twelfth century, it likewise began at about this time to delegate to other clergy powers or ‘faculties’ to grant dispensations and other papal graces. Much of this delegated authority passed to curial officials, notably the cardinal or ‘major’ penitentiary, who, along with the minor penitentiaries subordinate to him, received ever expanding faculties from successive popes, so much that by the mid thirteenth century his activity was discharged through a growing new department of papal government, also called the penitentiary.Footnote 11 By the fifteenth century it expedited many of the same graces as the papal chancery, except dispensations for plurality, which the chancery continued to issue. In addition popes conceded faculties to papal agents, including legates a latere, nuncios and even cameral collectors, to exercise in those provinces where they were sent from the curia. Bishops might also possess faculties, notably those enjoying the status of legatus natus such as the archbishop of Canterbury, and could even concede certain graces ex officio, but their dispensing powers were generally limited.Footnote 12
Wolsey was, therefore, not unique in having delegated papal authority to issue dispensations even in the English realm. Papal officials visiting the kingdom had long enjoyed faculties as part of their commission, and several graces they granted to English and Welsh beneficiaries survive.Footnote 13 Even if such papal agents were more conveniently accessible than the distant curia, they were transient and intermittent sources of papal graces, however, and their faculties were often restricted to dispensing small numbers of people.Footnote 14 Consequently, Wolsey's position as a permanently resident legate a latere in the English kingdom was remarkable; only Cardinal Beaufort had paralleled this a century earlier and even his legatine powers had been stymied by the English Crown and episcopate.Footnote 15 Nevertheless, Wolsey's legatine authority had to be carefully built up over many years of lobbying the papacy, not least for amplification of his faculties.Footnote 16 Wolsey had sought the legation along with the cardinalate since at least 1514, but whereas Leo X conceded the latter in 1515, he long proved reluctant to grant the former, in particular because it would set a precedent for a ruler's minister holding extraordinary power over a national church, especially at a time when national monarchies were increasing their control over churches in their realms. Leo only yielded in 1518 by making Wolsey co-legate with Cardinal Campeggio, largely to facilitate the latter's entry to England, which Henry VIII had resisted. The pope sent Campeggio to further plans for a crusade against the Turks, which he had long sought to finance by taxing the English church; Wolsey had promised to raise the money without result, and Leo intended the joint legation to induce Wolsey to deliver.Footnote 17 This inducement was not enough to satisfy Wolsey, however. Leo's initial commission made him legate only for the duration of Campeggio's stay in England and for the sake of the crusade. On 27 August 1518 Leo issued a further bull authorizing both legates to reform monasteries, but not secular clergy too as Wolsey had hoped. The Italian curialist Silvestro Gigli, bishop of Worcester, who was lobbying for Wolsey at Rome, relayed to Leo Wolsey's complaints about the ‘prohibitions to his legatine authority’.Footnote 18 Leo apparently considered his demands for a fuller commission ‘importunate’, because it would impinge too much on the authority of the English bishops and because Wolsey had still not fulfilled his promise about clerical taxation. The pope was also unmoved by Wolsey's assertion that he sought more faculties ‘not for the sake of extorting money but to do some good in the Lord's vineyard and reform the clergy’.Footnote 19 His actual motivation for seeking greater legatine authority is a matter of debate, and will be addressed later on. What is clear, however, is that Wolsey was preoccupied by the potential expiry of his legation on Campeggio's departure; he had sought a separate fuller commission for himself even as the joint legation was being conceded.Footnote 20 Nevertheless, before Campeggio left England on 24 August 1519, Wolsey had only managed to secure a papal bull on 10 June empowering him to reform the monasteries on his own after his co-legate's return to the curia.Footnote 21 Leo's dissatisfaction at Wolsey's failure to raise the crusade tax remained the chief sticking-point, as Kelly observed: ‘Whereas the pope displayed obstinacy in extending the legateship in the hope of attracting a subsidy, the cardinal was using the prospect of taxation to extort amplification of his powers’.Footnote 22 Wolsey indeed continued to petition Leo, and with support from Campeggio and Henry VIII he had secured the promise of a bull by December 1519 extending his legation. This would only be for a year dated from Campeggio's departure, that is until 24 August 1520, but on 6 January 1521 Wolsey obtained another extension for a further two years beyond this deadline.Footnote 23 Wolsey had still not delivered the long-promised taxation, which continued to irritate Leo, but the pope's concern to deter England from an alliance with France had apparently persuaded him to be more conciliatory toward Wolsey, prime mover in Anglo-French relations.Footnote 24 This doubtless also accounts for two more bulls issued respectively on 1 April and 27 June 1521, which not only further extended Wolsey's legation to ten years in total but also conceded extraordinary faculties to issue dispensations and other favours.Footnote 25
The April bull allowed him to appoint forty apostolic notaries, fifty ‘golden knights’, and the same number of counts palatine and papal chaplains, and any amount of papal scribes, within the realm and his own household. As Kelly suspects, Wolsey probably saw these papal titles as largely a means to attract and reward familiars. Additional concessions included powers to legitimize bastards, normally the prerogative of temporal rulers, and confer degrees in canon and civil law, theology, arts, and medicine. No evidence has been found for Wolsey's exercise of any of these powers, except the latter and only in one case: a commission on 30 September 1525 to award Richard Foxford a doctorate in both Roman and canon law.Footnote 26 The other faculties conceded were arguably more significant, and certainly his use of them is better documented. He might grant dispensations from defectus natalium, defectus aetatis and other ‘irregularities’ (impediments to ordination or the use of orders already conferred), allowing promotion to all, even holy orders, including the priesthood; ministry in such or existing orders even at the altar, that is celebrating mass; and tenure of any kind or number of benefices with or without a cure, in effect pluralism. Wolsey might also dispense secular clergy to study and graduate in civil law,Footnote 27 and religious to preach anywhere; and grant absolution from excommunication and other spiritual sanctions imposed by ecclesiastical judges or canon law (i.e. in ‘reserved cases’) or to anyone failing to say their required hours. Above all, Wolsey obtained the long-coveted power to reform secular clergy, even bishops, and punish them himself or through a deputy. His use of this power, and of his existing authority to visit monasteries and correct religious, has attracted much attention, not least because of the reaction it supposedly provoked among the English episcopate, including Archbishop Warham of Canterbury, although recent historiography suggests that this was not as negative as has often been assumed.Footnote 28 Though it is not the intention here to revisit this issue, Wolsey's dispensing powers were relevant to reform, as we will later see, and his bull of June 1521 was to extend these even more dramatically.
It confirmed the April bull's concessions regarding clerical reform, absolution from spiritual sanctions, and the awarding of degrees and papal titles, except that Wolsey might now confer any number of the latter. It defined his faculty to dispense from defectum aetatis in greater detail, as permitting ordination to the subdiaconate, diaconate and priesthood at 17, 18 and 23 respectively for secular clerks and 16, 17 and 22 for religious, as well as tenure of a benefice with a cure at 18. He might further license under-age clergy to seek ordination to two of these grades on the same day, extra tempora a iure statuta and from all Catholic bishops; albeit any bishop might issue letters dimissory allowing clergy in his diocese to seek ordination outside of it. The bull did not elaborate upon his other existing faculties but added many new ones, several likewise concerning ordination and benefices. He might dispense clergy holding benefices with a cure so they were not obliged to take holy orders for up to seven years, provided that they became subdeacons within the first two years of that period. He might dispense male religious, except friars, to hold a secular benefice with a cure, that is issue ‘capacities’. He might also absolve any religious, including mendicants, from the reserved sin of apostasy and its canonical penalties, and dispense them from irregularity; (which regular priests could incur by celebrating divine offices while excommunicated as apostates).Footnote 29 Penitent apostates often sought to return to the religious life, but not always to their original house or order, indubitably repelled by the same reasons which had prompted them to flee it in the first place. These might include the severity of its rule, as Wolsey might dispense the transfer of apostates to laxer orders, even permitting mendicants to enter non-mendicant orders: a dilution of the canonical requirement to license transfers to another house or order ‘of equal or stricter observance’.Footnote 30 He might concede some graces only to certain clergy, notably those in his household. He might dispense his familiars, graduates, and noblemen to hold up to four incompatible benefices in plurality, and any man living at his expense, up to three; and authorize his familiars to unite two of their benefices into one, even parish churches. Other faculties regarded graces mainly requested by laity. He might dispense marriages in the third degree of consanguinity or affinity, and the third and fourth degrees combined, and from an impediment of cognatio spiritualis or public honesty, recognizing their issue as legitimate. His marriage dispensations could be retrospective, since he might also absolve couples who had married knowing of such impediments without a prior dispensation.Footnote 31 He might not, however, concede a dispensation for the ‘levirate’, that is marriage between a man and his childless brother's widow, coincidentally what Henry VIII had needed in order to marry Catherine of Aragon. Wolsey might, nevertheless, license solemnization of marriages without reading of the banns (as any bishop might do within his own diocese),Footnote 32 or during Lent and other forbidden times. Further graces more often sought by laity than clergy and which he might concede released from religious obligations. He might ‘commute’ pious intentions in wills into some other pious duty (alia pietatis opera), and license consumption of eggs, butter, cheese and other dairy produce during Lent and other fasting periods when this was forbidden, even meat if the beneficiary's doctors advised it. Finally, Wolsey might concede graces designed to facilitate popular piety. These included licences for laity or clergy to appoint a personal confessor, secular or regular, which relaxed the obligation to confess to their parish priest. He might extraordinarily empower the confessor to commute vows to go on long-distance pilgrimages to Rome or Compostella (but not vows of perpetual chastity or for entering the religious life) and to absolve from observing oaths; this was important for it was usually reserved to the pope and oaths formed a major part of ecclesiastical jurisdiction. Violators of oaths as solemn promises before God were often sued for perjury in English church courts by Wolsey's time, even if their promises were of a worldly nature (most cases regarded non-payment of debts). The confessor might also grant absolution in all but reserved cases and a plenary indulgence at the point of death (in mortis articulo).Footnote 33 Wolsey himself might grant indulgences too, for ten years each and forty in total, as he saw fit. He might also license nobles, priests or graduates to have a portable altar, where masses and other divine offices might be celebrated for them and their households anywhere, even before day-break or in places interdicted by ‘ordinary’ authority, which canon law did not normally allow.Footnote 34
This wide range of faculties was significant because it enabled Wolsey to confer many of the same graces which petitioners sought from the papal curia, notably the penitentiary, and thus potentially to rival Rome as a source of these favours for English and Welsh supplicants, as I have argued elsewhere.Footnote 35 Indeed, his powers to grant dispensations, absolutions, and licences were broadly comparable with those of the cardinal penitentiary, especially on marriage, and even exceeded them in some respects, notably concerning dispensations for uniting benefices and pluralism, which the chancery might issue but not the papal penitentiary. Admittedly, he might not issue the full range of graces in the penitentiary's gift, and the June bull expressly excluded some of them, particularly commutation of vows for the religious life and chastity.Footnote 36 Certainly the bulls of 1521 were still not enough to satisfy Wolsey: he continued to press for fuller legatine authority, doubtless conscious of the more extensive faculties other cardinals enjoyed.Footnote 37 Leo X's successor, Adrian VI, agreed in 1523 to confirm the five-year extension of Wolsey's legation (till 24 August 1524), but hesitated to renew it for life and refused any further faculties.Footnote 38 But Giulio de’ Medici's election as Clement VII on Adrian's death in late 1523 raised Wolsey's hopes, for de’ Medici had been cardinal protector of England and they had collaborated on allying England with the papacy and empire against France from 1522; in January 1524 Clement indeed confirmed his legation ‘with all faculties’ for life. Even this did not fully please Wolsey, who ‘thought his bull of faculties somewhat restrained’. In particular he sought that his faculties to grant graces to familiars be extended to include non-familiars.Footnote 39 Although Clement VII issued further letters concerning Wolsey's legation, none are known to have added to his faculties of 1521.Footnote 40 Two of Wolsey's surviving letters of dispensation from the mid 1520s would claim to exercise new faculties granted by Clement, but no independent evidence supports this.Footnote 41 And Clement VII was reluctant to increase his powers, for he feared that they might deprive the curia of business and income from English or Welsh petitioners, a position that Wolsey's exploitation of his faculties would justify, as we will later see. Indeed, English agents reported that the curia opposed his demands in 1524 as it was ‘in great misery’ and ‘totally impoverished’ since its revenues from France and Germany had declined.
Wolsey's ambition for greater legatine power remained unabated, however, if the curious text in Appendix 1b is at all indicative. It takes the form of a breve, a kind of papal document that originated by 1389 ‘as an alternative to the traditional bullae of the chancery’ and was drawn up by papal secretaries, who first appear under Benedict XII (1334–1342) and came to form new curial departments by the fifteenth century.Footnote 42 The text's format as a breve is signalled by its brief intitulatio, simply naming the pope as Clement VII, and by the address ‘Dilecti filii’.Footnote 43 Though the addressee is omitted along with the greeting, it has long been supposed that Wolsey was the intended recipient.Footnote 44 First, the text occurs in a Cotton manuscript comprising a collection of letters and papers concerning Anglo-Papal relations in 1527. The text's date is omitted, but its references to the pope's captivity allude to the ‘Sack of Rome’ by imperial troops in May 1527, after which Clement VII and his cardinals remained captive in the Castel Sant’Angelo for months. Second, its addressee was apparently a legate whom the text appointed as papal vicar with unprecedented delegated authority during this crisis (‘ut in inaudito casus eventu insolitam potestatem per delegacionem exerceas’) and within the bounds of his legation (‘infra terminos legationis tue’); in an English context Wolsey is the obvious candidate. But, several features of this text make its authenticity doubtful. It lacks the external appearance of a papal breve, being written not as a single-sheet parchment document sealed with the papal fisherman's ring but over six paper folios unsealed. It is probably not a copy of a breve either, even though its truncated address and dating clauses might suggest this, but appears more like a draft and a rather clumsy one at that. Passages of the text are crossed through, but this reads more like redrafting than correcting copyist's errors, notably on fol. 236r–v, where statements are deleted as redundant since they merely rephrase previous ones.Footnote 45 Its author was striving to imitate the curia's humanistic Latin and formulae but not always successfully, for example in the superfluous repetition of ‘non obstantibus’ at the end. Much more suspect than the text's style is its content, which purported to delegate power to concede all dispensations and other graces both within and beyond papal authority, even relaxing divine law, as if the pope could grant divine power outside his Petrine commission. This is all the more remarkable given that in 1527 Henry VIII began to seek a divorce from Catherine of Aragon on the basis that their marriage and the papal dispensation permitting it contradicted divine law.Footnote 46 Presumably this text seeking unlimited dispensing power was drafted at Wolsey's request, with the aim of gaining papal approval for it, or a redrafted version, at the curia, and the drafter's imagination overcame his judgement. Certainly it is incredible that Clement VII issued such a commission, and there is no evidence that Wolsey received one or acted as if he had.
Even if we take this as proof of his continuing dissatisfaction with his dispensing powers, the evidence for Wolsey's use of them is, in fact, extensive; and what I have traced is collected in Appendices 2–4. This evidence comprises some of Wolsey's original letters of dispensation,Footnote 47 and copies of many others, all but one found in English episcopal registers.Footnote 48 The letters, over ninety altogether, date from between 12 August 1521 and 7 September 1529, which indicates that Wolsey began exercising his faculties soon after receiving them in the bulls of April and June 1521 and continued to do so until at least a month before his fall from grace in October 1529, which effectively ended his legatine activity. This body of evidence also suggests that he issued on average about a dozen such letters a year, but in fact it only represents the tip of the iceberg. A list survives, edited in Appendix 2, which records 110 graces that he issued in one year alone, between 10 July 1525 and 4 July 1526. And letters have been traced for only seven of these 110 graces,Footnote 49 which implies that the total number of his letters of dispensation was well over ten times higher than the ninety or so known to survive, that is over one thousand letters. The actual total was probably even higher than this, since the list of 1525–1526 appears to record only graces for which Wolsey had received payment. It is certainly incomplete since it omits as many as seventeen graces from the same year known from extant letters.Footnote 50 Likewise, another list, edited in Appendix 3, records some 174 graces which Wolsey issued in the three years to 23 October 1529, but this includes only those for which he was still owed payment at his fall.Footnote 51 Speculative as it is to extrapolate the full extent of his dispensing activity from such incomplete evidence, this activity was evidently substantial.
Its scale far exceeded, for example, the papal penitentiary's dealings with English and Welsh petitioners. Under Pope Alexander VI (1492–1503) the office approved about sixty petitions a year from England and Wales, according to its registers, but this figure had declined to only four in 1525–1526,Footnote 52 the same year when Wolsey approved at least 110 graces. Of these four two came from petitioners who were apparently visiting the curia, but it is less clear why the other two supplicants did not turn to Wolsey instead.Footnote 53 In any case most petitioners in England and Wales clearly found it more convenient to approach him rather than a distant curial office for favours that he and the penitentiary were equally competent to grant. It is harder to gauge the effect of Wolsey's activity on papal chancery business, since the calendar of entries for Great Britain and Ireland in its registers has not yet been published for the 1520s. However, English bishops’ registers provide some indication, since papal dispensations were often copied there. When such registers record papal graces that the chancery issued during Wolsey's dispensing activity, these are largely favours which Wolsey was not competent to grant. Most authorized unions of benefices,Footnote 54 which Leo X had empowered him to grant only to certain beneficiaries. Moreover, episcopal registers generally contain many more graces issued by Wolsey than the chancery in this period;Footnote 55 clearly, where Wolsey might issue the same graces as the chancery, English supplicants preferred to seek them from him. And such registers depict more starkly the effect of Wolsey's dispensing activity on English business at the papal penitentiary, even compared with the office's own registers. In fact, penitentiary letters virtually disappear from English bishops’ registers, having appeared there in considerable numbers before his activity. Wolsey's own register as archbishop of York records numerous penitentiary letters sought by petitioners in his diocese from 1513 onward, but they stop dead early in 1521 and only copies of his own graces appear there from 1522 to 1528. The same pattern occurs in other episcopal registers, where penitentiary letters generally only reappear after Wolsey's fall forced English petitioners to turn back to Rome for most graces.Footnote 56 Nonetheless, Wolsey's dispensing activity during the 1520s rivalled that of Rome in Henry VIII's realm, and even eclipsed it in the case of the papal penitentiary. And this situation arguably became even more acute after the ‘Sack of Rome’ in May 1527 effectively paralysed papal government for months, if not years, after; the penitentiary, in particular, does not appear to have resumed normal activity until the early 1530s.Footnote 57 Indeed, Appendix 4 indicates the extent of Wolsey's activity in the aftermath of the ‘Sack’. Even if Wolsey never obtained the unlimited dispensing powers which he appears to have coveted in these circumstances (see Appendix 1b), in effect he had replaced the curia as the source of dispensations in the English realm by the late 1520s, when chancery graces also all but vanish from English episcopal registers.
This development is all the more remarkable in that his dispensing activity penetrated into all twenty-one English and Welsh dioceses, despite the alleged clerical resistance to his legatine authority. At least one grace was obtained from him in each diocese, and many more in most dioceses.Footnote 58 Admittedly, the evidence is too patchy to give a complete picture, but the regional pattern that emerges is perhaps not altogether surprising. The larger dioceses understandably account for more of Wolsey's known graces than the smaller, notably the extensive Coventry and Lichfield, Lincoln and York dioceses compared with the tiny Ely and Rochester dioceses. Certain dioceses may be well represented because of their ecclesiastical wealth. Salisbury and Winchester dioceses were noted not for their size but their rich benefices; many of Wolsey's numerous graces for beneficiaries in these dioceses were indeed dispensations for plurality.Footnote 59 The number of graces in bishops’ registers also partly depends on varied diocesan registration practices. The York archiepiscopal chancery had a long tradition of enregistering many of the papal graces obtained by petitioners in its diocese.Footnote 60 The large number of Wolsey's graces in his York register probably owes more to this, and the diocese's size, than the fact that he was the diocesan; he only spent significant time in York diocese after his fall, when his dispensing activity effectively ceased. By contrast, contemporary registers for Canterbury and Chichester record no graces secured from any source by petitioners in these dioceses. The small number of Wolsey's graces for Canterbury diocese might also reflect the fact that its archbishop held his own dispensing faculties as legatus natus, but even the exercise of these went unrecorded in Archbishop Warham's register (1503–1532). Nevertheless, Wolsey's activity does not appear to have been limited by others with papal faculties elsewhere; other episcopal registers record graces issued by papal agents before and after Wolsey's dispensing activity but virtually none during it:Footnote 61 further proof of how he dominated English trade in dispensations in the 1520s.
It remains to be seen how Wolsey exercised his dispensing powers: what kinds of graces did he grant, and how far were these within the limits of his known powers? The question matters not least because historians disagree on how he used his legatine authority generally. Pollard spoke of the ‘ruthless vigour with which he used his legatine powers’,Footnote 62 but Kelly and Gwyn have instead portrayed Wolsey as careful not to overstep the bounds of his legatine authority. In order to test the validity of such interpretations in relation to Wolsey and dispensations, we need to compare his dispensing activity with his faculties. In practice he granted a wide range of graces, both to clerical and lay beneficiaries, even if we do not have evidence for his use of each of his faculties. One of his major categories of business was marriage, hardly surprising given that roughly half the supplications approved by the penitentiary concerned marriage by Leo X's pontificate (1513–1521).Footnote 63 Indeed about half of Wolsey's graces from 1525–1526 listed in Appendix 2, that is 53 out of 110, regard marriage. Only eight graces relating to marriage feature among his letters of dispensation in Appendix 4, but his graces for clergy are generally better represented in episcopal registers than those for laity. None of Wolsey's graces from 1526–1529 listed in Appendix 3 are said to concern marriage, but the nature of most of these graces was unspecified, and it recorded 31 graces (out of 174, i.e. over a sixth of this total) issued to pairs of men and women, which most likely regarded marriage.Footnote 64 Most of his matrimonial graces in Appendices 2 and 4 were dispensations for the third and fourth degrees of consanguinity and, less often, affinity in various permutations (including the third and fourth degrees combined); several others dispensed from cognatio spiritualis; and a few were licences for solemnization without banns.Footnote 65 Almost all had been requested before marriage; only two were retrospective, but the couples in question claimed that they had been unaware of the impediment concerned and hence the need for a dispensation prior to marrying.Footnote 66 All of these graces, even these two, broadly fell within the terms of Wolsey's bull of June 1521. But two other graces did not, for both dispensed from the second degree of affinity.Footnote 67 One of them is known as a letter, and its preamble describes Wolsey's faculty to issue marriage dispensations as granted by Leo X and confirmed by Clement VII, but even this does not mention the second degree and conforms to the terms of the bull.Footnote 68 Dispensations from the second degree were rare, and even the cardinal penitentiary often sought express papal approval for such grants since they apparently did not lie within his ordinary faculties.Footnote 69 Perhaps Wolsey had done likewise in these instances, but it is odd that his letter does not say so, as the penitentiary's letters normally do, especially given the disjunction between the faculty which it describes and its grant exceeding that.
Another major part of Wolsey's dispensing activity regarded defectus aetatis, which displays similar anomalies. Thirty-three such graces are known.Footnote 70 Twenty-five of them concern under-age ordination in most cases specifically to the priesthood but in a few others also to deacon's or even all holy orders.Footnote 71 Of this twenty-five, seven allowed such ordination at 24, seventeen at 23 and one at 22, the lowest age at which clergy might be dispensed by Wolsey to enter the priesthood, according to the bull, but provided that they were religious, which in this instance the ordinand was not.Footnote 72 Some of these dispensations made further concessions in relation to ordination, including promotion to two orders on the same day, extra tempora statuta a iure, or by any Catholic bishop, all of which also lay within the bull's terms.Footnote 73 In addition, two of Wolsey's dispensations for under-age ordination along with his eight other graces concerning defectus aetatis permitted tenure of a benefice with cure of souls. Half of these allowed this at ages ranging from 19 to 24, all above the youngest age of 18 at which Wolsey might dispense for this according to the bull.Footnote 74 The other half, however, allowed such benefice-holding below this age-limit, at 17 and even 16.Footnote 75 An incomplete letter of Wolsey, which must have granted a similar grace and probably in late 1525 (Appendix 4. 31), includes a preamble claiming that Wolsey held a faculty from Clement VII to dispense men from the age of fifteen to obtain an incompatible benefice. This would have justified Wolsey's graces for benefice-holding below the age-limit set by Leo X in 1521, and they date from mid February 1525 onwards (i.e. from Clement VII's pontificate), but none of them invoke this faculty. Hence, it cannot be verified on the available evidence, and, as we will later see, more than one English petitioner doubted by Clement VII's time whether Wolsey possessed all the dispensing powers he asserted.
He also interpreted his dispensing powers broadly and likewise claimed that Clement VII had extended them in another key area: pluralism and unions of benefices. The bull of April 1521 authorized him to grant graces in these matters as part of his dispensations from ‘irregularity’; but in practice he does not appear to have done so. Nonetheless, the bull of June 1521 further permitted him to dispense graduates, noblemen, and his familiars in these matters. He certainly used this faculty extensively; forty of his dispensations for plurality are known, and eighteen for unions of benefices. It is less clear that he restricted these favours in accordance with the faculty's terms. Of the forty recipients of his dispensations for plurality, sixteen are known to have been graduates, but it is unclear whether any of the other twenty-four were his familiars or noblemen, though it seems doubtful that all of them were.Footnote 76 Admittedly, it has not proved possible to identify these recipients fully, particularly those listed in Appendix 3 because of the minimal information which this provides about them, but graduates listed in Appendices 2 and 4 are generally specified as such in the sources edited there, which implies that others not so specified were not graduates. Wolsey did at least limit himself to dispensing for a plurality of two incompatible benefices in all but two cases, which regarded three benefices, a ‘trialty’; the bull of June 1521 actually permitted him to dispense for up to four. In the case of unions, eleven of the eighteen beneficiaries are known to have been graduates, and one of these was also a familiar of Wolsey’s.Footnote 77 Their graduate status is again specified in most cases, doubtless because it mattered under the bull of June 1521. Those of uncertain status are mainly listed in Appendix 3, admittedly, but two of Wolsey's letters for unions implied that recipients of such graces were less restricted than the June bull stated in any case. The first letter was issued in April 1523 allegedly by virtue of a faculty granted by Leo X and confirmed by Adrian VI for uniting benefices, without specifying its restrictions. The second from November 1526 instead referred to a faculty of Clement VII to unite benefices for anyone in Wolsey's legation, even non-familiars provided that they were noblemen or graduates.Footnote 78 Certainly Wolsey had supplicated Clement in 1524 to extend his faculties for familiars to non-familiars; if Clement overcame the curia's reluctance to concede this, it seems on this evidence that Wolsey obtained nothing more than confirmation of Leo's original faculty in terms designed to make it sound wider than it really was. However, in practice Wolsey seems to have dispensed non-familiars not covered by the confirmed faculty. He also licensed non-residence in many of his dispensations for plurality, which Leo X's bulls did not explicitly authorize either.Footnote 79 Chancery bulls dispensing plurality routinely included a clause permitting non-residence, and Wolsey's dispensations may simply have followed this practice. But a few of them expressly omitted the clause, and Wolsey also issued some licences for non-residence separate from any dispensation.Footnote 80 Moreover, Wolsey permitted non-residence for the canonical reasons of university study or residence in another benefice held in plurality, in common with chancery bulls, but in a few cases he also allowed it for the worldly purpose of serving the King, Queen, or high nobility.Footnote 81 This seems contrary to canonical prohibitions against clerical involvement in secular affairs, but bishops had long disregarded these in England by entering royal service, as Wolsey himself demonstrated.Footnote 82
Wolsey also seems to have interpreted his powers creatively in granting other kinds of graces. For example, the bull of June 1521 allowed him to license ordination extra tempora statuta a iure, by any Catholic bishop or to two orders on one day within his dispensations for defectus aetatis, but he also issued such graces, often in combination with one another, separate from these dispensations.Footnote 83 Indeed, he rarely appears to have granted these graces in the context of such dispensations.Footnote 84 Ironically, he attached them to at least three dispensations for defectus natalium, which Leo's bulls did not specifically allow either.Footnote 85 Indeed a recipient of one such dispensation later petitioned the chancery, since ‘some’ doubted whether Wolsey's faculties might authorize the ordination of illegitimate men extra tempora statuta a iure (Appendix 4. 40); the petitioner obtained papal confirmation by January 1525 that he might still enjoy the benefits of his dispensation despite these doubts. Even Wolsey's own letters do not suggest that Clement VII had extended his faculty for dispensing from defectus natalium. One of his dispensations for this from mid 1525 simply states that Clement VII had confirmed Leo X's faculty to dispense men of illegitimate birth to receive all holy orders and two incompatible benefices, which defined more precisely but did not significantly add to Leo's concession in his bull of April 1521.Footnote 86 Though Wolsey clearly pushed his faculties to the limits and beyond on occasion, his dispensations for defectus natalium are remarkably few, especially compared with those for defectus aetatis; (and both had been major categories of Anglo-Welsh business at the papal penitentiary).Footnote 87 Maybe English and Welsh clergy perceived Wolsey's faculties in this area as restricted in more ways than one.
The only other graces that he conceded in significant numbers were capacities, and even here he exceeded the terms of his faculties. The bull of June 1521 authorized Wolsey to dispense non-mendicant male religious to hold a secular benefice. But Wolsey issued at least five such dispensations to mendicants out of twenty-one which he is known to have granted.Footnote 88 The only other religious who apparently obtained more of these from Wolsey were regular canons. No doubt, the long-standing involvement of both the friars and regular canons in lay pastoral care made them especially predisposed to entering the parochial ministry. Wolsey dispensed some of them to go even further, however, by being non-resident from their benefice, wearing their habit under secular priest's dress, or even both, which again Leo X's bulls had not explicitly authorized.Footnote 89 He doubtless interpreted his power to issue such graces widely since he saw it as part of his mandate to reform regular clergy. Indeed he granted at least three capacities, and a licence to transfer to another order, to religious from houses which he suppressed in the mid 1520s.Footnote 90 Whether reform motivated Wolsey's pursuit and exercise of dispensing powers more generally will be discussed later.
As for his other graces, these were few and miscellaneous. Most were only loosely related to his faculties granted by Leo X, if at all. They included licences for religious bodies to collect alms and sell indulgences,Footnote 91 which might be associated with his faculties to license preaching and grant indulgences. Wolsey also dispensed from defectus corporis at least once (Appendix 4. 78), which the April bull's faculty to dispense from all ‘irregularities’ might have covered. He used his faculty to license consumption of forbidden foods during fasting periods but in a way that the June bull did not intend, not for specific individuals but everyone resident in his legation.Footnote 92 Wolsey, moreover, licensed at least one priest to celebrate mass twice on Sundays (Appendix 2. 40), which none of his known faculties authorized. Nevertheless, evidence has not been traced for Wolsey's use of several of his faculties, notably those to license personal confessors and portable altars, absolve apostates, and commute intentions in wills. But it does not mean that Wolsey never employed such faculties. More likely it reflects the nature of the evidence. The tenor of most of Wolsey's graces recorded in Appendix 3 is unspecified, while episcopal registers, the main source for Appendix 4, traditionally recorded only certain kinds of papal graces, principally marriage dispensations and dispensations regarding ordination or benefices.Footnote 93 The recipients of these graces doubtless had them copied into episcopal registers, in the case of married couples to prevent local church courts dissolving their unions because of the impediments requiring dispensation, and in the case of clergy to secure ordination and admission to benefices from local bishops. These beneficiaries probably had to pay for such copies, particularly because they were often made by notaries in Salisbury and other dioceses in order to guarantee their legal authenticity.Footnote 94 Doubtless to avoid such costs some clergy did not have dispensations from Wolsey copied but simply presented them on seeking ordination, hence these graces are only known from references to them in ordination lists.Footnote 95 This may be one reason why other graces of Wolsey’s, notably many of those listed in Appendix 2, do not appear in bishops’ registers. Another explanation is that Wolsey's graces do not seem to have required ‘execution’ by bishops. This was a procedure associated with letters of dispensation issued by the curia: these letters were issued in response to petitions, and petitioners receiving these had to present them to a commissary; the letters summarized their petition and required him to verify its claims; if he found these to be true, the letters authorized him to ‘execute’, or put into effect, the grace requested, but not otherwise.Footnote 96 The commissary, to whom the letters were addressed, was usually the petitioners’ bishop or his vicar; hence such letters were often copied into bishops’ registers, normally with the record of their execution, but no such record has been found alongside Wolsey's letters in episcopal registers. Not all papal graces required execution, admittedly, notably licences for personal confessors, but many of Wolsey's would have done if the curia had issued them. Nonetheless, his graces did not wholly escape official scrutiny. Some were shown at visitations, notably in 1537 when royal confirmation had to be sought for them lest they were deemed void as papal graces following the break with Rome.Footnote 97 One dispensation issued by Wolsey on 1 June 1527 was even subjected to judicial inquiry in the same month.Footnote 98 Richard Pescod exhibited it before Winchester Consistory Court to justify his retention of a fellowship at Winchester College and rectory at Shaw (Berks.) in plurality, but the judge objected to the dispensation's implication that his fellowship was a compatible benefice when, as Pescod confessed, it required continual residence, and thus ordered Pescod to explain why he should not incur the canonical penalty on this account. No final judgement on the dispensation's validity was recorded, but Pescod had clearly erred by failing to ask for the right sort of dispensation, that is one specifying his benefice as incompatible and including a non-residence clause as Wolsey had given to others.Footnote 99 Gwyn goes too far in attributing failure here to Wolsey's legatine administration rather than Pescod,Footnote 100 but if the former had required execution of its graces, doubtless such errors would have been more systematically detected.
Little is known about Wolsey's legatine administration, but the documents edited below refer to the personnel concerned with his dispensations. The first known scribe to engross Wolsey's letters of dispensation was ‘R. Toneys’ (or ‘Toneys’); between May 1522 and June 1526 his signature appears under the plica of two original letters on the right and his name is recorded below nine others in bishops’ registers. He also kept a register of Wolsey's graces; this does not seem to have survived, but the list of 1525–1526 in Appendix 2 refers to it and was doubtless based on it.Footnote 101 He was probably Robert Toneys, a Cambridge graduate in civil law who held canonries at Salisbury and Crediton while in Wolsey's service.Footnote 102 Two other names regularly appear at the foot of Wolsey's dispensations from November 1526 (by which time Toneys had apparently died). One was a William ‘Claiburgh’ (or ‘Claiburn’), who signed under the plica on the right in letters down to December 1528 as Wolsey's ‘datarius’, a title borrowed from the papal curia, which originally designated the official who dated and sealed chancery documents.Footnote 103 His duties were doubtless similar and apparently included collecting taxes for Wolsey's graces.Footnote 104 He was doubtless William Claybrook or Clayburgh, another Cambridge graduate who was a doctor of canon and civil law by 1522–1523 and held various benefices from 1519, including the Worcester archdeaconry from 1531 until his death in 1534.Footnote 105 By May 1529, Edmund Bonner, DCL of Oxford, had replaced him as Wolsey's ‘datarius’, at least down to July and probably till the latter's fall in October; Bonner was also Wolsey's chaplain by 1529 till the cardinal's arrest in November 1530.Footnote 106 The other name that regularly appeared beside the datary's (and sometimes on its own) was John Hughes, who signed under the plica on the left in letters until mid 1529 as Wolsey's ‘actuarius et registrarius’.Footnote 107 He succeeded Toneys not only as registrar of Wolsey's graces but probably also their scribe. Moreover, as his title ‘actuarius’ implies, Hughes kept accounts of taxes charged for Wolsey's dispensations, even before Toneys's death, as early as May 1525, and until Wolsey's fall.Footnote 108 After this event, his financial records as ‘former receiver’ (receptor) of income from Wolsey's ‘faculties’ served as the basis for the list edited in Appendix 3. He is presumably the John Hughes who was an Oxford graduate in both laws by 1514 and DCL by 1528.Footnote 109 Indeed all those involved in administering Wolsey's graces had relevant legal expertise, which is clearly why Wolsey engaged them. It also seems that they formed part of his household and travelled around with him, as Wolsey's graces are normally dated at his residence near Westminster but occasionally at others.Footnote 110
The growing division of labour that this prosopography illustrates was doubtless necessitated by increasing demand for Wolsey's graces and the income which these generated. Some idea of the volume of business can be gained from the sources in Appendices 2 and 3, which were compiled primarily as financial records. The list in Appendix 2 recorded an income totalling £209 13s 4d from the 110 graces issued by Wolsey in the year following July 1525. Another account for a longer, unspecified period circa 1525 refers to £334 received by John Hughes for Wolsey's dispensations.Footnote 111 By 23 October 1529 the arrears alone, recorded in Appendix 3, for Wolsey's graces granted in the previous three years amounted to £822 7s 5¼d. It is hardly surprising then that Clement VII complained of his curia's falling income from dispensations when resisting Wolsey's demands for greater faculties in 1525. It is, nevertheless, remarkable that Wolsey deprived it of business despite charging more for graces than its own offices. As I have noted elsewhere,Footnote 112 a comparison between the list of Wolsey's graces from 1525–1526 and a contemporary tax-list of the papal penitentiary shows that his fees were usually higher. Wolsey's charges for some graces may even have increased in the late 1520s; for example a licence for uniting benefices cost £4 in his list of 1525–1526, but between £5 and £15 in the list compiled in late 1529.Footnote 113 Despite such fees, English and Welsh petitioners still found it more convenient to approach Wolsey than the curia: its distance made the process of petitioning lengthier and arguably dearer given the hidden costs involved in engaging proctors and other intermediaries to relay requests to Rome.Footnote 114 The ‘Sack’ made the curia even less accessible in the late 1520s, leaving little choice but to petition Wolsey. However, whether his administration deliberately profiteered in raising its fees for some graces at this time is hard to judge.
This leaves the question of Wolsey's motives and intentions in seeking and using dispensing powers. One interpretation is that Wolsey exercised his legatine powers for the sake of ‘self-aggrandizement’.Footnote 115 This is chiefly Pollard's view. It belongs to a ‘Protestant’ historiography which perceived the pre-Reformation church as corrupt; and, for Pollard, Wolsey epitomized this corruption. Revisionist scholarship has challenged this opinion of both the late medieval church and Wolsey as its nadir. Nevertheless, Wolsey always yearned for greater legatine authority than the papacy was prepared to concede, and the alleged breve in Appendix 1 hints at the scope of his ambition; there is little doubt that he strove to rival other contemporary cardinals in this regard. But, it is unlikely that the aim of Wolsey's dispensing activity was to dominate the English Church; its bishops had few if any dispensing powers, so dispensations had to be sought outside their jurisdiction in any case. And if Wolsey exceeded his dispensing powers on occasion, this was most likely in reaction to popular demand, since Wolsey, like the curia, conceded graces largely in response to petitions. Indeed popular anticipation of his legatine powers and their benefits existed as early as 1516.Footnote 116 Wolsey possibly lobbied for faculties to meet this popular expectation. It cannot be denied that he profited financially from granting dispensations, charging even higher fees for them than Rome itself, but he was nowhere near as dependent on them for income as the curia was, and the fees were partly necessary to cover the administrative costs of issuing such graces.Footnote 117 And he had, of course, claimed that his aim in seeking legatine powers was not monetary gain but church reform. His reforming intent is best illustrated by his dispensations for religious (and his dealings with religious houses more generally).Footnote 118 In particular, he used such graces in conjunction with his suppression of houses, notably by issuing capacities to the last two priors of Poughley and a transfer to the last prior of Daventry in 1525, both of which priories Wolsey dissolved in order to convert their assets for the use of Cardinal College at Oxford. This redirection of ecclesiastical resources to a new religious purpose can be interpreted as reform. And his activity would set a precedent for the dissolution of all monasteries over ten years later. Not coincidentally, Thomas Cromwell who oversaw it was a former protégé of Wolsey, and his suppression of religious houses was also combined with the granting of capacities to their former brethren.Footnote 119 The latter were issued by the Faculty Office, which Henry VIII had established in 1534 to replace the curia as a source of graces within his realm, and it was arguably here that Wolsey's dispensing activity led the way most of all for religious change.
First, Wolsey's legatine administration probably bequeathed the new office's name. The list of arrears compiled in late 1529 (Appendix 3) misleadingly referred to most of his graces as ‘faculties’ (properly speaking his powers to grant them rather than the graces themselves) and thus called their financial administration ‘officium receptionis facultatum’. Wolsey's ‘Faculty Office’ effectively closed on his fall, and this list is part of a dossier of inventories recording his assets seized by the Crown. Doubtless, the list impressed on royal government how great the demand for and income from dispensations were, and influenced Henry VIII's decision to allow them to continue through a new ‘Faculty Office’ and to share in its revenue.Footnote 120 At least one former employee of Wolsey's ‘Faculty Office’, John Hughes, appears to have joined the new office, and his past experience potentially influenced it; (another, Edmund Bonner, also became a fellow traveller with the Henrician Reformation, rising to the episcopate by 1538). Above all, Wolsey's ‘Faculty Office’ had established a model for a local, national source of dispensations, preparing the way for a remarkable continuity within a reformed church and a radical change, as contact with Rome as a ‘well of grace’ became redundant.
A Note on Editorial Method
Appendices 1a, 1b, 2, and 3 comprise documents printed in full, while further documents are calendared in Appendix 4. The transcription of the (Latin) texts printed in full preserves the spelling and capitalization of the manuscripts, while the punctuation is editorial. Line breaks in these texts are indicated thus /, except in Appendix 1a as this contains a copy of an original text, while the texts in Appendices 1b, 2, and 3 are all original documents. Editorial comments (in italics) on these texts, foliation and words or letters supplied by the editor appear in square brackets; uncertain extensions of abbreviations in these texts appear in curved brackets, while [] refers to blank spaces where text has been left out and [. . .] where text has been lost.Words added on the writing line in these texts appear between these symbols \ /; words added in the margin appear between these \\ //. The numbering (in square brackets and bold) of the multiple entries in the texts in Appendices 2 and 3 is editorial. The calendared documents are also numbered (in square brackets and bold), and the English summary of these Latin texts seeks not only to convey their content but also to follow their formulaic wording as closely as possible. In these calendared documents Latin Christian names are given in their English equivalents, Latin forms of Welsh patronymics in their standard Welsh forms, and place names in their modern forms; surnames are given as they appear in the manuscripts, and any other original wording including place names appears in round brackets and italics. After the summary, the dating clause of the document is given with the date in the modern calendar form, followed by any annotations or endorsements to the document and its dimensions (if an original document, as opposed to a copy). Calendared documents end with their archival source (in italics) and, where applicable, folio numbers.
