Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 January 2017
The question of the perpetrator is largely uncharted territory in the history of the Soviet Union. The term is rarely used in the historiography of the Stalinist Soviet Union. In part, this omission is based upon a reluctance to go beyond Iosif Stalin in assigning agency or responsibility for the immense crimes of his reign. In part, the omission derives from decades-long restrictions on archival access. Lynne Viola begins with an exploration of the postwar trajectories of the historiographies of the mid-twentieth century's classically paired “totalitarian” regimes in order to understand the relative absence of “perpetrator studies” for the Stalinist 1930s. She then examines the question of the Soviet perpetrator, less to demarcate who the perpetrator was than to offer a conceptualization of the range of factors that enabled, conditioned, and shaped their violent acts. Intended to raise questions for further study, Viola's article is complemented by comments from Wendy Goldman and Peter Fritzsche.
1. MarkRoseman, , “Beyond Conviction? Perpetrators, Ideas and Action in the Holocaust in Historiographical Perspective,” in Biess, Frank, Roseman, Mark, and Schissler, Hanna, eds., Conflict, Catastrophe and Continuity: Essays on Modern German History (New York, 2007), 83; and Browning, Christopher R., The Path to Genocide: Essays on Launching the Final Solution (Cambridge, Eng., 1992), x. See also the nuanced and open discussion of the historiography in Michael Wildt, An Uncompromising Generation: The Nazi Leadership of the Reich Security Main Office, trans. Tom Lampen (Madison, 2009), 3–18.
2. For a ränge of views on the trials, see Bloxham, Donald, Genocide on Trial: War Crimes Trials and the Formation of Holocaust History and Memory (Oxford, 2001); Earl, Hilary, The Nuremberg SS-Einsatzgruppen Trial, 1945-1958: Atrocity, Law, and History (Cambridge, Eng., 2009), chap. 1; Devin 0. Pendas, , “Seeking Justice, Finding Law: Nazi Trials in Postwar Europe,” Journal of Modern History 81, no. 2 (June 2009): 347–68; and Douglas, Lawrence, The Memory ofjudgment: MakingLaw and History in the Trials ofthe Holocaust (New Haven, 2001).
3. See, e.g., Applebaum, Anne, Gulag: A History (New York, 2003), epilogue and esp. 575, where she uses the phrase “Gulag denier,” in relation to a certain “few” but unnamed scholars; and Courtois, Stéphane et al., eds., The Black Book of Communism, trans. Murphy, Jonathan and Kramer, Mark (Cambridge, Mass., 1999), especially articles by Martin Malia and Stephane Courtois, both of whom see communism as the moral equivalent of Nazism.
4. The trial ended without resolution. For information on the sources yielded by the trial, see 1.1. Kudriavtsev, , ed., Arkhivy Kremlia i staroi ploshchadi: Dokumenty po “delu KPSS” (Novosibirsk, 1995).
5. See, in particular, the fine historiographical discussions in Geyer, Michael and Fitzpatrick, Sheila, eds., Beyond Totalitahanism: Stalinism and Nazism Compared (Cambridge, Eng., 2009), esp. chap. 1.
6. For a history of the model, see Abbott Gleason, Totalitarianism: The Inner History of the Cold War (New York, 1995). Totalitarianism founds its theorists in Carl Friedrich, Zbigniew Brzezinski, Jacob Talman, and, most famously, Hannah Arendt. See Arendt, Hannah, The Origins of Totalitarianism new ed. (New York, 1973); Friedrich, Carl J. and Brzezinski, Zbigniew K., Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy, 2d rev. ed. (Cambridge, Mass., 1965); and Talman, J. L., The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy (London, 1952).
7. See Bloxham, Genocide on Trial, 2-6.
8. Cited in Douglas, The Memory ofjudgment, 91.
9. Hilberg, Raul, The Destruction ofthe European Jews (New York, 1985), 288.
10. Arendt, Hannah, On Violence (New York, 1970), 38.
11. Arendt, Hannah, Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality ofEvil, rev. ed. (New York, 1985), 276.
12. Ibid., 252.
13. For a discussion of the intentionalist-structuralist debate, see Kershaw, Ian, Hitler, the Germans, and the Final Solution (New Haven, 2008), pt. 3.
14. Tucker, Robert C., ed., Stalinism: Essays in Historical Interpretation (New York, 1977), esp. xi–xx.
15. Kershaw, Hitler, 246. Emphasis in the original.
16. For a discussion of the German literature, see Herbert, Ulrich, “Extermination Policy: New Answers and Questions about the History of the ‘Holocaust’ in German Historiography,” in Herbert, , ed., National Socialist Extermination Policies: Contemporary German Perspectives and Controversies (New York, 2004), 4–11.
17. Browning, Christopher R. (with contributions by Jürgen Matthäus), The Origins of the Final Solution: The Evolution of Nazi Jewish Policy, September 1939-March 1942 (Lincoln, 2004), 214.
18. Kershaw, writes: “Hitler would Signal a ‘green light’ to party radicals to step up measures against Jews; ‘action’ would inevitably build from below, putting pressure on the regime to sanction it, and ultimately Hitler's intervention; this would ‘legitimate’ the radical action before starting the process once more … without any need for explicit orders.” Kershaw, , Hitler, 20–21,40-41.
19. For classic work in the revisionist genre, see Fitzpatrick, Sheila, ed., Cultural Revolution in Russia, 1928-1931 (Bloomington, 1978); Fitzpatrick, , Education and Social Mobility in the Soviet Union, 1921-1934 (Cambridge, Eng., 1979); Arch, Getty J., Origins of the Great Purges: The Soviet Communist Party Reconsidered, 1933-1938 (Cambridge, Eng., 1985); Kuromiya, Hiroaki, Stalin's Industrial Revolution: Politics and Workers, 1928-1932 (Cambridge, Eng., 1988); Manning, Roberta, “Government in the Soviet Countryside in the Stalinist Thirties: The Case of Belyi Raion in 1937,” Carl Beck Papers in Russian and East European Studies, no. 301 (Pittsburgh, n.d.); and Viola, Lynne, The Best Sons ofthe Fatherland: Workers in the Vanguard of Soviet Collectivization (New York, 1987).
20. Malia, , “Foreword: The Uses of Atrocity,” in Courtois et al., eds., Black Book of Communism , xx. In “To the Editors,” Kritika 3 no.3 (Summer 2002): 569–71, Malia, writes, “To really put the revisionist corpse behind us, its conceptual failures will have to be explicitly [his emphasis] recognizedbyaconsensus ofthe field, ifpossiblebysome ofthe responsible parties themselves.” In “On the Primacy of Ideology: Soviet Revisionists and Holocaust Deniers,” Kritika 5, no. 1 (Winter 2004): 100–101 , Michael David-Fox discusses Malia's political critiques of the revisionists, noting “The Soviet historical tragedy thus repeats itself as historiographical farce, with Malia issuing the call for self-criticism, recantation, and condemnation by an activist majority.“
21. For a sense ofthe tone ofthe debate, see Fitzpatrick, Sheila, “Revisionism in Retrospect: A Personal View,” Slavic Review 67, no. 3 (Fall 2008): 682–704.
22. Browning, Christopher R., Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland (New York, 1992); Goldhagen, Daniel Jonah, Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust (New York, 1996).
23. Browning, Ordinary Men, 161.
24. Goldhagen, Hitler's Willing Executioners, 6x 2013; 7, 28-29, 266–67, 419.
25. Hilberg, Destruction of the European Jews, 277. E.g., Earl, The Nuremberg SSEinsatzgruppen Trial, 140-41, takes a middling view between Browning and Goldhagen. For another nuanced view, see Wildt, An Uncompromising Generation. Wildt presents a sophisticated analysis of the conjuneture of generation, institution, and war to understand the shaping of the leaders of the Reich Security Main Office. Wildt is careful (and in this unusual) to note that his conclusions do not extend necessarily to other groups of Nazi perpetrators (425).
26. Two decades of archival work have yielded multiple empirical studies and a voluminous array of published documents on Soviet violence in the 1930s that allow us to begin the work of excavating the Soviet perpetrator. Some of the best work includes Zhdanova, G. D.. et al., eds., Massovye repressiiv Altaiskom krae, 1937-1938 gg.: PrikazNo. 00447 (Moscow, 2010); Stalinism v Sovetskoi provintsii, 1937-1938 gg.: Massovaia operatsiia na osnoveprikaza No. 00447 (Moscow, 2009); Junge, Marc, ed., “Cherez trupy vraga na blago naroda“: “Kulatskaia operatsiia” v Ukrainskoi SSR1937-1941 gg., 2 vols. (Moscow, 2010); Danilov, V., Manning, R., Viola, L. et al., eds., Tragedüa Sovetskoi derevni. Kollektivizatsüa i raskulachivanie. Dokumenty i materialy, 1927-1939, 5 vols. (Moscow, 1999-2006); Berelovich, A. and Danilov, V., eds., Sovetskaia derevnia glazami VChK-OGPU-NKVD, 1918-1939: Dokumenty i materialy, 4 vols. (Moscow, 1998-2005); as well as the works of Tepliakov, A. G., most notably Mashina terrora: OGPU-NKVD Sibiri v 1929-1941 gg. (Moscow, 2008); Junge, Marc and Binner, Rolf, eds., Kak terror stal “bol'shim” (Moscow, 2003); Leibovich, O. et al., eds., “Vkliuchen v operatsiiu“: Massovyi terror v Prikam'e v 1937-1938 gg. (Moscow, 2009); Stepanov, A. F., Rasstrelpo limitu: Iz istorii politicheskikh repressii v TASSRvgody “ezhovshchinu” (Kazan, 1999); Samosudov, V. M., 0 repressüakh v Omskom Prürtysh'e: Istoricheskie etiudy (Omsk, 1998).
27. Goldman, Wendy, Terror and Democracy in the Age of Stalin: The Social Dynamics of Repression (Cambridge, Eng., 2007), and Goldman, , Inventing the Enemy: Denunciation and Terror in Stalin's Russia (Cambridge, Eng., 2011); Hagenloh, Paul, Stalin's Police: Public Order and Mass Repression in the USSR, 1926-1941 (Baltimore, 2009); and Shearer, David, Policing Stalin's Socialism: Repression and Social Order in the Soviet Union, 19241953 (New Haven, 2009). See also the excellent studies in McLoughlin, Barry and McDermott, Kevin, eds., Stalin's Terror: High Politics and Mass Repression in the Soviet Union (New York, 2003). Although unpublished, the work of Cynthia V. Hooper should be noted as an excellent study examining (among other things) the structural and institutional framework for repression. See Hooper, , “Terror from Within: Participation and Coercion in Soviet Power, 1924-1964” (PhD diss., Princeton University, 2003). Also noteworthy are the works of Alexopoulos, Golfo, including Stalin's Outcasts: Aliens, Citizens, and the Soviet State, 1926-1936 (Ithaca, 2003); Alexopoulos, , “Stalin and the Politics of Kinship: Practices of Collective Punishment, 1920s-1940s,” Comparative Studies in Society and History 50, no. 1 (January 2008): 91–117; and Alexopoulos, , “Amnesty 1945: The Revolving Door of Stalin's Gulag,” Slavic Review 64, no. 2 (Summer 2005): 274–306. Alexopoulos's fortheoming work on practices in the gulag will undoubtedly prove formative in our knowledge and interpretations.
28. Halfin, Igal, Terror in My Soul: Communist Autobiographies on Trial (Cambridge, Mass., 2003); Halfin, , From Darkness to Light: Class, Consciousness, and Salvation in Revolutionary Russia (Pittsburgh, 2000); Halfin, , Intimate Enemies: Demonizing the Bolshevik Opposition, 1918-1928 (Pittsburgh, 2007); Halfin, , Stalinist Confessions: Messianism and Terror at the Leningrad Communist University (Pittsburgh, 2009); and Hellbeck, Jochen, Revolution on My Mind: Writing a Diary under Stalin (Cambridge, Mass., 2006).
29. Arch, Getty J. and Naumov, Oleg V., The Road to Terror: Stalin and the Self-Destruction of the Bolsheviks, 1932-1939, trans. Sher, Benjamin (New Haven, 1999), particularly the introduetion.
30. See the important new collection by Steinberg, Mark D. and Sobol, Valeria, eds., Interpreting Emotions in Russia and Eastern Europe (DeKalb, 2011), in particular the editors’ introduetion and the chapters by Ronald Grigor Suny (“Thinking about Feelings“) and Glennys Young (“Bolsheviks and Emotional Hermeneutics“).
31. Sofsky, Wolfgang, The Order of Terror: The Concentration Camp, trans. Templer, William (Princeton, 1997).
32. Bauman, Zygmunt, Modernity and the Holocaust (Ithaca, 1992), 18. See also Weitz, Eric D., A Century ofGenocide: Utopias ofRace and Nation (Princeton, 2003).
33. See, in particular, Weiner, Amir, “Nature, Nurture, and Memory in a Socialist Utopia: Delineating the Soviet Socio-Ethnic Body in the Age of Socialism,” American Historical Review 104, no. 4 (October 1999): 1114–55; and Weiner, , ed., Landscaping the Human Garden: Twentieth-Century Population Management in a Comparative Framework (Stanford, 2003), especially the introduction by Weiner and the brilliant article by Peter Holquist, “State Violence as Technique.”
34. See, e.g., Omer Bartov's critique of Sofsky, in, “ Ordering Horror: Conceptualizations of the Concentrationary Universe,” Germany's War and the Holocaust: Disputed Histories (Ithaca, 2003), 105–11; and Viola, Lynne, “The Aesthetic of Stalinist Planning and the World of the Special Villages,” Kritika 4, no. 1 (Winter 2003): 101–28.
35. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv sotsial'no-politicheskoi istorii (RGASPI), f. 560, op. 1, d. 10,1.159. This quote is taken from “Zapiski osobista,” by M. F. Zhabokritskii, an unpublished manuscript dated 1967.
36. Levene, Mark, Genocide in theAge ofthe Nation State, 2 vols. (London, 2005), 1:99.
37. Levi, Primo, The Drowned and the Saved, trans. Rosenthal, Raymond (New York, 1989), 186–87.
38. Regardless ofthe theoretically precise categorizations ofthe police files.
39. For an example of these characterizations in Germany, see Roseman, “Beyond Conviction?“
40. For examples, see Tucker, Robert C., Stalin as Revolutionär)/, 1879-1929: A Study in History and Personality (New York, 1973); Rieber, A. J., “Stalin, Man of the Borderlands,“ American Historical Review 106, no. 5 (December 2001): 1651-91; Rieber, , “Stalin as Georgian: the Formative Years,” in Davies, Sarah and Harris, James, eds., Stalin: A New History (Cambridge, Eng., 2005), 18–44; Rancour-Laferriere, Daniel, The Mind of Stalin: A Psychoanalytic Study (Ann Arbor, 1988).
41. Viola, , The Best Sons ofthe Fatherland, 21,222n45; Getty, Origins ofthe GreatPurges, 46,68–69,82-83; Viola, Lynne, The Unknown Gulag: The Lost World of Stalin's Special Settlements (New York, 2007), 108–9; Bakirov, E. A. et al., eds., Butovskiipoligon, 1937-1938, 8 vols. (Moscow, 1997), 1:26. On the use of alcohol among Einsatsgruppen members, see, e.g., Browning, Ordinary Men, 61, 69, 82-85; Hilberg, , Destruction ofthe European Jews, 146; and Sereny, Gitta, Mo ThatDarkness (London, 1990), 200.
42. Tepliakov, A. G., Protsedura: Ispolneniia smertnykhprigovorov v 1920-30-kh godakh (Moscow, 2007), 33–37.
43. Fitzpatrick, Education and Social Mobility.
44. Viola, Lynne, Peasant Rebeis under Stalin: Collectivization and the Culture of Peasant Resistance (New York, 1996), 24–27; and Viola, , “The Campaign to Eliminate the Kulak as a Class, Winter, 1929-1930: A Reevaluation of the Legislation,” Slavic Review 45, no. 3 (Autumn 1986): 503–24.
45. See, e.g., Hagenloh, Stalin's Police, 278-81.
46. See, e.g., the document in Viola, Lynne et al., eds., The War against the Peasantry, 1927-30: The Tragedy ofthe Soviet Countryside, trans. Shabad, Steven (New Haven, 2005), 279–88; and Viola, Unknown Gulag, 36.
47. On “apartment denunciations,” see Fitzpatrick, Sheila, “Signals from Below,“ Tear Off the Masks! Identity and Imposture in Twentieth-Century Russia (Princeton, 2005), 228–29.
48. Tepliakov, Protsedura, 67-71.
49. Vatlin, A. Iu., Terror raionnogo masshtaba (Moscow, 2004), 85–87.
50. For Nazi Germany, see Browning, Ordinary Men, 170.
51. Viola, Best Sons, 127-29.
52. E.g., Goldman, Terror and Democracy in the Age of Stalin, 175, 205-6.
53. E.g., Grigorenko, Petro G., Memoirs, trans. Whitney, Thomas P. (New York, 1983), 28,36; Kopelev, Lev, Isotvoril sebe kumira (Ann Arbor, 1978); Orlova, Raisa, Memoirs, trans. Cioran, Samuel (New York, 1983), ix-x, 65, 83, 72.
54. See Halfin, Stalinist Confessions.
55. Clark, Katerina, Petersburg: Crucible of Cultural Revolution (Cambridge, Mass., 1995), ix-x.
56. A similar approach can be found in James Waller's masterful BecomingEvil. Waller combines a macrohistorical approach with a psychosocial exploration of the individual perpetrator. Starting from what seems now to be the consensus view—that perpetrators were “ordinary people“—he examines a ränge of factors including what he calls “ancestral shadows” (ethnocentrism, xenophobia, the desire for social dominance), the forces that mold perpetrators (cultural belief Systems, moral disengagement, rational self-interest), the culture of cruelty (the role of Professional socialization, binding factors of a group, the merger of bureaucratic role and person), and the notion of the “social death of the victim” (the us-them mentality, dehumanization, blaming the victim). He further argues that a “trigger” is necessary to put in motion this cultural and social baggage, therefore highlighting the situational and the contingent. See James Waller, Becoming Evil: How Ordinary People Commit Genocide and Mass Killing (New York, 2002). . Etkind, Alexander, Internal Colonization: Russia's Imperial Experience (Cambridge, Eng., 2011), 249.
58. Stalin, I., Sochineniia, 13 vols. (Moscow, 1951-1955), 11:171.
59. See, e.g., Molotov Remembers: Inside Kremlin Poltics. Conversations with Felix Chuev (Chicago, 1991), 254.
60. Hagenloh, Stalin's Police; and Shearer, PolicingStalin's Socialism.
61. Viola, Unknown Gulag, 5-6; Viola, Peasant Rebeis under Stalin, 32-38.
62. E. H. Carr was the first scholar to note that policy often determined class in the Soviet context. See Carr, , Socialism in One Country, 1924-1926, 4 vols. (London, 1958-1964), 1:99
63. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv ekonomiki (RGAE), f. 7486, op. 37, d. 23233,177.
64. Viola, Peasant Rebeis under Stalin, chaps. 1,4-5.
65. Goldman, Terror and Democracy in the Age of Stalin; and Goldman, Inventing the Enemy.
66. Viola, Unknown Gulag, 104-12.
67. Afans'ev, Iu. N. et al., eds., Istorna Stalinskogo Gulaga. Konets 1920-kh—pervaia polovina 1950-kh godov. Sobranie dokumentov v semi tomakh (Moscow, 2004-5), 2:34, 43, 67–69, 96-99,109-13,145-46.
68. See Alexander Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago, trans. Thomas P. Whitney and Harry Willetts, 3 vols. (New York, 1973-78). The classic memoir account on the criminal-political dichotomy is by Eugenia Semenovna Ginzburg, Journey into the Whirlwind, trans. Paul Stevenson and Max Hayward (New York, 1967), but many other memoirs by intellectuals testify to this as well.
69. On interrogations, see the provocative and erudite Stalinist Confessions by Igal Halfin. Halfin was the first western scholar to explore interrogations. His great contribution is to examine the ways in which the dominant ideological discourse shaped the world of both interrogator and victim, thus, in his opinion, blurring the lines between perpetrator and victim. While his focus on Leningrad students allows him to make this argument quite brilliantly, it limits the possibilities of generalizing this understanding of perpetrators, not only beyond the Great Terror (e.g., the dominant discourse does not exist at any level during the mass repression of peasants in the early 1930s and represents at best a small part of the story within the gulag), but even within the Great Terror (when our attention turns away from the capital cities and away from communists and intellectuals). Nadezhda Mandelstam, Hope against Hope, trans. Max Hayward (New York, 1976), 81.
71. Viktorov, V. A., Bezgrifa “sekretno“: Zapiski voennogo prokurora (Moscow, 1990), 138–39.
72. Ginzburg discusses this phenomenon in Journey into the Whirlwind.
73. Arendt, On Violence, 56.
74. Harris, James, “Resisting the Plan in the Urals, 1928-1956,” in Viola, Lynne, ed., Contending with Stalinism: Soviet Power and Populär Resistance in the 1930s (Ithaca, 2002), 201–27.
75. Levene, Genocide in the Age of the Nation State; Mark Mazower, Dark Continent (New York, 1998). For other comparative works, see Gellately, Robert and Kiernan, Ben, eds., The Specter of Genocide: Mass Murder in Historical Perspective (Cambridge, Eng., 2003); Kiernan, , Blood and Soil: A World History of Genocide and Extermination from Sparta to Darfur (New Haven, 2007); Mann, Michael, The Dark Side ofDemocracy: Explaining Ethnic Cleansing (Cambridge, Eng., 2005); and Bloxham, Donald and Gerwarth, Robert, eds., Political Violence in Twentieth-Century Europe (Cambridge, Eng., 2011).
76. See, e.g., Gerlach, Christian and Werth, Nicolas, “State Violence-Violent Societies,” in Geyer, and Fitzpatrick, , eds., Beyond Totalitarianism, 151; and Christian Gerlach, Extremely Violent Societies: Mass Violence in the Twentieth-Century World (Cambridge, Eng., 2010).
77. Levene, Genocide in the Age of the Nation State, 1:112–13,163,174,176.
78. Fitzpatrick, Sheila, The Russian Revolution, new ed. (New York, 1994), 140.
79. See Hagenloh, Stalin's Police; and Shearer, Policing Stalin's Socialism.
80. See Getty's pioneering work on center-periphery conflicts, beginning with his Origins ofthe Great Purges.
81. See Viola, “Aesthetic of Stalinist Planning.“ As a salutary warning, it is worth noting the words of the German historian of National Socialism, Wildt, who writes in respect to the study of the Nazi perpetrator: “Future research on the subject will be guided not by the presupposition of a Single, predominant perpetrator type but by the analysis of different actors and institutions, of intentional will to exterminate and structural conditions, of ideology and function, as well as of individual premeditation and the dynamics of situational violence.” Wildt, An Uncompromising Generation, 8.
83. Verdery, Katherine, “Postsocialist Cleansing in Eastern Europe: Purity and Danger in Transitional Justice” (unpublished manuscript, 2011), 11,18.
84. Cited in Wieviorka, Annette, The Era of the Witness, trans Stark, Jared (Ithaca, 2006), 94.
85. Browning, Ordinary Men, xx.