Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 March 2016
Viewers of the recent television series ‘The Voyage of Charles Darwin’ must have been amused at the portrayal of Samuel Wilberforce, bishop of Oxford, at the famous meeting of the British Association at Oxford in 1860, at which Wilberforce condemned the evolutionary doctrine of Darwin’s Origin of Species. This Wilberforce is the vaudeville villain of the Victorian stage, saturnine and leering in his initial triumph, and with more than the suggestion of horns and tail, as he stalks off scowling darkly after his discomfiture by T. H. Huxley. In the vulgar mythology of the television screen, Huxley and Wilberforce are not so much personalities as the warring embodiments of rival moralities, Huxley, the archangel Michael of enlightenment, knowledge, and the disinterested pursuit of truth; Wilberforce, the dark defender of the failing forces of authority, bigotry and superstition. The picture has the stark contrast and attractive simplicity of traditional legend. As a debate, it dramatizes a great conflict of principle. With its Victorian setting, only the stock conventions of melodrama can do it justice, and so it lives on in the popular mind as the best known symbol of the nineteenth century conflict of science and religion.
For assistance with this article I am especially grateful to Dr Ann Loades and Dr David Knight of the university of Durham, Peter Sedgwick of the university of Birmingham and Dr Christopher Wright of the British Library. I had completed this paper when I read J. R. Lucas, ‘Wilberforce and Huxley: a Legendary Encounter’, The Historical Journal 22 (June 1979) pp 313–30. Mr Lucas has not seen Miss Browne’s significant essay (see footnote 32) or James Moore’s recent book (see footnote 12). Mr Lucas is less interested in the religious context, is more exclusively concerned with the details of the debate, and we differ on a number of points of interpretation; but both our points of agreement and difference establish the uncertainty of the episode.