Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 March 2016
This essay will explore a few of the myriad competing tensions of motive, ideology and practicality that were created by, and existed during, the time of the Crusades. The First Crusade was launched in 1095 when Pope Urban II called for the liberation of Jerusalem from the Muslims of the Near East. Four years later, the knights of Western Europe captured the holy city and established a series of territories in the Levant. Over time the Muslims began to fight back and by 1187, under the leadership of Saladin, they defeated the Franks (as the settlers were known) and recovered Jerusalem. The particular focus here is on the Third Crusade (1187—92), the campaign called in the aftermath of this seismic event. Popular history books often characterize this as the great clash between Richard the Lionheart and Saladin, and between Christianity and Islam. They describe battles and sieges; they might also highlight the divisions between Richard and Philip Augustus, and the failure of the crusade to recover Jerusalem. Such points are certainly central to a discussion of the Third Crusade but they are symptomatic of more detailed treatments of the expedition that have not, to date, placed the subject in a fuller context. One aspect of this broader approach is to emphasize the diversity of participants within the Christian and Muslim forces, to take the crusade beyond the Richard and Saladin binary.
This essay is dedicated to the memory of Dr John Doran (1966—2012), a fine scholar and a truly warm-hearted man, who was taken from us far too soon.
1 James, Reston Jr, Warriors of God: Richard the Lionheart and Saladin in the Third Crusade (London, 2001), is one such example. See Lewis, Bernard, Islam and the West (Oxford, 1993), 12–13 , for a more scholarly perspective, albeit one that follows the 'clash of civilizations’ line.
2 This is my longer term purpose regarding a study of the Third Crusade for Yale University Press.
3 Eddé, Anne-Marie, Saladin,transl. Todd, Jane-Marie (Cambridge, MA, 2011), 67–270; The Crusade of Frederick Barbarossa:The History of the Expedition of the Emperor Frederick and related Texts , transl. Loud, Graham A., CTT 19 (Farnham, 2010).
4 Jubayr, Ibn, The Travels of Ibn Jubayr, transl. Broadhurst, Roland J. C. (London, 1952), 300-1.
5 Roger of Howden, Gesta Henrici II et Ricardi I,ed. Stubbs, William, 2 vols, RS 49 (London, 1867), 1: 359 ; Phillips, Jonathan P., Defenders of the Holy Land: Relations between the Latin East and the West, 1119-1187 (Oxford, 1996), 251-64.
6 These events are outlined in the introduction to Caffaro, Genoa and the Twelfth-Century Crusades , transl. Hall, Martin A. and Phillips, Jonathan P., CTT 26 (Farnham, 2013), 11, 32—6. The texts can be found in I Libri lurium della Repubblica di Genova , ed. Dino Puncuh et al., 9 vols (Rome, 1992-2002), 1/1: 97-102, 182-3; 1/2: 152-60.
7 Roger of Howden, Gesta Henrici II et Ricardi I, ed. Stubbs, , 2: 11—13 (Caffaro , transl. Hall, and Phillips, , 213—15).
8 Scriba, Ottobono, ‘Annals', ed. Belgrano, Luigi and Imperiale, Cesare, in Annali genovesi di Caffaro e de’ suoi continuatori, Fonti per la storia d'ltalia, 118 vols (Rome, 1887—1993), 12: 23-4 (Caffaro , transl. Hall and Phillips, 145). The document is in 1 Libri lurium , ed. Puncuh et al., 1/2: 135-7 (Caffaro , transl. Hall and Phillips, 215-16). For a discussion of the award of privileges to Genoa and Pisa at this time, see Jacoby, David, 'Conrad, Marquis of Montferrat and the Kingdom of Jerusalem, 1187-92', in idem, Trade, Commodities and Shipping in the Medieval Mediterranean (Aldershot, 1997), 187–238.
9 For example, the cathedrals of Mainz and Speyer had privileges inscribed on them, see Quellen zur Verfassungsgeschichte der deutschen Stadt im Mittelalter, ed. Hergemöller, Bernd-Ul-rich (Darmstadt, 2000), 118—23, 184—8. My thanks to Professor Felicitas Schmieder for this reference.
10 This struggle is discussed in the introduction to Caffaro, transl. Hall and Phillips, 24—7. The relevant papal letters are translated ibid. 207—11; for the texts, see 1 Libri lurium , ed. Puncuh, et al., 1/2: 113—16, 119—26.
11 See the important article by Merav Mack,'A Genoese Perspective of the Third Crusade', Crusades 10 (2011), 45—62. See also Scriba, , 'Annals', ed. Belgrano, and Imperiale, , 32 (Caffaro , transl. Hall, and Phillips, , 148—9).
12 Guglielmo Cassinese (1190-1192), ed. Hall, Margaret W., Krueger, Hilmar C. and Reynolds, Robert L., 2 vols (Turin, 1938), 1: 129—30.
13 On Conrad's journey, see the anonymous Regni Ierosolymitani brevis historia,ed. Belgrano, Luigi, in Annali genovesi di Caffaro e de’ suoi continuatori , 11: 144—5 (Caffaro , transl. Hall and Phillips, 164—5). For the charter, see 1 Libri lurium , ed. Puncuh et al., 1/2: 137-40 (Caffaro , transl. Hall and Phillips, 216-18).
14 I Libri lurium , ed. Puncuh, et al., 1/2: 140—2 (Caffaro , transl. Hall, and Phillips, , 220—1).
15 Guglielmo Cassinese, ed. Hall, Krueger and Reynolds, , 1: 6, 365. William of Tyre's comments after King Amalric's failed attack on Egypt in late 1168 included a lament regarding the negative impact of this outcome on Egyptian traders who had come to the Latin kingdom and spent large sums of money. In other words, usually there was a substantial level of trade between the Christians and Muslims of the Near East: William of Tyre, Historia 20. 10 (CChr.CM 63A, 924); ET William of Tyre, A History of Deeds done Beyond the Sea, transl. Babcock, Emily A. and Krey, August C., 2 vols (New York, 1943), 2: 358.
16 Ekkehard of Aura, Frutolfi et Ekkehardi chronica necnon anonymi chronica imperatorum, ed. and transl. Schmale, Franz-Joseph and Schmale-Ott, Irene, Ausgewählte Quellen zur deutschen Geschichte des Mittelalters 15 (Darmstadt, 1972), 158-9.
17 See Bull, Marcus G., 'Views of Muslims and of Jerusalem in Miracle Stories, c. 1000-c. 1200: Reflections on the Study of First Crusaders’ Motivations', in idem and Housley, Norman, eds, The Experience of Crusading, 1 : Western Approaclies (Cambridge, 2003), 13–38, at 23.
18 Caffaro, ‘Annals', 13 (Caffaro , transl. Hall, and Phillips, , 56).
19 For a broader discussion of Genoa and the First Crusade, see Phillips, Jonathan P., ‘Caffaro of Genoa and the Motives of the Early Crusaders', forthcoming in Per Ingesman, ed., Religion as an Agent of Change (Leiden, 2015). For the acquisition of relics, see Polonio, Valeria, ‘Devozioni di lingo corso: lo scalo genovese', in Ortelli, Gheradro and Puncuh, Dino, eds, Genova, Venezia, il Levante nei secoli xii—xiv (Venice, 2001), 349-94.
20 Stern, Samuel M., ‘An Original Document from the Fatimid Chancery concerning Italian Merchants’, in Studi orientalistici in onore di Giorgio Levi delta Vida, 2 vols, Pubblicazioni dell'Istituto per l'Oriente 52 (Rome, 1956), 2: 529—38.
21 Oberto Cancelliere, ‘Annals', ed. Belgrano, Luigi and Imperiale, Cesare, in Annali genovesi di Caffaro e de’ suoi continuatori , 11: 228, 237 (Caffaro , transl. Hall and Phillips, 142-5).
22 Jacoby, David, ‘The Supply of War Materials to Egypt in the Crusader Period', Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 25 (2001), 102—32, especially 104—10; Lev, Yaacov, 'A Mediterranean Encounter: The Fatimids and Europe, Tenth to Twelfth Centuries', in Shipping, Trade and Crusade in the Medieval Mediterranean: Studies in Honour of John Pryor , ed. Gertwagen, Ruthy and Jeffreys, Elizabeth (Farnham, 2012), 131-56, at 135-7.
23 From Shama, Abu, in Eddé, Saladin , transl. Todd, , 449.
24 Ibid. 451; Scriba, , 'Annals', ed. Belgrano, and Imperiale, , 11 (Caffaro , transl. Hall, and Phillips, , 143).
25 I Libri lurium , ed. Puncuh, et al., I/I: 223 (Caffaro , transl. Hall, and Phillips, , 191).
26 Cited in Jacoby,'Supply of War Materials', 109.
27 Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils , ed. and transl. Tanner, Norman J., 2 vols (New York, 1990), 1: 223; Menache, Sophia, ‘Papal Attempts at a Commercial Boycott of the Muslims in the Crusader Period', JEH 63 (2012), 236-59.
28 Jacoby, David, ‘Venetian Commercial Expansion in the Eastern Mediterranean, 8th—11th Centuries', in Mango, Marlia M., ed., Byzantine Trade, 4th-12th Centuries: The Archaeology of Local, Regional and International Exchange, Publications of the Society for the Promotion of Byzantine Studies 14 (Farnham, 2009), 371—92, at 380.
29 Jubayr, Ibn, Travels , transl. Broadhurst, , 26.
30 La continuation de Guillaume de Tyr (1184— 97), ed. Ruth Morgan, M. (Paris, 1982), 74—5; ‘The Old French Continuation of William of Tyre', in The Conquest of Jerusalem and the Third Crusade , transl. Edbury, Peter W., CTT 1 (Aldershot, 1996), 66.
31 Scriba, Ottobono mentioned the agreement with Majorca:'Annals', ed. Belgrano, and Imperiale, , 26. See also Eddé, , Saladin , transl. Todd, 252—5.
32 Jacoby, , ‘Conrad of Montferrat', 220-1; Abulafia, David, The Two Italies (Cambridge, 1977), 182. See also Cuglielmo Cassinese, ed. Hall, Krueger and Reynolds, , 1: 365.
33 Mack, , 'Genoese Perspective', 57—8. For the charters, see Guglielmo Cassinese, ed. Hall, Krueger and Reynolds, , 1: 174, 365; 2: 36-8, 77, 154, 180, 187.
34 Guglielmo Cassinese, ed. Hall, Krueger and Reynolds, , 1: 174; Eddé, , Saladin , transl. Todd, , 252-5.
35 Caffaro , transl. Hall and Phillips, 224—5; I Libri lurium , ed. Puncuh, et al., 1/2: 146-52.
36 Köhler, Michael A., Alliances and Treaties between Frankish and Muslim Rulers in the Middle East: Cross-Cultural Diplomacy in the Period of the Crusades , transl. Holt, Peter M., rev., ed. and intro. Hirschler, Konrad (Leiden, 2013), 155—62; Phillips, Jonathan P., The Second Crusade: Extending the Frontiers of Christendom (London, 2007), 269—78.
37 Hamilton, Bernard, ‘Our Lady of Saidnaya: An Orthodox Shrine revered by Muslims and Knights Templar at the Time of the Crusades', in Swanson, Robert N., ed., The Holy Land, Holy Lands and Christian History , SCH 36 (Woodbridge, 2000), 207—15; Kedar, Benjamin Z., ‘Convergences of Oriental Christian, Muslim and Frankish Worshippers: The Case of Aydnâyâ and the Knights Templar', in Hunyadi, Zsolt and Laszlovsky, Józef, eds, The Crusades and the Military Orders: Expanding the Frontiers of Medieval Latin Christianity (Budapest, 2001), 89–100.
38 Tolan, John V., ‘“Veneratio Sarracenorum“: Shared Devotion among Muslims and Christians, according to Burchard of Strasbourg, Envoy from Frederick Barbarossa to Saladin (c . 1175)', in idem, Sons of Ishmael: Muslims through European Eyes in the Middle Ages (Gainesville, FL, 2008), 101—12.
39 Alfonsi, Petrus, Dialogue against the Jews , transl. Resnick, Irven M., Fathers of the Church, Medieval Continuation 8 (Washington DC, 2006); Tolan, John V., Petrus Alfonsi and his Medieval Readers (Gainesville, FL, 1993), 27—33, 98.
40 Tolan, John V.,'Peter the Venerable on the “Diabolical Heresy of the Saracens'”, in idem, Sons of Ishmael , 46—63; Burman, Thomas E., Reading the Qur'an in Latin Christendom, 1140-1560 (Philadelphia, PA, 2007).
41 Tolan, John V., Saracens: Islam in the Medieval European Imagination (New York, 2002), 105—34, quotation at 111. For an example of a First Crusade text acknowledging the martial virtues of Muslim warriors, see Gesta Francorum et aliorum Hierosolimita-norutn , ed. and transl. Mynors, Roger A. B., intro. Hill, Rosalind M.T., Nelson's Medieval Texts (London, 1962), 21.
42 Tolan, , Saracens, 126—8. See also Jubb, Margaret, ‘The Crusaders’ Perception of their Opponents', in Nicholson, Helen J., ed., Palgrave Advances in the Crusades (Basingstoke, 2005), 225-44.
43 On the flowering of crusade texts in the early twelfth century, see Phillips, , Second Crusade, 17—36.
44 Robert the Monk, The Historia Iherosolimitana of Robert the Monk , ed. Kempf, Damien and Bull, Marcus G. (Woodbridge, 2013), lxv—lxxiv, lists 84 manuscripts, dating from the twelfth to the sixteenth centuries.
45 Ibid. 43, 63—4; ET in Robert the Monk's History of the First Crusade, transl. Sweetenham, Carol, CTT 11 (Aldershot, 2005), 130, 156; see also the discussion in the Introduction, at 56.
46 Kempf, Damien, ‘Towards a Textual Archaeology of the First Crusade', in Bull, Marcus G. and Kempf, Damien, eds, Writing the Early Crusades: Text, Transmission and Memory (Woodbridge, 2014), 116-26, at 123-4.
47 Kedar, Benjamin Z., Crusade and Mission: European Approaches towards the Muslims (Princeton, NJ, 1984), 3–41.
48 Cited in Bernard Hamilton, ‘Knowing the Enemy: Western Understanding of Islam at the Time of the Crusades', Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society 3rd ser. 7 (1997), 373-87, at 373-6.
49 Otto of Freising, Chronica sive Historia de duabus civitatibus (MGH SRG i.u.s. 45, 510); ET The Two Cities: A Chronicle of Universal History to the year 1146 , transl. Mierow, Charles M. (New York, 1928), 412; Tolan, , Saracens, 109.
50 Cole, Penny J., ‘“O God, the Heathen have come into your Inheritance” (Ps. 78.1):The Theme of Religious Pollution in Crusade Documents', in Shatzmiller, Maya, ed., Crusaders and Muslims in Twelfth-Century Syria (Leiden, 1993), 84—111, at 86—8; Thomson, Rodney M., 'William and Some other Western Writers on Islam', in idem, William of Malmesbury , rev. edn (Woodbridge, 2003), 168—77.
51 Ibn Jubayr noted mosques in Acre and Tyre: Jubayr, Ibn, Travels , transl. Broad-hurst, , 318, 321.
52 Ralph of Caen, Tancredus (CChr.CM 231, 107, lines 3633-5); ET The Gesta Tancredi of Ralph of Caen: A History of the Normans on the First Crusade , transl. Bachrach, Bernard S. and Bachrach, David S., CTT 12 (Aldershot, 2005), 143-4.
53 Walter the Chancellor, Bella Antiochena; ET Walter the Chancellor's The Antio-chene Wars , transl. Edgington, Susan B., commentary by Asbridge, Thomas S., CTT 4 (Aldershot, 1999), 101. On Islam and polytheism, see Talmon-Heller, Daniella, Islamic Piety in Medieval Syria: Mosques, Cemeteries and Sermons under the Zangids and Ayyubids (1146-1260) (Leiden, 2007), 228-32.
54 For an overview of William's life, career and writings, see Edbury, Peter W. and Rowe, John G., William of Tyre: Historian of the Latin East (Cambridge, 1988).
55 Schwinges, Ranier C., 'William of Tyre, the Muslim Enemy and the Problem of Tolerance', in Gervers, Michael and Powell, James M., eds, Tolerance and Intolerance: Social Conflict in the Age of the Crusades (Syracuse, NY, 2001), 124—32. See also Morton, Nicholas E., ‘William of Tyre's Attitude Towards Islam: Some Historiographical Reflections', in Deeds done Beyond the Sea: Essays on William of Tyre, Cyprus and the Military Orders Presented to Peter Edbury , ed. Edgington, Susan B. and Nicholson, Helen J., Crusades - Subsidia 6 (Farnham, 2014), 13–23.
56 William of Tyre, Historia , 1: 109 (History , transl. Babcock, and Krey, , 1: 65).
57 Edbury, and Rowe, , William of Tyre , 23—4.
58 William also regarded the ShTī'tes as closer to Christian doctrine than the Sunn: William of Tyre, Historia 1.4 (CChr.CM 63, 109-10; History , transl. Babcock, and Krey, , 1: 65).
59 Schwinges, , ‘William of Tyre', 126—7.
60 William of Tyre, Historia 21.8 (CChr.CM 63A, 972; History , transl. Babcock, and Krey, , 2: 410).
61 Humphrey met with al-Adil, Saladin's brother, on several occasions: see Shaddad, Beha ad-Din Ibn, The Rare and Excellent History of Saladin , tr. Richards, Donald S., CTT 7 (Aldershot, 2001), 174, 179, 198, 231. See also Attiya, Hussein M., 'Knowledge of Arabic in the Crusader States in the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries', JMedH 25 (1999), 203-13.
62 Barber, Malcolm, The Crusader States (London, 2013), 308.
63 Shaddad, Ibn, Rare and Excellent History , transl. Richards, , 90. The story is also included in Shama, Abu, ‘Two Gardens', RHC Or. 4: 396-7.
64 Shaddad, Ibn, Rare and Excellent History , transl. Richards, , 91. This episode might well be labelled a majlis , that is, an interreligious debate: see Lazarus-Yafeh, Hava et al., eds, The Majlis: Interreligious Encounters in Medieval Islam , Studies in Arabic Language and Literature 4 (Wiesbaden, 1999).
65 Cobb, Paul M., Usama ibn Munqidh: Warrior Poet of the Age of the Crusades (Oxford, 2005), 59—62.
66 The Old French continuation of William of Tyre described this, including a scene in which Reynald was tortured in front of the fortress, leading to its capitulation. There is, however, a sense of Reynald being (at first) well entertained; there is no explicit statement that he spoke Arabic, although an exchange between the count and Saladin is part of the narrative: La continuation , ed. Morgan, , 79—82 ('Old French Continuation', transl. Edbury, , 70—3).
67 al-Jawzi, Ibn, in Christian-Muslim Relations: A Bibliographical History, Volume 3 (1050-1200) , ed. Thomas, David and Mallett, Alex (Leiden, 2011), 733.
68 Ibn ‘Asakir, ibid. 683—9. For more on Ibn ‘Asakir and his views of Jesus, see Mourad, Suleiman A. and Lindsay, James E., The Intensification and Reorientation of Sunni Jihad Ideology in the Crusader Period (Leiden, 2013), 8–9.
69 Mourad, and Lindsay, , Sunni Jihad Ideology , 57, 80.
70 ‘Apologetic Commentary on the Creed', in Christian-Muslim Relations 3 , ed. Thomas, and Mallett, , 671—5.
71 Kedar, Benjamin Z., ‘Croisade et jihad vus par l'ennemi: une étude des perceptions mutuelles des motivations', in Balard, Michel, ed., Autour de la premiére croisade (Paris, 1996), 345-55.
72 See the letter mentioned in n. 7 above, along with, for example,'Two excitationes for the Third Crusade: The Letters of Brother Thierry of the Temple', ed. Pryor, John H., Mediterranean Historical Review 25 (2010), 147—68.
73 De Expugnatione Terra Sanctae per Saladinum , in Ralph of Coggeshall, Chronicon Anglicanum , ed. Stevenson, Joseph, RS 66 (London, 1875), 209-62.
74 Peter of Blois, Passio Raginaldi principis Antiochie (CChr.CM 194, 40, 57).
75 Roger of Howden, Gesta Henrici II et Ricardi I , ed. Stubbs, , 2: 151—5; Gillingham, John B., Richard I (London, 1999), 138-9.
76 An important analysis of the diplomatic encounters of the Third Crusade is in Asbridge, Thomas S., ‘Talking to the Enemy: The Role and Purpose of Negotiations between Saladin and Richard the Lionheart during the Third Crusade', JMH 39 (2013), 275—96, although the bulk of the analysis concerns strategic matters.
77 Shaddad, Ibn, Rare and Excellent History , transl. Richards, , 173—4.
78 Ibid. 185-6.
79 Ambroise, , The History of the Holy War , ed. and transl. Ailes, Marianne and Barber, Malcolm C., 2 vols (Woodbridge, 2003), 2: 146-7.
80 Shaddad, Ibn, Rare and Excellent History , transl. Richards, , 198.
81 Itinerarium peregrinorum et Gesta Regis Ricardi , in The Chronicle of the Third Crusade , transl. Helen J. Nicholson, CTT 3 (Aldershot, 1997), 303—4; Ambroise, , Holy War , ed. and transl. Ailes, and Barber, , 148-9.
82 Shaddad, Ibn, Rare and Excellent History , transl. Richards, , 214-15.
83 Ibid. 227. Frederick II was reported as knighting Fakhr al-Din, a Muslim noble and diplomat in the 1220s: see Joinville, Jean de, Vie de saint Louis , ed. and transl. Monfrin, Jean (Paris, 1995), 96-9; ET in Joinville and Villehardouin: Chronicles of the Crusades , transl. Caroline Smith (London, 2008), 194—5.
84 Ambroise, , Holy War , ed. and transl. Ailes, and Barber, , 187—91.
85 Shaddad, Ibn, Rare and Excellent History , transl. Richards, , 223.
86 Munqidh, Usama ibn, The Book of Contemplation: Islam and the Crusades , transl. Cobb, Paul M. (London, 2008), 147.
87 Die Register Innocenz’ 111 , ed. Hageneder, O. et al., 11 vols (Graz, Cologne, Rome, Vienna, 1964—2010), 1: 775—6, no. 536 (539); ET in Contemporary Sources for the Fourth Crusade , tr. Andrea, Alfred (Leiden, 2000), 23-4.
88 Menache, 'Papal Attempts', takes the story through the thirteenth century.
89 Obviously the border of Muslim and Christian Iberia, as well as the trading cities, saw much longer levels of contact: see Tolan, Saracens.
90 Kedar, Crusade and Mission.
* This essay is dedicated to the memory of Dr John Doran (1966—2012), a fine scholar and a truly warm-hearted man, who was taken from us far too soon.