Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T06:05:09.643Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Generalized Management Strategies to Delay Herbicide Resistance: A Simulation Approach

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 April 2018

Argen M. West
Affiliation:
PhD candidate, Department of Mathematics, University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign, Champaign, IL, USA
Anthony L. Altieri
Affiliation:
Independent researcher, Boston, MA, USA
Steven A. Cryer*
Affiliation:
Fellow, Corteva™ Agriscience, Agricultural Division of DowDuPont™, Indianapolis, IN, USA
*
Author for correspondence: Steven Cryer, DowDuPont, 9330 Zionsville Road, Indianapolis, IN 46268. (Email: sacryer@dow.com)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Weed species develop resistance to herbicides through the repeated use of the same herbicide mechanism of action (MOA). Farmers often resort to different MOAs once a weed population has become resistant to the MOA that resulted in a resistant weed population. Delaying herbicide resistance is of great importance to growers due to the limited number of commercially available MOAs. Resistance may occur through monogenic or polygenic traits, and various academic and industrial modeling tools have been developed to help infer cause–effect from multiple interacting factors that may not be intuitive. This work explores various best management practices in delaying weed resistance, and we give details for monogenic and quantitative polygenic resistance models and investigate combinations of management strategies that lead to maximizing the product life span for a herbicide. Management practices under parametric uncertainty are provided to showcase how various practices can be used to extend lifetime product performance before resistance is manifest. Penalty functions associated with choosing a unique management strategy, based upon grower constraints, are the subject of a companion manuscript.

Information

Type
Weed Management
Copyright
© Weed Science Society of America, 2018 
Figure 0

Figure 1Weed life cycles of (A) a single cohort and (B) multiple cohorts.

Figure 1

Figure 2Herbicide dose–response function. The dark solid line represents the herbicide dose. A percentage of plants (in green) with higher tolerance level than the dose can survive.

Figure 2

Table 1Punnett square example for a homozygous resistant (RR) mating with a heterozygous (RS).

Figure 3

Table 2Mating table for outcrossing plants.a

Figure 4

Table 3Relationship between parent frequency and offspring frequency.a

Figure 5

Table 4Offspring proportions for two gene loci.

Figure 6

Table 5Mating table for a selfing plant for a single gene locus.

Figure 7

Table 6The frequency of the offspring for a selfing plant with a single gene locus.

Figure 8

Figure 3When a deep-tillage event occurs, the upper and lower seedbanks (and respective properties as seen: density, fraction of resistant seeds, and so on) are switched. Seeds are only input into the upper seedbank. If no deep-tillage event occurs, seeds accumulate in the upper seedbank, while seeds in the lower seedbank degrade over time.

Figure 9

Table 7Seed production parameters used in the analysis.

Figure 10

Table 8Summary of input parameters used in this analysis.

Figure 11

Table 9Dose–response data used to compare the fit associated with different sigmoid functions for 2,4-D against common weed species.

Figure 12

Figure 4Quantitative dose–response functions for homozygous resistant (RR), heterozygous (RS), and homozygous susceptible (SS) weeds approximated by a four-parameter sigmoid function.

Figure 13

Figure 5Three metrics used to characterize the weed resistant fraction over time.

Figure 14

Table 10Simulation results for resistance onset occurring in a finite size field.

Figure 15

Figure 6Simulation results for two herbicide mechanisms of action, but monogenic resistance has already been established for the first herbicide, H1, (initial resistant allele frequency:10−4) but not for the second herbicide, H2, (initial resistant allele frequency:10−8). (A) Seedbank density versus time and (B) fraction resistant versus time.

Figure 16

Figure 7Effect of cultivation for three cases: OFF all years, ON odd years+OFF even years, ON all years. Resistance is delayed the most by always using cultivation.

Figure 17

Figure 8Impact of deep-tillage events over product life span of 0, 1 (on year 10), and 2 (on year 10 and year 17).