Absent Citizens by Michael J. Prince is the latest book in an emerging literature on disability studies for the Canadian context. Prince is an extremely accomplished scholar in this field, currently the Lansdowne Professor of Social Policy in the Faculty of Human and Social Development at the University of Victoria in British Columbia. He is the author of ten previous books on policy issues ranging from budget analysis to pensions to mining. His background in politics and public administration equips him to bring classical Canadian and international political theory to bear on his treatment of disability studies. His connections with disability groups and movements in Canada provide context and texture to his discussions, and his relationships with federal and provincial policy makers ensure currency and relevance of the issues.
The field of disability studies in Canada has become increasingly well defined and delineated, and in Absent Citizens, Prince posits that disability studies is coming of age in Canada, as evidenced by a number of important accomplishments and events. And yet, disability issues are conspicuously absent from mainstream political discourse, and disabled people are notably absent from the political arena. The title, Absent Citizens, captures this linking of identity and citizenship with concepts of marginalisation, inequality and exclusion. In order to achieve citizenship, Prince contends that disabled people must attain cultural recognition, economic redistribution and political representation. In his seminal contribution to Canadian disability studies, Bickenbach (Reference Bickenbach1993) identified the three objectives of disability policy as equity, access and support, while federal government reports (1998) identify them as equity, inclusion and independence. Are these all saying the same thing? If so, I like Prince's language best in terms of communicating the fields where advocacy and initiative may be most needed.
The book unfolds in three parts. The first part, entitled Ambiguities, Exclusions and Divisions, highlights some of the contrasts and paradoxes in studying disability policy. Some of the most vivid and enduring images left from reading the book come from this part. This first chapter shows with stunning clarity the ambivalence in the reactions of Canadians toward people with disabilities. While Canadians pride themselves on tolerance and inclusivity, there is a persistent underlying thread of discomfort and avoidance in their reactions toward people with disabilities. From a policy perspective, this translates into the notion that someone else, preferably the government, should be doing something, but not at my expense. The second chapter evokes images of people with disabilities in urban settings, showing the potential alienation, as well as the richness and amiability, of city life. The third chapter reminds us of the double-edged sword of social programs. While they may enhance quality of life in an instrumental sense, they can also promote a social dynamic of stigmatisation and stratification. This phenomenon is clearly seen in the push–pull of disability identification – the resisting and claiming of the disability label as required by certain entitlements and benefit programs.
The second part, entitled ‘Capacities, Engagements and Inclusions’, offers four chapters with specific recommendations for enhancing policy process and outcomes for disabled Canadians. Prince recommends: a ‘disability lens’ as a routine perspective for policy analysis, a classification system for disability organisations in the community, a national inclusion index as a measure of progress on disability issues in public policy and a focus on electoral participation among disabled people. One of the most significant contributions of this part is a taxonomy of seven modes of citizen engagement in disability policy, with examples of where these have been used with some success.
In the concluding part of the book, Prince identifies the dominant Canadian political ideology as social liberalism – social because of our commitment to the collective, and liberal because of our value for tolerance, order and representative democracy. For the most part, Prince finds the disability movement's politics compatible with mainstream social liberalism; however, he observes that the disability community has been guided by two additional political ideologies that have not served it so well – the social model of disability and the human rights approach.
According to the social model, disability is created when an individual encounters a society that was developed without consideration for someone who might encounter it in a different way, such as with an impairment of brain, body or senses. This is a very sophisticated and nuanced notion, and while it captures perfectly the socio-political situation of people with disabilities, it has not pervaded the popular consciousness, or attracted the attention of policy makers. While it serves disability studies well as an academic discipline, it may not serve disabled people so well as a citizen's movement, and may contribute to their remaining ‘absent citizens’.
The second major ideology that governs disability discourse is the human rights approach. The human rights approach provides an essential mechanism for safeguarding the basic entitlements of citizenship. And yet, as Prince observes, it has had a disappointing record as a tool for establishing a policy framework and social structure that empowers people with disabilities. Individual case law has not typically translated into broader legislative and regulatory assurances of recognition, redistribution and representation. The human rights approach appears to be a necessary but not sufficient condition for a more equitable policy environment within which people with disabilities might flourish in Canada.
In 2001, Boyce and colleagues published the relatively hopeful A Seat at the Table, an edited volume analyzing the successes of disability advocates in impacting policy in Canada in the preceding decades. The intervening period between that volume and this one has clearly been a different time in disability politics in Canada. Prince is right on the mark in Absent Citizens in labeling the issues as they appear. He offers a compelling perspective, a deep and thorough political analysis, and a number of intriguing propositions for engaging and animating the disability studies academy and the disability advocacy movement towards full citizenship.
