This valuable volume addresses the complexities of the transitions from import-substituting industrialisation (ISI) to neoliberalism, and the different modes of incorporation, exclusion and reincorporation of the working class in five countries: Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Ecuador and Venezuela. The material is organised both thematically (social movements, trade unions and political parties) and comparatively across pairs of countries (Argentina/Brazil and Bolivia/Ecuador, with Venezuela standing apart). This arrangement offers both a refreshing perspective and an illuminating way to address the peculiarities and commonalities of each country case.
The argument across all chapters hinges around the concepts of incorporation and neoliberalism. Drawing upon the work of Ruth Berins Collier and David Collier, the contributors argue that, in Latin America, the popular sectors were first incorporated during the national populist period associated with ISI (1930s–1970s). Incorporation, here, refers to:
[…] the recognition of the claims of politically active popular sectors, the creation or adaptation of formal and informal rules that regulate their participation in politics, and their links to the policy process [… across] three dimensions: individual rights (particularly the universal right to vote); collective rights (the right to form associations and to participate in the polity); and substantive citizenship rights (the capacity to influence public policy to ensure that governments respond to core social and economic claims). (p. 7)
The first incorporation was dismantled (to a greater or lesser extent) following the transition to neoliberalism, which transformed not only economies but also societies profoundly, often leading to significant losses for the poorest. Their exclusion was effected by higher structural unemployment and informalisation of labour through trade liberalisation and deindustrialisation, extensive privatisations, and the withdrawal of transfers, social services and all manner of non-market protections by the state, such as denial of provision of public goods, and so on – and this happened, perhaps paradoxically, despite the transitions to democracy across the region. Unsurprisingly, the indicators of poverty and deprivation tended to worsen, while the concentration of income and wealth increased.
In the early 2000s, the global commodity boom and the strategic shift of US attention towards the Middle East facilitated the emergence of strong mass movements demanding a new form of incorporation into the dominant social and economic system. In the five country cases examined here, mass reaction in the form of protest and electoral mobilisation drove the rise of more or less moderate-left governments, ranging between the ‘Pink Tide’ and ‘twenty-first-century socialism’. The movements leading to, and following, the election of these leftist administrations drove the second incorporation. The book examines those struggles in detail, their roots in organised mass activity, and their political forms of expression through parties and movements that, in different ways, exercised a significant influence over administrations that were in power for many years and that, retrospectively, can boast achievements of very different orders.
The section on social movements examines the transformation of the old movements and the emergence of new ones, while the section on unions looks at the shifts in the structures of representation; in both cases, the contributors focus on their demands, strategies and relationship to the main political parties, the state and the policy-making process. Finally, the section on political parties reviews the changes in the party systems, including the emergence of new mass organisations, the continuing relevance of populism and the relationships of movements and unions with the traditional party structures. In all cases, the study sheds a powerful light on the effectiveness of mass action and its implications for democracy in Latin America. In doing this, the volume examines in detail the tendencies towards inequality, social exclusion, concentration of income, wealth and power and political repression that, historically, have been notorious features of Latin America. The essays also examine the reactions against them. This is valuable, and it brings to the readers both hope and a much-needed sense of perspective.
I am, however, unconvinced by the contributors’ use of the term ‘neoliberalism’, which in my view is not defined rigorously enough, leading to the claim that the Pink Tide/socialist governments were ‘post-neoliberal’. I disagree, because this argument relies too much on the self-serving rhetoric of political operators, rather than clear analysis of what neoliberalism is, and its disturbing continuity in Latin America. In this book, neoliberalism is defined as ‘a specific form of capitalism and a series of reforms to reorganize economic relations along neoclassical economic principles [… that] stressed the price system as the sole allocator of capital, labour, and land. Politics, meaning the state and representative institutions of democracy, as well as social policy, should be restructured so as to minimally interfere with the market’ (p. 6). This is not wrong but it is incomplete, and the ensuing imprecision suggests to several contributors that the second incorporation somehow ‘transcended’ neoliberalism. This is incorrect, and it would inevitably require analytical contortions such as, presumably, claiming that neoliberalism has returned in most countries in the region, but it may be pushed back again (e.g. Argentina under Mauricio Macri, followed by Alberto Fernández). This would dilute the term neoliberalism into a mélange of party programmes and government policies, which are always subjected to the fluctuating fortunes of the political conjuncture: there would be, then, a risk of analytical degeneration into the reporting of ‘facts’. This is not the case in this book: the analysis is framed clearly around the notion of incorporation, which provides a firm peg for the essays.
Finally, as the editor of a few volumes myself, I must commend the excellent work of Eduardo Silva and Federico Rossi in bringing to light such a valuable and tightly argued collection. It is often extremely hard to keep the chosen focus in an edited volume, because academic cats always resist, rebel and attempt to flee in all directions. Silva and Rossi have contained these fissiparous tendencies and produced a volume that is remarkably coherent across methodology, historical and analytical framework and style. I admire their work, and their capacity to bring this excellent book to fruition.
