Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T10:16:49.882Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Unheard Complexities in Lou Harrison's Main Bersama-sama and Bubaran Robert

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 August 2013

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Central among Lou Harrison's pioneering East-West fusions, the works for gamelan and Western instruments are frequently cited either as exemplars of the composer's Californian, postmodern musical sensibility or as noteworthy instances of cultural hybridity. Close examination of Main Bersama-sama (1978) and Bubaran Robert (1976, rev. 1981), however, shows that these pieces can and should be understood for what they tell us about Harrison's deep engagement with melody. A self-proclaimed “melode,” Harrison has mistakenly been regarded as a West Coast musical dabbler, writing tuneful pieces that lack the complexity that characterizes the work of his East Coast contemporaries. Yet analysis of the pitch structure of Main Bersama-sama and Bubaran Robert reveals intricate compositional “games” similar to the pre-compositional strategies of composers more typically associated with algorithmic compositional methods. Because these intricacies lie beneath the melodic surface of the music they have largely been unheard and unappreciated in Harrison's work. The melodic nature of these games not only challenges the widely accepted depiction of Harrison as a mere “tunesmith,” but also shows that Harrison explored the ability of melody (as opposed to large-scale tonal or harmonic schemes) to create form and serve a central generative function in his music.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for American Music 2013 
Figure 0

Example 1.Buka and Part A (unison writing), Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 1

Example 2a.4 + 4 measure construction of 1st melodic line played by suling/French horn (mm. 9–25), Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 2

Example 2b.3 + 5 measure construction of 2nd melodic line played by suling/French horn (mm. 25–41), Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 3

Example 3.Cycling of jengglong pitches, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 4

Example 4.Suling/French horn melody an embellishment of the underlying structural melody, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 5

Example 5.Sketch of unison melody in Part A (jengglong pitches indicated with downward stems) and the gong cycle, with structural melody played by jengglong, for Part B, Main Bersama-sama. Courtesy Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, McHenry Library, UCSC.

Figure 6

Example 6.Sketch mapping the gambang part to the underlying structural melody, Main Bersama-sama. Courtesy Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, McHenry Library, UCSC.

Figure 7

Example 7.Sketch of French horn melody with a simplified second half (the material presented after the internal repeat sign), Main Bersama-sama. Courtesy Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, McHenry Library, UCSC.

Figure 8

Figure 1.Two contour patterns, labeled melodicle a and melodicle b, played by the gambang in Part B, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 9

Figure 2.Melodicle a, connecting each line to the next, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 10

Figure 3.Melodicle c, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 11

Figure 4.Melodicle d, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 12

Figure 5.Melodicles e and f, operating at the surface level, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 13

Figure 6.Melodicles g and h, operating at the surface level, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 14

Figure 7.Melodic repetition in Part B; relationship between Part A and fourth line of Part B, Main Bersama-sama.

Figure 15

Example 8.Two halves of the balungan, Bubaran Robert.

Figure 16

Example 9.Changes to the melodic contour of the fourth gongan, Bubaran Robert.

Figure 17

Example 10.Pattern of gamelan gatra, Bubaran Robert.

Figure 18

Example 11.Pitch coincidence between the balungan and solo piccolo trumpet line in the final gongan, Bubaran Robert.

Figure 19

Example 12.Structural pitch coincidence between the trumpet and balungan, Bubaran Robert.