The “Great Writ” of habeas corpus surfaces at the most politically fraught times. The writ, with its origins in common law, permits a judge to inquire into whether the detention of a prisoner is authorized. When that prisoner is a political prisoner, a government official, a suspected terrorist, a recently freed slave, a slave catcher, a Nazi saboteur, a subversive writer, a suspected anarchist, an interned Japanese-American, a convicted murderer, or a convict cleared by DNA tests, habeas corpus can become the stuff of high political drama. Over the last decade, habeas corpus has again played a high-profile role. In response, scholars in several disciplines have revisited habeas corpus, resulting in a flowering of knowledge, approaches, and arguments about the writ and its history.
Justin Wert's book contributes to the corpus about habeas corpus with a sweeping picture of the varied uses of habeas in America, connecting its development in peacetime with its better-known role in times of war. Habeas corpus is highly technical in its legal use—today postconviction practitioners must master a subject as complex as any area of law, at their client's peril—but it is not a dry subject. Debates about the role of habeas today, whether review of Guantanamo detentions or state convictions, should be grounded in a sense of where this institution came from. Yet history is not the kind of guide that tells us where to go or what to do. Wert describes habeas as an adaptable judicial and political institution and not any particular set of rules or rights.
It would have required another book to show where habeas came from. Paul Halliday has written that modern classic, describing in Habeas Corpus: From England to Empire (Belknap, 2010) how judges gradually transformed habeas corpus into a powerful instrument to make accountable jailers who arbitrarily or illegally detained royal subjects. Halliday debunked myths that common law judges did not elicit and examine facts beyond the jailer's version, or were constrained by modern concepts of rights or jurisdiction.
The US system introduced new complications, however, including a federal judiciary that operated alongside a state judiciary, and concepts of separation of powers, but also incorporating English common law habeas process. The US Constitution, Article I, Section 9, provides that “The privilege of the writ of habeas corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in cases of rebellion or invasion the public safety shall require it.” Known as the Suspension Clause, the provision stands out as the only one in the Constitution recognizing a common law privilege, but without saying what content it must have. The delegates at the Convention did not find much controversial about the clause; they had just been on the receiving end of a series of British suspensions of habeas. The first US habeas statutes preserved much of the common law process, grounded in a judicial power to hold jailers accountable. Thus, careful historical analysis of records of colonial and early use of habeas corpus in the United States has suggested how narrow accounts of the early practice are incomplete.
Wert's focus is on politics and not on-the-ground judicial decision making. The core of the book describes antebellum habeas corpus—a fascinating period leading to dramatic changes in habeas statutes after the Civil War to allow federal judges to review all state convictions. Wert described the underappreciated role habeas played in enforcing the ugly and contested provisions of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1793. For example, federal judges released US marshals arrested by state authorities in the North for enforcing the Act by violently seizing fugitive slaves. Wert then describes events leading to a case that deserves far more attention, Ableman v. Booth, in which the US Supreme Court reversed the state court release of an abolitionist who interfered with the return of a fugitive slave. Habeas corpus played a troubling role in making clear that state courts could not easily interfere with an eroding national political settlement with the slave power. The political branches would have to take matters into their own hands.
The book recounts how Congress has used statutes alternatively to influence and alter, expand and contract, nudge and redirect the traditional judicial habeas process. The Suspension Clause anticipated cutting off habeas entirely in times of great emergency. However, the Constitution also gave Congress the ability to regulate jurisdiction of federal courts. This book describes larger political events and cases that sparked statutes regulating habeas, and political backlash to habeas rulings by the courts.
A broad temporal sweep means that some events are described in far greater detail than others. The recent past is only briefly sketched out, including the Supreme Court's War on Terror decisions, and the unsettled response of lower courts. The book does not have room to deal much with recent jurisprudence of the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act, or the politics surrounding the death penalty or wrongful convictions. Nor does the book do much justice to the fascinating role habeas has played in the immigration context. There is little engagement with scholarship that has long grappled with the relationship between politics and judicial review, including in the habeas context. The book may have bitten off far more that it could chew, and even so, there was far more material to digest.
Sometimes people castigate judges for being influenced by politics to call into question their independence and impartiality. However, as this book shows, even in charged cases in which judges cannot easily ignore politics, doing so oversimplifies the judicial role. Judges interpret laws enacted by politically accountable legislators. Judges review political acts of executives enforcing laws or agencies passing regulations. Complicating matters, politicians can anticipate this. They may hope to constrain such review by judges. Or they may try to shunt politically fraught choices off to judges, such as what to do with unpopular prisoners. Today, judges have openly asked that Congress revisit rules surrounding War on Terror habeas review, but Congress may continue to let things rest with the judges. Moreover, the judiciary is itself a tiered and complicated institution. For example, the Supreme Court may pass off hard questions to the lower federal courts, but at times it may decide to rein in judges with procedural marching orders.
Today's prisoner may be a suspected terrorist from Yemen, but tomorrow it may be a death row inmate claiming innocence using DNA or a prominent dissident seeking asylum. Judicial process may be applied in unforeseen future cases. It is no wonder that judges and politicians speak of preserving the flexibility of habeas corpus to adapt to new situations. However imperfect and limited habeas corpus remedies may often be in practice, Wert's book provides another reminder that we should study and try to improve judicial review of the detention of prisoners.
