Steve Cushion's book shows how rigorous scholarly work can both change the historical record and be written into an engaging narrative. One of the dogmatic myths about the Cuban Revolution is the lack of protagonism, or indeed, the marginalisation, of the Cuban working class, both in the insurrectionary movement of the 1950s and, as a consequence, ever since. Cushion refers to the role of the Cuban working class in the 1950s as a ‘hidden history’ and ‘wonders why this story is untold, particularly as the evidence is available in the archives for any researcher who cares to look’ (p. 212).
Within Cuba, collective memory, historical accounts and archive materials belie the myth of working-class passivity. But in English-language publications it predominates (exemplified in the works of Samuel Farber and Mike Gonzalez). The contention is that as the official trade union movement did not lead a proletarian, ‘socialist’, revolutionary struggle and as the locus of struggle was the Sierra Maestra, the Cuban Revolution did not represent the ‘self-emancipation of the working class’. In the early 2000s, this myth was undermined by Julia Sweig's book Inside the Cuban Revolution (Harvard University Press, 2002), and the Enrique Oltuski's memoirs, Vida clandestina (Wiley, 2002), and other revolutionary leaders. Cushion's Hidden Histories takes these contributions further by analysing ‘the participation of militant organized labor’ (p. 12) in different sectors, fronts and workplaces. In doing so he demonstrates the decisive power of the successful general strike on 2 and 3 January 1959, which secured victory for the Revolution.
Cushion's book makes three notable contributions to our knowledge of this history. First, his detailed account of labour mobilisations, within and outside the official trade union movement, considers Cuban workers as a class and the discussion is not limited to just sectoral or organisational realms – be that within the trade unions, the 26 July Movement (M26J), led by Fidel Castro, or the traditional Communist Party, the Partido Socialista Popular (PSP).
Second, it provides a political-economy explanation of labour relations in Cuba, demonstrating how domestic and international conditions in the dominant sugar industry impacted upon workers’ militancy and generated business support for Batista's authoritarian regime. Cushion argues that ‘there is, therefore, a link between the fall in the price of sugar, the resulting crisis of profitability, and the employers’ need to increase productivity that provides an explanation for the 1952 military coup and the support given to the resulting dictatorship by business interests’ (p. 44). Essentially, an authoritarian regime was required to crush worker resistance to the productivity drive. By identifying the centrality of economic factors, Cushion moves beyond limited political/idealist accounts and tiresome narratives of the Revolution built around Fidel Castro's charisma or psychology.
Third, Cushion reminds the reader how repressive Batista's regime became (‘the army and the police engaged in a campaign of terror, including the use of death squads and torture’, p. 219) and shows how this shaped workers’ responses, including the turn to armed struggle. He observes that ‘the sheer horror of the state violence meted out by the Batista dictatorship has dropped from sight in recent studies, but it needs to be remembered as an important factor contributing to the increasing popular hatred of the regime’ (p. 217).
Cushion notes that in the 1950s Cuba had the highest percentage of unionised workers in Latin America (p. 22). He provides a useful overview of the history, from the 1920s to the 1950s, of Cuban labour organisations and the political battle between competing factions for their control. This helps explain the lame response to Batista's coup in 1952 by the official trade union movement, which was then led by Eusebio Mujal, who, on an annual salary of US$285,000, ‘went on to become one of Batista's most loyal collaborators’ (p. 25).
The PSP began to radicalise, setting up locally-based Committees for the Defence of Workers’ Demands in November 1954, while the founding meeting of the M26J in June 1955 set up a workers’ section ‘to coordinate the movement's activities among organized labor’ (p. 34). With the implementation of these structures, corresponding with the decisive push from the dictatorship and business interests to confront the ‘crisis of productivity’ by squeezing Cuban workers, the stage was set for several decisive confrontations between workers and employees in 1955. Cushion analyses the factors which determined the success or, more often, the failure of these workers’ struggles and the intensification of brutality meted out by the dictatorship.
Cushion introduces the story of a group of trade union militants in Guantánamo, eastern Cuba, who
developed the concept of ‘movimiento obrero beligerente’ (trade unionism on a war footing). This was the combination of mass action with sabotage … to achieve this in conditions imposed by a dictatorship, they also pioneered a clandestine call structure that would later be extended nationwide to form the basic organisational model of the MR-26–7 [M26J] sección obrera (p. 106).
Workers in Guantánamo carried out decisive actions in support of the Granma boat landing in late 1956, which bought the M26J's nascent rebel army to the Sierra Maestra.
Cushion examines why the August 1957 strike in Oriente was a success, but the April 1958 strike failed. He demonstrates how the failure of the latter caused the M26J and the PSP to change their approach ‘and we see the start of a process of tactical convergence’ between them (p. 173). He details their more gradual organisational convergence, describing the two workers’ congresses which took place in territory controlled by the rebel army. The importance of these congresses, he asserts, is that they ‘show the true level of working-class organization in support of the revolution and refute the arguments of those who say that such support was merely passive’ (p. 17). The official trade union leadership was increasingly marginalised, while the working class was instrumental both to seizing and consolidating power in 1959: ‘in the first year of the new Cuba, organized labor played an important role in that process of consolidation and in the final triumph of the more radical wing of the revolutionary forces’ (p. 17). Indeed, Cushion's conclusion asserts that: ‘Without this contribution from organized labor, the Cuban Revolution would not have succeeded’ (p. 221). This important book has earned a required place on all reading lists on the history of the Cuban revolution.
