S-21, the central Khmer Rouge detention and torture center, where confessions were extracted from so-called “enemies of the revolution” before these men, women, and children were killed, seems to encapsulate the incomprehensible brutality and terror of the Khmer Rouge revolution in Cambodia.
Preserved now as a museum and a reminder of those atrocities, the Tuol Sleng prison, as S-21 is commonly called, is probably best known for the photographs of prisoners that were discovered there. This Khmer Rouge killing machine (as filmmaker Rithy Panh has called S-21)Footnote 1 operated through a multi-layered bureaucracy driven by fear; central to its operation was an obsessive if chaotic record-keeping. Although less than half of the photographs have been found, it appears that most of the 14,000 people who went through Tuol Sleng on their way to their deaths were numbered and photographed, following the French police tradition.
The archive of mug shots of Khmer Rouge victims, discovered in 1979, has been augmented in a variety of ways over the years, and the photographs have been reproduced in many venues: at the Tuol Sleng museum itself; through the collection and preservation of the negatives; in the Documentation Center of Cambodia's database of victims; and in films, art books, magazines, and museums around the world. Most recently they have been entered as material evidence in the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia trials of the architects of the Khmer Rouge revolution. A Google search will turn up thousands of reproductions in personal travel blogs as well as in news accounts, websites, exhibitions, plays, and essays. They have become ubiquitous, and recognizable to many with little or no knowledge of their provenance.
There is a reason these photographs have been so widely reproduced and frequently written about. They are arresting, disturbing, confusing. They draw in even the uninformed viewer in a way that is hard to understand. They seem to speak to us and yet, as the author of this book points out, we cannot know what they are saying. They are, of course, entirely mute.
Michelle Caswell begins with this experience. “What is it about . . . the thousands of mugshots . . . from Tuol Sleng prison that continues to speak to us? What do these records tell us, and why do we continue to be haunted by them?” (p. 6). Caswell is a scholar of archives, and her book examines these questions through the emerging field of archival studies. Her aim is to introduce historians, anthropologists, visual studies scholars, and human rights activists to the contributions that archival theory can bring to our understanding—and use—of the photographs. This is a tall order, as each of these communities has developed a body of scholarship around the photographs, working through different discourses with different concerns. But all of these have contributed to the social life of the archive, as Caswell puts it. Her book does an impressive job of outlining these scholarly discussions as she develops her own theoretical contribution based on an understanding of silence and agency in the evolution of this archive.
Caswell is concerned with the way archival sources are used to construct historical knowledge. She draws heavily on anthropologist Michel-Rolph Trouillot's theory of how silences are encoded into historical production.Footnote 2 “Not all events are recorded; not all records are incorporated into archives; not all archives are used to tell stories; not all stories are used to write history” (p. 10). Power is involved in each of these moments in the development of historical understanding, which determine what information is recorded and how it may be used. Indeed, “‘any historical narrative is a particular bundle of silences,’ with silences reflecting specific instances of the assertion of power” (p. 10, quoting Trouillot). Throughout the book, Caswell returns to the subject of silences and absences: what was not recorded and who is not represented in the archive, who does not speak, what we do not know, and how this shapes what we can know from the evidence at our disposal.
Caswell uses Trouillot's four-part theory of the role of silences in the development of historical understanding as a framework for considering the development of meaning around the Tuol Sleng photographs. But she draws on recent archival theory to show how the archive itself is not a fixed thing but rather a record of human activity: a set of documents fixed in the context of particular social and organizational activity that are constantly being recontextualized, “‘always in the process of becoming,’” as she writes (p. 13), quoting Sue McKemmish.Footnote 3 In this view an archive is never complete, and one can trace its evolving social life as records come to be understood, activated, and put to use in new ways under new circumstances to construct new narratives. Indeed, a major thrust of her work is to demonstrate how in recent years the Documentation Center of Cambodia in particular has mobilized the Tuol Sleng mug shots to promote human rights in Cambodia, enabling individual Cambodians to transform their stories of victimhood into stories of active agency. In the process, she offers a new image of the archivist as activist, transformed from passive librarian into an active participant in the construction of history and the promotion of human rights.
Caswell summarizes a broad range of scholarship on recent Cambodian history as well as visual studies theory. Her book is meticulously and usefully documented and engagingly written. She interweaves new archival theory into her discussion of the Tuol Sleng mug shots in a way that is accessible to scholars in other fields. Structuring the body of the book around Trouillot's theory of silences leads to some repetition in the middle chapters, and Caswell seems obliged at times to fit topics into her framework that do not always sit comfortably there. But overall, her discussion of the ways in which this archive has evolved over time in the context of recent Cambodian history is compelling and convincing.
My only substantive critique is regarding her discussion of the commodification of victimhood in chapter 4. In this chapter, Caswell discusses the photographs that tourists have taken of themselves with the two living survivors of the Tuol Sleng prison, who support themselves by selling books about their experiences at Tuol Sleng and posing for photographs with tourists for a fee. Caswell argues that these encounters draw tourists into a relationship with the survivors, who become witnesses to the necessary commodification of their memories and implicated in their ongoing struggle for survival in a society that has not compensated them (or anyone else) for their suffering. In this way their photos draw attention to power differentials and ongoing inequities in Cambodia today. She writes, “If properly contextualized, these new tourist-generated records have the ability to renew viewers' commitment to human rights in the future, transforming the[ir] blog readers into secondary witnesses and creating an ever-expanding circle of human rights performance as such records get pluralized and reused over time” (p. 152). Caswell emphasizes the importance of proper contextualization throughout her book in order to understand the many layers of meaning in the Tuol Sleng archive, used in different ways at different times and places. But I question whether most tourists to the Tuol Sleng Museum actually do understand the context of these encounters: the complex relationship between victimhood and survival, in the past as well as in present-day Cambodia, let alone casual viewers of their vacation blogs. Here an insistence on survivors' agency seems to trump a more nuanced discussion of the ongoing challenges for survivors at a time when most living Cambodians have had no direct experience with the Khmer Rouge, and are more focused on the future than the past. There is more to be considered here that may not fit easily into the framework that Caswell has established for her very interesting book.
The book's conclusion is a powerful and eloquent summary of the evolving significance of the Tuol Seng archive and the ethics of looking at the suffering of others. Caswell's analysis will be of interest to anyone who has thought about the layered context and meaning of photographs, the development of historical narratives, and the transformation of victimhood into agency as individuals work toward collective understandings of a difficult past.
