Sami Shalom Chetrit's innovative new book is a much needed intervention in the field of Mizrahi studies. It provides a comprehensive and interesting account of Israel's Jewish others and exposes, with much nuance and sensitivity, the ways in which individuals have attempted to challenge the power of the state.
The book's starting point is the mass migration of Middle Eastern Jewish communities to Israel after the state's establishment. Chetrit depicts the shock and fear felt by new migrants and how they coped with new realities. The book examines various forms of Mizrahi resistance—from the first stirring of protest within the transit camps in which Mizrahi Jews were settled during the 1950s to the more organized political movements of the 1980s and 1990s. The book likewise traces various aspects of the discrimination Mizrahi Jews faced during different periods of Israel's existence, related to housing, education, welfare, and citizenship rights. The ways that this theme is explored throughout the book illustrate, very tellingly, one of Chetrit's main theses, namely, that discrimination against Mizrahi Jews was not due simply to the state's poverty in the 1950s but was also rooted in socioeconomic and sociocultural contexts.
Inspired by Saidian critique and Ella Shohat's seminal theorization of Mizrahi identity, Chetrit shows how a particular conversation about Mizrahi Jews came into being in Israeli officialdom. Drawing on an impressive range of sources, such as governmental and Knesset discussions, reports by parliamentary investigation committees, platforms of political parties, and the Israeli press, the book documents the ways in which the state spoke about Jews whose culture was identified with that of the Arab and Middle Eastern enemy. While reading Chetrit's detailed analysis, I was struck by how much some of these discourses have in common with contemporary anxieties in Europe and the United States related to Muslim immigrants. Chetrit shows, for example, that Israeli officials expressed much concern about the high birth rate among Mizrahi Jews, their religiosity, and, more generally, their inability to be integrated into society—arguments that are raised today with respect to Muslim immigrants in the West. However, he rejects the notion that Mizrahi Jews were passive victims by illustrating that various groups of Mizrahi Jews met state policies with resistance. From the riots in Wadi Salib to the Mizrahi Black Panthers movement to the rise of new Mizrahi discourses in the Israeli public sphere, Chetrit reveals that there was always a multiplicity of ways, even under very difficult conditions, to offer an alternative to the nationalism of the ruling elites. Chetrit's definition of resistance is wide enough to encompass a variety of actions, such as organized protests, the formation of political parties, Robin Hood-like “crimes” (my favorite: the Panthers’ stealing of milk from grocery stores in a rich neighborhood in Jerusalem to give to children in poor neighborhoods), and the creation of alternative histories (such as the composition of a new Passover Haggadah, in which the exodus is not commemorated and the ancient Israeli past is evoked in order to bemoan the conditions of their lives in Israel).
The book's most interesting chapter analyzes the Mizrahi Black Panther movement. Chetrit presents a detailed reading of the movement's flyers and publications and describes how these activists came to see themselves as Jewish “panthers” in a poor neighborhood of Jerusalem called Musrara, which they renamed Harlem/Musrara. The author's discussion of their demonstrations, openness to the plight of the Palestinians, and neo-Marxist rhetoric make for a fascinating read. Among the chapter's gems is a recording of a conversation between Golda Meir and the Panthers, in which Meir asks them no less than five times why they chose “Black Panthers” as the name of their movement. Although Chetrit exposes Meir's misguided politics with regard to Mizrahi Jews in different parts of the book, this conversation represents his most salient evidence; Meir lays bare her fears concerning the Mizrahi appropriation of a global Third World struggle, which she wrongly identifies as anti-Semitic.
The last chapter of the book (which could have been divided into two separate chapters) deals with Mizrahi politics in the 1980s and 1990s. Chetrit focuses on the ways in which the more established Israeli political parties managed to incorporate Mizrahi claims for equality and social justice while co-opting (if not completely silencing) the Mizrahi radical agenda. The chapter also covers the rise of independent Mizrahi voices in a variety of domains in the Israeli public sphere. In his interesting exploration of the Shas party, Chetrit does a very good job of highlighting its position at the intersection of nationalist, Mizrahi, and Haredi politics and sheds light on how the party's leadership carefully navigated between these three poles. Chetrit's comparative perspective suggests that Shas should be juxtaposed not only with Ashkenazi-Haredi political movements but also, and more importantly, with radical Islamist ones. While I am not certain I agree with all of the comparisons Chetrit draws between Israel and Iran, his introduction of the Muslim Brotherhood and other Islamist organizations into a discussion of Shas is useful. It illustrates how much these movements have in common, in particular their ability to recognize the zones in which the state's social policies have failed, and to offer social services in their stead through religious organizations. Both Islamist parties and Shas, moreover, employ a religious message about the return to religious roots as a way of masking their radicalism. The chapter also very effectively charts changes in the Israeli academy as a result of the rise of the New Mizrahim, namely, the scholars, intellectuals, and writers who criticized Israeli policies toward Mizrahi Jews as part of a more general critique of Zionism. I wish Chetrit had further elaborated on these fascinating changes considering he was among the New Mizrahim.
There are a few domains where in my view the book could have gone a little further. Following Shohat, Chetrit sees the category “Mizrahim” not only as an Israeli construct but also as a term Middle Eastern Jews chose to adopt in order to challenge discrimination and injustice (just as the terms “black” or “queer” were adopted in the United States for political purposes). I would have liked to learn more, however, about the differences between the various Mizrahi communities in Israel and their specific histories (Iraqi, Yemeni, Moroccan, Turkish, Iranian, and so on) and between Mizrahi and Ethiopian Jews. Although the Ashkenazi elite treated diverse Mizrahi communities as one Oriental lot, there were vast socioeconomic differences between these communities that shaped their respective integration experiences in Israel. Chetrit likewise could have elaborated more on communities that were alternately labeled Mizrahi and Ashkenazi, such as Greek and Bulgarian Jews, or the children of mixed marriages between Mizrahi and Ashkenazi parents. Second, despite the theoretical sophistication of the work, Chetrit's employment of the “oppression/resistance” binary is at times limiting. For example, he treats the Panthers, for very good reasons, as being in opposition to the state, yet he fails to notice that some of their demands actually focused on mechanisms that would enable their integration into the state. What is most lacking, I feel, is a theoretical language that would enable us to think about Mizrahi Zionism and right-wing Mizrahi politics in Israel, especially because some Mizrahi politicians have used the emigration of Jews from Arab countries and emigrants’ loss of property in their countries of origin as a bargaining chip against the claims of Palestinian refugees. Chetrit uses the term “Ashkenazi Zionism” because the movement's intellectual origins, leadership, and early supporters were European. Nonetheless, there still remains the question as to how we should think about the manipulation of Mizrahi narratives to support a conservative agenda. How, for example, do we critique Shas' recent anti-Palestinian, antigay, or antifeminist agenda without reproducing “white” neoliberal anxieties about the rise of Mizrahi power? Or how do we think about Shaʾul Mofaz's teary appearance on Israeli television a few years ago, in which he told the Israeli public about the living conditions of his Iranian family in Israel, while promoting a right-wing political agenda that relied in part on his “credentials” as one of the architects of Israel's military policy during the second intifada? Are these simply responses to “Ashkenazi Zionism,” or do they represent a new hybrid construction? The story told by Chetrit ends on a hopeful note by introducing a host of Mizrahi nongovernmental organizations as well as academic and cultural activities, but I think that the less hopeful realities of Israeli politics should have been taken into account.
Yet, as I suggested previously, this is an exciting, interesting, and well-researched book, which I hope will be used by colleagues teaching classes on radicalism and identity politics in the Middle East. The growing interest in Mizrahi studies in the American academy enables many of us to offer courses dedicated entirely to Mizrahi politics and Mizrahi cultures in the Middle East. Chetrit's new study is an important contribution to our field. I hope the work will be translated into Arabic so as to continue recent conversations between Jewish and Arab scholars and intellectuals concerning the histories of Jewish communities in the Middle East. I also hope (perhaps unrealistically) that scholars of Jewish studies will include the book in classes about modern Jewish culture and history.
