Fariba Zarinebaf's book is a welcome addition to the literature on urban history and law in the Ottoman Empire. The book both gives an overview of current scholarship on 18th-century Istanbul and Ottoman law that is accessible to readers from other fields and contributes new insights based on original research in little-used sources, including records of arrests by city police officials, galley service records, and prison registers. Zarinebaf reaches a number of conclusions. One is that crime was on the increase in 18th-century Istanbul, but it is difficult to see how this claim can be substantiated in the absence of detailed work on crime in the 17th century and earlier. The second is that Ottoman authorities treated criminals generously by the standards of contemporary Europe. There were far fewer capital offenses in the empire than in contemporary England, and while in France galley service was often an effective death sentence, as convicts were worked until they dropped, in Istanbul convicts were usually sentenced to terms of less than a year and were often released early. The third relates to the modernization of the Ottoman penal system, which is usually dated to the 19th century; Zarinebaf argues convincingly that many of the 19th-century reforms had earlier roots. She finds that imprisonment was being used in the 18th century and that state authorities were increasingly taking the initiative to prosecute criminals rather than relying on private lawsuits issued by the victims, which was the norm in premodern Islamic law.
The book is divided into nine chapters. The first three are introductory: one gives an overview of Istanbul in the “Tulip Age”; another examines migration to Istanbul from the provinces and the consequent growth of marginalized populations in the city, which Zarinebaf highlights as the key socioeconomic context for crime in the period; the third describes the political context of the rebellions of 1703 and 1730. This is followed by three chapters examining different types of crime: the first on “Crimes against Property and Counterfeiting,” the second on “Prostitution and the Vice Trade,” which also covers alcohol consumption, and the third on “Violence and Homicide.” The last three chapters cover the institutions involved in detecting, prosecuting, and punishing criminals: one chapter examines the development of police institutions, another looks at the various law courts operating in the capital, and the last deals with forms of punishment, including prisons, penal servitude, fines, and banishment.
A key strength of Zarinebaf's book is her appreciation of the multiplicity of institutions and actors engaged in enforcing the law in Ottoman Istanbul. Scholarship on Ottoman law has focused overwhelmingly on the shariʿa courts, but Zarinebaf takes a much broader view and in fact shows that the capital's shariʿa courts played a relatively minor role in the prosecution of crime. More important were the Imperial Council (dīvān-i hümāyūn), presided over by the Grand Vizier, and the officers of the Janissary regiment, who not only arrested offenders but also often punished them without recourse to the courts. In addition to the Janissaries, Zarinebaf finds that the Bostancı regiment was increasingly involved in police work during the 18th century. Christian and Jewish criminals were often dealt with by their own religious authorities, which passed on only particularly troublesome repeat offenders to the kadi or the Imperial Council. Zarinebaf also emphasizes that much local policing was carried out unofficially by a kind of “community watch,” with the elders of a neighborhood supervising its residents.
Zarinebaf often segues imperceptibly between discussing the specific case of Istanbul and talking in a generalized fashion about the Ottoman Empire. The bigger picture may be intended to appeal to readers from other fields, but unfortunately it tends to obscure one of the things that Zarinebaf's research strongly suggests to the specialist: the uniqueness of the Ottoman capital. In Chapter 2, Zarinebaf highlights the importance of migration in creating the context for criminality; many provincial centers also attracted migrants, but few had the magnetism of Istanbul. There are also many other ways in which Istanbul was distinctive. The importance of galley service as a punishment was a consequence of the demands of the Ottoman navy, based locally; this did not have a parallel in most other regions of the empire and so made the prospects for male Istanbulite criminals very different from those of their provincial counterparts. The large non-Muslim population and the presence of European ambassadors complicated attempts to prohibit alcohol consumption and resulted in semiofficial zones of toleration; again, the situation differed greatly in many other parts of the empire. The prominent and expanding role in the prosecution of crime performed by the Imperial Council was also a feature unique to the capital. Zarinebaf suggests that a parallel role may have been played by governors’ councils in provincial cities, which is possible, but we do not know this yet, because provincial governors’ councils have not been adequately studied.
The book would have benefited from a clearer definition of crime. Zarinebaf appears to have borrowed a modern definition encompassing theft, violence, and moral infractions, rather than referring to the categorization of acts within Ottoman legal theory. But the borrowing is selective, and there are some aspects of the modern understanding of crime that she has left out: principally, what we would call white-collar crime committed by businessmen and government officials. Zarinebaf briefly describes tax-farmer corruption as a cause of peasant migration to Istanbul, and she also mentions that some gangs of Janissaries were involved in extortion. But she does not discuss in detail the misappropriation of wealth by high officials through levying excessive taxes or diverting government revenues. Similarly, although Zarinebaf covers counterfeiting and the selling of substandard or short-weight products by market traders, she does not discuss any cases of wealthy merchants defrauding their partners or investors. The overall impression is that “crime” is something perpetrated by the lower orders and that the misdeeds associated with the elite do not count. Perhaps that is how the Ottomans (or at least elite Ottomans) saw things, but if so, then this in itself is interesting and deserves exploration.
These minor criticisms notwithstanding, this is an important book that will be of great interest to scholars in the fields of Ottoman legal and urban history as well as to scholars thinking about crime and policing in the early modern period from a comparative perspective.
