This book, published as part of the Cambridge series Themes in Islamic History, is an important overview of charitable giving in Islamic societies across times and locales. Along with attempting to ameliorate Western suspicions of Muslim charities in the post-2001 environment, Singer sets out to accomplish the following five goals: to identify Islamic features, if any, in the ideology and practices associated with charity in Muslim societies; to “demystify” Islamic charity for 21st-century audiences; to validate the study of charity as a historiographical tool; to illustrate the ways in which the comparative study of charity can be used for comparative social history; and to promote the historical study of charity in Islamic societies (p. 217). In regard to the last goal, a leitmotif of the work, Singer points to the availability of certain premodern (especially Ottoman) sources and suggests questions for further research.
The book's broad historical and geographical scope not only makes it an ambitious study but also causes some discontinuity in terms of sustaining a focused argument and attention to exegesis. Nevertheless, Singer provides sufficient and diverse evidence—whether from the Qurʾan, the works of al-Ghazali (d. 1111), or early modern fatwas—to present a sophisticated picture of charitable giving, its symbolic, social, and economic dimensions, and its place in the arena of human beneficence. She draws some parallels with Judeo-Christian charitable traditions and brings into discussion contemporary visual illustrations and empirical anecdotes. Two premodern nonacademic sources that Singer uses repeatedly for eyewitness evidence are the travel books of Ibn Battuta (14th century) and Evliya Çelebi (17th century). She identifies certain Shiʿi norms and practices that are sometimes overlooked in introductory studies. The book is structured simply, written clearly, and dotted with insightful interpretations, making it useful to specialists and accessible to students.
Singer's approach is topical rather than chronological. Questions such as “Who gave? Who received? Who were the deserving and undeserving poor?” (p. 14) are addressed in separate chapters. The question of how “the charitable impulse was expressed in different historical settings” (p. 20) is explored from the perspectives of the donor and the recipient, the law and the public perception. Singer uses the terms “charity,” “beneficence,” and “philanthropy” interchangeably and points out that even the Qurʾan does not always clearly distinguish between zakat (obligatory alms) and ṣadaqa (voluntary charity) (see, for example, p. 36).
In the introduction, Singer points to a relative paucity of in-depth Western studies on Islamic charity and lists as neglected areas theological, ritual, and social aspects of Islamic almsgiving and philanthropy (pp. 24–25). To alert the reader to the complexity of charity dynamics in Islam, Singer notes that emphasis on charity as generosity shown to the needy leads to the common perception of patronage along vertical lines and may overlook the element of reciprocity (pp. 21–22). Compliance with such a universally required obligation as zakat “was mostly an invisible performance” (p. 26), and therefore its implementation across time and space is for the most part absent from the records. Monumental buildings or elites’ extravagant public donations of robes, food, and money not only were more visible than but also obscured the discreet acts of everyday almsgiving and kindness by those of modest means. Nevertheless, giving benefited most Muslims, and most Muslims gave.
Singer emphasizes that in the contexts of other forms of taxation and state economics dependent on tax collection, the place of zakat varied over time. Jurists debated zakat rules and faced the challenge of assessing changing forms of income and other wealth (pp. 42–43). Directed toward God in intent, but impacting people, communities, and authorities, obligatory almsgiving evolved in relation to material well-being and personal spiritual norms. The organization, collection, and distribution of zakat concerned and were contested by rulers, scholars, merchants, and farmers. A necessary part of local economies, zakat collection was subject to abuse and required periodic fatwas from jurisconsults to address new situations. Sufi hospices (zawāyāt) sometimes both collected and distributed alms. Despite the ideal of sharing wealth, poverty was not considered a sufficient “reason to receive beneficent distributions” (p. 9). In the chain of charity, the recipient might also be a giver in turn. Paying out money was not enough: intent and the manner of fulfilling the obligation were also of paramount importance. Singer also discusses zakāt al-fiṭr, or alms given to the poor at the end of the Ramadan fast. This is an obligation of a lower order (mentioned in the hadith but not the Qurʾan) though observed almost universally.
In addition to zakat, Singer discusses Muslim endowments and voluntary charity, legally defined as ṣadaqat al-taṭawwuʿ (alms of spontaneity). She explains the prominence of ṣadaqa in part by the fact that zakat “did not prove an effective instrument for relieving need and redistributing wealth” (p. 65). Singer also provides a useful “calendar of charity,” emphasizing the “variety and ubiquity of charitable gestures” (p. 73). The calendar includes regular and occasional opportunities for devotional giving, from Friday mosque attendance to boys’ circumcision celebrations to ʿīd al-fiṭr food distributions. Such public events allowed for more direct and informal contact between the giver and the recipient than did zakat and therefore more clearly demonstrated and reinforced patronage ties. Because they were also more observable than zakat, such events produced more accounts by European travelers impressed by the pervasive Muslim culture of giving, which Singer draws on in her study. Singer makes a point that children's education included learning about charity, whether from the teachings of the Qurʾan or from observing the actions of the surrounding community. Safe delivery from danger was routinely marked by giving alms, a point even recorded in the Arabian Nights. Mamluk and Ottoman sources document public distributions on behalf of the sick or in thanks for those who recovered from illness. Medical care was effected through endowed hospitals, but death and funerals were also accompanied by animal sacrifice and distribution of food and money. Chapter 2 includes a section on waqf, a highly visible form of endowed foundation supporting construction and maintenance of buildings dedicated to charitable service and/or paying for such services in perpetuity. Singer's discussion is based on the Hanafi regulations of waqf properties, deeds, and practices.
The aspirations, patronage, and status of donors are discussed separately from the needs, expectations, and behavior of the recipients of charity. Regarding the former, Singer highlights the cases of royal women active in endowments and other charitable work from Saljuq to Ottoman times. These are special cases not only because they are better documented than other women's activities but also because for the women themselves performing such deeds was an opportunity to play a role in public life. Paradoxically, elite women had greater freedom to practice charity than some men—Ottoman princes, for example, were not allowed to endow mosques, which might create the appearance of competing with the sultan over wealth and prestige. Guesthouses for travelers aided those without support networks and spread the fame of the donor far beyond his own land. Examples from Safavid Iran and Mughal India show ways in which Shiʿi or Hindu practices shaped patronage. Chapter 4, while concentrating on less visible beneficiaries of charity, hospitality, and patronage, emphasizes that none of these measures aimed to raise the recipient to the level of sustainable self-sufficiency. Here the author dwells on definitions of poverty, the merits and demerits of begging (pertaining especially to Sufis), and the categories of deserving poor, among whom were the dwellers of Mecca, Medina, and other holy cities of Islam. Again drawing comparisons, Singer remarks that unlike some European practices, Islamic relief did not require incarceration or controlled living conditions for beneficiaries. However, we know that some hospices for orphans and widows, being in effect charitable institutions for disadvantaged women, indeed controlled (sometimes quite strictly) the living conditions and behavior of inmates.
The section on the economics of charity reads almost like a separate article, outlining the modernization of the philanthropic administration in the Ottoman Empire and its successor states. Singer considers the nature of modern states’ disbursements and obligations to their citizens, concluding that while the Ottoman Empire was not a welfare state, it was a “welfare society.” She points to the large imperial waqfs as being closest to “state welfare agencies” (p. 183). Modernization of the Ottoman government and imperial administration entailed waqf reforms and deeply affected the mechanisms of welfare services. In the 20th century, state welfare agencies and better protection of property rights contributed to a decline in waqf endowments in some parts of the Muslim world, while state ministries took over some of the functions previously fulfilled by waqfs. “Managing poor relief” (p. 196) became a primary responsibility of late imperial charity in the Ottoman Empire and Egypt, and bureaucratization of poor relief became a preoccupation for new nation–states. Modern Islamist thinkers have highlighted zakat as an instrument of social justice and helped to revitalize its role as a fiscal mechanism. Official national zakat systems have been created, and the relationship between the poor and the police has also undergone a dramatic change. Modern communication and fundraising have allowed the formation of new associations, combining nationalist goals with Islamist reformist ideology. With minimal government support, some philanthropic associations have aspired to development projects or were formed by women to benefit women and girls. The late 20th century is marked by the appearance of transnational Islamic relief organizations and nongovernmental organizations.
