Playing Real: Mimesis, Media, and Mischief intervenes in longstanding discussions of liveness, mimesis, and mediatization. Using case studies across theatre, television, and gaming, Lindsay Brandon Hunter offers a close examination of performance events that take place in “a murky area in which the boundaries separating actual from virtual, genuine from artificial, and truth from fiction are difficult to discern” (xv). As Hunter argues, playfully blurring such boundaries offers a “fertile site for productive and pleasurable mischief” (xv) that “may not (always) provoke revolution, but . . . is usually a productive act simply because it provokes” (xix).
Playing Real unfolds across six chapters. The first examines the Electronovision film of John Gielgud's 1964 Broadway production of Hamlet, starring Richard Burton, as well as contemporary live broadcasting series such as the National Theater UK's development of NT Live and the Royal Shakespeare Company's Live from Stratford-upon-Avon. In considering the process of transferring live stage productions to broadcast film formats for global distribution, Hunter points to ideas of translation, interpretation, and didacticism. These ideas become central to developing her argument, which deemphasizes the liveness of theatre by thinking about it as brand rather than ontology (12). Chapter 2 continues with an examination of the 1964 Hamlet but delves into the Wooster Group's more recent use of the film in an intermedial production in 2007. This chapter's focus is less on the spectators’ evaluation or perception of liveness and instead turns to acting theory to question whether the traditional dichotomy of organic versus mechanical acting remains useful. Hunter's close reading of performer Scott Shepherd's powerful yet entirely imitative and derivative performance of Hamlet, based on Burton's original, is a convincing case for eschewing theatre's preoccupation with inspiration and spontaneity. Chapter 3 marks the shift to a consideration of the genre of reality television, primarily through The Bachelor franchise. This chapter's focus moves from an initial consideration of “true” love to consider embodiment and the reality TV star's performing body as a kind of authenticity marker. Chapter 4 focuses on The Hills, a “scripted reality” show following the lives of well-to-do Los Angeles personalities Lauren Conrad and Kristin Cavallari (66). This chapter offers a fascinating glimpse into the pleasure that viewers derive from sorting the fake from the real. For instance, Hunter quotes fans who enthusiastically, albeit accusatorially, point out continuity errors in filming (73–4). The final two chapters of Playing Real focus on alternate reality gaming (ARG). Chapter 5's investigation of World without Oil considers what happens when games purposefully blur boundaries between the real world and play world. Hunter expands Johan Huizinga's concept of the “magic circle” (86) to consider World without Oil's deliberate move into players’ real lives with the explicit aim of changing their behavior to become more environmentally friendly. Chapter 6 takes a close look at Conspiracy for Good, an alternate reality game sponsored by mobile communications company Nokia. This game's use of a familiar melodramatic structure worked to pit real game players against a fictional villainous corporation. This chapter delves into important questions about real-world impact by examining how Nokia's specific intervention in the game—namely, putting surveillance technology into the hands of consumers—has much broader implications for privacy and security beyond the game world.
Like Jenn Stephenson's Insecurity: Perils and Products of Theatres of the Real (2019), Hunter's book argues for the productive potential of unstable ontologies by examining performances that purport to offer audiences some experience of the real amid overt theatricalization and mediatization. The specific provocations of Playing Real stem from a reading of this ontological instability as thrilling and pleasurable. Of course, the focus on playfulness and mischief has the potential to read as neglectful of the very acute consequences that such boundary blurring between the real and not real has had in the twenty-first century; fake news, antivaxxers, QAnon, and other recent political events make such discussions highly charged. However, as Hunter's conclusion argues, mischief also has generative potential and prompts a kind of productive destabilizing of artistic hierarchies. Such mischief making, she argues, is relevant to the work twenty-first-century artists and audiences are creating and consuming.
Notably, Hunter makes good use of some data from actual game players and television fans in the latter half of the book; similar use of audience data in her other case studies, especially the theatrical examples of the first two chapters, would be useful areas of extension in support of her thought-provoking arguments about the decreasing centrality of liveness in performance. A further drawing out of the nuances and distinctions among the various terms being used—liveness, truth, authenticity, veracity, sincerity, immersion, reality—would also be an area for additional examination.
Overall, Hunter's engaging and lively writing is inviting and accessible. Her invocation of diverse examples from across theatre, television, gaming, and popular culture similarly reflects a sense of playfulness and curiosity. The varied case studies, ranging from Hamlet to True Tori (a reality TV show about Tori Spelling's relationship with husband Dean McDermott), offer a refreshing array of examples and make this book a useful read for those in the related fields of media and communication studies, fan studies, and television studies. Indeed, one of the strongest aspects of the text is the use of scholarship from similarly multidisciplinary fields. Hunter's text makes the potential of wide-ranging scholastic engagement clear to theatre and performance scholars, especially as it concerns foundational concepts like mimesis, mediatization, and liveness.
