Chad M. Bauman's erudite monograph investigates the genesis and development of Protestant Christianity among the Satnami in Chhattisgarh, Central India, during the British colonial period. This investigation, as the author points out, is not simply of interest to the historian or religious scholar. Rather, it sheds desperately needed light on the phenomenon of religious conversion, which is causing considerable political turmoil and communal violence in India today. Bauman accurately calls the work “a historical ethnography of a religious community, an interdisciplinary work informed by the methodologies in the study of religion, history, and anthropology” (pp. 20–21). The Satnami are both a religious and a social group in Chhattisgarh. The vast majority of them come from the Dalit, or “untouchable,” Chamar caste, which has traditionally made its living through tanning, the production of leather goods, and the removal of cattle carcasses. In the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century, a number of Chamar from Chhattisgarh started following a guru who proclaimed a new panth, or religious way, one that abjured idol worship and caste distinctions, and believed in the Satnam, or True Name. By the end of the nineteenth century, almost all of the Chamar in Chhattisgarh were Satnami.
After an introduction that provides some background and indicates the general trajectory of the study, the book proceeds to provide the historical and theoretical details that go into slowly and skillfully building the author's main argument, namely, that those Satnami who converted to Christianity appropriated, shaped, and molded the new religion in order to make it fit their desires and needs. The “Christianization of Chhattisgarh—limited as it was—also entailed the Chhattisgarhization of Christianity” (p. 6).
The first chapter of the book provides the cultural, social, and religious context of the study. This is done primarily by narrating the social and religious history of the Satnami. The second chapter takes up the issue of conversion, probing the question of why some people converted to Christianity, while others did not, and still others converted back from Christianity to the Satnami religion. One of the great strengths of this book is the way that it nimbly navigates through weighty theoretical material, and this chapter provides some good examples of how well the author deals with a plethora of theories from the social sciences. The next chapter explores how various stories, traditions, and myths of the Satnami Christians and of missionaries have operated to provide identity and useable histories. In this chapter, the theoretical discussions shift from a social scientific framework to a historiographical one.
Chapters 4 and 5 take up two of the Westernizing innovations introduced by missionaries to Satnami Christians, namely, Western medicine and Victorian gender roles for women. The fundamental argument in both chapters is the same: While an initial inquiry into missionary medicine and ideas of women's social roles might lead one to believe that these European innovations were imposed on the Satnami Christians, a closer examination of cultural dynamics and interchange between Indians and foreign missionaries reveals that the Satnami accepted these innovations for rather autochthonous reasons. Western medicine was accepted because, over a long period of time, it was shown to be effective—which was (and is) the basic criterion that the Satnami used for judging any medicine, of whatever origin. And Victorian gender roles for women were adopted because they serendipitously coincided with high-caste ideas about the proper place of women in society and the home. By changing their behavior to more closely reflect upper-caste notions of women's decency and propriety, the Christian Satnami could begin to lay claim to a higher-caste status themselves. The Satnami were thus engaging in what sociologist M. N. Srinivas famously termed Sanskritization, whereby castes or other socioreligious groups make claim to higher social status by imitating higher-caste behavior.
After these two fascinating discussions of Western medicine and gender roles comes a final chapter that narrates the stories of five Satnami and their encounter with Christianity. These five men typify or encapsulate the variety of Satnami responses to Christianity. The book ends with a conclusion in which the author returns to the question of conversion in the Indian context and the controversies that have surrounded it to this day. He provides an extremely sensitive and sensible view of religious conversion, a view that would certainly bring some calm and order to some very volatile situations.
This monograph is obviously written for academics, but academics in quite a range of disciplines. It has something important and interesting for scholars of religion, for historians of Christianity, for anthropologists, and for those interested in non-Western religions and their transformations and transmutations. Rich in theory, the text also possesses a compelling narrative voice that makes it a pleasure to read. Its judicious conclusions signal the welcome arrival of a balanced and mature scholar.
