Marcus Filippello's book is a history of the Ohori people of southeastern Benin. Drawing on extensive Ohori oral histories and French archival records, Filippello traces the emergence and growth of this community from its early development in the eighteenth century through various periods of instability and transformation in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. While the timeline for the earliest settlement of the Lama Valley remains a bit murky, it is clear that by the eighteenth century refugees from the collapsed empire of Oyo migrated into the valley in large numbers, transforming what had once been a loosely organized community of farmers into a centralized, politically independent state. While the Ohori are often considered members of the Yoruba diaspora, they resisted various efforts by outside forces to incorporate or conquer them. The political independence of the eighteenth century served as a point of pride for the Ohori, who fought first the French colonizers and later the Dahomey and Benin governments to protect their autonomy and secure prosperity for the community in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
Quite notably, the Pobe-Ketu Road anchors Ohori narratives of the past. The road is a space of danger and protection, risk and opportunity, continuity and change. It is simultaneously the path that brings people to the Lama Valley while it also offers a means to protect the community from invaders. This sort of ambivalence about roads has been widely discussed by Africanists. However, Filippello argues that the road is more than a palimpsest of Ohori narratives or a mnemonic device through which the Ohori recount the past. The Pobu-Ketu Road constitutes ‘a material and metaphorical space on which Ohori allegorically “record” their memories and perceptions of changing relationships with the natural and material worlds’ (9).
Through stories about road blocks, road construction, migration, and trade, Ohori crafted a narrative and practice of self-rule and resistance in the midst of significant political and economic change. The road brought refugees fleeing from the collapse of Oyo and slave raiders from Dahomey, processes that fostered the growth and political centralization of the state in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. In the early 1900s, when the French later attempted to build (or rebuild) the road into the forests of Igbo-Ilu, which protected Ohori villages, Ohori sabotaged its construction and ultimately rose up in rebellion. Indeed, Ohori resistance undermined French efforts to subjugate and control the Lama Valley throughout the first half of the twentieth century; however, that resistance came at a cost. Persistent fighting destroyed once vibrant centers of political power and economic exchange in Ohori communities and propelled residents to relocate elsewhere in the valley. But the road offered protection once again, as Ohori residents created new communities connected by secondary paths farther down the Pobe-Ketu Road, using the forest as protection for cotton and maize farms.
Ohori remembered later French efforts to build the SOCOLE (Société Coloniale d'Enterpises) road through the valley in the 1950s in much more favorable terms — the road is widely remembered in this era as producing an infrastructure of opportunity rather than of oppression, for it enabled Ohori farmers to transport their surplus cotton and maize for sale in Benin and Nigeria. But if the building of the road brought renewed economic prosperity, that prosperity did not last long, as the road quickly deteriorated due to the difficult clay soils of the valley. Postcolonial governments failed to invest in a reconstruction of the Pobe-Ketu Road, choosing instead to direct resources to big development projects that were supposed to build up the economy of the region. However, Ohori were often excluded from these new development projects, which further alienated them from the government of Benin. In other words, even after colonialism ended, the Ohori continued to use the road as a way to construct narratives of their own political independence and their resistance to broader state structures.
The politicization of mobility and infrastructure, which accompanied the expansion of French colonial rule in the late nineteenth century, often meant that the Pobe-Ketu Road appeared in both Ohori oral histories and archival records as an infrastructure, whose meaning and purpose was subject to contestations of political and economic power. However, as Filippello makes clear, the road also had significant cultural and spiritual significance for the Ohori. By the late nineteenth century, Ohori understood their community as a refuge that was protected by their environment and their ability to control the roads into and out of the valley. Religious leaders secured the community by placing spiritual objects along the road. The dense, sacred forests that surrounded the road both safeguarded Ohori residents and served as a symbol of Ohori power and autonomy. Even when French companies brought bulldozers and other machines into the valley to build a road, the trees of the sacred forest seemed to resist removal. After struggling for three days to fell a single tree, the construction company gave up and charted a new path around the forest.
As a history of the Ohori, this book significantly nuances narratives about the Yoruba diaspora and raises important new questions about the histories of seemingly marginal communities. In challenging historians to take seriously African oral narratives of place, environment, and mobility, Filippello builds on a robust body of scholarship by the likes of Terence Ranger, Jan Bender Shetler, and others. This study is also part of a larger scholarly movement to move away from the determinative emphasis on the colonial experience by tracing longer histories of continuity and change using indigenous historical and temporal frameworks.
The road plays a prominent role in both the title and the framing of the text, and yet it moves in and out of the narrative as a subject and analytical device. A more robust theorization of the relationship between memory, place, environment, and mobility in the introduction might have helped to explain the ways in which these different parts of the analysis connect to the overarching framework. But this does not significantly detract from what is a thoughtful and provocative book that explores the interconnected processes of cultural, social, political, and economic change in West Africa.
