With a population of half a billion people, speaking over 30 languages, governed by four broad political systems – ranging from presidential and semi-presidential democracies, to parliamentary republics and constitutional monarchies – and a multi-layered system of governance, distributing regulatory powers between central (or federal) and territorial governments, the European continent represents a fascinating case study for scholars interested in public affairs and lobbying. Not surprisingly, interest groups’ advocacy efforts are pervasive in European Union (EU) policy-making. With a 25% share of global GDP, the EU is “populated” by thousands of lobbyists representing the diverging interests of companies and civil society actors. Negotiation, mass-mobilisation, coalition and consensus building are daily occurrence in Brussels. This has caused many scholars, from various disciplines, to study lobbying practices in the European domain – with a steady growth in the number of scientific contributions to the topic. According to Google Scholar, 35 articles, papers or books titled with the word “lobbying” had already been published in the first quarter of 2018. Yet a systematic picture of lobbying in Europe was missing. No academic endeavour had covered the whole range of European national cases of lobbying.
The book edited by Alberto Bitonti and Phil Harris attempts to fill this gap in knowledge. Offering an original mix of contributions from academics (mostly political scientists) and lobbyists, the volume describes and compares lobbying in 28 EU Member States: a comparative analysis that, as the editors explain in the introductory chapter, targets various communities. First is obviously the academic community, and particularly political analysts. Second is the community of practitioners, who might be interested in gaining a clearer picture of current and future trends of the public affairs industry in EU. The public at large could also benefit from reading such a volume. After all, analysing lobbying is a way to shed light on key political, social, economic and legal issues at stake in contemporary Europe.
The approach of the volume is original, too. “Lobbying in Europe” escapes the most obvious solution – ie comparing regulatory frameworks. Beyond legal analysis, chapters tackle a number of elements to describe lobbying practices. This is due to practical reasons. Regulating lobbying is a rather recent concept in the majority of European states. Only seven countries have full legislation and mandatory registers (namely: France, Ireland, Lithuania, Austria, Poland, Slovenia, and the United Kingdom); two countries – Germany and The Netherlands – adopted soft regulations; other countries still, including Italy, lack a specific regulation of lobbying at the national level, but have regulations and registers implemented by regional administrations, Ministries and the national Parliament. Hence, the inclusion of additional elements to compare lobbying practices. These include the description of the country institutional framework, the political culture, the professionalisation and the numbers of the industry, as well as the perception of lobbyists by public opinion and politicians. Regrettably, however, not all chapters fulfil the promise to provide these data, partially missing the declared goal of the volume to offer a clear understanding of lobbying in each given country. This is probably due to the lack of a uniform methodology to harvest, streamline and analyse data – which results into chapters providing in-depth analysis of country’s lobbying, and chapters containing little more than narrative description. It must be said, for fairness, that this gap is partly fulfilled by the introductory and conclusive chapters. Both focus on the relationship between lobbying and democracy. Bitonti and Hills suggest that enhanced transparency of decision-making, combined with accountability of the public sector, and increased professionalisation of public affairs professionals, are the way forward to overcome the biased interest representation, and to move beyond the (perceived) dichotomy between democracies and interest groups.
Perhaps not the new point of reference in academic debate on lobbying – if this was ever the ambition of the volume – Lobbying in Europe sets a milestone in comparative analysis on lobbying practices, and it is destined to become a valuable reference tool to complement future research efforts on lobbying practices, institutional reforms and democracies.
