I. INTRODUCTION
This paper challenges the “absolute immizeration” doctrine ascribed to Karl Marx in Samuel Hollander’s latest book, The Economics of Karl Marx (2008). My method, which is based on large excerpts of Capital, may disconcert the reader at first. However, it is the only way to simultaneously attain the two objectives pursued here: to demonstrate, first, that Marx’s theoretical framework does not allow any kind of conclusion to be drawn regarding the “real-wage trend” and thus the role of absolute population growth in this supposed trend; and second, that none of the many long quotations used by Hollander supports his views, once these have been restored to the context from which they were extracted.
The aim of Hollander’s book is to renew the global approach to Marx’s Capital by stressing the determinant role played by market mechanisms in allocating resources, particularly the interdependence between prices and distribution. As in the case of Hollander’s previous books on the Classics, this one sees Marx’s Capital as a more or less conscious attempt to lay out the elements of a general equilibrium system in the absence of appropriate mathematical tools. The book is composed of five parts. The first one analyzes Marx’s mature works on the following issues: value and distribution, growth theory, growth and real-wage trend, growth and the falling rate of profit, and business cycles. The three next parts concern texts written before Capital, in which the categories and economic laws discussed in the first part were initially developed, while the last part tries to demonstrate that Marx had contemplated, from the 1870s, a reformist and evolutionary transition to socialism.
This paper is restricted to a detailed examination of the chapter dedicated to the so-called falling real-wage trend in Marx’s mature works. Among the issues more or less independently dealt with by Hollander, the Marxian wage theory occupies a prominent place, as it determines the evolution of supply and demand for labor and, thus, the conditions of the general equilibrium. If he/she wishes, the reader will judge on his/her own the pertinence of the rest of a book that deliberately excludes (p. 7) any discussion of commodity, money, and, more generally, discussion of the substance and forms of value, all subjects that Marx developed while noticing that “one of the chief failings of classical economy is that it has never succeeded, by means of its analysis of commodities, and, in particular, of their value, in discovering that form under which value becomes exchange value,” adding that this weakness explains why economists “who are thoroughly agreed as to labour time being the measure of the magnitude of value, have the most strange and contradictory ideas of money” (Marx 1867, pp. 91–92n).
With regard to the real-wage trend, Hollander defends one of the most controversial issues in his interpretation of Capital: “Marx’s adherence to a secular path of (industrial) wage which tends to decline towards the ‘subsistence’ level” (2008, p. 85).
According to this view, this “secular path” stems from the decreasing growth rate of labor demand in relation to the growth rate of population. This trend would render Marx’s opposition to Ricardo/Malthus’ law of population superficial. Hollander advances three arguments in support of his thesis. First, the subsistence level refers to zero growth in population, as in the Classics. Second, the increase in organic composition of capital (increase in capital/labor ratio) is purported to produce a relative decline of labor demand. According to Hollander, this decline is similar to that caused, in the Classics, by the fall of the rate of accumulation resulting from the decrease of agricultural productivity. Third, as the decrease of labor demand is an “ongoing process,” it eschews the need of any birth-rate policy that adapts population growth to the evolution of labor demand (2008, pp. 86–87).
According to Sowell (Reference Sowell1960), the subsistence wage contains an historical/moral element that includes the need for the growth of the working population. However, this interpretation supposes that in a less-advanced period of capitalism, the subsistence wage would not lead to an increase in the working population. After a brief history of the debate on absolute immizeration (section II), it will be shown that population growth is involved in the Marxian subsistence wage, notwithstanding the historical/moral element of the wage (section III). Moreover, not only does a low real wage not exclude the population growth, but a surplus population in some industrial sectors can exist alongside an excess of labor demand. This will lead into an analysis of the nature of surplus population in Capital and its role in the business cycle: surplus population cannot be seen only as a necessary condition of the business cycle, correctly stressed by Hollander (Reference Hollander2008, p. 100). Surplus population stems directly from the accumulation of capital, which makes business cycles inherent to the nature of capitalist production, something of which a general equilibrium approach is unable to conceive (section IV). In this way, the theory of dual labor force, which Hollander (Reference Hollander1985) takes from John Stuart Mill, misunderstands the origin and meaning of relative surplus population (section V). A careful examination of Hollander’s choice of quotations from Capital will show that, as technical progress is not exogenous (Ong Reference Ong1980; Cottrell and Darity Reference Cottrell and Darity1988; Sinha Reference Sinha1998), the decrease in the rate of labor demand cannot be an ongoing process. More generally, the apparent laws of supply and demand for labor produce a quite different picture from that of the law of accumulation, under which capital artificially produces a relative surplus population (section VI). The deepest flaw of Hollander’s analysis does not come from what he tries to ignore, but from his deliberate exclusion of the specifically Marxian categories of “labor power” and of “wages” defined as value of labor power (2008, p. 90). Since, for Marx, the purchase of labor power is very different from the living labor, which produces value during the working day, these categories allow for not only an account for the origin and nature of the capitalist exploitation, but also an argument against the law of population and more generally the law of supply and demand for labor in the Classics. Indeed, these categories permit an analysis of mechanisms that increase labor supply without increasing the number of workers. Thus, technical progress—i.e., the law of increasing organic composition of capital—is endogenous, since capitalists are forced by competition to find methods of producing relative surplus value. As we will see, this way of increasing surplus labor and decreasing necessary labor can produce a surplus population independently of the absolute population growth, or even “the introduction of capital-intensive methods of production in agriculture and the decaying part of the capitalist sector” (Ramirez Reference Ramirez1986, p. 546). Section VII summarizes the law of supply and demand for labor in connection with the law of relative surplus value, and justifies the ineffectiveness of birth control. Section VIII concludes.
II. BRIEF HISTORY OF THE “ABSOLUTE IMMIZERATION” DOCTRINE
The debate about the immizeration of the working class originates, in fact, from the development of the industrial revolution and the transformation of the agricultural population into wage workers. From 1790 to 1845, the deterioration of the workers’ living conditions was so spectacular that most of the discussions at the time did not concern the reality of impoverishment, but focused on its causes and remedies. Today, while the decline of real purchasing power is probably still in debate among historians, there is, nonetheless, a minimum agreement that “the mere change from the traditional diet of the pre-industrial man to the ignorant as well as impoverished free purchase of the urbanized and industrial one was likely to lead to worse feeding, just as the conditions of urban life and work were likely to lead to worse health” (Hobsbawm Reference Hobsbawm1962, p. 206. See also Thompson Reference Thompson1968, p. 351; and Rule Reference Rule1986, pp. 27–43).
Yet, at the time when Engels and Marx were starting to develop analyses on the law of wages under a capitalist regime, the workers’ living conditions were beginning to improve in such a way that henceforth the issue was to know if immizeration was absolute or only relative to the bourgeoisie’s standard of living. While, in 1844, Engels still supported that “only the very barest necessities, the mere means of subsistence, fall to the lot of labour” (1844, p. 441), in the Manuscripts of 1844, Marx starts to consider relative impoverishment (1844, p. 238). He evokes the minimum wage only as a law recommended by the economists (1844, p. 239). Furthermore, in The Condition of the Working Class in England (1845), Engels denied that any law irreversibly tended to workers’ absolute impoverishment. Workers’ competition undoubtedly tends to lower wages to their minimum, but when the labor market is balanced, the average wages stands, in fact, a little above the minimum (1845, p. 378). Moreover, Engels explicitly refutes Malthus’ law of population, and originates surplus population in the workers’ competition prompted by capital (1845, p. 380). On the other hand, from 1847 onwards, both Marx and Engels, respectively in Wages (1847, pp. 425–426) and in Principles of Communism (1847, p. 343), support the idea that the development of machinery within capitalism tends to lower wages to their minimum by de-skilling labor. Thus, in the Manifesto of the Communist Party, they write that “[t]he various interests and conditions of life within the ranks of the proletariat are more and more equalised, in proportion as machinery obliterates all distinctions of labour, and nearly everywhere reduces wages to the same low level” (1848, p. 492). Soon after the publication of the Manifesto, Bruno Hildebrand contested that industrial workers’ living standards were always getting worse, inaugurating in this way the debate on immizeration. Having said this, excepting the fall in the value of labor power caused by machinery, Marx and Engels exclude any law of impoverishment related to overpopulation. Indeed, pauperism “develops more rapidly than population and wealth” (1848, p. 495). The development of trade unions and social welfare legislation, on the one hand, and the recurrent cycles of expansion, crisis, and depression, on the other hand, profoundly changed Marx’s views on the evolution of wages from 1857 at the latest. The attribution to Marx’s mature works of a doctrine of minimum wage with respect to population growth comes from the confusion, consolidated by Arnold Toynbee’s Lectures (1896, p. 13), between Marx’s wages theory and the positions defended by Lassalle and the Social Democratic Party of Germany on the iron law of wages.
Since then, the debate on immizeration within Marxism has opposed three positions: first, Marx’s wage theory is wrong because absolute immizeration has not occurred, what was claimed by Eduard Bernstein [1911]; second, either this theory allows for the possibility of increasing real wages, nothwithstanding relative immizeration, and thus correctly depicting the condition of the working class, as Georgi Plekhanov (1901) argued against Peter Struve; or, third, the immizeration doctrine is correct and forms a fundamental component of Marxism since immizeration grows with the development of capitalism. This was the view that Rosa Luxemburg (1900) defended against the reformist orientation of the Second International.
In the history of Marxism, Bernstein was the first to attribute fallaciously the “absolute immizeration” doctrine to Marx (Tudor and Tudor Reference Tudor and Tudor1988). His revisionism rejected the idea that socialism would result from the worsening of social relations, as orthodox Marxism of the Second International supposedly claimed. This idea was indeed in contradiction to the historical trend of the end of the nineteenth century, at a time when the middle class was growing and the material conditions of the working class were improving (1988, p. 288).
During the era of Mixed Economy, many academics challenged the doctrine for various reasons. William J. Baumol vigorously recalled to what extent Marx was opposed to Lassalian’s iron law of wages, especially since “Marx was anxious to show that workers have the power to raise wages substantially even under capitalism” (Baumol Reference Baumol1983, p. 303). However, Allin Cottrell and William A. Darity (1988) rightly pointed out that the iron law of wages does not exclude any process of equilibrium tending towards a subsistence wage.
Miguel D. Ramirez (Reference Ramirez1986) and Kenneth Lapides (Reference Lapides1994) showed that the declining wage concerned the value of the labor power, which may be associated perfectly with an increase in real wages. Ronald L. Meek (1967), on the other hand, defends relative immizeration by comparison with the growth of real profits, but stresses the strength of counter-tendencies with respect to relative as well as to absolute immizeration. More recently, Ramirez again stressed the distinction between the active part of the labor force, which would suffer a relative deterioration in its social position, and the surplus population, which would experience a fall in its standard of living during the evolution of capitalism (Ramirez Reference Ramirez2007).
All these interpretations are based on more or less explicit quotations in Marx’s economic writings regarding the evolution of wages. It follows at least from their reading that Marx made neither any hypothesis on the wage trend nor any prediction on its direction. However, this paper emphasizes, rather, that Marx’s opposition to absolute impoverishment naturally follows his specific approach to the business cycle. According to Hollander, the decreasing real-wage trend in Capital proves Marx’s deep affinity with the Classics; i.e., that the increase in organic composition of capital expresses Ricardo/Malthus’ law of population in another manner, but leading to exactly the same result (2008, p. 381). As Hollander’s interpretation of Marx aims at showing the filiation of Capital with the Classics, my emphasis of the mechanisms of supply and demand for labor will show that Marx’s opposition to Ricardo/Malthus’ law of population relies on economic laws based on categories such as labor power and wages, necessary and surplus labor. The novelty of categories, which Hollander finds unnecessary for the analysis of Capital, founds the originality of Marx's critical method.
III. SUBSISTENCE WAGE AND POPULATION GROWTH
For the time being, let us suppose with Hollander that the ongoing decrease of the real wage comes from an excess of workers in relation to labor demand. At what point will this fatal decline cease to exist? We know that the worker’s wage in Marx has at least two components. Wages must first satisfy the worker’s physiological needs, those that allow him/her to reproduce him/herself as a mere worker. But, as a social individual, the worker has historical needs and consumes goods that express these more refined needs. If the wage decreases, the worker must sacrifice those goods first. Given these two wage components, what does the concept of a minimum wage signify? Hollander claims that an answer can be found in Value, Price and Profit. In this 1865 collection, Marx states that, with a minimum wage, the worker can only “maintain and reproduce itself, … perpetuate its physical existence”; i.e., “the physical perpetuation of the race” (Marx 1865, p. 144). It means that the worker may reproduce himself without an absolute increase in population (2008, p. 92). Ramirez (Reference Ramirez1986) has observed that the decrease stated by Marx does not concern the real wage, but the value of labor power, which does not exclude constant, or even increased, real wage. However, Hollander’s interpretation remains valid on this point, since it is true that here Marx clearly points out a general worsening of conditions, which is perhaps not limited to a decline in the value of the goods basket. According to Hollander, real wages would continue to decline until the working population reproduces itself without absolute growth, so that an absolute population growth should belong to the historical component of wages.
In connection to this, Ajit Sinha (Reference Sinha1998) responded that the definition given in Value, Price and Profit includes the word “multiply”: “the working class must receive the necessaries absolutely indispensable for living and multiplying” (Marx 1865, p. 144). Since Hollander did not change his view, was this because he was searching for Ricardo’s definition of wages? In his Principles, Ricardo states, at the beginning of the chapter on wages, that the natural price of labor “is that price which is necessary to enable the labourers, one with another, to subsist and to perpetuate their race, without increase or diminution” (1821, p. 93). Perhaps this explains why the words “perpetuation,” “conservation,” or “maintain” strongly suggest to Hollander that “reproduction” involves a zero growth of population (2008, p. 91, n. 8). Yet, on the other hand, a cursory survey of Marx’s texts prior to Value, Price and Profitgoes beyond merely suggesting what Marx means by the physiological reproduction of the labor power.
In Poverty of Philosophy, we read: “what is needed to produce this labor-commodity? Just enough labor time to produce the objects indispensable to the constant maintenance of labor, that is, to keep the worker alive and in a condition to propagate his race” (Marx 1847, p. 125). Almost the same definition is in the Speech on the Question of Free Trade: “what is the minimum of wages? Just so much as is required for production of the articles indispensable for the maintenance of the worker, for putting him in a position to sustain himself, however badly, and to propagate his race, however slightly” (Marx 1848, p. 462). In the same work, further on: “But do not imagine that the worker receives only this minimum wage, and still less that he always receives it.… But what of that? The class will still exist; nay, more, it will have increased.” (Marx 1848, p. 462). One year later, in Wage Labour and Capital, Marx states that
the cost of production of simple labor-power must include the cost of propagation, by means of which the race of workers is enabled to multiply itself, and to replace worn-out workers with new ones.… Thus, the cost of production of simple labor-power amounts to the cost of the existence and propagation of the worker (Marx 1849, p. 215).
Although Hollander affirms that there is a “wealth of statements pointing to zeropopulation growth at the minimum limit” (2008, p. 91, n. 9), he was able to find only one excerpt from Volume I, but that is preceded by a restrictive locution, in order not to anticipate the necessary conditions for the development of capitalist production. Also, as shall be developed further, the net population growth is not only extraneous to these conditions, but totally insufficient for the progress of accumulation:
The labour-power withdrawn from the market by wear and tear and death, must be continually replaced by, at the very least, an equal amount of fresh labour-power. Hence the sum of the means of subsistence necessary for the production of labour-power must include the means necessary for the labourer’s substitutes, i.e., his children, in order that this race of peculiar commodity-owners may perpetuate its appearance in the market (Marx 1867, p. 182; my emphasis).
Thomas Sowell (Reference Sowell2006, pp. 160–161) has criticized Hollander for having neglected the historical side of the subsistence wage. It must be said, on the contrary, that the net population growth is implied in the conditions of the workers’ subsistence, or, at least, that the subsistence wage entails the natural growth of the working class. There is indeed a “wealth of statements” that demonstrate how Marx differentiates himself from the Classics and how net growth belongs to the basic conditions of reproduction of the labor power. Furthermore, Hollander himself recognizes that there are few statements about a stationary state in Capital (2008, pp. 98–99). Having said this, we have to understand the way an excess of population emerges during the accumulation process and relates to the demand for labor.
IV. SURPLUS POPULATION AND BUSINESS CYCLE
In a comment concerning Hollander’s paper on Marx and Malthusianism (1984), Ramirez challenges his explanation of secular decline as a result of “the divergence between the respective growth rates in population and the demand for labor power” (1986, p. 543). If there were a decline in the value of labor power (not in the real wage), it could only be the result of the “increasing productivity of labor.” In his response, Hollander stresses that the internal population growth can meet the growing demand in child labor, which justifies control of the birth rate (1986, p. 549). Therefore, why does the working class spread beyond the needs of capital before the wage reaches the subsistence level? He claims that the factory workers’ pitiful means of living provoke them to early marriages and overstimulate their procreative instincts. The main feature of this phenomenon would be that “The net increase in labor supply in the modern industrial sector is thus a consequence of population growth internal to that sector, rather than of an inflow into that sector from (say) agriculture” (2008, p. 94). This phenomenon could also have proved to him that the surplus population does not depend on the wage level. However, before examining the origin and nature of the surplus population in Capital, it should be noted that this excerpt focuses on the specific conditions of the working population growth in the factory sector. Marx notices that workers in this sector quickly become unable to work—they are “used up” by the extremely harsh labor conditions. They soon become unexploitable, so that only a high birth rate, combined with early marriages, is able to replenish the factory labor market. Here, explains Marx,
In order to conform to these circumstances, the absolute increase of this section of the proletariat must take place under conditions that shall swell their numbers, although the individual elements are used up rapidly. Hence, rapid renewal of the generations of labourers.... (this law does not hold for the other classes of the population) (1867, p. 636).
But this proves to Hollander that surplus population in generalresults from early marriages and birth rates (2008, p. 106). Yet, the factory workers’ case proves, on the contrary, that the balance of supply and demand for labor may not be in contradiction to a surplus population. Although the surplus population increases, factories need a permanent flow of young male workers, who enter the reserve army as soon as they come of age. This explains why surplus population here “forms an element of the floating surplus population, growing with the extension of those branches of industry” (1996, p. 635). The specific paradox of this sector of production is that the natural increase in the number of factory workers does not meet the needs of the capital accumulation on the one hand, while, on the other hand, it exceeds those needs. The specific conditions of exploitation involved in factories do not show that surplus population is derived from an excessive birth rate in general, but that this sector always produces workers who are unable to be used for its needs, even if the truly exploitable labor market is balanced or if the supply of labor is insufficient.
Hollander is willing to recognize the benefits of a surplus population for capitalists, insofar as this surplus contributes to short-term business cycles. He provides many references from Capitalrelating to the urgent need for capital to have idle workers at its disposal (2008, p. 100). He also quotes excerpts that are related to the pressure the reserve army exerts on active workers during times of prosperity (2008, p. 101). Moreover, he notes that the changing needs of capital require a growing number of workers, and that this does not depend on natural population growth. As Marx said, “Capitalist production can by no means content itself with the quantity of disposable labour power which the natural increase of population yields. It requires for its free play an industrial reserve army independent of these natural limits” (1867, p. 629). Thus, Hollander does not deny the usefulness of this overpopulation during the successive business cycles. But he denies that these means are produced by these cycles: capital production is cyclical, owing to the fact that the supply of, and demand for, labor remain consistently unbalanced.
He recognizes that the reserve army depends on business cycles, but not that these cycles generate a reserve army. He recognizes that the cyclical nature of capitalist production requires a reserve army at its disposal, but not that the reserve army is created by capitalist production itself. This paradox is founded on the overall approach of Capital,according to which economics can be reduced to the pure mechanisms of supply and demand, which sooner or later tend towards balance. In order to transform Marx into a classical economist, Hollander needs to argue as a neoclassical economist. In this way, if there weren’t a constant excess of workers, the supply of capital would not periodically exceed labor demand; the cyclical tendency and its vicissitudes would soften and eventually disappear, if the working class were to adapt its supply to the decreased needs of capital, which are an “ongoing process, proceeding at an ever-faster rate” (2008, p. 100).
Here, we can grasp the underlying hypothesis on which this section of Hollander’s book is based: as soon as wages have reached the zero-growth population level, unemployment and, therefore, all kinds of business cycle would disappear. A stationary balance would have been attained, since labor demand, and thus the organic composition of capital, would have stopped increasing. However, in the meantime, Hollander suggests that the working class adapts its growth to the decreasing growth of labor demand (2008, p. 109). Indeed, as we shall soon see, he believes that the imbalance between labor and capital is, above all, derived from the forthcoming surplus population produced by growth of population, and not from the presentsurplus population produced by growth of capital. Hollander created the possibility of making this difference with his theory of dual labor force.
V. THE THEORY OF DUAL LABOR FORCE AND HOLLANDER’S DUAL THEORY
The above analysis proposes that, while the present surplus population increases the valorization of capital during the short-term business cycle, only absolute population growth may decrease the real wage over the long-term trend. To support this view, Hollander needed a theory that discards the role of the present surplus population in the real-wage trend. He found it in the theory of dual labor force, according to which workers are divided into skilled and unskilled workers, the latter group being those who are unable to take part in advanced production sectors (2008, p. 88). Thus, although the surplus population supplies the necessary labor force contingent for flexible capitalist development, this would not affect active workers’ wages, since definitively de-skilled workers, who are forced to retrain in intensive labor sectors, would fill the industrial reserve army. The theory of dual labor force should prove “the downward secular path of earnings of the ’active’ industrial workers determined by the market forces described in this chapter, independently of the existence of pools of unemployment and semi-employed” (2008, p. 106). For Hollander, only absolute population growth should explain the excess of active workers in the labor market.
However, here again, the way in which he “arranges” his quotations to support his thesis gives cause for alarm:
“There are not too many means of production produced to employ the able-bodied portion of the population. Quite the reverse. In the first place, too large a portion of the produced population is not really capable of working, and this through force of circumstances made dependent on exploiting the labour of others, or on labour which can pass under this name only under a miserable mode of production. In the second place, not enough means of production are produced to permit the employment of the entire able-bodied population under the most productive conditions, so that their absolute working period could be shortened by the mass and effectiveness of the constant capital employed during working hours” (Marx 1894, pp. 256–257, quoted in Hollander Reference Hollander2008, p. 102).
This excerpt is actually taken from the subsection “Excess Capital and Excess Population,” in which Marx explains the meaning of the expression “absolute overproduction of capital,” particularly when capital takes on the form of means of production. Does Marx refer to an overproduction in general; i.e., an overproduction of the means of production with respect to the population that is able to work? He makes it clear that “It is over-production of means of production only in so far as the latter serve as capital,and consequently include a self-expansion of value, must produce an additional value in proportion to the increased mass” (1894, p. 254). Therefore, there is overproduction with regard to a mode of production based on capital, which implies a surplus population who lives off others’ labor (unproductive workers), on the one hand, and a surplus population, which is still linked to outdated modes of production (handicrafts, etc.), on the other hand. But what makes the industrial surplus population unexploitable? It is certainly not the fact that it does not possess the skills required by modern production processes, since too much capital awaiting valorization has been produced, irrespective of the level of skill of the workers in excess. Thus, it is not labor but the means to exploit labor that became ‘unexploitable’: “It is no contradiction that this over-production of capital is accompanied by more or less considerable relative over-population” (1894, p. 254). A part of the active population’s labor becomes indeed unexploitable because
these same circumstances have also created, and continuously create, a relative overpopulation, an over-population of labourers not employed by the surplus-capital owing to the low degree of exploitation at which alone they could be employed, or at least owing to the low rate of profit which they would yield at the given degree of exploitation … such capital is absolute excess capital for the employed labouring population and for the home country in general (1894, p. 255).
A part of the active population’s labor does, in fact, become unexploitable, not because too few means of labor are produced but, on the contrary, because “too many means of labour and necessities of life are produced at times to permit of their serving as means for the exploitation of labourers at a certain rate of profit” (1894, p. 257).
VI. RELATIVE SURPLUS VALUE AND ENDOGENOUS TECHNICAL PROGRESS IN CAPITAL
Both the decreasing real-wage trend and the appropriateness of birth rate control rest on the hypothesis that the decreasing demand for labor is an ongoing process. As Hollander claims in making this hypothesis, he must simultaneously assume that technical progress is an exogenous variable; i.e., that it is unrelated to the evolution of wages and labor supply.
Concerning the legal restrictions to extend the working day, Marx notes that:
So soon as the gradually surging revolt of the working-class compelled Parliament to shorten compulsorily the hours of labour, and to begin by imposing a normal working-day on factories proper, so soon consequently as an increased production of surplus-value by the prolongation of the working-day was once for all put a stop to, from that moment capital threw itself with all its might into the production of relative surplus-value, by hastening on the further improvement of machinery (1867, pp. 412–413).
Given the working day, the means to decrease necessary labor and increase surplus labor are called by Marx ‘means of producing relative surplus value.’ In the age of modern industry, this law is realized through technical progress. In a sense, all forms of technical progress, from new machines to saving of raw materials, contribute to increase the relative surplus value, as they participate in lowering the value of commodities that enter directly and indirectly into working-class consumption. Even when technical progress improves the capitalist sectors unrelated to the production of these commodities, the extra profits mean that the worker has worked less for himself and more for the capitalist. Therefore, technical progress must be said to be endogenous by definition, and “will depend upon circumstances and possibilities as well as upon managerial predilections. The course of technological change under such conditions appears hard to predict” (Harvey 1982, p. 120). But a more specific case of the endogeneity of technical progress also exists. In fact, if a new machine, for example, is able to save labor and thus increase the organic composition of capital, it would never be introduced if the cost of the paid labor it replaces is, as Ricardo had already emphasized (1821, p. 392), not higher than the cost of labor to produce it. It follows that if the living labor necessary to produce commodities were reduced by half by a new machine, the capitalist would refuse to buy it if the price of production, and hence the rate of profit, remained unchanged, despite the fact that the value of depreciation “must be more than offset by the reduction in value resulting from the decrease in living labour.… For a society producing under capitalist conditions the commodity has not cheapened. The new machine is no improvement for it. The capitalist is, therefore, not interested in introducing it” (Marx 1894, pp. 260–261). Cottrell and Darity (Reference Cottrell and Darity1988) have rightly challenged Hollander’s hypothesis by claiming that the rising organic composition of capital is due to high wages and low reserve army. Here, indeed, the endogenous nature of technical progress comes from the fact that it depends on wages and thus on the level of surplus population:
Since the division of the day’s work into necessary and surplus labour differs in different countries, and even in the same country at different periods, or in different branches of industry; and further, since the actual wage of the labourer at one time sinks below the value of his labour power, at another rises above it, it is possible for the difference between the price of machinery and the price of the labour power replaced by that machinery to vary very much, although the difference between the quantity of labour requisite to produce the machine and the total quantity replaced by it, remain constant (Marx 1867, p. 396).
Let us note that new machines are not only sometimes contrary to workers’ interests but are also sometimes contrary to the interests of landowners. Marx quotes the case of English farmers who “had recourse to a reduction of production costs, among other things by the mass production of steam-engines and new machinery” because rents did not decrease after the increase in the price of corn. Moreover, this brought about “in part, an artificial over-population by throwing agricultural day-labourers out of work, and thereby caused a new drop in wages” (1894, p. 622). Therefore, machinery did not exclusively limit the increase of wages that a decrease in labor supply would have brought about, since the decrease occurred “in spite of the overall relative decrease in agricultural population during that decade as compared with the growth of total population, and in spite of an absolute decrease in agricultural population in some purely agricultural districts” (1894, pp. 622–623). In this respect, Hollander’s quoting of the specific case of Ireland and the brutal transformations in its agricultural sector as an exception to the so-called law of interrelation between the decrease of wages and the increase in population seems rather laughable.
When a capitalist replaces variable capital with constant capital, states Marx, this not only releases “the labourers immediately turned out by the machines, but also their future substitutes in the rising generation, and the additional contingent, that with the usual extension of trade on the old basis would be regularly absorbed” (1867, p. 633). According to Hollander, this statement concerns “the more difficult absorption of the additional labouring population through the usual channels” (1867, p. 633; Hollander’s emphasis). But this quotation is immediately preceded by the following passage:
Considering the social capital in its totality, the movement of its accumulation now causes periodical changes, affecting it more or less as a whole, now distributes its various phases simultaneously over the different spheres of production. In some spheres a change in the composition of capital occurs without increase of its absolute magnitude, as a consequence of simple centralization; in others the absolute growth of capital is connected with absolute diminution of its variable constituent, or of the labour power absorbed by it; in others again, capital continues growing for a time on its given technical basis, and attracts additional labour power in proportion to its increase, while at other times it undergoes organic change, and lessens its variable constituent; in all spheres, the increase of the variable part of capital, and therefore of the number of labourers employed by it, is always connected with violent fluctuations and transitory production of surplus population, whether this takes the more striking form of the repulsion of labourers already employed, or the less evident but not less real form of the more difficult absorption of the additional labouring population through the usual channels (1867, pp. 624–625).
We see that the working class should not only adapt its growth to capital’s tendency to increase the organic composition, but, at the same time, it must meet the needs of additional workers in sectors of production in which organic composition does not rise in an “ongoing process” but remains stable for a certain period of time. Therefore, if a growing population is barely employed by an accumulated additional capital, it is not because variable capital decreases in an ongoing process related to constant capital, nor because it decreases at an increasingly higher rate; but because it is constantly subjected to either a sudden increase or a brutal decrease in demand, either simultaneously within different sectors, or successively, with respect to global capital.
Let us initially assume that this leads to imbalance in the labor market. Does it also lead to a decrease in real wages (2008, p. 98)? Hollander finds evidence in the following excerpt from Capital: “the first word of this adaptation [of variable into constant capital] is the creation of a relative surplus population, or industrial reserve arm” (1867, p. 638). If we replace the square brackets by the real subject stated just before the excerpt, we find:
The folly is now patent of the economic wisdom that preaches to the labourers the accommodation of their number to the requirements of capital. The mechanism of capitalist production and accumulation constantly effects this adjustment. The first word of this adaptation is the creation of a relative surplus population, or industrial reserve army. Its last word is the misery of constantly extending strata of the active army of labour, and the dead weight of pauperism (1867, pp. 638–639).
Not only is there no explicit mention of real wages, but, rather, the “adaptation” in question concerns the level of population in relation to capital’s need for valorization, and does not deal at all with variable and constant capital. Moreover, in this passage, Marx examines the adaptation of population without making any allusion to an excess of absolute population growth in relation to an increase of labor demand. On the contrary, Marx notes that the productive population grows more slowly than capital does. If we continue the excerpt quoted, this becomes unambiguous:
The fact that the means of production, and the productiveness of labour, increase more rapidly than the productive population, expresses itself, therefore, capitalistically in the inverse form that the labouring population always increases more rapidly than the conditions under which capital can employ this increase for its own self-expansion (1867, p. 639).
This clearly shows that Hollander expresses the origin and evolution of relative surplus population in precisely the opposite terms to those of Capital: “Absolute labor demand is thus expanding though at a decelerating rate. A fall in the wage can only be explained by too rapid a growth rate of labor supply” (2008, p. 98).
In conclusion, Hollander also finds “apparently” mysterious the following excerpt, in which Marx seems to deny any absolute of population growth. This could cause doubts to appear concerning the conception of population, which touches on “an apparently absolute increase of the laboring population” (quoted in pp. 99–100):
This accelerated relative diminution of the variable constituent, that goes along with the accelerated increase of the total capital, and moves more rapidly than this increase, takes the inverse form, at the other pole, of an apparently absolute increase of the labouring population, an increase always moving more rapidly than that of the variable capital or the means of employment (1867, p. 624).
However, for Hollander, the doubt is only an appearance, as soon as we understand that surplus population is not due to absolute population growth, but to a decrease of labor demand in relation to population growth; i.e., labor supply. Perhaps what troubles him is that Marx does not claim at all that population growth is merely apparent. This would have been a denial that population effectively grows as capitalist production progresses. In fact, Marx claims that the progress of capitalist production moves forward under the appearance (scheint auf umgekehrt); i.e., under the inverted movement of absolute population growth, and this occurs without any absolute increase of population. In other words, the laws of accumulation and surplus population have an origin that is exactly the opposite of the one Hollander apparently wishes to describe; namely, an imbalance between growth in both labor demand and labor supply.
VII. THE MARXIAN LAW OF SUPPLY AND DEMAND FOR LABOR
The time has come to present Marx’s understanding of the supply and demand for labor. It appears very different from the Classics’ conception on which Hollander based his reading of Capital. Moreover, Marx’s original approach precludes any hypothesis on real-wage trend and a role of population growth in the labor supply. In spite of, and because of, the excerpts quoted by Hollander, we have seen that labor demand has an absolutely unpredictable rhythm of evolution, and that capitalist production yields through methods of surplus value a surplus population that is entirely unrelated to absolute population growth. But having said this, would it still be possible for workers to decrease their growth rate, and, thus, the reserve army used that is needed for the accumulation process? This case would imply that labor supply might be identified with the supply of workers. In other words, capital could not employ more labor without employing more workers. However, by distinguishing labor power from labor effectively realizedby the worker, Marx points out mechanisms of variations of supply and demand for labor that are partly unrelated to the supply and demand for workers.
Hollander’s omission of these mechanisms, such as the extension and intensification of labor, or employment of population strata previously untouched by capitalism (2008, pp. 104–105), is due to his exclusion of the category of labor power as distinct from labor. This is intentionally from his analysis, since he is convinced that it “plays no particular role in the positive analysis of the labor market,” and since wages appear as a labor price, and not as a labor power price (2008, p. 90).
In a pure (neo)classical manner, Hollander states a specific relation between a wage fund, on the one side, and a mass of employed workers, on the other side. This statement comes from one of the postulates of political economy that regards the working day as a fixed quantity and the wage as the price of labor (Mill 1871, pp. 337–338). But as soon as wages are defined as the value of labor power, this connection can express very different labor quantities and labor prices.
First, the extension of labor time or the intensification of labor during a given labor time means that more labor is produced with the same variable capital (Marx 1861–1864, pp. 317 and 324). This increases labor supply without increasing the number of workers. It is true that Hollander mentions this case, but in order to underestimate it, since “increasing effort is at most a supplementary force exerting downward pressure on the wage than as an alternative to expanded labor supply” (2008, p. 105). We have already seen that capital in the factory sector also had to face the restrictions to population growth. Yet, even if we exclude this case, variable capital can also increase with the extension of labor, without increasing the number of workers. Particularly with an increase in wages, ”a larger variable capital sets more labour in action without enlisting more labourers” (Marx 1867, p. 629). This occurs especially when this increase does not offset the increase in the ratio of surplus value to advanced capital. For Marx, indeed, increasing labor without increasing the number of workers is one of the main means of saving constant capital:
It is the absolute interest of every capitalist to press a given quantity of labour out of a smaller, rather than a greater number of labourers, if the cost is about the same. In the latter case, the outlay of constant capital increases in proportion to the mass of labour set in action; in the former that increase is much smaller. The more extended the scale of production, the stronger this motive. Its force increases with the accumulation of capital (1867, p. 629).
Therefore, extension or intensification of labor allows a given or higher variable capital to increase the amount of labor with the same level of labor power.
Second, and in the same way, this given variable capital allows, with the help of machinery, a higher level of unskilled labor power to the detriment of skilled workers. Contrary to the theory of dual labor force, Marx has always claimed that, in its first stage, modern industry replaced skilled and complex labor by unskilled and simple labor (Marx 1867, p. 466; and 1861–1863, p. 321).
However, the theory of dual labor force implies a part of surplus population periodically unexploitable by the new industrial modes of production. But Marx categorically denies that this surplus population leaves the value of labor power unchanged:
That portion of the working-class, thus by machinery rendered superfluous, i.e., no longer immediately necessary for the self-expansion of capital, either goes to the wall in the unequal contest of the old handicrafts and manufactures with machinery, or else floods all the more easily accessible branches of industry, swamps the labour-market, and sinks the price of labour-power below its value (Marx 1867, p. 434).
Yet, this tendency to replace skilled labor by formerly unexploitable labor power occurs precisely in sectors that were at the forefront of capitalist industry, such as gas factories, telegraphy, photography, steam shipping, and railways (Marx 1867, p. 448). Thus, machinery swells the reserve army; it produces “by opening out to the capitalist new strata of the working-class, previously inaccessible to him, partly by setting free the labourers it supplants, a surplus working population, which is compelled to submit to the dictation of capital” (Marx 1867, p. 411).
However, it is true that Hollander alludes to this de-skilling process when he mentions women’s and children’s entry into the labor market and the resulting decrease in wages (2008, p. 106). But he just conceives women’s and children’s labor in relation to the absolute growth of labor supply; i.e., as an additional form of proof that absolute population growth encourages a decrease in wages:
Population growth is thus actually stimulated by accumulation given capitalist factory conditions, such new additions finding their way rapidly into the labor market—there is no need to wait the standard generation of 20–25 years. Considering the net expansion of demand for labor as a whole that is supposed, demographic considerations must, we conclude, be introduced to account for falling wages in the broad marketfor labor (2008, p. 106).
But even if wages express the price of the labor power, they can express very different prices of labor, depending on the duration and intensity of the working day: “the daily and weekly wages, &c., may remain the same, although the price of labour falls constantly” (Marx 1867, p. 542).
Surplus population is boththe principal cause and the specific result of the many cases in which the amount of labor increases without increasing the number of workers. In all these cases, the reserve army does not push the wages down, but whips the active army and increases the length and intensity of labor. In a sense, these mechanisms, no doubt, imply a surplus population that Hollander wishes to see disappear via the birth-rate control. Moreover, inasmuch as the active army works longer and more intensively, it increases the reserve army over and above the absolute growth of population. Thus, as Marx notes, when accumulation increases “the supply of labourers by the ‘setting free’ of them” by increasing labor demand, “the pressure of the unemployed compels those that are employed to furnish more labour, and therefore makes the supply of labour, to a certain extent, independent of the supply of labourers” (1867, p. 634). Next, insofar as wages are partly unrelated to the effective quantity of labor or, in other words, insofar as the labor supply becomes unrelated to the number of workers, the surplus population itself becomes unrelated to population growth.
The mechanisms analyzed above have shown that supply and demand for labor can no longer be viewed as a law according to which two unrelated quantities confront each other, but as a law that permanently adapts the labor supply to the current needs of the capital in activity.
Thus, relative surplus population is the setting in which the law of supply and demand for labor evolves. It puts at the capitalists’ disposal an extra labor force for the peaks of the business cycle, as Hollander acknowledges, and contains wages within acceptable limits during the normal phases of the cycle. As we have seen, surplus population is the joint product of the accumulation of capital.
But more profoundly, surplus population both conditions, and results from, the very purpose of capitalist production: the production of surplus labor. In order to reach this objective, capital must set in motion necessary labor, which is the condition of surplus labor, and thus keep at its disposal an abundant population; but it must also lower necessary labor in order to increase surplus labor; hence, permanently produce an excess of population (Marx 1857–1858, p. 326). Thus, for Marx, the law of supply and demand for labor is not governed by the relationship between a wage fund and a mass of workers, but by the changing relationship between necessary and surplus labor within a given quantity of social labor.
All of Hollander’s analysis reduces the rising organic composition of capital to a law regarding the decrease of labor demand. He does not seem to notice that the relative surplus value expresses the more basic law concerning the decrease of necessary labor and the increase of surplus labor. Yet, this law involves not only a decreased demand for workers, but also an increased surplus labor from active workers, at the same time. Hence, increasing variable capital does not necessarily mean increasing “demand for labor.” Furthermore, the increase in variable capital can give rise to surplus workers without any increase in population. As we have seen, capital operates on both sides of the labor market simultaneously (1867, p. 633).
Given this capitalist law of population, Marx’s skepticism about a birth-rate control is unambiguous, notwithstanding the growth of supply in labor due to capital-intensive methods in agriculture and decaying capital sectors (Ramirez Reference Ramirez1986). Nevertheless, it does not prevent Hollander from remaining convinced that Marx was more Malthusian than he generally claims, particularly through his comments on the statistics related to capitalist production and population growth in England between 1846 and 1866. Marx combines these statistics with the English General Registrator’s speech, which stresses a lower growth in population in relation to the progress in industry and increase in wealth. However, comments Hollander, “Notwithstanding effective population control, living standards (Marx supposed) were falling, presumably because in his view the growth rate of labor demand was declining even faster” (2008, p. 107). Yet, it is Hollander who wrongly “supposed” that a birth-rate control is the issue at stake. Indeed, for Marx, the General Registrator’s speech gives support to one of the main general laws of capitalist production: “The stupendous productivity developing under the capitalist mode of production relative to population, and the increase, if not in the same proportion, of capital-values (not just of their material substance) … grow much more rapidly than the population” (1894, p. 265). And this increase, as we now know, cannot grow at an ongoing process.
VIII. CONCLUSION
The hypotheses on which Hollander bases the so-called “absolute immizeration” doctrine in his book on Marx are entirely unsupported by Capital. First, we have seen that no statement exists that would suggest that the subsistence wage involves zero growth in population, or that technical progress is exogenous. Thus, the decrease in labor demand cannot be viewed as an ongoing process. Second, it has been shown that the general equilibrium approach prevented an emphasis on the nature and mechanisms of the business cycle, and, hence, the way in which it produces a relative surplus population. Third, the endogeneity of technical progress also dismisses any ongoing process of increasing organic composition of capital.
However, the most important shortcoming of Hollander’s analysis lies in its deliberate omission of the specifically Marxian conception of: first, classical categories such as wages and labor power, by which Marx distinguishes the value of the labor power and the value produced by labor; and second, laws of capitalist production related to these categories, the first of which being the decrease of necessary labor and the increase of surplus labor. These laws and categories allowed Marx to emphasize mechanisms of supply and demand for labor that were partly unrelated to the supply and demand for workers. These mechanisms, in turn, whereby capital accomplishes these laws, create an artificial surplus population irrespective of the absolute growth of population, and, consequently, rules out any form of policy for birth-rate control.
