Until the last quarter of the twentieth century, few nations around the world felt compelled to protect historic shipwrecks and other underwater cultural heritage (UCH) from vandalism and exploitation. However, as long-lost shipwrecks became more accessible through the growing popularity of scuba diving and increasingly sophisticated underwater search and salvage technology, the need for such legislation became more apparent. Dromgoole's first edition of this book, Legal Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage: National and International Perspectives (The Hague: Kluwer, 1999), provided a much-needed look at how various nations were coming to grips with the problem through domestic legislation. In the first edition, 13 essays explored a wide variety of legislative schemes from as many nations. A final essay described the ongoing effort to create an international treaty to protect UCH in international waters.
Much has happened since the first edition: New legislation has been created in many countries, and the UNESCO Convention for the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage came into being in 2001. With this new volume, Dromgoole provides updates on legislation in 11 of the 13 nations originally surveyed, plus 5 new ones. Further, all of the essays in this book discuss national responses to the convention.
Several nations whose legislation is described in this book abstained from voting on the convention at its adoption. The United Kingdom, Sweden, Greece, and France all abstained on the final vote, even though they each claim to agree in principle with the convention. These nations and many others were concerned by various aspects of the convention, but a number of patterns emerge. Of widespread concern are articles 9, 10, 16, and 17, which attempt to establish some type of jurisdiction over UCH in the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) of the state's party, without actually extending coastal state jurisdiction into the EEZ. This may sound like a difficult task—and it is. Jurisdiction of any nature in the EEZ is a sensitive issue. A delicate balance was achieved with the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), which grants to coastal nations the exclusive right to explore and exploit the seabed for natural resources in the EEZ but nothing more. In particular, UNCLOS does not confer coastal states jurisdiction over or ownership of UCH lying in the EEZ. Some fear that the convention will upset the delicate balance achieved in UNCLOS. Others argue that, because UNCLOS says nothing on the matter, it is open for the convention to apply its own regime.
In essence, the convention gives coastal states a coordinating role in managing UCH within the EEZ beyond the limits of the contiguous zone, which at most lies 24 nautical miles off shore, and requires member states to establish domestic legislation under which they are to prosecute their nationals and vessels under their flag for improperly damaging UCH lying in the EEZ of any state signatory. These provisions are sometimes accused of allowing creeping jurisdiction into the EEZ.
It is rare for any nation to prosecute its nationals for actions occurring outside its geographical boundaries. The notable exceptions are prosecution for such heinous conduct as war crimes committed abroad and, more recently, pedophile sex tourism. Although it may be argued that damage to the UCH is not quite in the same league as these types of conduct, this is the approach taken by the convention to protect UCH lying beyond the nominal reach of state jurisdiction. It is perhaps not so surprising that a number of nations are uncomfortable with it.
The chapter on French law, in particular, goes into great detail about why France abstained. Apart from the jurisdiction issue, France was also uncomfortable with the convention's apparent indifference to general property rights and, in particular, the rights of flag states over their warships and military aircraft. This is somewhat surprising, given France's history of protecting its cultural assets. Indeed, author Gwénaëlle Le Gurun seems apologetic for France's abstention, noting that not only does France host the headquarters office of UNESCO, but France has never before abstained from voting on a UNESCO treaty.
Sarah Dromgoole's essay on U.K. law expresses the United Kingdom's similar concerns with the convention. A further issue for Britain, given the incalculable number of shipwrecks and other UCH that have sunk off Britain's coast over the millennia, is the convention's lack of a significance criteria, other than the 100-year minimum age. As Dromgoole notes, the United Kingdom believes it is simply impractical to protect every UCH site in its waters, not to mention staggeringly expensive.
Greece may well have been the first nation to protect UCH through legislation adopted in 1834, as Anastasia Strati notes in her essay. Legislative developments in the succeeding 172 years have strengthened Greece's protection of UCH. Nonetheless, Greece also abstained from the final vote; however, Greece was not so much concerned with extending jurisdiction into the EEZ as with the convention's mechanism for managing UCH in the EEZ. According to Strati, Greece felt that “the envisaged scheme of notification/protection of UCH is unnecessarily complicated, as it would require consultations with a number of states, even for the protection of a single statue” (p. 120).
The United States, although not a UNESCO member at the time of the adoption vote and therefore unable to vote, also opposes the convention largely because of the “creeping jurisdiction” concerns, according to the author of the U.S. chapter, Ole Varmer. Like France, the United States is also concerned about the convention's denial of flag state rights over sunken warships and other military or government ships and aircraft. These concerns seem obvious in light of the U.S. Navy's presence in virtually every part of the world and its desire for unfettered passage.
The other surprise is reading which states do not consider the convention's virtual ban on commercial salvage of UCH a hurdle to ratification, and those who do. Although this may be the single most contentious aspect of the convention to the handful of U.S. salvage firms (and their lawyers) who seek to make a living from treasure salvage, in this volume the salvage problem seems to be a minor issue. For example, although the United Kingdom is signatory to the 1989 International Salvage Convention, and has not elected to exclude historic shipwrecks from salvage as convention signatories are allowed to do, the United Kingdom has reserved the right to so exclude such shipwrecks in the future.
Even the United States is less concerned about banning salvage than about the EEZ jurisdiction issue, according to Varmer; virtually every relevant enactment by the U.S. Congress in the last 100 years has been squarely in favor of preservation and protection of archaeological and cultural resources, whether on dry land or the seabed. Treasure salvage continues only because the federal courts continue to grant salvage awards for wrecks found in U.S. waters that are not covered by a particular act of congress. It is conceivable that the U.S. Congress could ban salvage on UCH altogether.
By contrast, one of France's objections to the convention, and a major reason for its abstention, according to Le Gurun, is the convention's lack of respect for property rights in UCH. Although France was more concerned about state property rights than individual property rights, the elevated concern for property rights over UCH comes as something of a surprise from a nation so strongly identified with cultural heritage protection.
Apart from these broader issues of the convention, the book also contains a number of fascinating discussions, many of which reflect the multitude of national interests arising in UCH in any one location:
- A new chapter, by Maija Matikka on UCH protection in Finland, relates the strange case of the wreck Vrouw Maria (sunk in 1771), in which divers under permit from the National Board of Antiquities recovered six artifacts from the wreck and instituted a salvage claim in court. The case confronted the court with deciding whether salvage law trumped Finland's 1963 Antiquities Act; the court upheld the Antiquities Act and denied the salvage claim.
- Nessa O'Connor's chapter on Ireland updates her essay from the first edition. Of note is recent litigation in the Irish courts involving Gregg Bemis's efforts to conduct salvage on the Lusitania (1915). Bemis acquired ownership of the hull, engines, and tackle in the 1980s, which was confirmed by a U.S. Court. However, because the wreck site is subject to an Underwater Heritage Order pursuant to Ireland's National Monuments Acts, Bemis's plans for salvage have been delayed by litigation over the regulatory process imposed by the minister for arts and heritage.
- Australian archaeologist Bill Jeffrey, in addition to updating his comprehensive essay from the first edition on Australian law with insights into how the federal and state governments are beginning to work through some of the weaknesses in Australia's groundbreaking Historic Shipwrecks Act 1976, has also contributed a new chapter on the Federated States of Micronesia, drawing on his extensive work in helping that country develop a tourism-friendly protection scheme for the World War II shipwrecks in Chuuk Lagoon. In particular, Jeffrey manages to explain parts of the complex relationship between Micronesia and the U.S. government, particularly the U.S. National Park Service, which plays a major role in assisting Micronesia with protection and interpretation of Chuuk Lagoon wreck sites.
- A new chapter on UCH protection in the Netherlands explores the highs—such as the 1972 agreement with Australia to protect and study the remains of four Dutch East India Company (VOC) ships sunk off the coast of Western Australia in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries: Batavia (1629), Vergulde Draeck (1656), Zuytdorp (1712), and Zeewijk (1727—and the lows—the Netherlands has often awarded commercial salvage contracts for recovery of other sunken VOC ships.
- As with Ireland, Micronesia, and the Netherlands, the chapter on Spain also discusses issues arising from shipwrecks of one nation in the waters of another, and the opportunities for bilateral agreements as envisaged by the convention. The Spanish shipwrecks La Galga (1750) and Juno (1802) lie within 3 nautical miles of the eastern United States and were the subject of protracted salvage litigation and appeals until the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals decided that the wrecks would be left undisturbed as grave sites for their crews, as Spain wished.
The book is very comprehensive, but one might wish for wider coverage. Although this second edition adds material on five nations not previously covered, it does not address developments in many parts of the world.
There are no essays from Central and South America and the Caribbean, where much has been happening in the last 5 years. Panama, for example, was the first nation to ratify the convention, followed recently by Mexico, Paraguay, and Ecuador. This region has a rich legacy of colonial-era shipwrecks and no doubt precontact UCH as well. The issue inevitably arises over the convention's allocation of rights and responsibilities between the nation location of the UCH and the flag state of the UCH. These questions are further complicated by the presence on many colonial-era wrecks of treasure looted from the indigenous people of these nations; the convention is silent as to what interests, if any, are to be recognized in their descendants.
Africa is not particularly well represented, apart from Craig Forrest's examination of the history of UCH protection in South Africa. Both Libya and Nigeria ratified the convention in 2005, and it would be interesting to know more about their respective interests in UCH protection and their reasons for ratifying the convention. Further, Portugal's recent ratification is a significant step toward protecting colonial-era shipwrecks along Africa's coastlines.
In Asia only the People's Republic of China (PRC) is considered in a comprehensive chapter by Kuen-chen Fu, a Chinese scholar who received his legal education in the United States. Elsewhere in the region, there is widespread interest in the convention, as evidenced by the November 2003 UNESCO 2001 Convention Implementation Workshop for the Asia-Pacific Region held in Hong Kong. Archaeologists and legal specialists from Indonesia, Korea, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Sri Lanka, Thailand, and Vietnam, as well as the PRC, gave presentations describing the extent of UCH research and efforts at protective legislative in those countries.
Central and South America, Asia and Africa await exploration in a future edition. As a reference work on current UCH protection law, however, this book is essential reading for anyone involved in the protection of UCH in any jurisdiction.
