Avi Shlaim's Lion of Jordan is a meticulously detailed biography of the late King Hussein of Jordan, who played a pivotal role in the history and politics of the Middle East over close to half a century, beginning with his ascension to the throne in 1953. Shlaim offers the reader a wide-reaching historical tracing of the Hashemites’ ruling dynasty in the early 20th century, their role in the Arab Revolt, and the legacy Hashemite leaders Sharif Hussein ibn ʿAli and his son Abdullah ibn Hussein left to the young King Hussein as he struggled to find his footing in Jordan. The author recounts the political as well as the personal challenges the king faced, often in overwhelming circumstances. The threats to the throne and to Hussein's life and the causes he championed and betrayed are all part of the story Shlaim tells in over 600 pages.
Shlaim frequently refers to Hussein's reflections on King Abdullah and his influence on the young monarch. Both kings sought to control Palestinian territory, which in part prevented Palestinian leadership from delivering to Palestinians what they had been denied by the Balfour Declaration and the British during World War I. Scholars may argue that the ambitions of the surrounding Arab states along with the weakened position of the Palestinian people after the 1948 war left the Palestinians unable to govern even the bits of territory that remained of historic Palestine: Gaza and the Jordanian-designated “West Bank.” Yet, while Abdullah sought to expand his kingdom, and did so during the 1948 war, Hussein did not; rather, he sought only to maintain his kingdom's existence, which was no easy feat in a region of rivalries dominated by what he considered untrustworthy personalities and ideologies. The king maintained Jordan's existence in the face of persistent internal and external challenges, but he could not hold on to the territory his grandfather's army had secured in 1948, including East Jerusalem. Scholars (and Palestinians) have often asked whether Hussein was seeking “Jordanian” territory or a Palestinian homeland and state during his later pursuit to regain the West Bank, which Israel occupied in the 1967 war. Having reviewed the evidence, Shlaim posits a trajectory from Hussein initially seeking territory for Jordan to ultimately pursuing a homeland and state for the Palestinians after Jordan's disengagement from the West Bank in 1988.
Readers expect provocative, critical scholarship from Avi Shlaim, who has broken important ground for students trying to understand Zionist–Arab relations during the crucially important Mandate period in Palestine and Transjordan. This biography offers a comprehensive overview of the history of Transjordan and the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, tracing, as noted in the subtitle, “the life of King Hussein in war and peace.” It mainly relies on the many published works of history, politics, autobiography, and memoir on Jordan and on King Hussein, including the memoir of the king by his wife, Queen Noor. Yet the author's narrow source base limits his ability to offer much that is new about the life of one of the longest reigning monarchs of the 20th century.
Shlaim's international-relations approach to writing a history of the life of King Hussein stems from his disciplinary training, and he argues it “is the only sensible approach” to writing about a king whose entire career “revolved round waging war and making peace” (p. xiii). The author seems to have intended to write the definitive biographical study on this significant historical figure, yet he faced the challenge of identifying previously unseen historical sources. The absence of documents from Arab state archives is noteworthy, though this is a problem researchers of the Arab world have long faced. The author's two-hour interview with the king in 1996 focusing on Hussein's clandestine meetings with Israeli officials serves as the main source for Hussein's words. The king also invited Shlaim to Amman to share notes on his diplomatic meetings, an opportunity the author was unable to take advantage of, as the king became ill and passed away in 1999. Shlaim gained access to two substantial collections of private papers, one by an American journalist (who died before being able to publish his own biography of Hussein) and the other by the main Israeli official in charge of the back channel talks with Hussein. He also interviewed more than three dozen Jordanian officials and other members of the royal family as well as numerous Israeli, American, and British officials. These sources provided him rich details and engaging stories, particularly about the extent of and context for Hussein's secret peacemaking effort in the region.
The list of interviewees is long, but absent are Hussein's written records as well as those of his officials and family, which either do not exist or were inaccessible to Shlaim. Jordan's national archive is neither well catalogued nor readily available to researchers. The author relies on a number of American and British officials’ autobiographical writings but does not follow up with interviews to probe their roles in the peace process, the outbreak of war, or the provisioning of foreign aid in the region. Finally, Shlaim underutilizes the British and American diplomatic archives. In terms of the latter, the author only focuses on U.S. foreign-relations files from 1957 to 1968 even as much of the history he covers is post-1968. Absent a broader archival reach, it is difficult to accept this book as the definitive biography of King Hussein. Indeed, not long after Shlaim copyrighted his book, but a year before it went to press, Nigel Ashton's biography of the late king, King Hussein of Jordan: A Political Life (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 2008), was published. In a wonderful stroke of luck, Ashton gained, as he says in his acknowledgements, full and unfettered access to the king's correspondence files. This in itself may not make his work the definitive biography. Yet Ashton's access to the king's papers presumably afford him the opportunity—unavailable to Shlaim—to fill gaps in knowledge and open new areas of thinking in regard to the life and times of King Hussein.
With little that is new or surprising, the stories Shlaim presents ring familiar to readers of Jordanian history: Hussein's troubled relations with certain Arab states during different time periods, challenges he faced with Palestinians and PLO officials inside his own kingdom and, after 1967, in the Occupied Territories, among many other topics. Perhaps Shlaim's disciplinary interests prevented him from engaging the work of younger scholars who have taken up questions of identity in this most artificial of political states. He instead occupies himself with Hussein's main interests (and perhaps Shlaim's own): foreign affairs and regional politics. The author's overwhelming focus over the 600 pages of his book on Hussein's secret meetings with Israeli leaders gives the impression that little else happened throughout Jordanian history.
Shlaim notes that he chose to pursue this project because of the paucity of scholarship on Jordan. Such an observation may have been true in the late 1990s, when he conceived the work, but many articles and books on Jordan have been published over the last decade, most of which were not consulted. For example, Fawaz Gerges, Paul Kingston, Russell Lucas, Curtis Ryan, and Tariq Tell have dealt with various political and economic issues; Jillian Schwedler and Mansoor Moaddel have written on the Islamist movement in Jordan; and Betty Anderson and Kimberly Katz have written on nationalism and national identity in Jordan. Shlaim also does not always cite the published works of individuals he interviewed, such as Peacemaking: The Inside Story of the 1994 Jordanian–Israeli Treaty by former Jordanian officials Abdul Salam Majali, Jawad A. Anani, and Munther J. Haddadin (Reading, U.K.: Garnet Publishing Limited, 2006), the inclusion of which might have produced an interesting contrast to their oral accounts. All books cannot be all things, but Shlaim's omission of these and other studies that came out during the decade prior to his book's publication results in a limited representation of King Hussein's life that obscures the importance of several phenomena related to the king's rule: economic development, which Jordan pursued through tourism, investment, and other means; political parties and Islamic politics, two topics that have gained great traction over the past decade; and the critical subject of identity formation.
In sum, Shlaim's account of Hussein's life provides a deeply nuanced, poignantly felt, and at times hagiographic history to students of Jordan and the history of the Arab–Israeli conflict, with little that is new or surprising. Despite its length, the narrative is engaging. The reader becomes engrossed in the details of royal family life, cabinet shifts, and the king's travels for secret meetings with Israelis, as if she were part of the story. Shlaim offers both praise for and criticism of the king and critiques Israel where appropriate, evidence that his is honest scholarship. Apologists for Israel may disapprove of some of Shlaim's remarks, as for example when he states that Menachem Begin, the darling of the Israeli Right who made peace with Egypt, was “the leader of a right-wing terrorist group in the pre-independence period” (p. 397). The book offers little appeal for specialists of Jordanian and Middle East history, as they will be unsatisfied by the lack of new sources. It is also unlikely to be used in the classroom due to its length. The book will likely have popular appeal, however, because of Shlaim's reputation as well as general American sympathy for the late king.
