Jazz drummer Antonio Sanchez is not a conventional film scorer. Until recently, film soundtrack work remained outside of his purview despite a prolific career boasting over one hundred albums, collaborations with such artists as Pat Metheny, Chick Corea, and Michael Brecker, and an immense repertoire of jazz performance styles. Only in 2014, when director Alejandro González Iñárritu contacted him to perform the original score for his 2014 film Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance), did Sanchez's performance experience intersect with the film industry. Sanchez's original score challenged traditional film music conventions with two features that are relatively rare in cinema soundtracks. First, the score is improvised. With the exception of a few other examples in film music history, film scores are almost exclusively written out prior to production, reducing both economic and aesthetic risk for the filmmakers.Footnote 1 Second, Sanchez's score features solely percussion instrumentation, dismissing the melody and harmony that are preponderantly used in the majority of film scores. The resulting soundtrack is a fascinating demonstration of Sanchez's ability to channel his improvisational aptitude and command of his drum set's stylistic and timbral possibilities into an emotional narrative that sonically embodies the themes of Birdman itself. Furthermore, as a rare example of a jazz musician hired to score a film, Sanchez and his improvised jazz score open a critical dialogue about the intersections of the jazz and film art worlds, while also highlighting the possibilities for innovative freedom within the film industry's labor expectations.
“I want something that's not scripted, something jazzy. You're a jazz musician. That's what I want.”Footnote 2 Director Iñárritu conceived of Sanchez's percussion improvisations as an integral part of Birdman's narrative. The plot documents the struggles of washed-up superhero actor Riggan Thomson (played by Michael Keaton), who is trying to shed his commercial associations and establish himself as a “true” artist late in his career by producing a Broadway play. The film's central themes address Thomson's own ego, his career anxiety, and his growing insanity, as well as his complicated relationships with others—including his drug-addicted daughter, his girlfriend, his acting rival, and a powerful, antagonistic play reviewer. Sanchez's score sonically represents these themes. The frenzied aesthetic of his percussive grooves musically reflect Thomson's anxiety, disillusionment with his career, the chaotic status of his life, and his descent into madness. The drums simulate corporeality—heartbeats racing, neurons firing, palms sweating, as well as psychological states of mind—explicitly functioning as the musical embodiment of the characters’ emotions. Iñárritu has averred, “Sanchez's score... was absolutely key and irreplaceable. The intensity of the drum cues almost became a separate character in the film, and an indispensable part of it.”Footnote 3
The drum score is also an integral feature in the pace and tempo of the film and scenes. The movie itself was filmed as a single continuous, uninterrupted shot, in which scenes were not cut from each other, but were connected through the movement of the characters from location to location. Sanchez's improvisations, recorded in the pre-production stages of filming, provide the sonic threadwork that links these mobile, transitional moments together. In the soundtrack liner notes, Iñárritu claims, “I attempted Birdman... to be experienced in one continuous and uninterrupted shot. Very much as we live our lives. But not having the possibility to fragment time and space, it is almost a contradiction to the nature of cinema itself. DRUUUMMMMMSSS! Eureka! I thought the drums would help me to find the internal rhythm of the film and the audience will flow with it.”Footnote 4
Allow me to describe one of the tracks, “Dirty Walk,” as it is situated within the film itself. The dressing room in the St. James Theater is dirty and dim, backlit by faded afternoon sunlight creeping underneath a half-blinded window facing the New York streets. Riggan Thomson floats in the middle of a dingy greenroom in the theater as the voice of his superhero character, Birdman, haunts him. “How did we end up here?” Birdman taunts. “This place is horrible.” Birdman's monologue is interrupted when Riggan's computer rings; his daughter, Sam, angrily video calls him to find out what flowers he wants for his dressing room. The conversation abruptly ends as Sam yells, “I hate doing this job!” and hangs up. Riggan wearily sits down and sighs. As he does so, we hear a sharp and invasive drum hit, soon layered with the full drum set and cymbals. The camera pans to a close-up of Riggan's face—exhausted, disappointed, both?—and we hear a voice over the loudspeaker summoning Riggan to the theater stage. After a second encouragement from the loudspeaker, he visibly jolts out of his contemplative daze, rising quickly, putting on his pants, and walking out into the theater corridors. The percussion soundtrack remains viscerally present through this entire scene—a solid 4/4 groove interpolated with syncopated, full drum set improvisations. Tight hits on the snare and bass drum pierce loudly through the scene, the high-hat clasps the off-beats, the ride cymbal shimmers in and out of the rhythm. Syncopation is rampant, rhythmic motives shift and turn inward and outward on each other, but the groove—with or without the downbeats—is always there. The soundtrack is a syncopated march, reflecting Riggan's pace and movement as he progresses through the hallways toward the St. James stage, as well as the inner voices of Birdman and Sam beating in his mind.
The organization of the issued soundtrack album maintains its ties to the film as much as possible in the absence of the visual medium. The tracks are predominantly organized in the manner they appear on screen; the soundtrack is grouped with all of Sanchez's original score work in the first sixteen tracks, progressing from the opening credits through the final scenes.Footnote 5 Each piece tells a different part of the story, informing the overall narrative. Even in the absence of the film itself, Sanchez's improvisations sonically capture the themes of anxiety, internal conflict, and frustration that permeate the characters’ emotional states. The aptly named “Schizo” (track 10) evinces a sonic schizophrenia in which constantly changing percussive “voices” (e.g., snare drums rolls, bass drum hits, cymbal shimmers and crashes, and sharp rim shots) bombard the listener in an unpredictable, initially-meter-less and high-paced onslaught. “Internal War” (track 11) reflects internal emotional conflict through the sonic metaphor of “drums of war.” The piece begins with low, rumbling rolls on the floor tom, ferociously increasing in tempo and dynamics to represent an offensive internal siege, meeting the defensive line in explosive cymbal crashes. These “attacks” continue throughout the track, intertwined with the underlying, syncopated, “defensive” groove. Certain tracks move beyond the characters’ internal experiences to also sonically embody external relationships. “Just Chatting” (track 3) emerges in the film as Riggan walks through the theater corridors, arguing with his producer/lawyer Jake that the first preview of the play must be cancelled due to the inadequate talent of one of the lead actors (who has also recently been injured). Jake fights back that they would have to refund a full house, and that the to-be-dismissed actor would also have the right to file a lawsuit. Sanchez's percussive, clipped phrases and hits in this improvisation effectively simulate the fast-paced, energy-laden, and quarrelsome dialogue demonstrated between the two characters; the call-and-response interaction between the lower-pitched, syncopated snare and bass groove with interruptive cymbal and tambourine hits illustrates the dialogic, yet combative nature of the conversation. Throughout the soundtrack, Sanchez experiments with his drum set's timbral and textural capabilities, utilizing a variety of mallets and sticks (including his hands) and playing in both traditional and non-traditional ways (for example, hitting the rims or playing on the sides of the drums) in order to effectively evince the subtexts of each scene.
The quality of the sound recordings themselves is crisp and articulate, allowing listeners to identify intelligibly the manifold components of the percussion set that Sanchez is utilizing, and the ways in which these instruments interact with one another. There is a rawness, a presence to the recording quality that is often absent in smooth and clean high-definition recordings. Excess sounds that are typically edited out of final recordings—such as Sanchez asking the director a question, tuning his drums, and warming up with drumstick hits—lend the recording a more “realistic,” live quality. This aesthetic of grainy realism was intentional; Sanchez and Iñárritu agreed they wanted the soundtrack to sonically reflect “the gritty, live aesthetic of the film” and its setting in a dark, dirty Broadway theater.Footnote 6 Accordingly, Sanchez adjusted his conventional percussion setup, utilizing such techniques as putting tape on his drumheads, detuning them, and stacking his cymbals to make them sound more broken-in and well-used—ultimately giving the recordings a dirtier, grittier overall sound.
The accompanying notes to the soundtrack are brief but elucidating. They feature Iñárritu's description of the conceptualization and production of the album: how he and Sanchez initially met, how he decided upon Sanchez to compose the score, how he and Sanchez worked together to produce the improvisations, and how they utilized classical pieces at the end of the recording. Although these descriptions are valuable and informative, audiences may also have benefited from notes on each piece that described the scenes the improvisations accompanied, to afford listeners the opportunity to connect the music with the narrative, even in the absence of the film itself. Such extended notes could also address the sonic elements of the improvisations that correspond to particular narrative or emotional elements. I also would have appreciated comments from Sanchez himself. Given the uniqueness of this soundtrack endeavor—as well as Sanchez's relative unfamiliarity with film soundtrack work at large—it would be valuable for scholars and fans alike to get his personal take on his experiences as a jazz drummer improvising within a film-scoring context.Footnote 7
Overall, the Birdman soundtrack is a fascinating contribution to the diverse discographies of American cinema soundtracks, improvised jazz music, and extended percussion works—as well as Sanchez's own catalog. This work illuminates both the narrative possibilities of solo percussion performance and the potential intersections of jazz improvisation with film score composition. The soundtrack has received much critical acclaim among film critics and viewing audiences alike, winning awards and nominations from Critics Choice, the Golden Globes, and the British Academy Film Awards, among others. It will be interesting to see if the recognition of this score will spur future improvised soundtracks in upcoming films. I hope that it incites and continues to generate dialogue about the ways innovative musical performance can challenge conventional film industry hierarchies of labor and production, and how jazz–film intersections facilitate creative development among performing musicians themselves.
