Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T14:30:22.621Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

On the frequency selection mechanism of the low-Re flow around rectangular cylinders

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 January 2022

A. Chiarini
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano, via La Masa 34, 20156 Milano, Italy
M. Quadrio
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano, via La Masa 34, 20156 Milano, Italy
F. Auteri*
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano, via La Masa 34, 20156 Milano, Italy
*
†Email address for correspondence: franco.auteri@polimi.it

Abstract

In the flow past elongated rectangular cylinders at moderate Reynolds numbers, vortices shedding from the leading- and trailing-edge corners are frequency locked by the impinging leading-edge vortex instability. The present work investigates how the chord-based Strouhal number varies with the aspect ratio of the cylinder at a Reynolds number (based on the cylinder thickness and the free-stream velocity) of $Re=400$, i.e. when locking is strong. Several two-dimensional, nonlinear simulations are run for rectangular and D-shaped cylinders, with the aspect ratio ranging from $1$ to $11$, and a global linear stability analysis of the flow is performed. The shedding frequency observed in the nonlinear simulations is predicted fairly well by the eigenfrequency of the leading eigenmode. The inspection of the structural sensitivity confirms the central role of the trailing-edge vortex shedding in the frequency locking, as already assumed by other authors. Surprisingly, however, the stepwise increase of the Strouhal number with the aspect ratio reported by several previous works is not fully reproduced. Indeed, with increasing aspect ratio, two distinct flow behaviours are observed, associated with two flow configurations where the interaction between the leading- and trailing-edge vortices is different. These two configurations are fully characterised, and the mechanism of selection of the flow configuration is discussed. Lastly, for aspect ratios close to the jump between two consecutive shedding modes, the Strouhal number is found to present hysteresis, implying the existence of multiple stable configurations. Continuing the lower shedding-mode branch by increasing the aspect ratio, we found that the periodic configuration loses stability via a Neimark–Sacker bifurcation leading to different Arnold tongues. This hysteresis can explain, at least partially, the significant scatter of existing experimental and numerical data.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Dependence of the Strouhal number $St$ on the aspect ratio ${A{\kern-4pt}R}$ at $Re=400$. Green diamonds and red squares denote rectangular cylinders and D-shaped cylinders, respectively. The inset shows a zoom for $4.85 \le {A{\kern-4pt}R} \le 5.75$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Streamlines and vorticity colour map of the mean flow averaged over one shedding period. (a) D-shaped cylinder with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =6$. (b–d) Rectangular cylinders with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =4,5,7$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Dependence of the length (a) $\ell _s$ and (b) $\ell _w$ of the recirculation regions on ${A{\kern-4pt}R}$ for D-shaped (red squares) and rectangular (diamonds) cylinders. Blue, green, orange, grey and yellow colours refer to different branches in the $St$–${A{\kern-4pt}R}$ diagram.

Figure 3

Table 1.Details of the global stability analysis around the mean flow for the D-shaped cylinder (DC) with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =6$ and the rectangular cylinders (RC) with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =4,5,7$. Lengths $\ell _w$ and $\ell _s$ are the lengths of the recirculating bubbles in the wake and over the side, respectively; $\sigma$ is the real part of the unstable eigenvalue; and $St_l$ and $St_{nl}$ are the Strouhal numbers obtained by the linear stability analysis and by the nonlinear simulation.

Figure 4

Figure 4.(a,c,e,g) Real part of the cross-stream velocity component of the unstable mode. (b,d,f,h) Colour map of the structural sensitivity. (a,b) D-shaped cylinder with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =6$; (c–h) rectangular cylinders with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =4,5,7$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Instantaneous flow around the D-shaped cylinder with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =6$, represented with streamlines and vorticity colour maps. The periodic flow has period $T=5.6196$. (a–f) Six temporal instants at $t/T=0,0.08,0.16,0.24,0.32$ and $0.40$ are represented, respectively. Yellow diamonds indicate elliptical stagnation points, whereas green diamonds indicate the hyperbolic stagnation points.

Figure 6

Figure 6.As for figure 5, but for a rectangular cylinder with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =4$, for which $T=7.0662$. (a–f) The six temporal instants are $t/T=0.4,0.48,0.56,0.64,0.72$ and $0.8$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.As for figure 5 but for a rectangular cylinder with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =5$, for which $T=5.0668$. (a–f) The six temporal instants are $t/T=0,0.08,0.16,0.24,0.32$ and $0.40$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Steady symmetric flow at ${Re}=400$ for a rectangular cylinder with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =5$ (a) and a sharp LE indefinite flat plate (b). Streamlines are shown superimposed on the vorticity contour map.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Temporal evolution of the elliptical stagnation points on the top side of the cylinders during one shedding period. The $x$ position of the stagnation points is drawn with a square, red when they are attached and white when they are shed. Blue diamonds denote the distance between two successive LE vortices when they are both attached.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Dependence on ${A{\kern-4pt}R}$ of the shedding period in the configuration where the preferred frequency cannot be selected ($T_{LE}=L/n U_c$), the preferred TE period itself ($T_{TE}$) and the actual period ($T$).

Figure 11

Figure 11.Sketch of the interaction between the LE and TE vortices. (a) Flow configuration with $T_{TE}>T_{LE}$. (b) Flow configuration with $T_{TE}< T_{LE}$. Here $L^{-}$ denotes LE vortices with negative vorticity; $T^{-}$ denotes TE vortices with negative vorticity; $T^{+}$ denotes TE vortices with positive vorticity.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Evidence of hysteresis in the $St$–${A{\kern-4pt}R}$ curve. The green and yellow diamonds denote the $n=1$ configuration before and after the Neimark–Sacker bifurcation (bif), respectively; red diamonds denote the $n=2$ configuration. Dashed lines delimit the range of ${A{\kern-4pt}R}$ for which both configurations are stable.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Lock-in phenomenon in the Neimark–Sacker bifurcation on the $n=1$ horizontal branch. Dependence of the Arnold tongue constants (a) $p$ and (b) $q$ on the aspect ratio ${A{\kern-4pt}R}$.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Time history of the lift coefficients for $4.85 \le {A{\kern-4pt}R} \le 5.25$ in the different states. Aspect ratio ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =$ (a,b) 4.85, (c,d) 5.0625, (e,f) 5.125 and (g,h) 5.25. (a,c,e,g) The $n=1$ (bifurcated) state and (b,d,f,h) the $n=2$ state. The time history of $C_{\ell }$ is plotted over one $T_{lp}$ period for the $n=1$ bifurcated state and over one $T_{TE}$ period for the other cases.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Snapshots of the flow around the rectangular cylinder with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =5$, with the streamlines and vorticity colour maps, for (a) $n=1$ and (b) $n=2$.

Figure 16

Figure 16.As for figure 5, but for a rectangular cylinder with ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =5.25$, in the bifurcated state obtained in the continuation of the $n=1$ horizontal branch. (a–f) The six temporal instants span one LE vortex shedding period; they are $t/T_{LE}=0.14,0.27,0.4,0.53,0.66$ and $0.79$.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Dependence of the Strouhal number $St$ on the aspect ratio ${A{\kern-4pt}R}$. Comparison of the present results with previously published results. Present numerical data are at $Re=400$ (the $n=1$ bifurcated state is not reported for clarity). Experimental data from Nakamura et al. (1991) are at $Re=1000$. Numerical data from Ozono et al. (1992) are at $Re=1000$. Numerical data from Tan et al. (1998) are at $Re=400$. Experimental data from Mills et al. (2003) are at $Re=490$.

Figure 18

Table 2.Domain size for the grids employed in the grid-independence study.

Figure 19

Table 3.Variation of the drag and lift coefficients ($C_d$ and $C_\ell$) and of the shedding period $T$ for ${A{\kern-4pt}R} =3,5$ and $7$ at $Re=400$ on three different meshes. Mesh $M_0$ indicates the mesh used for the computations in this work; $M_1$ indicates a mesh with larger cross-stream and streamwise dimensions with the same grid resolution; and $M_2$ indicates a mesh with the same domain size as $M_1$ but with finer grid resolution. Subscript ‘$m$’ indicates the mean value, while subscript ‘$p$’ indicates the peak value.