The historiography of environmentalism sometimes seems a collective study of good intentions and bad outcomes. Some accounts excavate heroic figures until then missing from the literature, or little credited.Footnote 1 Others debate the price paid by the environment for industrialization and population growth, or warn of continued threats.Footnote 2
In the two books under review, the intent is to analyze the motives of the early conservationists, broadening our understanding of their legacy. For Carolyn Merchant, a long-time professor of environmental history, philosophy, and ethics at the University of California at Berkeley, the subject is George Bird Grinnell, who founded the first Audubon Society, and the nexus is gender. For Powell, a recent graduate of the University of California at Davis who now teaches at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore, the target is the concept of species extinction, and the frame is race. Together, the two authors position these early environmentalists within the context of their times. Conservationists they may have been, but the men and women of the early movement were hardly immune from the gendered, race-based worldview of the Progressive Era that fostered them.
Borrowing from an earlier essay, Merchant credits Grinnell with helping to “bridge the gender divide” in conservation.Footnote 3 As the editor of Field and Stream beginning in 1876, Grinnell concluded that the plight of birds endangered by plumed hats—a fashion that was killing an estimated 200,000 birds a year—could only be corrected by women. In 1887, founding a new organization he named after his intellectual mentor, John James Audubon, Grinnell said the Audubon Society would be dedicated to ending the slaughter of the birds by rousing the public. “The reform … must be inaugurated by women and if the subject is called to their attention, their tender hearts will be quick to respond,” he wrote (26).
As Merchant points out, this political outreach to women threatened the gender order, and men who sought to involve women in reform efforts were routinely mocked as “political hermaphrodites.” When, in 1909, John Muir fought for preservation of Hetch Hetchy Valley in Yosemite National Park, he welcomed female support. San Francisco city officials, eager to dam the valley to provide water for the city, pounced. As the city's engineer, Marsden Manson, put it, these advocates were misguided do-gooders, little but “short-haired women and long-haired men” (18–19).
But Grinnell was also a hunter, and founder, along with Theodore Roosevelt, of the Boone and Crockett Club that admitted only big-game hunters. Though later he advocated hunting with a camera as a preservation measure, as Merchant acknowledges, “he never gave up enjoying hunting game animals and game birds under strict rules and seasonal restrictions” (238). His appeal to men was that they adhere to a code of gentlemanly sport while hunting, and preserve the endangered. This dissonance between the conservationist and the hunter he never resolved, perhaps never saw. But for Merchant, Grinnell is a deft campaigner against the barbaric practice of women wearing dead birds on their heads, one whose own enjoyment of hunting makes the portrait more nuanced. She notices him reaching out to female hunters and writers, knowing that “if the women of America will take hold, … they can accomplish an incalculable among of good” (26). And she describes his decision, in 1892, to bring shoot photos of the endangered instead of aiming bullets at them as “a conservation measure to help protect nongame birds from the devastation of the feather trade and as a means of appreciating the beauties of nature” (238).
If Merchant's is a historical case study in the preservation of birds, Powell's is a macro history of animals of all species and humans of all races. Documenting the public's obsession with extinction, whether of a species or “the vanishing Indian,” Powell traces how white Americans from the mid-nineteenth century to the mid-twentieth conflated “wildlife depletion and racial decline” and concluded, with social Darwinian clarity, that in besting nature and native, they had triumphed as the more vigorous (2).
Many educated Americans in the mid-nineteenth century “drew on evolutionism to rationalize wildlife decline” and “clung to the belief that American Indians and free blacks would likewise fall once in competition with Euro-Americans.” A surging immigrant population led to fears that “urbanization and industrialization made the white race soft and over civilized, unable to compete with the rugged immigrant hordes” (46). By the last decades of the century, “growing numbers of Euro-Americans questioned their own vigor and linked their fate to that of dwindling wildlife and indigenous peoples” (14–16). As a result, support for eugenics and birth control grew, and “once-sporadic calls for reform gave way to resounding cries for preservation” (16).
In a particularly engaging chapter, “The Last of Her Tribe,” Powell examines public fascination with the very last living exemplar of any species—Martha, the last passenger pigeon, named for Martha Washington; Booming Ben, the last living heath hen; or Ishi, said to be the last living descendant of a Southern Yana tribe whose existence may have been manufactured by two University of California anthropologists (142). Found near starvation, “ravenous his whole life,” speaking no known tribal language, Ishi soon gained celebrity and some censure when his encounter with food on the table fattened his waistline. Cake, candy, jelly, ice cream, all delighted him. A Native American who was “ungracefully fat” did not comport with white America's stereotype of the vigorous savage Indian. “America wanted to believe they had seized the continent from brawny savages,” writes Powell, “not humans who struggled to feed themselves” (148). Martha and Ben were compared to the last Indians, while Ishi served as a metaphor for the nation's dwindling wilderness.
News stories about the last passenger pigeon or the disappearing bison or the “vanishing Indian,” concerns about what Frederick Jackson Turner famously dubbed the closing of the frontier, all contributed to a sense that white Americans “somehow owed their racial vigor to the continent's wilderness.” This desire to maintain the wilderness as a “tonic to mitigate the ills of industrialization and urbanization,” and to protect the primacy of white males was, in Powell's view, the wellspring of modern environmentalism (49).
As a result, Powell is attuned to the racism that informed the activism of the early conservationists. Madison Grant was a zoologist and conservationist whose The Passing of the Great Race (1918) explained how charity and government interference had, in Powell's description, allowed “inferior individuals and races to reproduce with greater frequency than ideal Nordics.” On his death in 1937, the New York Times summed up his life by saying, “The preservation of the redwoods, of the bison, of the Alaskan caribou, of the bald eagle … and of the purity of the ‘Nordic’ type of humanity in this country, were all his personal concerns, all products of the same urge in him to save precious things” (104–6).
Instructive are the differences between the two authors when describing Grinnell. Powell notices the Audubon founder's view of Yellowstone as “the last bastion of a vanishing frontier,” part of his mourning for the closing frontier. “We … have seen the Indian and the game retreat before the white man and the cattle, and beheld the tide of immigration … which threatens … to leave no portion of our vast territory unbroken by the farmer's plow,” he writes. (57). Like Theodore Roosevelt and William Temple Hornaday, president of the New York Zoological Society, his efforts “to rescue this environment were inseparable from … [a] desire to preserve distinct but related visions of white America. With plummeting animal and plant populations stoking their concern, these reformers sought to maintain the frontier partly to serve as a tonic to mitigate the ills of industrialization and urbanization” (49). For Merchant, Grinnell's greatest contribution may have been in his writings and appeals, where he “brought “the plight of birds and game to public awareness,” winning protection of Yellowstone National Park and other nature preserves, setting the stage for later conservation successes in the early twentieth century (235).
Both books are important interventions in the field of environmental history. A major influence in the field of ecofeminism, Merchant here contributes to the historiography of women as the wellspring for many state and local Audubon Societies—though noting that as always men served as president (39).Footnote 4 In addition, she leaves a rich trove of archival material for use by future students. Between her introductory chapters on Grinnell's early influences and development to her epilogue assessing his achievements, she shares primary source documents, reprinted from the pages of Audubon Society Magazine. There are five chapters of Grinnell's writings—his serialized biography of John James Audubon's life and character; his biography of Alexander Wilson, sometimes referred to as the father of ornithology; and his tales of the Audubon Society's history. There are also three chapters from the pages of the magazine of his monthly feature on birds, complete with color reprints of John James Audubon's original illustrations.
As for Powell, when he marshals the case that the bigoted views of the era motivated founders of the conservation movement, he is pioneering. With a nod to Gail Bederman, he says he hopes to link not race and gender but racial ideas and environmentalism (12).Footnote 5 Occasionally he overextends his argument beyond his evidence. Asserting repeatedly that people of color are uncomfortable in national parks, he concludes, “We need to build a more inclusive environmental movement, one that promotes a greater diversity of voices and balances the preservation of a broader range of natures” (191). If Powell means to suggest that people of color are uncomfortable in our National Parks because of this legacy of environmentalism's founders, it is an important question, worthy of further exploration.
