Charles Darwin was taxonomically promiscuous. Wedded to no one taxon, he flitted from organism to organism, much as his curiosity dictated, but also out of a utilitarian need for particular examples to support a general theory that explained the diversity of living organisms. Over the course of his long career he studied a staggering range of organisms, from earthworms to humans, barnacles to birds. Yet there was one group to which he had a special connection, relying on them frequently for handy examples, but also as a source of delight – plants. Though it would be hard to consider Darwin a botanist in the strict sense of the term, he used plants in at least three interrelated ways: in his thinking about evolution, in his own researches and in his professional life as a whole. By the end of his life, he had completed no less than six books – published between 1862 and 1880 – exclusively devoted to botanical subjects, in addition to articles published in the weekly Gardener's Chronicle and journals such as the Agricultural Gazette. But even earlier than that, the botanical world, and its complex phenomena, played a foundational role in the formulation of his grand theory as expressed in On the Origin of Species.
Darwin loved the things, to be sure, and marvelled at the beauty of the plant world like other naturalists in his day. But his was an aesthetic grounded in the remarkable assortment of vegetative and reproductive structures, and of the complex adaptations they displayed. Mating patterns that included self-fertilization and cross-fertilization, along with varying kinds of pollinating mechanisms often requiring other organisms such as insects and birds, made plants ideal for studies in co-adaptation; and the fact that they appeared to be plastic, demonstrating rapid adaptation to shifting environments, allowed attention to the phenomenon of adaptation itself, notably through studies exploring the direct and indirect effects of the environment. Even complex behaviours involving movement were observable in the plant world, as were peculiar phenomena such as insectivory. Best of all, plants were tractable as objects of study, and could be grown in a variety of conditions, including the hothouse and garden as well as, of course, the wild. In short, they made for splendid – and comparatively easy – organisms to study for anyone interested in understanding both the proximate and ultimate causes of the origin and maintenance of diversity in the natural world.
Historians of science have been aware of all of this for some time, of course, yet detailed studies devoted specifically to Darwin and plants have been few in number. Both books under review provide us with much-needed background to the botanical world as it figured in Darwin's life and work. A most welcome general picture is offered in Darwin's Garden: An Evolutionary Adventure, by David Kohn, no stranger to Darwin studies. Written for the non-specialist, and intended to accompany a special exhibit sponsored by the New York Botanical Garden in advance of the Darwin 2009 anniversaries, the book is celebratory in nature but devoid of hagiographic excess and nuanced in its assessment of plants in Darwin's life. The text is brief but elegant in style and artfully illustrated with portraits of important people, drawings and many lovely botanical images. Altogether, the reader gains a broad overview of Darwin's relations to plants and the breadth and complexity of his botanical researches while being introduced to newer insights, such as Kohn's own into the importance of Darwin's Cambridge mentor J.S. Henslow's teachings for Darwin's understanding of species and variation.
The centrality of plants in Darwin's life, and of that of his family, is the theme of Peter Ayres's The Aliveness of Plants: The Darwins at the Dawn of Plant Science. As author of the underappreciated Harry Marshall Ward and the Fungal Thread of Death (2005), Ayres has a fine understanding of late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century plant science, especially in Britain. He brings to bear his own scientific expertise in the plant sciences to illuminate not just Darwin's own botanical efforts, explored in great detail here, but also that of his grandfather Erasmus and his son Francis. As such, the book focuses not just on plant evolution but also on areas such as plant physiology, plant anatomy and experimental botany, all of which were shaped appreciably by the Darwins.
Although we learn much about the tradition of botanical study in the Darwin family before Charles, and about Charles's own researches, we learn the most about Francis and his pioneering efforts in plant physiology. Long overshadowed by his famous father, Francis Darwin has been too long neglected by historians of science. In Ayres's treatment, Francis emerges as one of the first professional, laboratory-based workers devoted to establishing a rigorous, experimental approach to the life sciences and to introducing the ‘new botany’ to Britain. His struggles to establish himself, his intellectual and social networks, his personal tragedies – all are sensitively explored and make for a rich study in and of themselves.
Ayres pays attention to broader contexts, including institutional settings such as Cambridge University, the roles of horticulture and agriculture in fuelling the study of plants across a range of disciplines in the late nineteenth century, and the introduction of new techniques and instruments as part of ‘the new botany’. He also gives due attention to the rich interactions and personalities through no less than five generations of Darwins. But the book's real strength is in the technical explication of the scientific work. We learn much about the logical development of each study undertaken, as well as the details of experimental design and execution, along the way gaining an appreciation of the history of the British plant sciences as a whole. Ultimately, the reader is persuaded by Ayres's bold statement that ‘no one person or laboratory did more than the Darwins, collectively, to prove that plants are sensitive beings, responding continuously to changes in their biotic and abiotic environments’ (p. 170, emphasis in original).
