‘Is a new biography of Eva Perón really necessary?’, Loris Zanatta, the author of several important books on different aspects of the history of religion and the state in Argentina, asks rhetorically at the beginning of his new biography of Eva. Since her death in 1952 Eva Perón (‘Evita’) has been the topic of innumerable biographies and studies written by her followers, her detractors and more or less independent scholars. She has also been the subject of films made in Argentina and abroad, of theatre plays and even of a rock opera. A woman of limited formal education but one who, at the same time, commanded a powerful intuitive intelligence, Evita has captivated the interest of foreigners and locals alike. For some, she represented the feminine incarnation of the devil, while for others she was an Argentine fairy queen. Probably, somewhere between the ‘Woman of the Whip’ and the ‘Mother of the Descamisados’, lies the Evita of flesh and blood.
Zanatta attempts, as many others have before him, to go ‘beyond the myth’ and to restore Evita to the realm of history. However, as he recognises, reconstructing the trajectory of ‘the real Evita’ is a difficult task given the relative scarcity of sources available. It is paradoxical that a woman who was at the centre of an enormous state-led effort at image-building, and who played such an important role in the public life of a country, has left so few documents (beyond propaganda) behind her.
Zanatta's argument revolves around two themes. First, he tries to show that Evita was much more powerful than we have usually thought. She had an autonomous, although ‘primitive’ (p. 434), political project. Second, Zanatta thinks that Evita's history provokes valuable reflections ‘on the relations between modernity and tradition, politics and religion, the individual and society, social integration and political democracy’ (p. 9). Moreover, Eva's political life shows the importance of the role of individuals in history. In this respect Zanatta demonstrates a healthy belief in the importance of human agency in history. However, this confidence sometimes leads him to simplify complex chains of events. The image of Evita that emerges from Zanatta's book is that of an almost all-powerful political actor who not only emancipated herself very soon from her husband's political – and not only political – tutelage, but who was able to impose her visions on the Peronist movement and, by extension, large portions of Argentine society and politics. Her commanding influence was felt in areas ranging from foreign relations to social policy. Evita represented, according to Zanatta, the pre-political and charismatic dimension of Peronism, while Perón represented the more rational aspect of it. Thus, Evita was a major obstacle in the institutionalisation of the regime. For instance, her powerful Fundación Eva Perón (Eva Perón Foundation), over which she exercised total control, imposed a limit to the establishment of a welfare state in Argentina. Perón became a prisoner of the system created by his wife, while she was able to reward those who were loyal to her, and to punish those of dubious loyalty. Evita appointed and dismissed ministers and other government officials at will, and carried out her own foreign policy independent of official interests. The increasingly strong Confederación General del Trabajo de la República Argentina (General Confederation of Labour of the Argentine Republic, CGT) became Evita's, and solely Evita's, political tool, although the forces she unleashed would eventually place the CGT in conflict with the equally powerful Fundación Eva Perón. Zanatta's Evita took her first political steps together with Perón and not under Perón, and this happened as early as 1943.
The image of a powerful Evita who played the tune to which Perón, and Argentina, danced is not really new, and sadly Zanatta has not unearthed any fresh evidence on Evita's political life. He bases his arguments on a limited number of published secondary sources and on a large number of reports from foreign ambassadors (Chilean, Spanish, French, Portuguese, US and Italian) which constitute the core of his corpus of primary sources. These archival materials sometimes provide interesting insights into the actual workings of the government, but they are frequently more useful in offering information on the perceptions that the foreign representatives had of Perón and Eva. Zanatta uses very few local sources, which is surprising since in recent decades plenty of documents from the Peronist government which are relevant to his theme have become available, including the archives of the Ministry of Technical Affairs, of the Secretary of the Press and even the Fundación Eva Perón, about which surprisingly little is said in the book.
Eva Perón is a well-written and engaging book, but the image of Evita, of Peronism and of Argentina that emerges from it is rather flat. Sometimes it seems that Zanatta uses his sources to corroborate what he already knows or supposes, rather than to offer new evidence or introduce nuances into a complex life such as Eva's. Many of the events that Zanatta attributes to Eva's will could be subject to different interpretations that Zanatta does not explore. In emphasising Eva's charismatic rule, he tends to ignore the importance of the ‘rational’ dimension of Peronist rule – for instance, the introduction of planning and the promotion of certain scientific activities – among other things which have been the subject of recent scholarship. Sometimes, however, Evita and her actions became functional to the ‘modern-rational’ aspect of Perón's rule.
Summing up, if what Loris Zanatta is trying to show is that Evita played a central role in the shaping of Peronism, eventually becoming a burden to Perón, it is easy to agree with him, but there is hardly anything new in this argument. However, if Zanatta wants to convince us that Eva was a totally autonomous agent who had the Argentine state, and also Perón, under her control, this is more difficult to believe, at least based on the kind of evidence presented in this book.
